Is that it? Must hurt, ain't it? That your Canada joined in the list of accusers that China is a currency manipulator.
My Canada? Your geography taking its toll?
No, we do not need to be serious about you and your arguments. The differences between Quantitative Easing and currency manipulation are glaring...
Says someone who knows
ZILCH about economic and thinks Japan and the EU will snap up your debt should China decides to throw them out. I guess this "military alliance" thing has lodged into that mind of yours a bit too deeply.
- Internal vs External. The American 'quantitative easing' monetary policy was very much internally targeted against domestic problems.
You have to becareful with your choice of words here. Quantitative Easing was irresponsibly used as a tool by America to drive down long term interest rates by mass printing the dollars and flooding the market with it. This resulted in a deliberate devaluation of the dollars (currency manipulation). It was America's desperate attempt to undermine the competitiveness of China as well as its other trading partners. "
was very much internally targeted against domestic problems." you say?
China's currency manipulation was mainly externally focused, as in how does the yawn fares against the <whatever currency>.
Funny how the world cared less about China's so called "Currency Manipulation" than America...erm I mean Gambit.
America have (Yet again, what a surprise) refused to label us as a currency manipulator. Regardless of how much you spin it, that day never came. Instead, America went on and accused Japan of manipulating its currency. I guess with them being the third largest economy and accepting bilateral trade to be conducted in their own currencies have greatly upset your country.
America must have been frustrated beyond belief!
I'd like to see them accuse the Koreans too of their Won, of course, the Americans love their Samsungs and LG's too much to do so.
Fact of the matter that China is your biggest creditor and supplier of common goods makes it so much harder for you to stomach. Manufacturing jobs will not return to the states regardless and it will not be able to compete with China in the things that we produce and export. When China no longer rely so heavily on the secondary sector (already happening), it will simply move on to countries such as India or Indonesia (Have fun labeling them too in the future)
Domestic consumption drove America's growth when ordinary Chinese were grubbing for food thanks to communist economic fook-ups. Today, it is American consumption (external) that ordinary Chinese need for them to leave those days of grubbing for food. China MUST have a low valuation for the yawn to sustain that growth at the expense of America's internal issues.
You can blame American capitalist "fook-ups" for that. America destroyed its own manufacturing industry and racked up a mountain of debt, is exporting inflation and is trying very hard to be funny by lecturing the world on stage that China is the cause of America's downfall.
Thanks to your country's poor economic planning that your country is now going down the pan. Keep arguing and blaming Bush, Obama, China, Rest of the world and what not. Those are the typical symptoms of a failed democracy
- Duration. The American 'quantitative easing' monetary policy is obviously short term in intention. On the other hand, China's currency manipulation predate the American's 'quantitative easing' monetary policy and require constant monitoring and actions in order to maintain the yawn's valuation against other currency. And again, it require an intense focus on external factors such as the constant REAL exchange rate instead of nominal exchange rate. Real (inflation adjusted) rates are more important than nominal exchange rates between currencies. Once this economic crisis is over, and there are recovery signs that it is, then domestic consumption will be enough to drive American growth again, as it has in the past, then there will be no more 'quantitative easing', while China must maintain the yawn's low valuation to maintain domestic growth.
For America perhaps (just you wait for them to unleash a new round of QE). The effects the last wave of QE has on the global economy is not so short term to say the least. Just look at the Euro zone, America's currency manipulation clearly did not help the likes of Greece, Italy, Iceland, Spain or Portugal. Nobody knows for sure when this economic crisis will be over, in fact more are anticipating a double dip recession, and not so optimistic of their road to recovery. Of course America would love to blame China out of convenience and shy away from developed symptoms of its poorly structured economy. Heck why not do something about Japan and South Korea too? I'd love to see how everyday Americans afford to pay for their goods as the value of the dollar declines and when faced by effects of hyperinflation.
- Response. The American 'quantitative easing' monetary policy was reactive to domestic affairs. On the other hand, China's currency has been proactive, predate the American 'quantitative easing' monetary policy, and must be long term, in order to keep the yawn's low valuation against other currencies.
Try replace the word China with America and Yuan with the dollar. You will quickly see that it works equally well both ways.
America hired you to play its role as the spin doctor now?
Are there similarities in consequences? Of course, such as possibly less costly US goods in export from said 'quantitative easing' and China's currency manipulation. But to say that the American 'quantitative easing' equals to China's currency manipulation is like saying the killing of a person in a cops-and-robbers situation, a woman vs a rapist in the middle of the night in her home, one soldier vs another soldier in combat, and an automobile accident, that all perpetrators of deaths in those situations must be treated the same. No contexts are sought, given consideration, and factored in prior to judgement in all of those situations.
A low Yuan benefits ones who imports from China, providing America stops manipulating its currency by devaluating it and increasing inflating the prices of everyday commodities. It is clear that America has done the world economy a lot of harm and is too coward to admit it.
You brought on the G20. I played your game and it turned out the G20 is not as gullible as you are. Every news source looked at the same G20 and everyone of them saw the same thing: That the G20 refused to call China a 'currency manipulator' out of political considerations, not technical ones.
The fact that America was the only one who came to the summit wagging its fingers at China about the so called "currency manipulation" issue. America was also the only one sitting there defending and tried in vain to justify its role in currency manipulation from all 19 members says otherwise.
It turned out that the G20 is not as gullible as you are and took America's word with a truck load of salt, of course they too refused to label America as a currency manipulator "out of political considerations".
Even your Canada said so.
My Canada? Oh.. you mean your "52nd state"
Looks like it is YOU who needs to take that basic economics class.
Wrong, more like a text book fail from
YOU.
It's hard trying to play economist when you have no clue how the society and economy works doesn't it?
Our? Please...!!! Spare us all that 'our'. You do not contribute to China's economic growth, defense, tax coffer, or even institutional memory. Heck, for all your support for China's dictators, you are too much of a coward to live under that which you defend on the Internet. In living in Canada, you are more American than Chinese.
I have no issues defending where I come from and the fact that I have a house there which I go back to annually is enough to put your cowardice to shame. You have a reason to leave Vietnam and a reason to serve the ones who brutalized the place you came from and are now too afraid to live under. And who told you that I live in Canada? It appears that
YOU have not only failed in
Economics, but in
Geography too!
Seeing your lack in ability to demonstrate how the market and global economy works and your failure to differentiate between the British and Canadian flag. Of course we do not need to be serious about you and your arguments.
Please spare readers of your ignorance. It is now clear to the readers that Economics is without a shadow of doubt, not your thing