Rajasthan doctor gets notice for advising patients to follow Islam

[California]

gosh, this is why we Support trump. dont want to overrun with these Religious fanatic bigots...

 

[danger007]

We are not talking about Christians. But missionaries. And buddy what I am talking about is pretty common in Indian hospitals, especially government hospitals. So there is nothing there to badmouth Christianity or normal Christians.

I have no idea though if RSS or ISKON members do it in India or abroad. Never seen in India. The bottomline is, if one is so religious, then they can go to a temple, and not a doc.

You notice most what you don't like .. .. the thing I noticed the people who organise Ganesh, Navarathri etc. in colonies Demand more money from Christians or other families.. if they refuse to donate.. those organisers force them or abuse them... it's pretty common around here... majority vs minority... of you know thousands of Babas or mathaas are involving in such activities.. it's not that only missionaries does that...

 

[farhan_9909]

So even without Pakistan the process to make India more and more Muslim continues

No wonder Jinnah left them on purpose.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

You notice most what you don't like .. .. the thing I noticed the people who organise Ganesh, Navarathri etc. in colonies Demand more money from Christians or other families.. if they refuse to donate.. those organisers force them or abuse them... it's pretty common around here... majority vs minority... of you know thousands of Babas or mathaas are involving in such activities.. it's not that only missionaries does that...

I can pretty assure you, that till my experience I have never seen something like that in Chennai or Madurai, the cities I frequent it.
As for other cities in other states, I cannot answer. I do not know. But again if such things are pretty common I do wonder how our media hasnt taken it up. You do know such news are "bread and butter" for such organisations.

If things are really like that in ur city, then I condemn it of the highest order. Noone should be forced to convert, give money for festivalities etc. I hope actions are taken against them.

As for missionaries thing, just one question. Me and my friends were asked to attend Mass in Church for a bat and ball. When we were damn kids. When we had no idea on politics, conversion saga. We happily went to church, attended it, had cake and got what we wanted. Trust me I had no biases then. We were kids for damn sake and it happened in a cosmopolitan city like Chennai.

 

[danger007]

I can pretty assure you, that till my experience I have never seen something like that in Chennai or Madurai, the cities I frequent it.
As for other cities in other states, I cannot answer. I do not know. But again if such things are pretty common I do wonder how our media hasnt taken it up. You do know such news are "bread and butter" for such organisations.

If things are really like that in ur city, then I condemn it of the highest order. Noone should be forced to convert, give money for festivalities etc. I hope actions are taken against them.

As for missionaries thing, just one question. Me and my friends were asked to attend Mass in Church for a bat and ball. When we were damn kids. When we had no idea on politics, conversion saga. We happily went to church, attended it, had cake and got what we wanted. Trust me I had no biases then. We were kids for damn sake and it happened in a cosmopolitan city like Chennai.

Like I told earlier people don't mind their own moles but count others ... how many Babas exploiting such cases ??? TTD conducting many spiritual programmes in every corner in Andhra .. they conduct such Program in our area.. we just don't mind because everyone have their own religious faiths and believes... some christians attended .. we don't even bother about because it is their personal choice.. when it comes to prayers within home ... many parivar attacking them lodging case on them, Using every tool available... with a free tag anti national .... I noticed a guy posted a news about a church father raping a girl... ignoring another rape by temple priest.... I will support him, if he posted both news..... members here targeting me as I wrote my view which is against them.. and they forgot many cases when I supported them against Pakistani members... recently a nutcase started abusing me for reporting another member...

 

[guest11]

Oiii come back to topic will ya

Problem is not the religion but the fact that a govt. employee cannot take part in such activities.

Cong MLA writes to Antony over general’s praise for Modi - See more at: http://indianexpress.com/article/ci...enerals-praise-for-modi/#sthash.87UxghZs.dpuf

Studying maj-gen's Modi praise, but Army apolitical: Gen Singh

http://www.rediff.com/news/report/s...rmy-apolitical-says-gen-vk-singh/20110318.htm

And the latest one

Nehru stopped India from becoming Hindu Taliban country: MP IAS officer’s praise lands him in trouble

http://indianexpress.com/article/in...cer-caught-in-row-for-praising-nehru-2819411/

 

[Sky lord]

Oiii come back to topic will ya

Problem is not the religion but the fact that a govt. employee cannot take part in such activities.
/

I don't know why this is being dragged out like this.

Is there a law or bye law that says that government officers cannot proselytize?
If there is a law what is the penalty? Why not just do whatever the penalty is like fine or suspension or whatever And be done with this.

A government doctor obviously cannot use her position of authority and trust to influence people in a personal matter.

Even though I can't imagine that by writing whatever she is writing she has influenced even one person in any way, still it adds pressure to patients who want to be on their doctors good books.

This is so ridiculous really and so easy to stop...a fine of Rs. 500 per prescription deducted from her salary will end this in a month.

 

[guest11]

I don't know why this is being dragged out like this.

Is there a law or bye law that says that government officers cannot proselytize?
If there is a law what is the penalty? Why not just do whatever the penalty is like fine or suspension or whatever And be done with this.

A government doctor obviously cannot use her position of authority and trust to influence people in a personal matter.

Even though I can't imagine that by writing whatever she is writing she has influenced even one person in any way, still it adds pressure to patients who want to be on their doctors good books.

This is so ridiculous really and so easy to stop...a fine of Rs. 500 per prescription deducted from her salary will end this in a month.

Both state and central govt. have some kind provisions for these. Some are more ruthless, public sector banks, who first suspend and then fire if you own a private business.

A friend of mine is transferring his assets to his mother's name just to prevent that.

 

[Sky lord]

Both state and central govt. have some kind provisions for these. Some are more ruthless, public sector banks, who first suspend and then fire if you own a private business.

A friend of mine is transferring his assets to his mother's name just to prevent that.

Well this is not a business per se, she is not making money on this.

Obviously this is a huge breach of professional ethics.

There must be some way to simply fine this woman and be done with it. Most peoples religiosity evaporates as soon as it starts affecting their wages. It's making a mountain out of a molehill.

The person who needs a tight slap is the hospital administrator whoever he is.

 

[livingdead]

Well this is not a business per se, she is not making money on this.

Obviously this is a huge breach of professional ethics.

There must be some way to simply fine this woman and be done with it. Most peoples religiosity evaporates as soon as it starts affecting their wages. It's making a mountain out of a molehill.

The person who needs a tight slap is the hospital administrator whoever he is.

Govt of India conduct rule for their employees says participation in proselytizing activity attracts disciplinary action... not sure if Rajasthan has that clause.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

Like I told earlier people don't mind their own moles but count others ... how many Babas exploiting such cases ??? TTD conducting many spiritual programmes in every corner in Andhra .. they conduct such Program in our area.. we just don't mind because everyone have their own religious faiths and believes... some christians attended .. we don't even bother about because it is their personal choice.. when it comes to prayers within home ... many parivar attacking them lodging case on them, Using every tool available... with a free tag anti national .... I noticed a guy posted a news about a church father raping a girl... ignoring another rape by temple priest.... I will support him, if he posted both news..... members here targeting me as I wrote my view which is against them.. and they forgot many cases when I supported them against Pakistani members... recently a nutcase started abusing me for reporting another member...

I understand. Bhakts here label everyone against their view as anti national. I have got that tag too. I have known u here for long and I dont need to give anyone a patriotic certificate to u or to any Indian member out here.

The thing is, we do not need to go by the things we write here. Even Bhakts here, after venting out their anger here in pdf, shut down the lap, then hang out with their Christian and Muslim friends. I had sincerely hoped, that if any govt had taken an real "secular" stance, this problem might not have even risen up.
Secondly not so long ago, YSR was CM and he was so popular, and he was christian. TTD or for any Hindu trust is under the ambit of govt. But minority groups arent. There is a social problems, and this is not a place. Perhaps I will start a thread on it soon, tagging u.
I think we do need to discuss it

 

[livingdead]

You notice most what you don't like .. .. the thing I noticed the people who organise Ganesh, Navarathri etc. in colonies Demand more money from Christians or other families.. if they refuse to donate.. those organisers force them or abuse them... it's pretty common around here... majority vs minority... of you know thousands of Babas or mathaas are involving in such activities.. it's not that only missionaries does that...

this chanda during puja is nuisance.. these guys take money and spend on booze and drugs.. many hindus dont want to give money but there is no other option.

 

[Soulspeek]

If he brought up ISKON, you could have brought up Missionaries /Evangelists. Those are entities who can be criticized. Religious prayers of any religion are out of bounds. Hope you understand the difference. Peace.

....and it is quite another thing to keep quite when that bigot brought in ISKON in a thread related to a crazy islamist doctor.

Your silence and the silence of those who thanked you on that is duly noted.

Since you have chosen to keep quite over your fellow christians attack on hinduism, you have no moral authority to preach to me about keeping religion out. Especially since I find that most of the bigotry I find in this forum is prompted by religion.

 

[cloud_9]

And she is a doctor?
.

 

[danger007]

this chanda during puja is nuisance.. these guys take money and spend on booze and drugs.. many hindus dont want to give money but there is no other option.

yeah my point is am not treating them as Hindus rather Bunch of goons... why do we need to see everything related to religion... Be it Hinduism or Christianity or Islam... people use religion as a tool for their personal gains... just like Babas using Hinduism... am not backing any pastors or preachers ... my point is think them as particular individual . like others who post targeted threads on Christianity to demean.. I don't prefer to post news related religion even if I noticed such articles... but few members are here on that mission... most of hospitals have gods idol and puja mandir... it's a good thing some may feel a hope for them in the name of God... When you go to Christian hospital... you may see Bible or something... if you have problem.. just go to another hospital... everyone preach greatness in their own religion.. nothing wrong in it..

If he brought up ISKON, you could have brought up Missionaries /Evangelists. Those are entities who can be criticized. Religious prayers of any religion are out of bounds. Hope you understand the difference. Peace.

my post is a response... any way thanks for your post..