'Ranjeet Singh's rise led to creation of Pakistan'

[Spring Onion]

My only complain about this thread is that a great Punjabi warrior's name is being needlessly dragged into something that happened 130 years after his death.

But please carry on with the debate about race and inferiority complexes.

Very right. MJ Akbar is trying to save his Akhand Bharat hindu leaders of the blame of creating two nation theory.

Ranjeet has nothing to do with creation of Pakistan. At that time all prince, nawabs, kings have to defend their states within states from attacks and invasions thats it

 

[Manas]

^^whatever sails your boat,its good riddance.Good speed.

 

[riCoh]

dil ka behlanay ko yeh khyal acha ha ghalib.

Partition ??? there was NO partition of India. rather India and Pakistan were carved out of different princely states and thats it.

Just google Partition of India....

And if u feel we suffer from inferiority complex....please google Partition of pakistan.

 

[Water Car Engineer]

Yeh you have to for covering up the divide on international foras. so i am not talking about here i am talking about the real actual Indian land where you are also divided in South Indians and North Indians. Marhati is imposed on many with a danda and so on.

Ya, you are making as if its like Southern India is going to secede from India or something. It not a big deal as your trying to make it bud.

 

[Manas]

dil ka behlanay ko yeh khyal acha ha ghalib.

Partition ??? there was NO partition of India. rather India and Pakistan were carved out of different princely states and thats it.

whatever sails your boat,its good riddance.Good speed.

 

[Spring Onion]

Just google Partition of India....

And if u feel we suffer from inferiority complex....please google Partition of pakistan.

You surely suffer from Pakistan phobia since 1930s so keep on suffering i am enjoying every bit of it damn the Hindu press even given the name Pakistan Resolution lolzz when even Pakistan was not created .

This should be enough for MJ Akbar to know it was Hindus' fear that created Pakistan

 

[Spring Onion]

Ya, you are making as if its like Southern India is going to secede from India or something. It not a big deal as your trying to make it bud.

lolzz why are you imagine things which are not said by me

 

[punit]

Partition ??? there was NO partition of India. rather India and Pakistan were carved out of different princely states and thats it.

of course there was NO INDIA before 1947. isnt it ?

 

[Gossipmonger]

Yeh you have to for covering up the divide on international foras. so i am not talking about here i am talking about the real actual Indian land where you are also divided in South Indians and North Indians. Marhati is imposed on many with a danda and so on.

These excuses MJ Akbar tried to make basis for break up of Pakistan while he forgot that in his adopted country Bharat even own Hindus are divided on the basis of cast

So you think Muslim citizen in India has adopted the country even when they are born here? Why..??? Just because they hate Pakistan's Islamic Hypocrisies, Pakistani's lie's and BS as much as rest of the Humanity on the Globe??? Your attack is not on an Indian but on your religion and you as well to say the least.
About Quote in Red, better i would refrain myself from responding than giving you some some space to BS.

 

[riCoh]

Blame this one ,then blame that one , the fact of the matter is India was partitioned and Pakistan & Bangladesh today is Independence country.

Beside that what irritate me is the inherent tendency among Akhanda bharat gang on the side and the bleeding heart secular leberal candle light wala on the side to constantly look for who to blame for partition and inability to accept of inevitably nature of partition due to horrendous diversity of the subcontinent.

If Pakistan hadn't seceded than somebody else ,say south india or Bengal & North east would have their own way.If not ,at the minimum pulls of different competitive regions in different directiosn would be too difficult manage and still make progress a one country.

All in all, Partition is blessing in disguise for India,especially Hindus now who are majority of indian population and so whoever is responsible for partiton of india ,i say thank you.

Cant agree more....If there was no partition, India would have turned into a Islamic state like what happened to Iran(persia).
50 crore Extremist Muslims in one single country would have exterminated Hinduism or any other religion from this land.

 

[Spring Onion]

So you think Muslim citizen in India has adopted the country even when they are born here? Why..??? Just because they hate Pakistan's Islamic Hypocrisies, Pakistani's lie's and BS as much as rest of the Humanity on the Globe??? Your attack is not on an Indian but on your religion and you as well to say the least.
About Quote in Red, better i would refrain myself from responding than giving you some some space to BS.

They ? dont compare a plural with a singular (he). MJ Akbar's paranoia about Pakistan and against Muslims can be very well understood. His grandfather was a Hindu and the conversion to Islam was also not by choice but by circumstance. He has a non-Muslim wife and his children are still with Hindu names. One being named after his Hindu grandfather.

So is the last person on earth who should be taken as unbiased or neutral about his views on Muslims, Islam and Pakistan.

 

[Rafi]

The truth is that their was no partition - two independent nations on the basis of nationhood were seeded from the erstwhile British Empire, what does Ranjit Singh have to with that!???

Ancient Pakistan is a reality that goes back 7,000 years, which for the majority of that time was essentially independent of bharat which modern india basically is.

 

[Spring Onion]

Cant agree more....If there was no partition, India would have turned into a Islamic state like what happened to Iran(persia).
50 crore Extremist Muslims in one single country would have exterminated Hinduism or any other religion from this land.

Oh so you are calling Indian Muslims as extremists too. ahh what a hypocrisy of bharatis about their Muslim population

 

[Truth Teller]

They ? dont compare a plural with a singular (he). MJ Akbar's paranoia about Pakistan and against Muslims can be very well understood. His grandfather was a Hindu and the conversion to Islam was also not by choice but by circumstance. He has a non-Muslim wife and his children are still with Hindu names. One being named after his Hindu grandfather.

So is the last person on earth who should be taken as unbiased or neutral about his views on Muslims, Islam and Pakistan.

Jana, why do you even bother to argue with them. Look at them; they can't even digest the fact their country was created on 15th August 1947.

Seems like they are on the verge of comitting suicide.

 

[Manas]

Cant agree more....If there was no partition, India would have turned into a Islamic state like what happened to Iran(persia).
50 crore Extremist Muslims in one single country would have exterminated Hinduism or any other religion from this land.

Nobody can exterminate Hinduism...it survived even in most trying conditions of foreign rules .So thats not an issue.

But then with more muslims , we had to be more accommodative towards islamic values which were anathema to our hindu values.