What's new

Pakistan spreading propaganda about 1971 genocide: PM

This IS FAOSTAT.

You are also forgetting the role of fats in dietary intake energy value.
I have shown earlier there is not much gap in per capita meat+fish consumption.Pakistani eat more meat less fish and Bangladeshi eat more fish less meat.Fish also contain fat,albeit healthy one,if you don't know:P.
 
Last edited:
Seems like some people are having a constipation for pointing the obvious.Sindh is largely desert. 68000 sq. km out of 140000 sq. km of Sindh is desert or half of the province.There are three deserts in Sindh-
Thar desert
Nara desert
Kohistan desert
Then there are semi desert region. So it seems 70-80 percent of Sindh is desert and semi desert.You can read the details in this report.
http://foreverindus.org/ie_ecosystem.php

Kohistan is the name of the entire desert region not a desperate desert.

Sindh also has like 35% population compared to Bangladesh.

Which means availability of more agricultural and less population density etc.


Another thing, Thar is the only desert in the world that turns green with rainfall thus sustaining life.
 
I have shown earlier there is not much gap in per capita meat+fish consumption.Pakistani eat more meat less fish and Bangladesh eat more fish less meat.Fish also contain fat,if you don't know:P.

Let me break it down for you:

Total energy supply for IND/BD/PAK = 2459/2450/2440 kcal per person per day

A protein provides 4kcal/gram as does a carbohydrate.

A fat provides 9 kcal/gram.

Taking the protein supply (protein quality is variable but lets just stick to the raw energy provided) of the three countries: IND = 59 grams BD = 55 grams PAK = 64 grams

That means 236 kCal, 220 kCal and 256 kCal respectively of energy supply from protein.

That is 9.6%, 9% and 10.5% of the total energy supply for each country.

Now the remaining non-starch/carb is obviously made up by the fat intake.

Thus for India, it would be 41% - 9.6% = 31.4% from fat intake

For BD it would be 20% - 9% = 11% from fat intake

For Pakistan it would be 50% - 10.5% = 39.5% from fat intake.

So by energy breakdown of carb/protein/fat for each country:

IND = 59/10/31
BD = 80/9/11
PAK = 50/10.5/39.5

According to 2010 Dietary guidelines for USA:

http://blog.myfitnesspal.com/ask-th...rb-protein-and-fat-breakdown-for-weight-loss/

The 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommends eating within the following ranges:

  • Carbohydrates: 45-65% of calories
  • Fat: 20-35% of calories
  • Protein: 10-35% of calories
Now you compare these intake profiles with that....tell me which of the three is doing worst? All 3 can definitely increase their protein intake somewhat for sure....but only one is heavily dependent on carbs for energy (and thus low diet diversity score).

The problem regarding BD is not so much the fat being half of the recommended minimum, but your protein quality being pretty abysmal according to the food security index....and your carb intake is 80% of your calories (well above 65% max recommended).

Why do you think all those BD immigrants are having 3 times the diabetes rate of the regular population? Its all the eating of rice. Ideally protein is the best substitution, but even transferring say 20% of energy intake to healthy fats from rice carbs would be much better.
 
Well, I would object to that too. I consider Sindh to be far more important to Pakistan than Eastern Bengal. I guess everyone has their own opinion.
True.Every one's perspective is different.For me, a small village in Bangladesh have more importance than entire Pakistan.:D
 
Let me break it down for you:

Total energy supply for IND/BD/PAK = 2459/2450/2440 kcal per person per day

A protein provides 4kcal/gram as does a carbohydrate.

A fat provides 9 kcal/gram.

Taking the protein supply (protein quality is variable but lets just stick to the raw energy provided) of the three countries: IND = 59 grams BD = 55 grams PAK = 64 grams

That means 236 kCal, 220 kCal and 256 kCal respectively of energy supply from protein.

That is 9.6%, 9% and 10.5% of the total energy supply for each country.

Now the remaining non-starch/carb is obviously made up by the fat intake.

Thus for India, it would be 41% - 9.6% = 31.4% from fat intake

For BD it would be 20% - 9% = 11% from fat intake

For Pakistan it would be 50% - 10.5% = 39.5% from fat intake.

So by energy breakdown of carb/protein/fat for each country:

IND = 59/10/31
BD = 80/9/11
PAK = 50/10.5/39.5

According to 2010 Dietary guidelines for USA:

http://blog.myfitnesspal.com/ask-th...rb-protein-and-fat-breakdown-for-weight-loss/

The 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommends eating within the following ranges:

  • Carbohydrates: 45-65% of calories
  • Fat: 20-35% of calories
  • Protein: 10-35% of calories
Now you compare these intake profiles with that....tell me which of the three is doing worst? All 3 can definitely increase their protein intake somewhat for sure....but only one is heavily dependent on carbs for energy (and thus low diet diversity score).

The problem regarding BD is not so much the fat being half of the recommended minimum, but your protein quality being pretty abysmal according to the food security index....and your carb intake is 80% of your calories (well above 65% max recommended).

Why do you think all those BD immigrants are having 3 times the diabetes rate of the regular population? Its all the eating of rice. Ideally protein is the best substitution, but even transferring say 20% of energy intake to healthy fats from rice carbs would be much better.
Although,dietary fat intake in Bangladeh is lower than India and Pakistan,it is not as skewed as your calculation shows.According to this source,Dietary fat intake in 2005-2007 for Bangladesh,India and Pakistan is 29gm,48gm and 67gm respectively.Or twice in case of Pakistan than Bangladesh or highest vs lowest among the three.You can come up with better source than it.
http://chartsbin.com/view/1156
 
Last edited:
Funny Pakistan doesnt even mention 71, thats some quiet propaganda machine we have. I have Pakistanis might have developed some gestures to spread propaganda quietly, something like when I scratch my left ear it means 71 Genecide is fake and when they scratch their testiculs it means :blah:
 
BD Muslim folks were the at the ultimate receiving end during the British Indian rule. IMO, they wanted Pak at all costs. But, they couldn't do it all alone. Only for the genius of Rahmetli Jinnah Pak could be created out of the jaw of Ram Rajya. What a pity that BD folks voluntarily got under the complete capitulation of that very Ram Rajya!!! According to BJP leaders, BD is like Sita to be re-captured for Ravana (using proxies like Bibhishana)...

Yet, they chose to leave Pakistan. Why?

Largely because of your own issues.

Pakistan even has nationalists. What does Bangladesh have?
Bangladesh is considered to be among the poorest nations on earth and is bad as India when it comes to poverty.

Lol.

India is above Pakistan in GDP per capita, as well as HDI.

All rubbish!

Bangladesh is a very backward country. India has more poor than all of sub-saharan Africa.

Why are you talking on behalf of BD? Are you Bangladeshi?

India has more people than ALL of AFRICA combined. So India is a very large country. A small fraction of it is still large.

Not attempted but real genocide took place.I think if Bangladesh and India both start observing the day as a genocide day than a massive force will create and other country will follow rapidly.Indian govt. should seriously consider this.May be Bangladesh govt. need to discuss about it with Indian PM.

LOL. I guess we should allow and encourage more Pakistanis and Bangladeshis to talk to each other.

They keep fighting, and then Bangladesh and Bangladeshis turn friendly towards us, making our job easier.
 
Yet, they chose to leave Pakistan. Why?

Largely because of your own issues.



Lol.

India is above Pakistan in GDP per capita, as well as HDI.



India has more people than ALL of AFRICA combined. So India is a very large country. A small fraction of it is still large.



LOL. I guess we should allow and encourage more Pakistanis and Bangladeshis to talk to each other.

They keep fighting, and then Bangladesh and Bangladeshis turn friendly towards us, making our job easier.
LOL, India has more poor than Pakistan!
Don't make me laugh! LOL! LOL!:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

LOL, India has more poor than Pakistan!
Don't make me laugh! LOL! LOL!:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:
I don't care about Bangladesh.
Bangladeshis needs to take care of their own country.
 
Again, I could probably count on my fingers the amount of Pakistanis who would have read this, and the claims your PM made about it being sponsored by our intelligence. Tell you what, please send me the name of the book.

As for the rest of Pakistan, we have very well moved on, it seems you folks haven't and your PM would quicker use this issue as a political tool too.

She uses it to discredit BNP because they have ties with Jamat which is purely for internal consumption. You know It goes like this -- Anti Pak Remark from BD Government -----> Pakistanis respond ------> The response is fed to common Bangladeshis ------> Common Bangladeshis respond because of nationalism ------> Pakistanis respond in reply -----> Mutual Hatred ----> BNP blamed for not hating enough.

The best way for Pakistan would be ignoring and provoking speeches. Videos like this doesnt help Pakistan at all

 
Its like our colony :lol: and unlike British, we have our colony.



Your food is similar to Drividian people of South India. Why Bangal despite North East state have South Indian influenced diet ?
No doubt they are Your colony practically...Had it not been India how could they have achieved independence..
 
Current Awami regime is illegal-nazayez. They have no people mandate to admin the nation.

Awami league basically an extension of Bharati political party. They have no credibility of their own. This shame less hasina is standing on her raggedy feet by leaning on Modi.

Everything Hasina does is to please her Indian masters. No difference here. So ignoring BD is best policy for Pakistan now.
 
Current Awami regime is illegal-nazayez. They have no people mandate to admin the nation.

Awami league basically an extension of Bharati political party. They have no credibility of their own. This shame less hasina is standing on her raggedy feet by leaning on Modi.

Everything Hasina does is to please her Indian masters. No difference here. So ignoring BD is best policy for Pakistan now.
Thanks for your honest opinion.
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom