What's new

Racial profiling at US airports? Here's an app for that

SajeevJino

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Nov 5, 2011
Messages
795
Reaction score
-1
Country
India
Location
Israel
passeneger-screening-chicago-airport-lg.jpg



Travelers who suspect they are victims of profiling by security screeners at US airports can now lodge a complaint in minutes, thanks to a smartphone application released on Monday.

The Sikh Coalition, supported by African American, Latino and Muslim civil rights groups, said its FlyRights app can be used by anyone who feels their rights were violated at the security barrier.

"For too long, the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) has kept a long leash on its screeners, telling them not to profile, but taking no effective measures to stop it," said its director of programs Amardeep Singh.

"Until that happens, we call on the public to hold the TSA accountable by downloading the FlyRights app and filing reports when appropriate."

According to Department of Homeland Security data, only 11 official complaints of improper TSA screening were filed in the first half of 2011 through a bureaucratic process most travelers know nothing about.

The Sikh Coalition, which speaks for the 500,000-strong Sikh American community, expects that figure to grow "exponentially" once FlyRights -- a free download for iPhone and Android -- is widely distributed.

With their turbans and beards, both expressions of their faith, Sikh Americans often found themselves mistaken for Arabs in the emotional aftermath of the September 11 attacks in 2001.

Many Muslim Americans, including women who wear the hijab, say they too have been singled out for additional TSA searches for no apparent reason other than the way they look and dress.

"It is known that profiling is not an effective means of law enforcement," said Gadeir Abbas of the Council on American-Islamic Relations.

"When we profile, we not only stigmatize the minority community, but we also do our concerns about safety a disservice."

In a sign of the app's potential scope, Singh said the very first person to use it Monday alleged she encountered gender discrimination on her way to an early-morning flight.

Building on the TSA's own complaint process, FlyRights users can specify whether they have been wrongly treated by a TSA security officer on the basis of race, religion, gender, ethnicity, nationality or disability.

It goes on to ask for flight and incident details, before the user hits a blue button and sends the complaint directly to the civil rights offices of both the TSA and Homeland Security. The Sikh Coalition gets an optional copy.

The app's key advantage, he said, is that travelers can fire off a complaint within minutes of an incident -- rather than several hours later, once they find a computer at their destination.

In an email to AFP, the TSA -- which screens two million passengers a day at more than 450 airports -- denied it uses profiling. It also appeared to dispute the need for the app, saying travellers should complain directly to it.

"TSA does not profile passengers on the basis of race, ethnicity or religion," TSA spokesman Kawika Riley said.

"We encourage any traveler with a concern about potential discrimination to contact TSA directly through our numerous channels of communication."

Prabhjit Singh, a Washington-based motivational speaker who travels extensively, alleged that he has been profiled around 30 times by TSA staff since February 2007.

The first time, he told AFP, he was ordered to submit to a pat-down of his deep-blue turban at Baltimore's BWI airport despite passing without incident through a metal detector.

In time, he said, he discovered the TSA had issued a directive calling for pat-downs of anyone wearing a turban, yarmulke or cowboy hat -- "and there really isn't any space (in a turban) to put anything."

Racial profiling at US airports? Here's an app for that
 
.
The problem is TSA doesn't allow people to use cellphones at the Immigration points. I was once held for 6 hours with 100 other Muslims for no reason at all. Just sit, they made me miss my connecting flight then called us one by one and let us go, in the whole while, one guy pulled out a cellphone the TSA lady came shouting in like he is about to do god knows. NO CELLPHONES can't you read? Sure we can but you know there are usually people outside waiting to pick us up (and mine were at the other airport I was connecting to) and we need to inform them when we are delayed at immigration for 6 hours.

So I'm pretty sure they won't let you lodge your complaint either.
 
.
^^^^welcome to the land of free (free caucasians)
 
.
My complaint with Sikh rights activists in the US is that they have no sense of minority unity. The emphasize a lot on the fact that "Hey we are different from Muslims, target your bigotry on them, not on us".
 
.
My complaint with Sikh rights activists in the US is that they have no sense of minority unity. The emphasize a lot on the fact that "Hey we are different from Muslims, target your bigotry on them, not on us".

I don't think they say go target the muslims, they just like to point out that they are not Muslims. Its not just with Sikhs though, there is hardly any unity amongst different religious groups. You won't see Muslims protesting when Hinduism is insulted, and you won't see the Hindus protesting when Islam is insulted. Bit unfair to single out the Sikhs.
 
.
My complaint with Sikh rights activists in the US is that they have no sense of minority unity. The emphasize a lot on the fact that "Hey we are different from Muslims, target your bigotry on them, not on us".

While what u say is absolutely true, but isn't it natural for the Sikhs to feel aggravated for being mistaken as Arabs?? In addition the article says that the Sikh community is being supported by African American, Latino and Muslim civil rights groups. This means that there is a consensus between various groups on this issue.

The Muslims rights groups should also come up with such initiatives so that this evil of racial profiling is done with. Personally i think it is a little bit hard for TSA though because on one hand they have to insure security for their country men but also keep in mind the sensitivities of individuals. The incident which u described above is it that they just go by ur name if it sounds Muslim or is it by appearance?? I am curious as i have never been to any foreign country till now.
 
.
I don't think they say go target the muslims, they just like to point out that they are not Muslims. Its not just with Sikhs though, there is hardly any unity amongst different religious groups. You won't see Muslims protesting when Hinduism is insulted, and you won't see the Hindus protesting when Islam is insulted. Bit unfair to single out the Sikhs.

Sikh and Muslim rights activist groups are really strong in the US. I'm sure the issue between their non-cooperation lies with the Sikhs since they like to distance themselves, Muslims would like to have a joint movement for rights.

While what u say is absolutely true, but isn't it natural for the Sikhs to feel aggravated for being mistaken as Arabs?

They can scream all their lives then and it won't work, they will still get killed for looking like Muslims. The only way is to come together and fight against racism against minorities.
 
.
My complaint with Sikh rights activists in the US is that they have no sense of minority unity. The emphasize a lot on the fact that "Hey we are different from Muslims, target your bigotry on them, not on us".

Part of that stems from the fact that they are the biggest victims of hate crimes since 9/11. The average Sikh is more likely to face a hate crime than the average Muslim.
 
.
Part of that stems from the fact that they are the biggest victims of hate crimes since 9/11. The average Sikh is more likely to face a hate crime than the average Muslim.

I really can't comment on that... Since they will just face crimes from people who can't distinguish between the two. Muslims will face crimes even from the ones that can.

But yeah, not all Muslims are bearded, but most Sikhs are so that may cause this issue. But other than violent crimes, racial profiling crimes where the immigration or TSA officer gets to see our papers and know for sure that we are Muslims.

In DC once I was in the baggage scanning line once, this Indian or Pakistani (can't be certain) TSA officer walks up to me, asks me for my passport, see the green color and says "Please come here", pulled me out of the line. Right next to the line was one of those full body gunpowder scanners. Made me get into them, it puffed some air on me. The India/Pakistani guy had left by that time this process was being taken care by full on white people. All the while the line that I was pulled out from is looking curiously and terrified like I was about to blow myself up or some bomb would be discovered off of me. Just saw my freakin green passport and that was enough for them to determine I am threat. Imagine that. If I would have shown any hesitation they might have just shot me.

In this process they had seen my tickets to Dubai and so when the entire ordeal was over the white guys brought an Arab guy who was so fakingly pleasant and he goes "Ahlan wa Sahlan ya rafeek!" Americans eventually become very nice to you once they know you are not carrying any bombs. I'm like dude, I don't speak Arabic fluently... "But you're going to Dubai!" I'm like oh god, get an education! I think he thought this was a lie. I should probably learn some Arabic to speak in America.
 
.
Asim,

You had the the time and oppurtunity---you should have killed OBL and his cohorts on the slopes of Tora Bora----you should also have killed those pakistanis who wanted to fight jihad in afghanistan as enemy of the state of afghanistan----.

OBL was already a dead man 10 + years ago----an enlightened and intelligent nation would have had its millitary help round him up killed him and sent him in a package to the u s----they should also have killed all the insurgents like Sheikh M and Abu Zubeida etc etc etc and sent them in a package to the u s rather than capturing them alive----.

My young friend----you are and you will pay the price of the sacrifices that you did not make in time and so will the next generation to come.

Pakistanis need to love themselves first---and stop kissing the feet of those in an Abbayyia and Jubba---and don't make it the safe haven for those committing acts of death and defiance in other nations.
 
. .
I really can't comment on that... Since they will just face crimes from people who can't distinguish between the two. Muslims will face crimes even from the ones that can.

But yeah, not all Muslims are bearded, but most Sikhs are so that may cause this issue. But other than violent crimes, racial profiling crimes where the immigration or TSA officer gets to see our papers and know for sure that we are Muslims.

In DC once I was in the baggage scanning line once, this Indian or Pakistani (can't be certain) TSA officer walks up to me, asks me for my passport, see the green color and says "Please come here", pulled me out of the line. Right next to the line was one of those full body gunpowder scanners. Made me get into them, it puffed some air on me. The India/Pakistani guy had left by that time this process was being taken care by full on white people. All the while the line that I was pulled out from is looking curiously and terrified like I was about to blow myself up or some bomb would be discovered off of me. Just saw my freakin green passport and that was enough for them to determine I am threat. Imagine that. If I would have shown any hesitation they might have just shot me.

In this process they had seen my tickets to Dubai and so when the entire ordeal was over the white guys brought an Arab guy who was so fakingly pleasant and he goes "Ahlan wa Sahlan ya rafeek!" Americans eventually become very nice to you once they know you are not carrying any bombs. I'm like dude, I don't speak Arabic fluently... "But you're going to Dubai!" I'm like oh god, get an education! I think he thought this was a lie. I should probably learn some Arabic to speak in America.

I got pulled out of the line at JFK once as well. Its not pleasant, its actually scary, not to mention pretty humiliating what with our baggage wrt the white man, but that's how it is. You want to do business there, you grit your teeth and carry on.
 
.
I really can't comment on that... Since they will just face crimes from people who can't distinguish between the two. Muslims will face crimes even from the ones that can.

But yeah, not all Muslims are bearded, but most Sikhs are so that may cause this issue. But other than violent crimes, racial profiling crimes where the immigration or TSA officer gets to see our papers and know for sure that we are Muslims.

In DC once I was in the baggage scanning line once, this Indian or Pakistani (can't be certain) TSA officer walks up to me, asks me for my passport, see the green color and says "Please come here", pulled me out of the line. Right next to the line was one of those full body gunpowder scanners. Made me get into them, it puffed some air on me. The India/Pakistani guy had left by that time this process was being taken care by full on white people. All the while the line that I was pulled out from is looking curiously and terrified like I was about to blow myself up or some bomb would be discovered off of me. Just saw my freakin green passport and that was enough for them to determine I am threat. Imagine that. If I would have shown any hesitation they might have just shot me.

In this process they had seen my tickets to Dubai and so when the entire ordeal was over the white guys brought an Arab guy who was so fakingly pleasant and he goes "Ahlan wa Sahlan ya rafeek!" Americans eventually become very nice to you once they know you are not carrying any bombs. I'm like dude, I don't speak Arabic fluently... "But you're going to Dubai!" I'm like oh god, get an education! I think he thought this was a lie. I should probably learn some Arabic to speak in America.


On my trip to Dubai I am sure sporting a beard I will have a pleasant experience :)
 
.
I've been all over the world. The only airport where I had trouble, was when I took a connecting flight through South Korea.

Since I guess they were looking for the "East Asian" type.

American airports are a nightmare though, and I tend to avoid going to America for any reason. My relatives live in Canada anyway.
 
. .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom