Pakistan to give nationality to Bangladeshi immigrants, announces Imran Khan

[Psychic]

And for Bengalis in Karachi, those people are there because of the legacy of East Pakistan and 1971 war.

Most came in late 70s and 80s.

As for question able loyalty
We have leaders who said
if kala bagh dam is made pakistan will break
Pakistan is behind mumbai attack
Pakistan is behind Terrorism in Afghanistan
Some there sons whose name is in Panama case say they r not subject to Pakistan laws as r Britsh

So such people can be pakistani let's give these kids a chance perhaps we can get a few really good ones that can compensate and even give turnover compared to bad ones

Might as well give citizen ship to 3 million Afghans.

Must be very good for us since a few among us are also treacherous just like a vast majority of Afghan refugees.

Showing hatred for Afghan refugees while itself partially responsible to create those refugees by destabilizing Afghanistan

Afghans fighting against each other or getting @ss r@ped by Russia/US is also Pakistan's fault. Just like the global warming which is evil ISI's conspiracy.

 

[Al-zakir]

Deportation or continue living as stateless.

We are not responsible for their misery. They didn't come here legally.


Tolerating them now will be the same as opening floodgates for illegal immigrants.
Anyone come here illegally and breed, he will hit the jackpot...his child will be a Pakistani citizen.

Deportation-you can try but knowing the reality it may not happen. If it was possible, it would have happened long ago.

Stateless-it’s possible but Pakistan will not be slum and crime free, ever. Is that what you want?

You have a problem and you need a solution . A solution should not lead to another problem, if you know what I mean.

 

[Psychic]

Stateless-it’s possible but Pakistan will not be slum and crime free, ever. Is that what you want?

So giving them passport will mean that we will be slum free or crime free?

Many Pakistanis are living in slums and are criminals.

 

[zain41]

You have rubbed salt on the leech's mouth.

This is one muslim country is literally a leech.Sucking always in the name of muslim ummah(gulf Arab, Turkey) or USA(frontline ally) or China(strategic partner to counter India). Showing hatred for Afghan refugees while itself partially responsible to create those refugees by destabilizing Afghanistan. And for Bengalis in Karachi, those people are there because of the legacy of East Pakistan and 1971 war. But as usual, this treacherous nation is betraying them despite they being loyal to their country.As East Pakistan is no more, so those people have lost their usefulness to this selfish, backstabbing nation.Still hypocritically claiming that their country was formed as the homeland of Indian subcontinent muslims.

Let’s not generalize the views of a whole nation based on 3 or 4 pdf members the fact that this topic even came up shows we are headed in a positive direction and things will get better inshallah from here on out

 

[Al-zakir]

So giving them passport will mean that we will be slum free or crime free?

Many Pakistanis are living in slums and are criminals.

IK wants to build Pakistan as Riyasat e Madina. So why not, in sha Allah.

 

[Psychic]

IK wants to build Pakistan as Riyasat e Madina. So why not, in sha Allah.

Riyasat e Madina did not have subversive foreigners in it.

And we know how bloody the post-Prophet (PBUH) era has been.

Akhtar Mengal has already threatened that he will not sit quiet if Afghans are awarded citizenship. This humanitarianism will only lead to chaos.

 

[khanmubashir]

Who did a proper census of refugees royalty
By this logic Trump is right to ban all.muslims because some r anti USA

 

[Dubious]

please go teach this to
KSA
UAE
Bahrain
Oman
Kuwait
Malaysia
Brunei
turkey
these are rich Muslim countries and they will kick you out after you open mouth and put you in jail .

All except Turkey are Sultanates not the same as democracy......

 

[ranawat]

Its a risky initiative. I hope national security is not comptomised as a result.

How muslim ummah is going to harm a country which was made for muslims , ummah does not believe in boundaries.

 

[Desert Fox]

Khawaja Nazimuddin was also a very noble person.
A decent man with a kind heart, soft spoken and friendly.
He was known as "Quaid e qillat"(Leader of scantiness) when he was our PM after the famous Quaid e Millat---There was a shortage of almost everything during his tenure.
He simply couldn't handle the stress and lacked the decision making power which a leader is supposed to have.

Being noble alone is not enough for a ruler, especially when you are running a country like Pakistan.
The leader must be a wise and strong-willed personality--- otherwise, every Tom[China/US], Dick[Afghanistan] and Harry[Bangladesh] will take advantage of the honorable Prime Minister's "Nobility"[read naivety].

We won't let our country become a dumping ground for Afghan and Bengali trash. Our own sons of the soil require the PM's immediate attention right now, they must be our first priority.
Those who want to live on charity can try rich Muslim brotherly countries.
@Desert Fox @Nilgiri @django

Well said. Nobility alone is not enough, in fact can be dangerous if the will to take decisive action on behalf of millions of ones countrymen is lacking. One might as well just retire in some remote village and live the life of a monk.

Also nobility got the Czar killed because he was to afraid to take decisive measures.

I understand your concerns but what opinion do you have beside do something about these stateless people.

I guess you can gas them to death or dump a bomb in Machar colony.

Or we can workout some agreement with Myanmar (we're already selling them airplanes) and funnel these illegal Bangladeshi citizens back to their motherland.

Where there's a will there's a way.

Exactly.
Send them to their country which according to them is doing a lot better than a war torn taliban infested hellhole of ours.


That didn't use to happen pre-1971.
Price of freedom, their women got sold out---in another country.

They also work for Arbi Sheikhs as house maids. No Pakistani women ever did either of that.

Well said.

No Pakistani women ever did either of that

Alhamdulillah, and may they never. Ameen!

 

[Al-zakir]

Well said. Nobility alone is not enough, in fact can be dangerous if the will to take decisive action on behalf of millions of ones countrymen is lacking. One might as well just retire in some remote village and live the life of a monk.

Also nobility got the Czar killed because he was to afraid to take decisive measures.


Or we can workout some agreement with Myanmar (we're already selling them airplanes) and funnel these illegal Bangladeshi citizens back to their motherland.

Good plan. I’m okay with it.

So, how about Afghan?

That didn't use to happen pre-1971.
Price of freedom, their women got sold out---in another country.

They also work for Arbi Sheikhs as house maids. No Pakistani women ever did either of that.

When comes to this, Bd is begairat. Lakh di lanat.

 

[django]

Khawaja Nazimuddin was also a very noble person.
A decent man with a kind heart, soft spoken and friendly.
He was known as "Quaid e qillat"(Leader of scantiness) when he was our PM after the famous Quaid e Millat---There was a shortage of almost everything during his tenure.
He simply couldn't handle the stress and lacked the decision making power which a leader is supposed to have.

Being noble alone is not enough for a ruler, especially when you are running a country like Pakistan.
The leader must be a wise and strong-willed personality--- otherwise, every Tom[China/US], Dick[Afghanistan] and Harry[Bangladesh] will take advantage of the honorable Prime Minister's "Nobility"[read naivety].

We won't let our country become a dumping ground for Afghan and Bengali trash. Our own sons of the soil require the PM's immediate attention right now, they must be our first priority.
Those who want to live on charity can try rich Muslim brotherly countries.
@Desert Fox @Nilgiri @django

It seems PM Khan is doubling down on this absurdity, he needs to realise we are living in a most dangerous neighbourhood "were good guys comes last", these benglerdeshis will be a fifth column for RAW/benglerdesh whilst Afghanis will naturally support their own NDS and ethno-fascism of Ghani in Kabul, I have many friends and contacts within the various Afghan communities residing in Pak, get to know them well and they spill out their beliefs and friend believe me this is a most common view among Afghan Pashtuns, in their ideal world all the areas of Pak which are inhabited large Pashtun communities (even if not majorities in a particular area) even they should be part of "Loy Afghanistan" ie Attock, Haripur, Abbotabad heck even Gwadar and any non Pashtuns ie Hindkowans should be expelled, once they create this Loy Afghanistan they will seize Tajik, Uzbek...Hazara areas of Afghanistan and dump those folks in Amu Darya and populate those areas with Pashtuns, I kid you not this is their ultimate dream and mindset,,,,such folks should not be permitted to reside here any longer than absolutely necessary, sure their are many good folk among them but the majority strongly subscribe to their utopian concept of "Lebensraum" in our part of the world.Kudos Sir

So how you going to address this issue?
Imran Khan asked?

He is very noble person. May Allah persevere guy sir, Imran Khan.



They are hoping to be settle in Pakistan. They want to live in an Urdu speaking country, unfortunately Bd can not accommodate this demand.

Pakistan should give them a concrete answer. Yes or no and close this chapter for good.

Bd can easily absorb them if they accept Bd citizenship and move out of these camps but Bd can not force them to accept Bd citizenship.

In background beauty Naz Baloch was cringing at his comments at 1:25
@Zibago

I understand your concerns but what opinion do you have beside do something about these stateless people.

I guess you can gas them to death or dump a bomb in Machar colony.

Don't worry Sonny with rising Indian muslim population and conversion rates of Hindu to islam India would be muslim voters majority nation in next 50 years so u will be ruled by Muslim unless u go collapse agian as united Hindu India had done after passing a century or so
Historically

As for this it's our internal matter no need for your Rundi Rona which u think to be an advice onour personal matters
We don't need it

Sir with due respect the man is talking sense, we cannot reward illegal immigration PERIOD.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Well said.

Perhaps you can explain this enigma to me. Whilst we all know about the war in Afghanistan which has devastated that country - first with Soviets and then USA/NATO. Both superpowers. So we can understand that will set off a refugee crisis.

But why does Karachi have so many illegals from Bangladesh, Myanmar, Sri Lanka and India [the latter is often hidden but we know 100,000s have migrated there over the last few decades and mixed in with the previous migrant wave. MQM actively provided cover for this and media has hidden this] yet source countries brag at every opportunity how well they are doing on the economic front?

And for the record most of these Indian/Bangla migrants are post 1980s but conveniently hide behind thre pre 1971 and pre 1950 waves.

 

[Mage]

At least under IK Pakistan is looking to tackle this issue. Which is a great step forward itself.

 

[Al-zakir]

@Zibago