Pakistan refuses to release Dr Afridi despite US pressure

[AmberDutt]

You missed the point. Even an allies spy is a spy. Working for any other nation is a crime-treason immaterial they worked for freind or enemy.

Secondly the theory that isi either complicit or incompetent is simply flawed. If they did know he was there it does not follow isi is incompetent to say otherwise is just anti isi anti pakistani propagand propagated by pakistans enemies

ISI is really between a rock and hard place on this one.. If they say they knew, they are damned. If they say they didnt, they are still damned..

 

[lem34]

So in a nutshell , assisting to find Osama's location is a treason to Pakistan , right ?

Please do not apply your interpretation to what I have said. Its irelevant whether it was Osama or not. How would you treat in india an allies spying in india? No country can accept agents from other countries whether they be their own nationals or other nationals

This theory that the ends justify the means is a slippery slope that we do not wish to go down

 

[Gautam]

Complicit with outside nation is treason in any language and any country. Remember that jewish guy who was jailed in america for treason cos he gave american secrets to israelies even though israel and america are practically one.

---------- Post added at 04:54 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:53 PM ----------



Also it will have adverse effect on other ngo's work in health. people will no longer trust doctors etc

You didn't get the context Aryan. spying on a country is a different thing and spying on a terrorist is different. he didn't spy on pakistan, but he did on osama. pakistan should be happy for him.

 

[Night_Raven]

You missed the point. Even an allies spy is a spy. Working for any other nation is a crime-treason immaterial they worked for freind or enemy.

Fine , by that reason , do go ahead !

But if this man is convicted and jailed , please don't crib when the worldwide media slams your country for having jailed the source which led to OBL's snatch.

Speaking of dealing one's credibility a double whammy.

If they did know he was there it does not follow isi is incompetent

Then what were they waiting for : use OBL further as a strategic asset to milk more money from Uncle Sam?

Aryan_B : The world is not so naive , you have to remember that.

 

[lem34]

ISI is really between a rock and hard place on this one.. If they say they knew, they are damned. If they say they didnt, they are still damned..

No they are not. As I said the fact that they did not know he was there it does not follow that they are incompetent. Its the same as saying the attack on Bombay (which we all abhor) that raw were complicit because some of the police killed had uncoverd hindu extremists in the earlir train bombing and it was a set up by raw. And if raw didnt know about it they were incompetent. It just isnt that simple guys. Anyway am going out for dinner Amberbhai have a good evening we make talk later.

 

[Doctor09]

there is no place for Traitors.............traitors must be hanged

 

[acetophenol]

lets wait to see what decision pak judiciary takes on that guy

 

[Imran Khan]

he is pakistani and he is treator of pakistan US should keep his dirty A$$ our of this legal matter of pakistan .these hostile steps of US bring more hate in our hearts .and idiot politicians should stop worship USA now for hell sake.

 

[somebozo]

Digusting to see that an Afridi who are staunch Pakistani patriot and loyalist is caught doing this. He is shame to his nation as well his people.

 

[Gautam]

The biggest terrorist was living life king size quite comfortably in a big mansion. while Someone who helped in finding the biggest terrorist, is in jail!
Is helping in the search operation of a terrorist anti pakistani?
wtf

 

[DV RULES]

US is exceeding from its legal limits, This guy should punish hard that no one will think about working for foreign intelligence. The US has history to support criminals and assistance. What the hell Hillary called president to release who sold its nationalism and patriotism for some dollars.

 

[DV RULES]

The biggest terrorist was living life king size quite comfortably in a big mansion. while Someone who helped in finding the biggest terrorist, is in jail!
Is helping in the search operation of a terrorist anti pakistani?
wtf

Yes, wtf you people have sympathy for this stupid doctor? His activity comes in act of spying so he should sit in the jail as long as possible. He was not allowed by Pakistani authorities to do that and finding this terrorist by US special forces was an illegal act. If they conducted operation jointly then there were no objection over who is caught and why and when.

So stop this nonsense in favour of this traitor.

 

[lem34]

Fine , by that reason , do go ahead !

But if this man is convicted and jailed , please don't crib when the worldwide media slams your country for having jailed the source which led to OBL's snatch.

Speaking of dealing one's credibility a double whammy.




Then what were they waiting for : use OBL further as a strategic asset to milk more money from Uncle Sam?

Aryan_B : The world is not so naive , you have to remember that.

Ends do not justify means. Laws are there for a reason not for fun nor can they be discarded. It doesnt matter what pakistan does world press esp western press is controlled by zionists and they will print crap about pakistan no matter what pakistan does

---------- Post added at 07:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:11 PM ----------

The biggest terrorist was living life king size quite comfortably in a big mansion. while Someone who helped in finding the biggest terrorist, is in jail!
Is helping in the search operation of a terrorist anti pakistani?
wtf

Gautam have you read the earlier posts. Your assertions have already been adequatly addressed

 

[Gautam]

Yes, wtf you people have sympathy for this stupid doctor? His activity comes in act of spying so he should sit in the jail as long as possible. He was not allowed by Pakistani authorities to do that and finding this terrorist by US special forces was an illegal act. If they conducted operation jointly then there were no objection over who is caught and why and when.

So stop this nonsense in favour of this traitor.

How is he a traitor? he was not spying on pakistan, he was spying on osama!
how is finding a terrorist an anti pakistani act? we all were doing the same thing after all.

 

[hunter_hunted]

And y is America is so much eager for his release something fishy going on may b if he really is working for CIA may b he know some thing special.