What's new

Pakistan will not join the BRICS?

Asian.Century

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 1, 2010
Messages
10,754
Reaction score
-2
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Pakistan will not join the BRICS?

Countering Western Interests is the goal of BRICS. It wants the de-dollarisation of the currency.

BRICS - has Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa a grouping of world economies.


For Pakistan it is not clear, what BRICS wants to achieve, the goals are unclear, the objectives are mix.

Will Pakistan join BRICS?​


As of now I can say there is no discussion from Pakistani side, says official

ISLAMABAD:Pakistan has not made any formal request to join BRICS, the bloc of leading developing nations Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, as officials here say it is premature to draw any conclusion when the group itself has yet to evolve a consensus on the expansion plan.

There have been reports particularly in the Indian media claiming that Pakistan has shown interest in joining the BRICS and China has already started lobbying for it.

The BRICS represent about 40% of the world's population and a quarter of global GDP.

Leaders of BRICS are in Johannesburg for a three-day summit. Since the formation of the group in 2009, this is the first time BRICS has got lot of traction. The interest in many Western capitals stems from fears that Russia and China, two big players in the grouping, are seeking to expand their role through BRICS with an aim to counter the US or West-led global financial system.

China’s President Xi Jinping called for unity among his BRICS counterparts at a summit on Wednesday as he pushed the case for expanding the grouping to face a global “period of turbulence and transformation.”

Read more: China's Xi calls for accelerated BRICS expansion

According to Reuters, leaders of the bloc of leading developing nations Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa are meeting in Johannesburg with discussions around establishing a framework and criteria for admitting new members topping the agenda.

While all BRICS members have publicly expressed support for growing the bloc, divisions remain over how much and how quickly.

Bloc heavyweight China has long pushed for expansion and views its deteriorating relations with Washington as well as heightened global tensions resulting from the Ukraine war as adding urgency to the enlargement project.

Addressing the summit of the bloc’s leaders, Xi said he was glad to see that developing countries had shown great enthusiasm in participating in BRICS and many of them have applied to join.

Read also: BRICS summit of emerging economies begins in South Africa

“We should let more countries join the BRICS family to pool wisdom and efforts to make global governance more just and equitable,” Xi said.

Ahead of the summit certain Indian publications claimed that China wanted Pakistan to be part of the BRICS, something that New Delhi would object to.

However, background discussions with foreign office officials here suggested that Pakistan might be following the developments with regard to BRICS but yet to make up its mind to join the grouping.

“I think the Indian media is reading narrowly on the Chinese and Russian desire to expand the BRICS,” remarked one official while requesting anonymity.

The official was of the view that BRICS first had to decide whether it wanted the expansion and discussions about Pakistan or any other country joining the bloc came later.

“As of now I can say there is no discussion from the Pakistani side,” the official added.

The cautious response from Pakistani officials appears to suggest that it also does not want to become the part of bloc politics. Russia and China have shown clear intent to use BRICS to counter G-7, the grouping of powerful wealthy developed nations.


More than 40 countries have expressed interest in joining BRICS, say South African officials, 22 of whom have formally asked to be admitted.

Details of the criteria for joining could be included in a joint declaration due to be finalised on Wednesday.

Beyond the enlargement question, boosting the use of member states’ local currencies in trade and financial transactions to lessen dependency on the US dollar is also on the summit agenda.

South African organisers had said there would be no discussions of a common BRICS currency, an idea floated by Brazil as an alternative to dollar-dependence.

At least 15 potential new member countries — including Saudi Arabia, Algeria and Argentina — are under consideration to join the bloc’s New Development Bank (NDB), its chief financial officer said on Wednesday.

The NDB, which has long tapped China’s capital market for funding, is registering an Indian rupee bond programme worth $2.5 billion over five years after it issued its first South African rand bond last week.

President Putin, who is attending the summit virtually because of fear of arrest over warrants issued by the International Criminal Court, has pushed for de-dollarisation.

