What's new

Pakistan’s rogue elite

Now this is something which you Non-Muslims are entirely unaware of, you people think that Muslims are extremely devoted to Islam, whereas being a Muslim myself i know for a fact that majority of people only invoke Islamic injunctions when they suit their needs other than that they have no morals or ethics when it comes to their interests -
As a child, my next-door neighbors in 1971 were Pakistani diplomats, so I learned this lesson very early.

...being a non Muslim you will have hard time digesting this and most convenient for you/others is to simply blame the religion and lump all it's adherents into one category.
Where did I blame "the religion" for Pakistan's troubles?

...baring "gas chambers", would everything Nazi Germany did become Kosher?
Have India's Muslims been disenfranchised, had their bank accounts groundlessly seized, been forbidden from pursuing higher education, or herded into concentration camps?

Ignoring the fact that I stated people are receptive to their message. Ergo, people have agency.
What does "people have agency" mean?
 
.
A lot of that is happening in Kashmir and though it has many ethnic groups, some say Kashmiris have tribes of Jews within them who converted to Hinduism, Islam or left for Israel.
Have India's Muslims been disenfranchised, had their bank accounts groundlessly seized, been forbidden from pursuing higher education, or herded into concentration camps?
 
.
Yes they are doing that. If the medium is not gas, doesn't make it sound better.
o_O

I'm just replying to you because it is interesting to see so much love for our neighbor. Israel has always been of special interest to me, though never in my life I've ever seen, encountered or talked to an Israeli in my life. So my encounter with you is pretty.... umm amazing... for me.
I'm not an Israeli. I'm an American. Sorry to disappoint!
 
.
As a child, my next-door neighbors in 1971 were Pakistani diplomats, so I learned this lesson very early.

Where did I blame "the religion" for Pakistan's troubles?
General statement man, i didn't imply that you were saying so......I guess i should have mentioned that in my previous post. What i am trying to tell you is that Muslims aren't what the world thinks of them, especially the Westerners including yourself. Muslims do all sorts of things which are prohibited in Islam yet their religion is blamed for all their folly's, the only thing they don't tolerate is Blasphemy and that is only a concern for them when they don't have anything at stake otherwise....well you know Saudis....They take offenses to their Monarchs more seriously than anything else. Hope you got my point.
 
.
American Jews are equally informed about Israel, isn't it? After all Jerusalem is your Mecca.

No need to be sorry. I'm an American too
o_O

I'm not an Israeli. I'm an American. Sorry to disappoint!
 
. .
...What i am trying to tell you is that Muslims aren't what the world thinks of them, especially the Westerners including yourself.
There are Muslims I admire. Even one or two Pakistani Muslims. So I may not be a good target for generalizations.
 
. .
What does "people have agency" mean?


In your context, I used agency as a mode of action.

Have India's Muslims been disenfranchised, had their bank accounts groundlessly seized, been forbidden from pursuing higher education, or herded into concentration camps?


And did all this dehumanization occur overnight in Nazi Germany? And are these specific dehumanizing acts the only path to a Nazi Germany? Rwanda, anyone?

Read more:
Mufti turned Kashmir into a military concentration camp, says Mirwaiz

There are Muslims I admire. Even one or two Pakistani Muslims. So I may not be a good target for generalizations.


And there are Jews I admire so neither am I a good target for generalizations. :enjoy:
 
Last edited:
. .
Still unclear to me.


Elaborate what is unclear.

The concentration camps started as soon as Hitler assumed power: link


This is not Oppression Olympics.

You have failed to answer basic questions:
  • Did all this dehumanization occur overnight in Nazi Germany?
  • Are these specific dehumanizing acts the only path to a Nazi Germany? Rwanda, anyone?
 
.
You have failed to answer basic questions:
  • Did all this dehumanization occur overnight in Nazi Germany?
  • Are these specific dehumanizing acts the only path to a Nazi Germany? Rwanda, anyone?
You want free tips on how to create a dictatorship? Not from me.
 
. .
argument for Pakistan was that Muslims
That argument was satiated in 1947. There is no point in having "Groundhog Day" every day. Pakistan is nearly 70 years old. At 70 you don't wake up in the morning and debate about why you were born. We all are born on one pretext or other. America was born because of tax and tea? You don't debate everyday about the "tea and taxes" being the reason why you exist do you?

And you are aware the region that became Pakistan in 1947 had been integrated into BRITISH India only 98 years before. British India was mere British construct and began to fall apart as they began to weaken.

Link > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Gujrat

Lesson in history. Burma, Bangladesh, India and Pakistan.


0C1RvdO.jpg




India's Hindu majority.
And as somebody who is rather partial to America I would suggest you don't sling the Indian balls so much - That would be like me going to Israel and praising the virtues of Arabs. I would be pulling the rug under my feet. Take away the point of me even engaging with Israeli's.
 
.
That argument was satiated in 1947. There is no point in having "Groundhog Day" every day. Pakistan is nearly 70 years old. At 70 you don't wake up in the morning and debate about why you were born. We all are born on one pretext or other. America was born because of tax and tea? You don't debate everyday about the "tea and taxes" being the reason why you exist do you?
Very sensible. Accepted.

...I would suggest you don't sling the Indian balls so much -
???

That would be like me going to Israel and praising the virtues of Arabs. I would be pulling the rug under my feet. Take away the point of me even engaging with Israeli's.
?????
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom