PLA Officer's view on the tactical situation of the LAC

[Figaro]

Via SiegeCrossbow over at SDF

Background : I found this analysis (starting 3:55) from an ex PLA military officer of the Nanjing military district (pre-reform) and there are actually a lot of solid analysis from a pure military standpoint. Way better than the usual chest thumping rants from both Indian and Chinese amateurs.

Key points : The officer takes the Indian threat very seriously but pointed out several baffling strategic decisions from the Indian side and the most egregious of which is stationing so many troops near the LAC. Not only are they covered by PLA artillery fire, but they present a huge logistical liability come winter. He also pointed out that Indian infrastructure in the area are prone to destruction by Chinese and Pakistani forces and should India launch an attack, they’d be at a disadvantage since China holds several strategic choke points.

https://www.ixigua.com/6858919717826986499?logTag=r-pGYrhg5Rz5qm5KowqES

 

[Feng Leng]

The video is excellent. Indian Army has no choice but to attack within the next four months or else withdraw their troops in a humiliating manner. If they attack, they may choose either armor movements in the Depsang plains or along the north and south banks of Pangong Lake. Either way, Indian Army is terrified of the H-6 strategic bombers that we deployed in the theater.

 

[flowerfan2020]

Look guys I know we all want a nice little war to settle the scores but let's be honest. There won't be any. Delhi is ruled by a bunch of c**ks. Beijing is ruled by a bunch of bigger c**ks. Was is too difficult to release the footage from Galwan/officially declare Chinese causality figures? Nope. But they didn't. They didn't protest against any of India's claims. All we got was the usual moronic Geng Shuang emulator talking about "muh territorial integrity".


Learn from RT/TRT/CNN.

All of Thise

Look guys I know we all want a nice little war to settle the scores but let's be honest. There won't be any. Delhi is ruled by a bunch of c**ks. Beijing is ruled by a bunch of bigger c**ks. Was is too difficult to release the footage from Galwan/officially declare Chinese causality figures? Nope. But they didn't. They didn't protest against any of India's claims. All we got was the usual moronic Geng Shuang emulator talking about "muh territorial integrity".

Learn from RT/TRT/CNN.

If Indian so sure Chinese has causality why not release some footage from your side? I am sure the Indian has carried cameras all the time.

 

[Dark1]

Look guys I know we all want a nice little war to settle the scores but let's be honest. There won't be any. Delhi is ruled by a bunch of c**ks. Beijing is ruled by a bunch of bigger c**ks. Was is too difficult to release the footage from Galwan/officially declare Chinese causality figures? Nope. But they didn't. They didn't protest against any of India's claims. All we got was the usual moronic Geng Shuang emulator talking about "muh territorial integrity".

Learn from RT/TRT/CNN.

India is adroitly using the conflict to throttle Chinese exports to India . Latest is the restriction on tvs and parts. A 8 b usd annual jolt for the Chinese. Not a murmur from the Chinese. Taking everything quietly..

 

[Telescopic Sight]

If Indian so sure Chinese has causality why not release some footage from your side? I am sure the Indian has carried cameras all the time.

Enslaved people under the boot of the CCP will never be able to spaek freely and only paid professionals's voice is heard from China.

So use your organisation's influence and share the videos of the Indian soldiers being killed. No ?

All your news comes only from India ? You guys have nothing from CCP masters ? Sad.

 

[flowerfan2020]

Enslaved people under the boot of the CCP will never be able to spaek freely and only paid professionals's voice is heard from China.

So use your organisation's influence and share the videos of the Indian soldiers being killed. No ?

Yeah, including all of the fake news from Indian. From few Chinese soldiers kill then 10 to 60s....

 

[Telescopic Sight]

Yeah, including all of the fake news from Indian. From few Chinese soldiers kill then 10 to 60s....

Indians can say 600 Chinese dead , what can you show in return to prove any lies ? Nothing!

When the entire population of China is dependant on Indian sources for news of how their boys fared in combat, is that not enslavement ?

Don't bother replying, unless it is monetarily beneficial to you.

 

[Realtalk108]

Indians can say 600 Chinese dead , what can you show in return to prove any lies ? Nothing!

When the entire population of China is dependant on Indian sources for news of how their boys fared in combat, is that not enslavement ?

Don't bother replying, unless it is monetarily beneficial to you.

Exactly. Not releasing an official or at least a semi official tally of losses/gains is down right moronic. India can lose an entire battalion and Modi will still remain comfortable. If this were America, they would have been running 24x7 feed of their gainz by now.

China is a country run entirely by boomers. Read Global Times. Cringemax. It's like a bank clerk is delivering the threats. "India needs to remember China is very powerful, OK?" Are you threatening or pleading?

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Indians can say 600 Chinese dead , what can you show in return to prove any lies ? Nothing!

When the entire population of China is dependant on Indian sources for news of how their boys fared in combat, is that not enslavement ?

Don't bother replying, unless it is monetarily beneficial to you.

They can show the dozen or so captured indian POWs they returned and the territory they still hold.. so much for proof.

 

[Telescopic Sight]

They can show the dozen or so captured indian POWs they returned aso much for proof.

How correct of you ! Yet, the Chinese public and these forum Chinese don't have even that !

Completely locked up in their cages, these poor folks.

 

[Figaro]

Indians can say 600 Chinese dead , what can you show in return to prove any lies ? Nothing!

When the entire population of China is dependant on Indian sources for news of how their boys fared in combat, is that not enslavement ?

Don't bother replying, unless it is monetarily beneficial to you.

Are you stupid or are you just to lazy to look up sources? Numerous accounts of the Chinese forces in the Galwan battle have already been stated on Chinese social media, such as Weibo. No one, besides the Indians, believe in the Indian version of events lmao.

Enslaved people under the boot of the CCP will never be able to spaek freely and only paid professionals's voice is heard from China.

So use your organisation's influence and share the videos of the Indian soldiers being killed. No ?

All your news comes only from India ? You guys have nothing from CCP masters ? Sad.

This is such a stupid red herring. The point @flowerfan2020 was making was that if the Indian account of a decisive victory and the massacre of 100+ Chinese soldiers were true, they would have already released the footage. Evidently this has not happened. IIRC, the Indians were more than happy to release footage of one captured Chinese recon patrol officer getting beat to a pulp by 10 Indian soldiers on social media (an event that likely sparked the Galwan incident). You think the Indians would be noble enough not to release the videos had the event gone their way?

 

[Han Patriot]

Indians can say 600 Chinese dead , what can you show in return to prove any lies ? Nothing!

When the entire population of China is dependant on Indian sources for news of how their boys fared in combat, is that not enslavement ?

Don't bother replying, unless it is monetarily beneficial to you.

The burden of proof comes from the claimant mate. Lol. What amazing logic!

 

[Han Patriot]

Are you stupid or are you just to lazy to look up sources? Numerous accounts of the Chinese forces in the Galwan battle have already been stated on Chinese social media, such as Weibo. No one, besides the Indians, believe in the Indian version of events lmao.

This is such a stupid red herring. The point @flowerfan2020 was making was that if the Indian account of a decisive victory and the massacre of 100+ Chinese soldiers were true, they would have already released the footage. Evidently this has not happened. IIRC, the Indians were more than happy to release footage of one captured Chinese recon patrol officer getting beat to a pulp by 10 Indian soldiers on social media (an event that likely sparked the Galwan incident). You think the Indians would be noble enough not to release the videos had the event gone their way?

We also release a pic of 5 tied up Indians all bashed up like nuggets.

 

[IblinI]

for those Indian comes here, we are not the one jumping up and down crying for revenge, so either you fire the first shot or stop whinning.
the last thing we need is an Indian lecturing about way of life, living standard.

 

[Figaro]

for those Indian comes here, we are not the one jumping up and down crying for revenge, so either you fire the first shot or stop whinning.
the last thing we need is an Indian lecturing about way of life, living standard.

While the Indian posters here may outwardly insist otherwise, deep down they know that 20 to 50 of their "elite mountain" troops were killed and 60 more captured, including several high ranking officers. Hence why the calls for revenge against China ...