There has been a debate within BRICS to introduce a single currency or trade in their local currencies in order to reduce dependence on the US dollar.

However, prospects of such a proposal getting through are slim as two key members of BRICS—India and Brazil—may not back the idea given both countries are also closely aligned with the US and its interests.

 
What is there really to join?

It's just the equivalent of a managerial meeting hiding under the façade of an international organization.

It came about a BRIC, by a financial manager, added the S from South Africa to have an African country.

There's little to no ability to cooperate and form a unified front.

Just an attempt to bring about a new organization and present it as the new leaders of the Global South.
 
What is there really to join?

It's just the equivalent of a managerial meeting hiding under the façade of an international organization.

It came about a BRIC, by a financial manager, added the S from South Africa to have an African country.

There's little to no ability to cooperate and form a unified front.

Just an attempt to bring about a new organization and present it as the new leaders of the Global South.

Exactly what I asked but go no answer - What is the benefit of joining?
 
Exactly what I asked but go no answer - What is the benefit of joining?

For the existing 5 members international prestige.

New members, a new battleground to pit China-India (by extension China-West), benefits if played well.
 
And Asim Whisky won't sleep with Angelina Jolile...no one asked the sepoys to join BRICS...
 
Pakistan will not join the BRICS?

Countering Western Interests is the goal of BRICS. It wants the de-dollarisation of the currency.

BRICS - has Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa a grouping of world economies.


For Pakistan it is not clear, what BRICS wants to achieve, the goals are unclear, the objectives are mix.

Will Pakistan join BRICS?​


As of now I can say there is no discussion from Pakistani side, says official

ISLAMABAD:Pakistan has not made any formal request to join BRICS, the bloc of leading developing nations Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, as officials here say it is premature to draw any conclusion when the group itself has yet to evolve a consensus on the expansion plan.

There have been reports particularly in the Indian media claiming that Pakistan has shown interest in joining the BRICS and China has already started lobbying for it.

The BRICS represent about 40% of the world's population and a quarter of global GDP.

Leaders of BRICS are in Johannesburg for a three-day summit. Since the formation of the group in 2009, this is the first time BRICS has got lot of traction. The interest in many Western capitals stems from fears that Russia and China, two big players in the grouping, are seeking to expand their role through BRICS with an aim to counter the US or West-led global financial system.

China’s President Xi Jinping called for unity among his BRICS counterparts at a summit on Wednesday as he pushed the case for expanding the grouping to face a global “period of turbulence and transformation.”

Read more: China's Xi calls for accelerated BRICS expansion

According to Reuters, leaders of the bloc of leading developing nations Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa are meeting in Johannesburg with discussions around establishing a framework and criteria for admitting new members topping the agenda.

While all BRICS members have publicly expressed support for growing the bloc, divisions remain over how much and how quickly.

Bloc heavyweight China has long pushed for expansion and views its deteriorating relations with Washington as well as heightened global tensions resulting from the Ukraine war as adding urgency to the enlargement project.

Addressing the summit of the bloc’s leaders, Xi said he was glad to see that developing countries had shown great enthusiasm in participating in BRICS and many of them have applied to join.

Read also: BRICS summit of emerging economies begins in South Africa

“We should let more countries join the BRICS family to pool wisdom and efforts to make global governance more just and equitable,” Xi said.

Ahead of the summit certain Indian publications claimed that China wanted Pakistan to be part of the BRICS, something that New Delhi would object to.

However, background discussions with foreign office officials here suggested that Pakistan might be following the developments with regard to BRICS but yet to make up its mind to join the grouping.

“I think the Indian media is reading narrowly on the Chinese and Russian desire to expand the BRICS,” remarked one official while requesting anonymity.

The official was of the view that BRICS first had to decide whether it wanted the expansion and discussions about Pakistan or any other country joining the bloc came later.

“As of now I can say there is no discussion from the Pakistani side,” the official added.

The cautious response from Pakistani officials appears to suggest that it also does not want to become the part of bloc politics. Russia and China have shown clear intent to use BRICS to counter G-7, the grouping of powerful wealthy developed nations.


More than 40 countries have expressed interest in joining BRICS, say South African officials, 22 of whom have formally asked to be admitted.

Details of the criteria for joining could be included in a joint declaration due to be finalised on Wednesday.

Beyond the enlargement question, boosting the use of member states’ local currencies in trade and financial transactions to lessen dependency on the US dollar is also on the summit agenda.

South African organisers had said there would be no discussions of a common BRICS currency, an idea floated by Brazil as an alternative to dollar-dependence.

At least 15 potential new member countries — including Saudi Arabia, Algeria and Argentina — are under consideration to join the bloc’s New Development Bank (NDB), its chief financial officer said on Wednesday.

The NDB, which has long tapped China’s capital market for funding, is registering an Indian rupee bond programme worth $2.5 billion over five years after it issued its first South African rand bond last week.

President Putin, who is attending the summit virtually because of fear of arrest over warrants issued by the International Criminal Court, has pushed for de-dollarisation.

There has been a debate within BRICS to introduce a single currency or trade in their local currencies in order to reduce dependence on the US dollar.

However, prospects of such a proposal getting through are slim as two key members of BRICS—India and Brazil—may not back the idea given both countries are also closely aligned with the US and its interests.

Do not wish to see Pakistan anywhere near BRICS.
 
I don't think Pakistan is a good fit in BRICS. It is a 'Puppet of the West' as proved by ouster of Imran Khan. Only strong countries which have independent foreign policy should be given first choice.
 
Pakistan will not join the BRICS?

Countering Western Interests is the goal of BRICS. It wants the de-dollarisation of the currency.

BRICS - has Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa a grouping of world economies.


For Pakistan it is not clear, what BRICS wants to achieve, the goals are unclear, the objectives are mix.

Will Pakistan join BRICS?​


As of now I can say there is no discussion from Pakistani side, says official

ISLAMABAD:Pakistan has not made any formal request to join BRICS, the bloc of leading developing nations Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, as officials here say it is premature to draw any conclusion when the group itself has yet to evolve a consensus on the expansion plan.

There have been reports particularly in the Indian media claiming that Pakistan has shown interest in joining the BRICS and China has already started lobbying for it.

The BRICS represent about 40% of the world's population and a quarter of global GDP.

Leaders of BRICS are in Johannesburg for a three-day summit. Since the formation of the group in 2009, this is the first time BRICS has got lot of traction. The interest in many Western capitals stems from fears that Russia and China, two big players in the grouping, are seeking to expand their role through BRICS with an aim to counter the US or West-led global financial system.

China’s President Xi Jinping called for unity among his BRICS counterparts at a summit on Wednesday as he pushed the case for expanding the grouping to face a global “period of turbulence and transformation.”

Read more: China's Xi calls for accelerated BRICS expansion

According to Reuters, leaders of the bloc of leading developing nations Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa are meeting in Johannesburg with discussions around establishing a framework and criteria for admitting new members topping the agenda.

While all BRICS members have publicly expressed support for growing the bloc, divisions remain over how much and how quickly.

Bloc heavyweight China has long pushed for expansion and views its deteriorating relations with Washington as well as heightened global tensions resulting from the Ukraine war as adding urgency to the enlargement project.

Addressing the summit of the bloc’s leaders, Xi said he was glad to see that developing countries had shown great enthusiasm in participating in BRICS and many of them have applied to join.

Read also: BRICS summit of emerging economies begins in South Africa

“We should let more countries join the BRICS family to pool wisdom and efforts to make global governance more just and equitable,” Xi said.

Ahead of the summit certain Indian publications claimed that China wanted Pakistan to be part of the BRICS, something that New Delhi would object to.

However, background discussions with foreign office officials here suggested that Pakistan might be following the developments with regard to BRICS but yet to make up its mind to join the grouping.

“I think the Indian media is reading narrowly on the Chinese and Russian desire to expand the BRICS,” remarked one official while requesting anonymity.

The official was of the view that BRICS first had to decide whether it wanted the expansion and discussions about Pakistan or any other country joining the bloc came later.

“As of now I can say there is no discussion from the Pakistani side,” the official added.

The cautious response from Pakistani officials appears to suggest that it also does not want to become the part of bloc politics. Russia and China have shown clear intent to use BRICS to counter G-7, the grouping of powerful wealthy developed nations.


More than 40 countries have expressed interest in joining BRICS, say South African officials, 22 of whom have formally asked to be admitted.

Details of the criteria for joining could be included in a joint declaration due to be finalised on Wednesday.

Beyond the enlargement question, boosting the use of member states’ local currencies in trade and financial transactions to lessen dependency on the US dollar is also on the summit agenda.

South African organisers had said there would be no discussions of a common BRICS currency, an idea floated by Brazil as an alternative to dollar-dependence.

At least 15 potential new member countries — including Saudi Arabia, Algeria and Argentina — are under consideration to join the bloc’s New Development Bank (NDB), its chief financial officer said on Wednesday.

The NDB, which has long tapped China’s capital market for funding, is registering an Indian rupee bond programme worth $2.5 billion over five years after it issued its first South African rand bond last week.

President Putin, who is attending the summit virtually because of fear of arrest over warrants issued by the International Criminal Court, has pushed for de-dollarisation.

There has been a debate within BRICS to introduce a single currency or trade in their local currencies in order to reduce dependence on the US dollar.

However, prospects of such a proposal getting through are slim as two key members of BRICS—India and Brazil—may not back the idea given both countries are also closely aligned with the US and its interests.


There is a difference between what Russia and China "want to do" and "what can be done."

Russian economy is in decline and Russian goods do not have global demand. Many Russians buy foreign goods.

Chinese economy is one of the largest and Chinese goods have global demand but this is possible with American support. Many Chinese buy foreign goods while others have their needs met from domestically manufactured goods.

American economy is the largest in the world and American goods have global demand. American companies are also important customers in numerous countries.

USD is a globally accepted currency and it allows consumers around the world to buy American T-bonds, shares in American companies, and products from many countries including China. Who wants to give up on these benefits?

What 2022 has revealed is that the dollar system has the resilience and strength that it does because it is deeply entrenched and buttressed by both commercial and geopolitical interests. Not for nothing the economist Daniela Gabor has coined the phrase “the Wall Street consensus” to highlight the role of investment bankers, fund managers, and their client borrowers in maintaining the dollar-based global financial network. In major crises this system becomes an overt public-private partnership secured from the top down by the liquidity swap lines extended by the Fed to the major central banks of Europe, Latin America, and Asia. In geopolitical confrontations, its reach is expanded by close cooperation between the United States and its security policy partners in Europe and East Asia. But most of the time the de-risking provided by public authorities for dollar-centered global finance remains in the background. The system appears to sustain itself based above all on the resilience of the U.S. economy and its dynamic financial markets.


This article is a must read.

China does not substitute US in any sense. Chinese markets do not substitute American markets. Chinese financial system is not a substitute to American financial system.

BRICS can allow developing countries to cooperate with each other in better ways and reduce impact of American sanctions in theory, but it cannot make American financial system irrelevant.

If you want to grow and prosper, you must have good bilateral relations with US and access to American financial system. You will end up like Afghanistan, North Korea, Russia, Sri Lanka, Somalia, and Venezuela otherwise.

Pakistan is also broke but due to its own faults and over-reliance on China to meet its needs.
 
If KSA UAE are admitted Pakistan will want to join. It’ll be just fomo for Pakistan .
China is anxious to build an anti US coalition for soft power.
 
BRICS cant achieve its goals as members are suspicious about others intentions..moreover, there is no respect for other members concerns..there is just self interest...if pak joins, it will create even more roadblocks...
 
Back
Top Bottom