What's new

PTI claims improvement in K-P, but the tales of Nathiagali speak otherwise

Devil Soul

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
22,931
Reaction score
45
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
PTI claims improvement in K-P, but the tales of Nathiagali speak otherwise
By Aaminah Qadir Published: July 21, 2015
28652-image-1437469473-930-640x480.png

Landslides, destruction and chaos on the roads leading into Nathiagali. PHOTO: AAMINAH QADIR

I spent my childhood playing in daisy-filled meadows, walking the pakdandis and exploring the narrow roads of Nathiagali. I have drifted along these pakdandis for miles, getting lost in the green hills only to be brought home by the villagers who witnessed us growing up. My family and I are blessed that we can flee to the Galiyats, escaping the hustle bustle and frenzy that has seeped into almost every other city in Pakistan.

The hill station has been my parents and grandparents retreat of choice since the 60s. This year brings the fourth generation of our family to the Galiyats at a tender age of just nine months. Over these decades, Nathiagali has become our home and the people residing in the villages surrounding it have become our extended family. The residents of Nathiagali have taken over the preservation of its unique charm personally by planting over 150,000 trees. They also started a local ambulance service and have uplifted the educational standards of schools. And hence, predictably, any destruction of my home evokes strong emotions in me.

What has set Nathiagali apart from other hill stations is how it remains in its natural state — untouched. The occasional VIP movement shakes the peace — whether they are passing through to go to the governor’s or chief minister’s house — but they all pass, leaving behind the quaint town with its residents and its narrow roads. The hill station has been conserved, because unlike Murree and other once-beautiful hill stations, its care has been left to the people who live within it. That is until the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf’s (PTI) government came into power in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) with its lofty plans to expand roads and tourism.

Let me clarify — I am a proponent of increasing tourism, as are the shopkeepers and locals I have consulted. The K-P government’s plan to open guesthouses to the public is promising; this will provide tourism spaces that once belonged solely to government and army personnel. I am hopeful the plan will be mindful about the importance of proper maintenance of facilities and historic spaces.

However, their intention to make these free or cheap for the public is misguided. Heritage sites such as the ones they have now opened up to the public are preserved by charging top-dollar worldwide. Furthermore, the previously government-run chalets called the “Sarhad Tourism Chalets” are run-down and dilapidated, due to a lack of adequate maintenance.

None of the locals are willing to stand by and watch the destruction and defacing of their hometown; one of the rare few places free from the clutches of our short-sighted and ill-planned leadership. Shopkeepers say that they find no logical reason to expand the roads of the bazaar (market) — the project the government has embarked on — as tourism is peaking, even before such expansion. They complain construction was at a standstill the entire year and only resumed in the last six weeks of summer, during peak tourist season, with no management present which is clearly hampering this tourist season currently underway.

Consequently, the bazaar is ridden with slush, landslides and overflowing water, and age-old trees are being cut at random. Many in the marketplace are disillusioned; they say the new government has destroyed Nathiagali beyond repair, that it can never be restored to its original state. Shopkeepers complain their business has seen a decline since the beginning of the project and worry things won’t pick up if the area’s sanctity isn’t safeguarded.

Ultimately, the government fails to recognise the problem is of management, that wider roads will not alleviate traffic problems as there are no policemen or government officials supervising the streets or the construction work. It is heart breaking to witness the PTI government ruin the character of a beautiful hill station — a hefty price to pay for wide roads. After all, small hill stations and towns in Europe and America have flourishing tourism industries with small, winding roads, so why can’t we?

Below is the story in pictures:

1.png

This road leading to the Nathiagali Bazaar was constructed during the British Raj. It has been demolished in order to construct a dual carriageway. Shopkeepers say the government has “ruined” the bazaar.

2.png

A view of the 40-feet deep parking lot that was set to be constructed. Locals say the government has now abandoned the idea of a lot, and is simply extending the road, obstructing current access to the shops.

3.png

Age-old trees destroyed. Could they not have been avoided?

4.png

Here is a picture of a newly carpeted road. Why have these trees been cut when they are clearly not obstructing the road path? The management displays a sheer lack of care for the few regions of Pakistan that remain in their natural, beautiful state.

5.png

A 200 year old tree cut and destroyed.

6.png


7.png

Landslides, destruction and chaos on the roads leading into Nathiagali.
 
.
8.png

The township I strive to preserve.

In light of the above, I question Malik Amin Aslam, the architect of the PTI’s green growth initiative, about the efficacy of his Billion Tree Tsunami project (quoted by Rina Khan in Dawn).

Is PTI implementing a policy whereby every 100 trees chopped down in Nathiagali will be planted elsewhere? I fail to understand this “creeping green revolution” after seeing 200-year-old trees, which can easily be preserved, being destroyed on a daily basis on the pretext of “development”. The way the expansion project has been at a hiatus for the last 10 months is testament to an inefficient government’s effort and to what lies in store in the future for my home. Some argue the PTI is taking positive action in K-P, but the reality in Nathiagali says otherwise.

I urge everyone to press Imran Khan to bring an end to deforestation in Nathiagali. What does it say about our leadership, Mr Khan, knowing that we cannot even preserve a township of approximately 50,000 people?

All photos: Aaminah Qadir
Aaminah Qadir
The author is an aspiring politician. She has completed her undergraduate degree in Global Affairs at Yale and is currently studying Law at the University of Cambridge. She tweets as @AaminahQ

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.
 
.
PTI claims improvement in K-P, but the tales of Nathiagali speak otherwise
By Aaminah Qadir Published: July 21, 2015
28652-image-1437469473-930-640x480.png

Landslides, destruction and chaos on the roads leading into Nathiagali. PHOTO: AAMINAH QADIR

I spent my childhood playing in daisy-filled meadows, walking the pakdandis and exploring the narrow roads of Nathiagali. I have drifted along these pakdandis for miles, getting lost in the green hills only to be brought home by the villagers who witnessed us growing up. My family and I are blessed that we can flee to the Galiyats, escaping the hustle bustle and frenzy that has seeped into almost every other city in Pakistan.

The hill station has been my parents and grandparents retreat of choice since the 60s. This year brings the fourth generation of our family to the Galiyats at a tender age of just nine months. Over these decades, Nathiagali has become our home and the people residing in the villages surrounding it have become our extended family. The residents of Nathiagali have taken over the preservation of its unique charm personally by planting over 150,000 trees. They also started a local ambulance service and have uplifted the educational standards of schools. And hence, predictably, any destruction of my home evokes strong emotions in me.

What has set Nathiagali apart from other hill stations is how it remains in its natural state — untouched. The occasional VIP movement shakes the peace — whether they are passing through to go to the governor’s or chief minister’s house — but they all pass, leaving behind the quaint town with its residents and its narrow roads. The hill station has been conserved, because unlike Murree and other once-beautiful hill stations, its care has been left to the people who live within it. That is until the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf’s (PTI) government came into power in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) with its lofty plans to expand roads and tourism.

Let me clarify — I am a proponent of increasing tourism, as are the shopkeepers and locals I have consulted. The K-P government’s plan to open guesthouses to the public is promising; this will provide tourism spaces that once belonged solely to government and army personnel. I am hopeful the plan will be mindful about the importance of proper maintenance of facilities and historic spaces.

However, their intention to make these free or cheap for the public is misguided. Heritage sites such as the ones they have now opened up to the public are preserved by charging top-dollar worldwide. Furthermore, the previously government-run chalets called the “Sarhad Tourism Chalets” are run-down and dilapidated, due to a lack of adequate maintenance.

None of the locals are willing to stand by and watch the destruction and defacing of their hometown; one of the rare few places free from the clutches of our short-sighted and ill-planned leadership. Shopkeepers say that they find no logical reason to expand the roads of the bazaar (market) — the project the government has embarked on — as tourism is peaking, even before such expansion. They complain construction was at a standstill the entire year and only resumed in the last six weeks of summer, during peak tourist season, with no management present which is clearly hampering this tourist season currently underway.

Consequently, the bazaar is ridden with slush, landslides and overflowing water, and age-old trees are being cut at random. Many in the marketplace are disillusioned; they say the new government has destroyed Nathiagali beyond repair, that it can never be restored to its original state. Shopkeepers complain their business has seen a decline since the beginning of the project and worry things won’t pick up if the area’s sanctity isn’t safeguarded.

Ultimately, the government fails to recognise the problem is of management, that wider roads will not alleviate traffic problems as there are no policemen or government officials supervising the streets or the construction work. It is heart breaking to witness the PTI government ruin the character of a beautiful hill station — a hefty price to pay for wide roads. After all, small hill stations and towns in Europe and America have flourishing tourism industries with small, winding roads, so why can’t we?

Below is the story in pictures:

1.png

This road leading to the Nathiagali Bazaar was constructed during the British Raj. It has been demolished in order to construct a dual carriageway. Shopkeepers say the government has “ruined” the bazaar.

2.png

A view of the 40-feet deep parking lot that was set to be constructed. Locals say the government has now abandoned the idea of a lot, and is simply extending the road, obstructing current access to the shops.

3.png

Age-old trees destroyed. Could they not have been avoided?

4.png

Here is a picture of a newly carpeted road. Why have these trees been cut when they are clearly not obstructing the road path? The management displays a sheer lack of care for the few regions of Pakistan that remain in their natural, beautiful state.

5.png

A 200 year old tree cut and destroyed.

6.png


7.png

Landslides, destruction and chaos on the roads leading into Nathiagali.
Putin-Ukraine-meme.jpg
 
.
So destruction from natural disaster are now being blamed on PTI....Wow WHAT a powerful party it can command nature

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Had PTI built a road and it got uprooted with the tree or had they built a metro station and it started looking like Venice this claim would have some stand.....But when previous party never built anything, and now party is just adjusting in their first year ....People with common sense wouldnt throw such allegations....


Suprisingly same people give a blind eye to 1 party in Punjab since 7 yrs who still cant mitigate the destruction from natural disasters and they expect a party in their 1st yr to do soo.... :woot: THAT is not only high expectations but shows BIASED BS!

That is until the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf’s (PTI) government came into power in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) with its lofty plans to expand roads and tourism.
And then people wonder why PTI doesnt make metro in KPK or make more roads and why they dont exploit tourism....Maybe some need to start wondering what the people want not what OUTSIDERs supporting another party think the locals want ...

However, their intention to make these free or cheap for the public is misguided. Heritage sites such as the ones they have now opened up to the public are preserved by charging top-dollar worldwide. Furthermore, the previously government-run chalets called the “Sarhad Tourism Chalets” are run-down and dilapidated, due to a lack of adequate maintenance.

None of the locals are willing to stand by and watch the destruction and defacing of their hometown; one of the rare few places free from the clutches of our short-sighted and ill-planned leadership. Shopkeepers say that they find no logical reason to expand the roads of the bazaar (market) — the project the government has embarked on — as tourism is peaking, even before such expansion. They complain construction was at a standstill the entire year and only resumed in the last six weeks of summer, during peak tourist season, with no management present which is clearly hampering this tourist season currently underway.
Surprise surprise....People in Punjab feel sorry for KPK to not have large wide roads and no metro like and here are people who dont want it...Wonder whom to listen to...

Ultimately, the government fails to recognise the problem is of management, that wider roads will not alleviate traffic problems as there are no policemen or government officials supervising the streets or the construction work. It is heart breaking to witness the PTI government ruin the character of a beautiful hill station — a hefty price to pay for wide roads. After all, small hill stations and towns in Europe and America have flourishing tourism industries with small, winding roads, so why can’t we?
Looks like someone is really sick of roads :unsure:

3.png

Age-old trees destroyed. Could they not have been avoided?

4.png

Here is a picture of a newly carpeted road. Why have these trees been cut when they are clearly not obstructing the road path? The management displays a sheer lack of care for the few regions of Pakistan that remain in their natural, beautiful state.

5.png

A 200 year old tree cut and destroyed.
Honestly speaking none of the trees look like they have been cut...unless PTI is mother nature :unsure:

OR they have pathetic machinery that they couldnt cut properly...

Landslides, destruction and chaos on the roads leading into Nathiagali.
How is this linked to PTI is beyond me...

Is PTI implementing a policy whereby every 100 trees chopped down in Nathiagali will be planted elsewhere? I fail to understand this “creeping green revolution” after seeing 200-year-old trees, which can easily be preserved, being destroyed on a daily basis on the pretext of “development”. The way the expansion project has been at a hiatus for the last 10 months is testament to an inefficient government’s effort and to what lies in store in the future for my home. Some argue the PTI is taking positive action in K-P, but the reality in Nathiagali says otherwise.
If this is true it should def be stopped....But if it is mother nature and the blame is landing on PTI then this venting should def stop too!
 
.
So destruction from natural disaster are now being blamed on PTI....Wow WHAT a powerful party it can command nature

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Had PTI built a road and it got uprooted with the tree or had they built a metro station and it started looking like Venice this claim would have some stand.....But when previous party never built anything, and now party is just adjusting in their first year ....People with common sense wouldnt throw such allegations....


Suprisingly same people give a blind eye to 1 party in Punjab since 7 yrs who still cant mitigate the destruction from natural disasters and they expect a party in their 1st yr to do soo.... :woot: THAT is not only high expectations but shows BIASED BS!


And then people wonder why PTI doesnt make metro in KPK or make more roads and why they dont exploit tourism....Maybe some need to start wondering what the people want not what OUTSIDERs supporting another party think the locals want ...


Surprise surprise....People in Punjab feel sorry for KPK to not have large wide roads and no metro like and here are people who dont want it...Wonder whom to listen to...


Looks like someone is really sick of roads :unsure:


Honestly speaking none of the trees look like they have been cut...unless PTI is mother nature :unsure:

OR they have pathetic machinery that they couldnt cut properly...


How is this linked to PTI is beyond me...


If this is true it should def be stopped....But if it is mother nature and the blame is landing on PTI then this venting should def stop too!
I want to confront you really bad for your arguments but I'll let it slide this time. :enjoy:
 
. .
kiyun? kiya PTI "really" commends nature? :woot:
No but its in the government whose responsibility is to ensure natural disasters bring minimum damage. Plus those trees dont look like mother nature took them away they look cut. :woot:
You're asking for it.:tsk:
 
.
No but its in the government whose responsibility is to ensure natural disasters bring minimum damage. Plus those trees dont look like mother nature took them away they look cut. :woot:
You're asking for it.:tsk:
They look cut? I you telling me that is how people in Pakistan "cut" a tree for development? Looks like something a landslide damaged after some lightning struck it!

2nd yes govt's responsibility to MINIMIZE not to END natural disasters....
 
.
They look cut? I you telling me that is how people in Pakistan "cut" a tree for development? Looks like something a landslide damaged after some lightning struck it!

2nd yes govt's responsibility to MINIMIZE not to END natural disasters....
They look cut. How can a land slide do this to such old trees.:pissed:
There are a few more things about your post but you don't seem to be that enthusiastic either so let it go.:sarcastic:
 
.
They look cut. How can a land slide do this to such old trees.:pissed:
They are old trees....in the mountains...takes 1 heavy rock to smash an old tree...I am not talking about the tree stump reaching the stump stage but the hacking done left and right

There are a few more things about your post but you don't seem to be that enthusiastic either so let it go.:sarcastic:
I prob dont know the situation at hand but:

3.png

Age-old trees destroyed. Could they not have been avoided?

4.png

Here is a picture of a newly carpeted road. Why have these trees been cut when they are clearly not obstructing the road path? The management displays a sheer lack of care for the few regions of Pakistan that remain in their natural, beautiful state.

5.png

A 200 year old tree cut and destroyed.



6.png

This is what nature can do:

Torres.jpg


bloomberg_1465641c.jpg


The hacking does look like they were hacked...but not all the pix look like something human did ...Unless they are incompetent and didnt do it well

This is how man made tree stumps look like:

s8.jpg


05-4-saw.jpg
 
.
They are old trees....in the mountains...takes 1 heavy rock to smash an old tree...I am not talking about the tree stump reaching the stump stage but the hacking done left and right
I don't know that much about trees but from what I've heard I think older trees have stronger roots and all. But they do look axed.
 
.
I don't know that much about trees but from what I've heard I think older trees have stronger roots and all. But they do look axed.
Yes they have stronger roots and the roots are looking ok-ish in the hill...However the bark looks like someone had a practice with a new axe not something one would do when wanting to build a road....More like vandalizing or just immature people hired to do the cutting...
 
.
i wonder why these morons never written any article against PML N PPP for not stopping deforestation who had governments many times in both federal and provincial governments ... its only PTI who is banging timber mafia in kpk
 
.
i wonder why these morons never written any article against PML N PPP for not stopping deforestation who had governments many times in both federal and provincial governments ... its only PTI who is banging timber mafia in kpk
Or why no one gave details about how new metro station got flooded without flood controls :unsure:

Or how this happens every year since a very long time but "RESPONSIBLE GOVERNMENT" HASNT been able to solve it:

11781839_851745094911146_1844913885814445238_n.jpg


but its in the government whose responsibility is to ensure natural disasters bring minimum damage.
Damage minimizing since 7 yrs :woot:

VS 2nd yr of new govt :unsure:

Lets see:

SS:

17thChief Minister of Punjab

In office
8 June 2008 – 26 March 2013

3rdPresident of Pakistan Muslim League (N)

In office
20 February 1997 – 12 October 1999

1stExecutive Vice President of Pakistan Muslim League (N)
In office
30 September 2002 – 27 July 2011

And we still havent MINIMIZED floods in Punjab :cray:
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom