INDIAPOSITIVE
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Sep 20, 2014
- Messages
- 9,318
- Reaction score
- -28
- Country
- Location
Racist? International outrage over Australian cartoon showing Indians eating solar panels
The cartoon was drawn by cartoonist Bill Leak for The Australian, and immediately faced backlash on social media
TNM Staff| Monday, December 14, 2015 - 13:46
The cartoon by Bill Leak for The Australian
A cartoon in an Australian paper that shows starving Indians trying to eat solar panels has received widespread criticism and been termed 'racist'.
The cartoon comes in the backdrop of the climate deal signed in Paris where India, which is the fourth largest emitter of greenhouse gases, has also promised to curb carbon emissions.
Read:Paris Climate Deal: Neither The Polar Bear Nor The Poor Are Served
The cartoon was drawn by cartoonist Bill Leak for The Australian, and immediately faced backlash on social media. People also took shots at him, claiming that a serious accident that he had after falling from a balcony a few years ago, has made him 'racist' ever since.
Speaking to The Guardian, Amanda Wise, an associate professor of sociology at Macquarie University said “This cartoon is unequivocally racist and draws on very base stereotypes of third world, underdeveloped people who don’t know what to do with technology. India is the technology centre of the world right now and has some of the most high-tech industries on the planet in that part of the world. The underlying message is that people in developing countries don’t need all these technologies to do with climate change – they need food."
“This only demonstrates the … provincial ignorance of both the journalist, cartoonist and publication...In truth, the bewildered farmers in Leak’s cartoon could probably teach him a thing or two about solar panels, while treating him to the indisputable pleasures of mango chutney,” Shoma Chaudhury, editor of Catch News told The Guardian.
A similiar incident had occured last year when The New York Times (NYT) published a racist cartoon showing India with a cow and knocking on the “Elite Space Club” soon after the country's successful mission to Mars. Indians, made sure that the publication got to see their wrath, with a steady influx of comments on social expressing their displeasure at the cartoon, and hordes of comments demanding an apology.
Here are some of the reactions that came in from Twitter on Bill Leak's cartoon.
David Pope@davpope
How backward is Aust #climate politics? Here, the absurd racist rubbish published by Murdoch's national newspaper
4:36 AM - 14 Dec 2015
Giovanni Torre@GiovanniTorre
The next time Bill Leak falls of a ladder an Indian brain surgeon will save his life...
1:24 PM - 14 Dec 2015
the thirst noël@scottsues
do you think Bill Leak could put together a solar panel
12:36 PM - 14 Dec 2015
lana del neigh@LanaDelNeigh_
Saddest thing is how racist lowlives like Bill Leak use "free speech" as defence, like they think they're doing powerful, subversive work.
10:57 AM - 14 Dec 2015
j.r. hennessy@jrhennessy
can someone give bill leak one of those adult colouring books to entertain himself until he learns not to be racist
10:43 AM - 14 Dec 2015
Mr Denmore@MrDenmore
Hey Bill Leak, some facts on India's renewable energy sector. They're a lot smarter than your cartoons are funny. http://mnre.gov.in/
5:57 AM - 14 Dec 2015
Saint Bhakthi✔@bhakthi
*Writes email to Bill Leak explaining that brown people aren't stupid. Deletes email. Does not-stupid things with life instead*
5:09 AM - 14 Dec 2015
DeeMadigan@deemadigan
There are some fine writers at the @australian but today’s tripe on Pell and the Bill Leak cartoon do it no favours.
4:45 AM - 14 Dec 2015
Lawfarismist@RanTLaw
Imagine the stuff that Bill Leak doesn’t publish!
4:26 AM - 14 Dec 2015
elbows out tweeting@illywhacker_
Bill Leak's Wikipedia updated.
Racist? International outrage over Australian cartoon showing Indians eating solar panels | The News Minute
The cartoon was drawn by cartoonist Bill Leak for The Australian, and immediately faced backlash on social media
TNM Staff| Monday, December 14, 2015 - 13:46
The cartoon by Bill Leak for The Australian
A cartoon in an Australian paper that shows starving Indians trying to eat solar panels has received widespread criticism and been termed 'racist'.
The cartoon comes in the backdrop of the climate deal signed in Paris where India, which is the fourth largest emitter of greenhouse gases, has also promised to curb carbon emissions.
Read:Paris Climate Deal: Neither The Polar Bear Nor The Poor Are Served
The cartoon was drawn by cartoonist Bill Leak for The Australian, and immediately faced backlash on social media. People also took shots at him, claiming that a serious accident that he had after falling from a balcony a few years ago, has made him 'racist' ever since.
Speaking to The Guardian, Amanda Wise, an associate professor of sociology at Macquarie University said “This cartoon is unequivocally racist and draws on very base stereotypes of third world, underdeveloped people who don’t know what to do with technology. India is the technology centre of the world right now and has some of the most high-tech industries on the planet in that part of the world. The underlying message is that people in developing countries don’t need all these technologies to do with climate change – they need food."
“This only demonstrates the … provincial ignorance of both the journalist, cartoonist and publication...In truth, the bewildered farmers in Leak’s cartoon could probably teach him a thing or two about solar panels, while treating him to the indisputable pleasures of mango chutney,” Shoma Chaudhury, editor of Catch News told The Guardian.
A similiar incident had occured last year when The New York Times (NYT) published a racist cartoon showing India with a cow and knocking on the “Elite Space Club” soon after the country's successful mission to Mars. Indians, made sure that the publication got to see their wrath, with a steady influx of comments on social expressing their displeasure at the cartoon, and hordes of comments demanding an apology.
Here are some of the reactions that came in from Twitter on Bill Leak's cartoon.
David Pope@davpopeHow backward is Aust #climate politics? Here, the absurd racist rubbish published by Murdoch's national newspaper
4:36 AM - 14 Dec 2015
Giovanni Torre@GiovanniTorre
The next time Bill Leak falls of a ladder an Indian brain surgeon will save his life...
1:24 PM - 14 Dec 2015
the thirst noël@scottsues
do you think Bill Leak could put together a solar panel
12:36 PM - 14 Dec 2015
lana del neigh@LanaDelNeigh_
Saddest thing is how racist lowlives like Bill Leak use "free speech" as defence, like they think they're doing powerful, subversive work.
10:57 AM - 14 Dec 2015
j.r. hennessy@jrhennessy
can someone give bill leak one of those adult colouring books to entertain himself until he learns not to be racist
10:43 AM - 14 Dec 2015
Mr Denmore@MrDenmore
Hey Bill Leak, some facts on India's renewable energy sector. They're a lot smarter than your cartoons are funny. http://mnre.gov.in/
5:57 AM - 14 Dec 2015
Saint Bhakthi✔@bhakthi
*Writes email to Bill Leak explaining that brown people aren't stupid. Deletes email. Does not-stupid things with life instead*
5:09 AM - 14 Dec 2015
DeeMadigan@deemadigan
There are some fine writers at the @australian but today’s tripe on Pell and the Bill Leak cartoon do it no favours.
4:45 AM - 14 Dec 2015
Lawfarismist@RanTLaw
Imagine the stuff that Bill Leak doesn’t publish!
4:26 AM - 14 Dec 2015
elbows out tweeting@illywhacker_
Bill Leak's Wikipedia updated.
Racist? International outrage over Australian cartoon showing Indians eating solar panels | The News Minute
