What's new

Pakistan’s Faith in Its New Leader Is Shaken

batmannow

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jan 28, 2008
Messages
18,830
Reaction score
-19
Country
United States
Location
Thailand
PAKISTAN's FAITH IN ITS NEW LEADER IS SHAKEN !!!
NYTimes.com
By JANE PERLEZ
Published: September 26, 2008
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan — A week after the bomb attack on the Marriott Hotel here, Pakistan is struggling to deal with a financial meltdown and a terrorism threat that has moved to the nation’s heart and badly shaken confidence in the new government among Pakistanis, diplomats and investors alike.

In New York on Friday, President Asif Ali Zardari met with representatives of a group of donor countries, including the United States and Saudi Arabia, who were trying to come up with $5 billion to prevent Pakistan from defaulting on its debt.

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said afterward that the United States would work toward Pakistan’s economic stability. But no decisions were made, according to participants, except that the donors would meet again in Abu Dhabi next month.

As the financial situation has deteriorated, diplomats here have become increasingly uneasy about the government’s capacity to prevent further attacks on the scale of the hotel bombing, which killed at least 53 people and wounded more than 250 others.

“The cabinet in Islamabad is confronted with a general breakdown of the state,” said an editorial in the Friday issue of The Daily Times, a newspaper that generally supports the government of President Zardari.

In an extraordinary attempt at calming the jitters, Rehman Malik, the senior adviser at the Interior Ministry, met Friday with more than 50 ambassadors to try to reassure them that their embassies and their staffs would be safe.

Mr. Malik’s audience went into the meeting with “very deep concern,” a senior diplomat said. They came out barely reassured, he said.

He and another Western ambassador, neither of whom wanted to be identified when commenting on domestic matters, said they were disturbed that Mr. Malik did not report any progress on the investigation into the Marriott bombing, or how it was carried out. “If they start arresting groups, that would reassure us,” the senior diplomat said.

Mr. Malik used a PowerPoint presentation to outline new security measures that included more police officers around the enclave where many embassies are situated, and more concrete barriers and closed-circuit television cameras.

But a second ambassador said that although Mr. Malik showed “good will,” there were grave doubts about the government’s ability to finance and follow through on the steps.

The American Embassy closed its visa section on Thursday and Friday after what it called continuing threats. Embassy staff members were encouraged to work from home. All American government employees were forbidden, according to embassy orders, to stay at hotels in Pakistan’s main cities.

The bombing has cast gloom over the capital that is compounding the economic troubles that outlasted the administration of President Pervez Musharraf.

Lawyers and businessmen have talked about moving away, particularly to Dubai or Malaysia. Foreign investment had almost dried up before the attack, they said, and now some worried it would disappear altogether. Some of Pakistan’s biggest businessmen had already shipped capital abroad, crimping new business ventures.

Moody’s, the international credit rating agency, cut Pakistan’s credit outlook from “stable” to “negative” on Tuesday, citing dwindling foreign exchange reserves, risks from extremists and high inflation.

Foreign exchange reserves have shrunk to $5.7 billion, with only about $3 billion available to cover payments for oil and food, according to the International Monetary Fund.

A major disappointment for the government has been the failure of Saudi Arabia, a traditional benefactor, to announce concessions on oil. In past economic crunches, Saudi Arabia has agreed to defer payment for the 100,000 barrels of oil Pakistan imports daily from the kingdom, the economists said.

That has not happened this time, and even with the recent drop in oil prices, Pakistan is eating through its reserves at the rate of about $1.25 billion a month, Pakistani economists say.

“The international community cannot allow Pakistan to become a failed state,” said a senior economist from one of the international financial institutions trying to salvage the economy.

Diplomats and others are weighing what steps to take for themselves.

British Airways announced this week that it was suspending all flights from London to Islamabad, the only direct connection between Europe and Pakistan.

At a meeting on Friday, senior officials of the United Nations agencies in Pakistan postponed a decision on whether to send family members of their foreign employees home, participants said.

Such a move would have sent an unmistakable signal that the security situation was grave. It would also likely have prompted some of the 250 United Nations employees to leave with their families, threatening projects ranging from Unicef’s efforts to immunize children against polio to the World Food Program’s distribution of food.

Of most concern, the ambassadors said, is lax security in the capital. On the night of the bombing, the policemen along the roads in the center of the city, which is designated a high-security “red alert zone,” were sitting on the curb eating in the ritual breaking of the Ramadan fast, the senior diplomat said.

That was one reason it was so easy for the truck to approach the Marriott without scrutiny, he said.

Pakistani officials and Western diplomats said they believed that the attack had been organized by the Pakistani Taliban, who work with Al Qaeda in the tribal areas bordering Afghanistan.

Most troubling was the likelihood that the huge amount of explosives — estimated at 1,300 to 2,200 pounds — had been loaded onto the truck over time in relatively small quantities.

It seemed likely that the truck was prepared somewhere within Islamabad, according to a Pakistani intelligence official who declined to be identified by name because he was not authorized to talk on the matter. He said the suicide bomber who drove the truck came from a training camp in Waziristan, a Qaeda stronghold.

The explosives used for the bomb were TNT and RDX, mixed with aluminum oxide, said Talat Masood, a retired army general and a former director of Pakistan’s largest munitions and weapons factory.

Such explosives are commonly found in anti-tank mines, Mr. Masood said. The explosives could have come from stores left behind by the Soviets when they left Afghanistan, he said. He said he was confident that investigators would discover the “signature” that would reveal where the explosives came from.

Though the death toll published by Pakistani newspapers is 53, foreign embassies said they had been informed by the Pakistani foreign office that more than 60 had died.

Two American military men — Petty Officer Third Class Matthew J. O’Bryant, 22, of Duluth, Ga., a Navy cryptologic technician, and Maj. Rodolfo I. Rodriguez, 34, of El Paso, from the Air Force’s 86th Construction and Training Squadron at the Ramstein Air Base in Germany, died in the attack, the American Embassy said. A third American, described as a contractor for the State Department, is unaccounted for, the embassy said.

Even Pakistanis accustomed to suicide bomb attacks against government installations have been shaken by the attack on a landmark hotel and the prospect of more assaults on soft targets.

At a shopping center in Islamabad, Akhlaq Abbasi, 60, leaned on his counter and surveyed his empty store. Sales of fabric for men’s suits and drapes, and cloth for women’s traditional dress had evaporated since the Marriott attack, he said.

Babar Sattar, a prominent lawyer, talking over a cup of coffee at McDonald’s, said he would stay. But everyone was depressed, he said. “The government’s first reaction was: ‘We’ve done all we could.’ That’s what really terrifies people. There seems no way to stopping the attacks.”:agree:

Pir Zubair Shah contributed reporting.
 
All these are happening immediately after Zardari came to power, isn't that something. This is what happens when a convict becomes the leader of the state, the crooks get the message that their man is in power and consequently they become bolder and bolder. Sharif and Musharraf should have come to an understanding; that would have prevented PPP from winning the election and now Pakistan is paying for that failure.
 
instead of staying at home and tackling the critical issues of the country, our president is on a world jaunt from where he is returning empty handed. our PM is making statements which dont make sense because they dont have a handle on the issues. it seems that rehman malik has been entrusted with the running of the country's affairs.

inflation during sept has touched 33%. the rupee rate is shooting towards 80=1USD, the foreign ex. reserves are dewindling fast and power outages are on the rise, the prospects of rabi crops is bleak due to 35% shortage of irrigation water (thanks to india closing the inflows from the chenab) and therefore effect the sowing of sugarcane and wheat crops. already the s/cane production has been downgraded from 62 mill tons to 56 and wheat area under cultivation will reduce by 10-15%. this will force pakistan to import very expensive sugar and wheat to meet domestic consumption.

all this will fuel hyper inflation. get ready for a wild ride.
 
Dude, your posting a doomsday scenario. Your President is out to get money to ensure that Pakistan does not default on debt as the forex is going down(as it is everywhere). Inflation is high everywhere, and the flow of Chenab is low as it is every year during the season.
 
Dude, your posting a doomsday scenario. Your President is out to get money to ensure that Pakistan does not default on debt as the forex is going down(as it is everywhere). Inflation is high everywhere, and the flow of Chenab is low as it is every year during the season.

i invite u to come and spend a week with me in karachi and find out yourself. it is reality.
 
I think fatman has rightly pointed out the helplessnes that the local populace feels over the evolving situation and the lacklustre performance of the Government in this regards. To be honest they could not have scome in at a worse time when the whole world is in an economic meltdown. However, still a political setup might be received with more acceptability in the world and dealing with an economic crisis will give them a good taste of governance. under these circumstances Zardari has not done too badly. I know of the economic woes but if he is able to sort this mess out democracy would have come a long way from its reincarnation. Mind you we seem to be having a Presidential style of Government rather than parliamenttary style.
waSalam
Araz
 
Exactly what i mean-its a global problem.Zardari is not to blame.

But something comes to mind-before the elections, Zardari was talking about reducing the President's post to a ceremonial head, with the real powers being in the hands of the Prime Minster. What happened to that? Zaradari has revoked his own powers? Laid down the executive powers to the PM? Whats happening on that front?
 
Exactly what i mean-its a global problem.Zardari is not to blame.

But something comes to mind-before the elections, Zardari was talking about reducing the President's post to a ceremonial head, with the real powers being in the hands of the Prime Minster. What happened to that? Zaradari has revoked his own powers? Laid down the executive powers to the PM? Whats happening on that front?

Nothing happened and dont even expect anything to happen. It was an all out drama. Zaradri will keep all powers with himself and PM would be a follow on stooge.
Also i disagree with your earlier post that he is out there to collect money for Pakistan. This is not how you collect money, i.e by begging. He needs to stay at home, tackle the most important issues at hand, something like the security lapse that we saw in marriot hotel. We need to make Pakistan a safe place for investers to invest in. We need to make sure that our economic reforms remain constant so that the trust of the investers could be restored.
How long do you think the money got by begging will last? Unless and until a more concrete policy is adopted by this government, just touring around the world with a kashkool in hand will not bring any good to Pakistan, it may fill some pockets though.
 
Exactly what i mean-its a global problem.Zardari is not to blame.

This is one of the most misconceived arguments - that Pakistan’s Economic woes are a result of some Global problem.

The recent problems are 100% due to PPP’s insincerity, recent economic mismanagement, corrupt legacy and lack of credibility amongst investors. Seven months and they have yet not come up with any viable economic plan!

Let’s take a GLOBAL view:

Foreign Reserves

• China’s foreign exchange reserves rose to $1.81 trillion at the end of June 2008.
• Japan’s foreign reserves increased $996.975 billion at the end of May 2008.
• Malaysia’s foreign reserves increased to become $125.2 billion as at May 30, 2008.
• India's foreign reserves increased by US $ 110.5 billion during 2007-08 to US $ 309.7 billion. As on July 18, 2008, India’s foreign exchange reserves were US $ 307.1 billion.

• Pak’s DECREASED from $16 billion to $8 billion in just six months. Around 50% depleted!

So it’s NOT a Global problem!


Stock Markets

• Indian Stocks closed at 13,994 points on 22 September 2008. They’ve been average 13,000 to 14,000 points since ONE year.
• The Hong Kong Hang Sen Index closed 19,632 points on 22-9-08. They been average the same since ONE year.
• The Nikkei Tokyo closed at 12,090 points on 22-9-08. They’ve been average the same since ONE year.
• The Shangai Composite Index closed at 2,236.41, having jumped 9.5% recently.(Link)

• Pak was the BEST PERFORMING in ASIA till Feb 2008. (Link)

KSE in Feb 2008 was at: 14,500 points @ $75 billion market capitalization.
KSE now in Sept 2008 is at: 9300 points @ $46 billion market capitalization.

Pity now, KSE LOST worth $29 billion market capitalization and has been freezed at 9200 points to prevent further loss! Lost above 5000 points!

So it’s NOT a Global example!

Inflation

• Indian inflation remained steady and stable at 12.14% on 25 Sept 2008. (Link)
• Chinese inflation balances growth and inflation at average 7% at Sept 2008. (Link)
• Singapore inflation steady at 6% to 7% at Sept 2008. (Link)
• Middle East inflation averages 10%.

Pak’s inflation hits 30 year high in Sept 2008. Bureau of Statistics reported CPI jumped by 25% compared to last year. (Link)

So it’ NOT a Global problem!


Rupee devaluation

• Indian rupee is Rs.44 per dollar. It’s remained overall in b/w Rs.42 to Rs.47 per dollar since year 2000.
• Pakistan rupee is Rs.78 per dollar. It’s fallen from Rs.61 per dollar in just 6 months. Record devalued!
So it’s NOT a usual global phenomenon!


Pakistan’s Economy overall devastation after 18 Feb elections:

1- Foreign reserves fell from $16 billion to $8 billion.
2- Rupee devalued from Rs.61 per dollar to Rs.78 per dollar.
3- Inflation 30 year highest ever.
4- Foreign investment stagnated and $12 billion flew away to Dubai.
5- KHI stock exchange fell by 5000 points and lost $29 billion worth.


So please don't call this mis-management as Global phenomenon! Regards
 
I don't know why people are blaming the PPP for the drop in foreign reserves. Firstly, those foreign reserves were NOT sovereign wealth funds that belonged to the govt of Pakistan at all like the trillion that china holds. They were bogus money created by Shortcut Aziz to make it look like Pakistan was doing well when in reality they were just debts! :hitwall:

Yes, for 8 years Shortcut and Mushy were busy sabotaging the pakistani economy with economic timebombs set to go off when they were overthrown. Being a dictator Mushy could easily have turned the balance of payments around due to $65 billion in incoming panic dollars from pakistani expatriots after 911 but instead he burned up that opportunity by wrecking the economy by selling off state assets to foreigners, granting huge tarrif concessions to foreign and domestic telecommunications cartels(incredible drain of forex) and of course Mushy didn;t touch the Sindh coal reserves but waited for the oil prices to spiral sky high.

Now the PPP idiots are getting blamed for the disaster Mushy and Shortcut created in order to weaken and subdue the pakistani economy. Oh, they also wrecked power generation capacity and Pakistan now has brownouts every day.
 
Anybody with an ounce of intelligence will figure out the current woes are not the result of PPP's bad policies, but rather the fruit of the policies from the previous administrations 9 years of managing the economy.
The bulk of the foreign exchange surplus was actually bought from the local black currency market, a policy although initiated to a very limited extent under Nawaz Sharif, but taken to extremes during Manufactured Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz's tenure. This put undue pressure on the currency, as it got out that the Govt was willing to buy dollars, they ended up paying prememium of up to a few percentage on the actual black market dollar prices, pushing the Rupee even lower. It was a vicious circle.
That option is still open to the govt, as there is plenty of black market dollar in circulation, however it is to the credit of the financial management of the govt that they have not yet taken this route.

That said, it is also true that nowhere within the PPP do we see any men and women of real calibre, in terms of good administrators, thinkers and problem solvers. Some of the decisions taken by the govt, and some of their failed initiatives show they have no sense of RealPolitik, the case of the failed clampdown on the ISI comes to mind.

The PPP is learning on the job, as it has not had much recent experience of governing. Zardari has proven to be an astute and wily politician, considering the way he has masterminded his own rise to power, leaving polical casualties of stature, like Makhdoom Amin Fahim, Nawaz Sharif, and Perves Musharraff. Let's see how he is as a governor and administrator, and policy maker.
History is his to be made, how will he pen his name in it?
 
Last edited:
=maqsad;199737]I don't know why people are blaming the PPP for the drop in foreign reserves. Firstly, those foreign reserves were NOT sovereign wealth funds that belonged to the govt of Pakistan at all like the trillion that china holds. They were bogus money created by Shortcut Aziz to make it look like Pakistan was doing well when in reality they were just debts! :hitwall:

Bogus money or just debts? First decide.

It doesn't matter if they're held by government or nation's wealth.

Coming to the economics of forex reserves, they are basically held to achieve a balance between demand for and supply of foreign currencies, for intervention, and to preserve confidence in the country's ability to carry out external transactions.

While analysing the potential cost or benefit of holding such reserves it is pertinent to always keep in view the objective of holding reserves which include maintaining confidence in monetary and exchange rate policies, enhancing the capacity of the central bank to intervene in forex markets, capacity to absorb shocks in times of crisis and, above all, provide market confidence to indicate that the economy is well-placed to meet all external obligations and, of course, the security of backing domestic currency by external assets.

Further, it helps the country maintain the investor confidence required to attract the much-needed FDI in crucial and core sectors of the economy. The country also benefits by using the excess forex reserves to repay its liabilities and also use a part of its reserves to finance the import of capital and intermediate goods and to boost domestic production.


Being a dictator Mushy could easily have turned the balance of payments around due to $65 billion in incoming panic dollars from pakistani expatriots after 911

You write $65 billion panic dollars? Wouldn't it have been the 'just debt' you wrote above?

Balance of payments did become favorable in 2003. After 9/11, State Bank did raise around $25 billion, which was used to decrease our account deficit, decrease foreign debt and increase exports.

but instead he burned up that opportunity by wrecking the economy by selling off state assets to foreigners,

Do you know that Pakistan has raised ONLY $6 billion selling state assets in the past 15 years while our economy grew by $85 billion.

Daily Times - Leading News Resource of Pakistan

granting huge tarrif concessions to foreign and domestic telecommunications cartels(incredible drain of forex)

Telecommunications attracted around $10 billion foreign investment.

Pakistan became a hot spot for IT outsourcing
Welcome to E-Commerce Times

and of course Mushy didn;t touch the Sindh coal reserves but waited for the oil prices to spiral sky high.

Sindh coal exploration started in Musharraf's era and that's how we came to know that Sindh had coal record reserves!

Sept 2006: The government has decided to develop the Thar coal for power generation on a priority basis to overcome energy crisis following confirmed estimates that its reserves were equivalent to at least 850 trillion cubic feet (TCF) of gas — about 30 times higher than Pakistan’s proven gas reserves of 28 TCF. Focus on Thar coal for power generation -DAWN - Top Stories; September 02, 2006


Now the PPP idiots are getting blamed for the disaster Mushy and Shortcut created in order to weaken and subdue the pakistani economy.

agreed! PPP are idiots!

Oh, they also wrecked power generation capacity and Pakistan now has brownouts every day.

In 1999, our installed capacity was merely 15,860 MW. (With Hydel 4826 + Thermal 10,897 + Nuclear 137)

In 2005-06, our installed capacity increased to become 20,495 MW. (With Hydel 6499 + Thermal 13,534 + Nuclear 462)

Read the article: Electricity - Solutions & On-going projects
Electricity: Solutions and Ongoing Projects Our leader - Musharraf
 
Our bloody president is hardly in Pakistan. Hes always out at world tours. No one wanted him as a president, he might be removed soon enough by Gen. keyani

-Regards
 
Our bloody president is hardly in Pakistan. Hes always out at world tours. No one wanted him as a president, he might be removed soon enough by Gen. keyani

-Regards

He may not be any good for Pakistan but Army's interference at this juncture would be ill advised and disasterous for pakistan. This is a political game ,let the politicians sort it out. There are no strong arm solutions to the problem, and such a solution will lead to a major disaster and even dismemberment of the country.
Araz
 
Nation should have known this before voting for PPP. There is no point in crying over split milk. Now let's enjoy democracy by Zardari.
 
Back
Top Bottom