What's new

Pakistan’s Defense budget: Majestic Myths & Humble Reality?

Zibago

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 21, 2012
Messages
37,006
Reaction score
12
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Pakistan’s Defense budget: Majestic Myths & Humble Reality?
February 13, 2017651 2

News Analysis

Defense budget outlays of different nation states reveal a picture altogether different from perceptions commonly held by public- even aware citizenry. For instance data on the site of Global Firepower.com shows how Saudi Arabia has become the top third spender with $56 billion per annum and India now ranks 7th with $40 billion.

United States defense budget, at a almost $600 billion, is more than the combined budget of China, Russia, UK, France, Germany and India. This explains the disproportionate power and reach of Pentagon across the world.

Global Firepower, GFP, is an open source site affiliated with MilitaryFactory.com sites that provides figures publicly available. In its article: “Defense Budget by Country” it provides actual figures of 2015 expenditures from more than 100 countries. These figures that shatter the myths held by public, media, civil society and politicians and raise the interesting question: How most in media and civil society come to form their opinions?

Defense Budget by Country – Global Fire Power

The United States has the largest defense budget with $581 billion which is almost four times the defence budget of China which is its main competitor and ranks second on the global list of defense expenditures. But Saudi Arabia surprises us by its enormous figure of $56.7 Billion; but more so because it is now third defense spender on the global list.

United States defense budget, at almost $600 billion, is more than the combined budget of China, Russia, UK, France, Germany and India. This explains the disproportionate power and reach of Pentagon across the world.

Apparently Pakistan’s ability to control its defense expenditure comes from reliance upon tactical devices.

Interestingly Pakistan’s defence outlay of $7 Billion is at 27th position at the top in sharp contrast to its regional rival India which stands 7th in ranking with enormous spending of $40 Billion.

Read more: Cold War new norm between India & Pakistan..?

These figures reveal that most civil society activists, politicians and media pundits who keep on harping on the massive defense expenditure in Pakistan are ill-informed and have very little understanding of the issue. While their argument that poor nations, or any perhaps any nation, should not divert much needed resources from education, health and public welfare into defense makes sense. But their inability to structure their point of view in the realistic context of regional situation only weakens their stand point.


Surprisingly, India’s massive defence outlay, $40 billion, seldom becomes an issue in Indian politics, media and civil society despite the fact that majority of Indians live in the situations of extreme poverty.

Pakistan’s defense budget appears to be comparatively much smaller despite half a million standing troops because it relies primarily upon missile technology, and its ability to deliver small pay loads, as deterrence. In recent years India, supported by United States, has tried imposing curbs on Pakistan’s build up of small tactical devices. But apparently Pakistan’s ability to control its defense expenditure comes from reliance upon tactical devices.

Surprisingly, India’s massive defence outlay, $40 billion, seldom becomes an issue in Indian politics, media and civil society despite the fact that majority of Indians live in the situations of extreme poverty.
10-defence-exp-300x163.png
pakistan-defence-300x166.png
https://www.globalvillagespace.com/...defense-budget-majestic-myths-humble-reality/
@Musafir117 @Moonlight @PaklovesTurkiye @django @The Sandman @Hell hound
 
.
Defense budget has to viewed in relation to either GDP or annual budget of the country. In case of India, it spends $40 billion against a total budget of $280 billion. that makes it roughly 14 percent of its budget. Pakistan spends $7 billion against a total budget of $44 billion which makes our defense spending about 16 percent of the total budget. As Pakistan is currently facing some very serious security threats this defense outlay is justified. Simply harping on about all those counties that spend more than us is not the solution. they have more money and hence can spend more.
Our priority should be to pay our taxes to ensure that the government has a lot more money to spend on development projects and providing other services. We also need to increase our GDP so that other areas do not take a hit from excess defense spending.
 
.
Two year old figures , i believe this year its 58 billion.
 
.
Pakistan’s Defense budget: Majestic Myths & Humble Reality?
February 13, 2017651 2

News Analysis

Defense budget outlays of different nation states reveal a picture altogether different from perceptions commonly held by public- even aware citizenry. For instance data on the site of Global Firepower.com shows how Saudi Arabia has become the top third spender with $56 billion per annum and India now ranks 7th with $40 billion.

United States defense budget, at a almost $600 billion, is more than the combined budget of China, Russia, UK, France, Germany and India. This explains the disproportionate power and reach of Pentagon across the world.

Global Firepower, GFP, is an open source site affiliated with MilitaryFactory.com sites that provides figures publicly available. In its article: “Defense Budget by Country” it provides actual figures of 2015 expenditures from more than 100 countries. These figures that shatter the myths held by public, media, civil society and politicians and raise the interesting question: How most in media and civil society come to form their opinions?

Defense Budget by Country – Global Fire Power

The United States has the largest defense budget with $581 billion which is almost four times the defence budget of China which is its main competitor and ranks second on the global list of defense expenditures. But Saudi Arabia surprises us by its enormous figure of $56.7 Billion; but more so because it is now third defense spender on the global list.

United States defense budget, at almost $600 billion, is more than the combined budget of China, Russia, UK, France, Germany and India. This explains the disproportionate power and reach of Pentagon across the world.

Apparently Pakistan’s ability to control its defense expenditure comes from reliance upon tactical devices.

Interestingly Pakistan’s defence outlay of $7 Billion is at 27th position at the top in sharp contrast to its regional rival India which stands 7th in ranking with enormous spending of $40 Billion.

Read more: Cold War new norm between India & Pakistan..?

These figures reveal that most civil society activists, politicians and media pundits who keep on harping on the massive defense expenditure in Pakistan are ill-informed and have very little understanding of the issue. While their argument that poor nations, or any perhaps any nation, should not divert much needed resources from education, health and public welfare into defense makes sense. But their inability to structure their point of view in the realistic context of regional situation only weakens their stand point.


Surprisingly, India’s massive defence outlay, $40 billion, seldom becomes an issue in Indian politics, media and civil society despite the fact that majority of Indians live in the situations of extreme poverty.

Pakistan’s defense budget appears to be comparatively much smaller despite half a million standing troops because it relies primarily upon missile technology, and its ability to deliver small pay loads, as deterrence. In recent years India, supported by United States, has tried imposing curbs on Pakistan’s build up of small tactical devices. But apparently Pakistan’s ability to control its defense expenditure comes from reliance upon tactical devices.

Surprisingly, India’s massive defence outlay, $40 billion, seldom becomes an issue in Indian politics, media and civil society despite the fact that majority of Indians live in the situations of extreme poverty.
10-defence-exp-300x163.png
pakistan-defence-300x166.png
https://www.globalvillagespace.com/...defense-budget-majestic-myths-humble-reality/
Major portion of Indias defence budget goes to salaries and pension. As such it is not a big budget per se compared to our gdp or size of the country.
 
.
Pakistan’s Defense budget: Majestic Myths & Humble Reality?
February 13, 2017651 2

News Analysis

Defense budget outlays of different nation states reveal a picture altogether different from perceptions commonly held by public- even aware citizenry. For instance data on the site of Global Firepower.com shows how Saudi Arabia has become the top third spender with $56 billion per annum and India now ranks 7th with $40 billion.

United States defense budget, at a almost $600 billion, is more than the combined budget of China, Russia, UK, France, Germany and India. This explains the disproportionate power and reach of Pentagon across the world.

Global Firepower, GFP, is an open source site affiliated with MilitaryFactory.com sites that provides figures publicly available. In its article: “Defense Budget by Country” it provides actual figures of 2015 expenditures from more than 100 countries. These figures that shatter the myths held by public, media, civil society and politicians and raise the interesting question: How most in media and civil society come to form their opinions?

Defense Budget by Country – Global Fire Power

The United States has the largest defense budget with $581 billion which is almost four times the defence budget of China which is its main competitor and ranks second on the global list of defense expenditures. But Saudi Arabia surprises us by its enormous figure of $56.7 Billion; but more so because it is now third defense spender on the global list.

United States defense budget, at almost $600 billion, is more than the combined budget of China, Russia, UK, France, Germany and India. This explains the disproportionate power and reach of Pentagon across the world.

Apparently Pakistan’s ability to control its defense expenditure comes from reliance upon tactical devices.

Interestingly Pakistan’s defence outlay of $7 Billion is at 27th position at the top in sharp contrast to its regional rival India which stands 7th in ranking with enormous spending of $40 Billion.

Read more: Cold War new norm between India & Pakistan..?

These figures reveal that most civil society activists, politicians and media pundits who keep on harping on the massive defense expenditure in Pakistan are ill-informed and have very little understanding of the issue. While their argument that poor nations, or any perhaps any nation, should not divert much needed resources from education, health and public welfare into defense makes sense. But their inability to structure their point of view in the realistic context of regional situation only weakens their stand point.


Surprisingly, India’s massive defence outlay, $40 billion, seldom becomes an issue in Indian politics, media and civil society despite the fact that majority of Indians live in the situations of extreme poverty.

Pakistan’s defense budget appears to be comparatively much smaller despite half a million standing troops because it relies primarily upon missile technology, and its ability to deliver small pay loads, as deterrence. In recent years India, supported by United States, has tried imposing curbs on Pakistan’s build up of small tactical devices. But apparently Pakistan’s ability to control its defense expenditure comes from reliance upon tactical devices.

Surprisingly, India’s massive defence outlay, $40 billion, seldom becomes an issue in Indian politics, media and civil society despite the fact that majority of Indians live in the situations of extreme poverty.
10-defence-exp-300x163.png
pakistan-defence-300x166.png
https://www.globalvillagespace.com/...defense-budget-majestic-myths-humble-reality/
@Musafir117 @Moonlight @PaklovesTurkiye @django @The Sandman @Hell hound
I have heard from serving officers, off the record that it is much higher than official stats indicate.I hope it is.
 
.
In recent years India, supported by United States, has tried imposing curbs on Pakistan’s build up of small tactical devices. But apparently Pakistan’s ability to control its defense expenditure comes from reliance upon tactical devices.

curbs on Pakistan's nuclear build up by US and India? when did this happen? the only way this "could" happen was via sanctions and US has not imposed any sanctions on Pak for TNWs. and pray - what sanctions can India put on Pak anyways?
 
.
Btw Whats the total revenue of army owned enterprises? do they use it in defense also?
 
. .
Hazoor e wala! Nangy taar ko touch nahi krna chahye. These organizations are suppose to welfare not warfare.
well true,
well its not for civies but they must be having some internal audit for all the earnings? arent they?
 
.

Latest posts

Military Forum Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom