What's new

Poverty shocks student on India trip

Status
Not open for further replies.

grey boy 2

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 23, 2009
Messages
6,484
Reaction score
-2
Country
China
Location
United States
Poverty shocks student on India Trip : Knight Errant
written by Mary MusilekApril 21, 2010

A three night stay on a house boat in Kerala, a night on the beach at the Arabian Sea, and a visit to the Taj Mahal are only a few of the experiences that seven BSM students had while traveling to India over Spring Break. However, doing service work at an elementary school and an elderly home, as well as seeing the enormous poverty in the country, were among the more shocking and memorable moments of the trip.

When asked what moment of the trip really struck them, the students overwhelmingly said seeing the poverty, even over going to a tiger preserve, riding elephants, touring a marble factory, and helping house wives make baskets. “For sure the most shocking thing we saw there was the extreme poverty. It is something that was so hard to comprehend, so many people just live as beggars on the streets and have nothing to their name,” said sophomore Sarah Silvestri.

After learning that one third of the population lives below the poverty line, the group saw more poverty than they ever expected. “We saw villages where every house, if you can even call them that, was made out of torn cloth and rocks piled on top of one another,” said Silvestri.

Students were exposed to even more poverty when they visited an elderly home. “This was not a home as you probably picture, it was a shed and a yard where 150 people live. There were no beds and only a couple of benches, so most people sleep outside on the dirt,” said Silvestri. Students described that the people that lived at the home sat around all day and didn’t even have proper bathrooms. “Their shower was a hose and their bathroom was a bucket filled with urine and feces because no one wanted to empty it,” said Luther.

The yard is home to many mentally challenged adults that a monk took in off the street, and this really had an impact on some of the BSM students. “It was sad because all of those people were on the street because their families didn’t want them anymore and so one monk went around and helped them all,” said Luther.

For many, traveling to a third world country is a new experience and provides a new view of the world. “It opened my eyes to see the level of poverty in the world, and it made me more grateful for what I have,” said sophomore Melissa Luther.

This trip was more than a vacation for these students, many of them came home with a new perspective. “It made me realize that people say ‘I want…,’ here when there, they don’t even say, ‘I need…,’ they just live with what they have,” said Luther. Silvestri also felt a shift in the way she viewed her life after visiting India. “This trip made me realize that for some reason I was born into a life of extreme blessing and luxury while these people, who I am no better than, are born into a life of poverty and challenge that is nothing like what I have to deal with,” said Silvestri, “yet everyone there seemed so happy with what they had and content. It was humbling and made me realize how selfish my life is.”

Coming from a country where population and pollution aren’t that big of a problem, students were shocked by what they saw of both of these in India. “There is garbage everywhere, just piled along the sides of the streets or filling up open fields,” said Silvestri, “literally the only garbage can I saw was at the Taj Mahal.” Coming home made students realize the extent of the pollution even more so. “It was a little weird coming back to Minnesota because of the temperature difference and the cleanness of our air,” said junior Allie Ison, “their air is so dirty because of all the pollution.” And in regards to overcrowding, Silvestri commented on the amount of traffic in India. “The driving there was crazy. If there was a three lane street, there would be five cars going across it,” said Silvestri.

Not all of what the BSM students saw was sad or shocking, though.
“The school was a much more uplifting and joyous experience. These children have limited resources, however they were full of laughter and very smart,” said Silvestri, “it gives you hope for the next generation, however you realize many of these kids will not be able to afford college so breaking their cycle of poverty will be extremely difficult.”

After an experience like the one these seven students went on, it doesn’t seem shocking that the students hope to continue doing service and learning more about third world countries in the future. “I saw how much they were in need of the help and so I would easily go to another third world country,” said Luther.

Silvestri even feels that there was a deeper reason to her going on this trip than just experiencing a different culture for herself. “I know there was a reason I went on the trip and that I need to share my experience with others and continue to use my multiply resources to help improve the poverty and the living conditions of the people we were exposed too,” said Silvestri.
 
.
another thread is started on indian poverty ,same answers with same ques,with same post
 
.
another thread is started on indian poverty ,same answers with same ques,with same post

and by the same Chinese guy too.
I hope the politicians of India are half the concerned like our good buddy greyboy.

@ grey boy2- good job buddy. Thanks for reminding us again and again that there are still needy and poor. Your posts are an eye opener, will give money equivalent to 10 yuan the next time i see a poor man.

Thanks again. Keep up the good work.:cheers::smitten:
 
.
another thread is started on indian poverty ,same answers with same ques,with same post

Did you even care to read the arcticle ? i guess not,

Its a about the view of American students after visiting your country,

By burying your head in the sand simply won't change the reality if

its the "Hard Cold Facts" period. :smitten::pakistan::china:
 
.
There is garbage everywhere, just piled along the sides of the streets or filling up open fields,” said Silvestri, “literally the only garbage can I saw was at the Taj Mahal.”

This is public toilet in Bombay!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
Did you even care to read the arcticle ? i guess not,

Its a about the view of American students after visiting your country,

By burying your head in the sand simply won't change the reality if

its the "Hard Cold Facts" period. :smitten::pakistan::china:

i read the article,we know the reality that our 37% population is bpl,wat do u expect frm us,we know wat we r,now it's ur time to mind ur business and control ur poverty left.after finishing ur task come and hepl india to do so:cheers::cheers:
 
.
What is it with their obsession with crap?

India's crap*
 
.
.
these are facts about india and indian memebrs should admit it.

India is a super duper state only in the minds of india's netizens on ground the situation is quite bleek.
 
.
In this video u can clearly see its a mentally retarded poor fellow.

Twisting it as public toilet shows your true colors and the unlimited hatred you have against Indians and India in general.

How pathetic the level of thought some people have. I pity you.

The video seems to be made by an American tourist , you can hear his say things.

He must have seen the ads about 'incredible india' but what he saw when he landed in india was quite different.

So you think the American guy who made this video hates india ?!
 
.
these are facts about india and indian memebrs should admit it.

India is a super duper state only in the minds of india's netizens on ground the situation is quite bleek.

Nobody ever , i repeat ever have said India is a developed nation full of rich people.

If you want somebody to admit that there are poor people in India , i will do that for your mental satisfaction.

We get more reports on poverty, poverty alleviation, sanitation, sanitation schemes, drinking water problems, solutions for it in our daily Indian newspapers. We don't need a third party to point it out for us each day in a defense forum.

I am happy that these problems are not there in your country and is the only unique feature of the poor India.
 
Last edited:
.
Sometimes i just wonder about my Indian friends here, when a thread

positive to India, you guys jump in joy, when a negative one comes

up you are piss, either doing your usual name calling personal attacks

or by derailing the thread with trolling for the purpose of getting the

thread lock.

May i remind you no matter how hard you try, you ain't changing

nothing but a "poor loser mentality in full display"
:smitten::pakistan::china:
 
.
watever india is only due to the contribution of the pc of population,india is a super state and will remain to do so.if u have enough guts,then cross india.u will get to know who is super and who is failed one.i think u getting my point:pakistan::pakistan:



Dont fall into the level of a person whose only thoughts and words are same like what we saw in that video.

We cant argue and win,. They are a rich country with 100% sanitation and no poor people.Lets learn from them.
 
.
Sometimes i just wonder about my Indian friends here, when a thread

positive to India, you guys jump in joy, when a negative one comes

up you are piss, either doing your usual name calling personal attacks

or by derailing the thread with trolling for the purpose of getting the

thread lock.

May i remind you no matter how hard you try, you ain't changing

nothing but a "poor loser mentality in full display"
:smitten::pakistan::china:

well done rich boy. Come on everybody jump with joy. greyboy has given us another debatable thread. again..
 
.
well done rich boy. Come on everybody jump with joy. greyboy has given us another debatable thread. again..

This is the last reply to you, your attempt of trying to drag me to

your level failed.

Once again, stop your name calling personal attack, if you had nothing

contribute to this thread, will you kindly "Bug Off" thanks in advance.
:smitten::pakistan::china:
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom