@PAKISTANFOREVER We must never overlook the fact that only the extreme North West India shares common heritage with Pakistan. We can't deny this - only religion is the division. However this is less than 3-4% of India and if you want to reallty be kind say 5%. That means Pakistan is dissimilar to 95% of India.
I get into lot of flak for this but frankly I don't care I am going to say what I feel. I don't see any similarity between my people with Indian Bengali, Orrssan, Assamese, Telagu, Tamil, Kannada, Malaylam Keralites, Maratta, Bihari, Gujrati, and others too many to enumerate. I don't care what religion they are - for me they are Gangas. Period. I am not saying they are inferior - I am saying they are nothing to do with me.
In Pakistan my only brothers are Punjabi, Baloch, Kashmiri and Sindhi. That is my Pakistan exactly the way Sir Allama Iqbal envisioned.
"Personally, I would like to see the Punjab, North-West Frontier Province, Sindh and Baluchistan amalgamated into a single State".
and Rehmat Ali placed thre meat on the bones by asking for in his pamphlet "Now or Never".
"Punjab, North-West Frontier Province (Afghan Province), Kashmir, Sind and Baluchistan".
I am sick of Indian's making it look like Pakistan is just a sanctuary for Indian Muslim's. There are nearly 180 million Bihari, Assamese, Tamil etc Muslims in India - The Indian's look at Pakistan as just a extention of these. I refuse to accept that. Further the Indian's use the Indian Punjabi's and 'Haryanvis' who are just another subset of Punjabi's as the 'face' of India and proof that India is same as Pakistan. Which again is lie. It's like Nigerians using the Black American's as proof that USA is like Africa.
I am soon taking a break from this forum but rest assured if Pakistan is not defined as differant from India and moves away from acting like a sanctuary for Indian Muslims that will cause in the long term a question. Which way? West or East. The western provinces of Pakistan look West and if the others pull toward India the inevitable fracture will happen along the faultline.
Rattled? Having a differant opinion then yours or not following the sheep makes me emotional? Strange outlook of life you have !