What's new

PTM holds rally at Bannu, calls for unity among Pakhtun leaders

Agree. East of Indus merges with India while West of Indus merges with Afghanistan and Iran.

List one ethnicity group in India that want to merge east of indus with India. You wont find one thats because they want to break away from India.
 
List one ethnicity group in India that want to merge east of indus with India. You wont find one thats because they want to break away from India.

Why don't you can ask Sidhu if he wants east and west Punjab to be merged or not?

Were you just not advocating for ethno-states? According to your rationality and logic, India should be divided into 30 different states.

Indics are a mixed race to start with. So they fall into a single mixed ethnic category.
 
Why don't you can ask Sidhu if he wants east and west Punjab to be merged or not?



Indics are a mixed race to start with. So they fall into a single mixed ethnic category.
Sidhu doesnot matter his elders showed us a lot of love we all remember that
 
Your argument is like the position during cold war when people said Germans can never unite. Yes political forces tried to divide them but today Germans are a signle & a strong nation. This is going to be repeated in the case of Koreans, Pushtuns and Kurds. Politics can delay but cannot prevent ethnic unity forever.

Once again, you're argument is flawed. East Germany and west Germany are STILL politically and economically divided. In Bavaria in particular, nazism and far right fascism is still deeply rooted, while in the west, the politics is mainly left wing. The two frequently argue over the future of germany, and this has divided many germans on what Germany's future should look like.

The Libyan/Syrian refugee crises showed just how divided Germany still is.

Not to mention the economic gap between the former east and west German states. What was once called east Germany is STILL poor, and there is still rampant violence there. On top of that, there are many east germans that do no like being a part of a united germany.

You are misreading the elections. PTI won in KPK because Pushtuns see IK as their great Pushtun leader.

Okay, let's ask @Pakhtoon yum . If you were to vote for IK, would you vote for him because he's Pashtun? Or because of his political beliefs?

@PaulSimon your views here are blatantly racist. Pashtun people are not a hive mind, they don't all believe the same thing. If they did, there wouldn't be 3 different parties (PTI, ANP, PTM) with sizable Pashtun members.

PTI won in Punjab as there are sizable Pushtuns in Punjab too. IK himself is a Pushtun from Punjab.

https://tigerkhan007.blogspot.com/2017/08/pakistan-census-2017-pashtun-population.html

Tuesday, August 29, 2017
Below is the approximate Pashtun population of Pakistan. The population of FATA has been grossly understated in Census 2017 (IDPs during operation in South Waziristan exceeded 1.5 million). According to my calculation the population of FATA has to be around 8-10 million. Furthermore, the percentage in my estimation of Pashtuns in non-Pashtun areas has also been very conservative, however, i am of the opinion that the below numbers give us some idea of the population of Pashtuns in Pakistan.



I have come across many studies that puts Pashtun population solely in Karachi at around 7 million. Furthermore, in case of Punjab, there is Pashtun indigenous population in Attock and Mianwali district, in addition to the migration of Pashtuns to major cities of Punjab due to economic reasons. Finally, war on terror has pushed many pashtuns to Sindh and Punjab which has to be considered.
The Pashtun voter base in Punjab is small, while it can sway certain electoral results, it's not enough to win the elections. The Pashtun voter base in Punjab is important to shore up support, but expecting to win punjab with only pashtun voters is extremely stupid.

You yourself are misreading the population census and election results.
 
Last edited:
Inka konsa mandate hy do seats aur aik mangey ki fata election mein to wo bhi nahi
So was PTI”M” when Khan has only one seat, Ye Khan tou Bohat bolta thha. Hundi se peisa bhejo, Police ko Maro, General patloon mein Peishab Kar deta hai Buzdil hai, attack on PTV on Parliment, attack on police mobile to rescue comrades etc etc.
Anyway
Maro jo bhi awaz nikale
 
So was PTI”M” when Khan has only one seat, Ye Khan tou Bohat bolta thha. Hundi se peisa bhejo, Police ko Maro, General patloon mein Peishab Kar deta hai Buzdil hai, attack on PTV on Parliment, attack on police mobile to rescue comrades etc etc.
Anyway
Maro jo bhi awaz nikale
Janab inki seats giri hein in sey to andron e khana anp ka bhi phada hy inka tamam manjan hi flop hy jalso mein afghani bula letey hein
Ethnic politics is dying in Pakistan yhe sooner nefarious elements in US state department realize it the better
 
The Pashtun voter base in Punjab is small, while it can sway certain electoral results, it's not enough to win the elections. The Pashtun voter base in Punjab is important to shore up support, but expecting to win punjab with only pashtun voters is extremely stupid.

You yourself are misreading the population census and election results.

The populist and punjab oriented pashtoon electoral strength couldn't win PTI that much large chunk of Punjabi seats if it wasn't for the more ethnic rural vote bank. People got fed up of navaz bros using state power for propping up their one biradri in every nook and cranny and in many cases going over the board to facilitate them at the expense of established businesses - - - - - - -.
 
So was PTI”M” when Khan has only one seat, Ye Khan tou Bohat bolta thha. Hundi se peisa bhejo, Police ko Maro, General patloon mein Peishab Kar deta hai Buzdil hai, attack on PTV on Parliment, attack on police mobile to rescue comrades etc etc.
Anyway
Maro jo bhi awaz nikale
Next election aik seat bhi nahi miley mi aur inka voter anp kha jaye gi
 
Is PAKISTAN becoming Pakhtunistan ? We do not want PAKISTAN to become a tribal republic, a path to destruction.
 
Janab inki seats giri hein in sey to andron e khana anp ka bhi phada hy inka tamam manjan hi flop hy jalso mein afghani bula letey hein
Ethnic politics is dying in Pakistan yhe sooner nefarious elements in US state department realize it the better
That’s why i said Bhai
Maro jo bhi awaz nikale, be like west or be like China, we are munafiq always pick between that and we have messed like that.
I personally don’t care if once freakin clean all the mess and OPER WALE take control of country for at least 50 years then give it to someone sincere.
 

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom