PAF shoot down IAF SU-30 MKI l News & Discussion

[war&peace]

Too small for a wing. It is horizontal stabiliser

 

[Zapper]

You should've posted it from your old account. Why'd you wanna create a whole new account with Yankee flags in pursuit of proving an MKI kill hoping it would make you more credible

 

[war&peace]

You should've posted it from your old account. Why'd you wanna create a whole new account with Yankee flags in pursuit of proving an MKI kill hoping it would make you more credible

Does not matter which flags he has. This is PDF and not bhindian media where all types of crap and lies are deliberately promoted & propagated. Two Pakistani members, myself included, debunked it already.

 

[Imran Khan]

not at all

 

[War Thunder]

You should've posted it from your old account. Why'd you wanna create a whole new account with Yankee flags in pursuit of proving an MKI kill hoping it would make you more credible

He posted a question, not an opinion.
Doesn't matter who and where he is from, and he is not giving out an opinion to gain or seek credibility.

Now the questions is, why did the post made you so insecure that you had to question his flags instead of trying to refute the media he provided?



As for the OP. The SU-30MKI fell in a cantonment in occupied Kashmir. You can't expect parts of it to be found in Pakistan.

 

[SIPRA]

As for the OP. The SU-30MKI fell in a cantonment in occupied Kashmir. You can't expect parts of it to be found in Pakistan.

Correct and to the point.

 

[Trailer23]

The Su-30 is a beast. Even its Horizontal Stabilizer might be bigger than the MiG-21's wings.

 

[Earth_Shine]

No it doesn't. It is a horizontal stabilizer of a MiG21. Been posted before

I thought it was the tip of the front wing, but, I realize now, it is the "Horizontal Stablizer of Mig 21.

 

[Evora]

Why you need to create a new thread just for one youtube clip which you not even sure about? You may upload it in already existing threads.
Around 70% to 80% threads created are existed already or based on rumours or fanboy wishes. I dont understand why everyone is given freehand to create new thread.
My suggestion is new thread should be created after the permission of moderator.

 

[glycogen]

I know that this is a pretty old topic but I just don't understand the evidences. Yes the f-16s FCR did confirm the kill along with AWACS radar footage, but it is entirely possible that the flanker was hit but survived. Also, I remember that a user on the forum mentioned something of picture evidence? Like were the TGPs set to AA? Anyways I'd really like to get some info and clears the misconceptions. Thanks!

 

[Riz]

I know that this is a pretty old topic but I just don't understand the evidences. Yes the f-16s FCR did confirm the kill along with AWACS radar footage, but it is entirely possible that the flanker was hit but survived. Also, I remember that a user on the forum mentioned something of picture evidence? Like were the TGPs set to AA? Anyways I'd really like to get some info and clears the misconceptions. Thanks!

Listen carefully what IOK eyewitness saying .. It was 2nd indian jet that crashed in sher makri area on the other side of LOC..

 

[zain41]

Listen carefully what IOK eyewitness saying .. It was 2nd indian jet that crashed in sher makri area on the other side of LOC..

this vid closes the chapter doesn’t it
Indian people on an Indian news channel saying they saw plane crash and talked to pilot? Has to be two different planes since abhinandan landed on our side

 

[Mighty Lion]

Listen carefully what IOK eyewitness saying .. It was 2nd indian jet that crashed in sher makri area on the other side of LOC..

Already busted that theory:

He is clearly talking about Abhinandan's MiG-21 since his Mig crash site in AJK was just 4 km from our sher makadi tehsil in J&K

Distance between Sher Makadi & MiG-21 crash site (Latitude: 33° 13' 54.6" North Longitude: 73° 57' 23.4" East) is about 5 km. And as Sher Makadi is just 2 km from LoC any crash smoke/fire there would be visible to Pakistanis just like MiG-21 crash smoke was visible to Indians. Which means Pakistanis would have then posted pics of smoke or fire on Indian side of LoC.

Also since the MiG-21 crash site was so close to Sher Makadi he though it might have crashed there. We know that Abhinandan MiG-21 came from the direction of Rajauri so his description matches exactly with Abhinandan MiG-21. He says he saw a plane crashing near Sher Makadi which is just 5 km from actual crash site of Abhinandan so he might have though that Abhinandan's falling plane came down in sher makadi.

Also he clearly mentions he saw ONE pilot ejecting which matches with Abhinandan MiG 21 description as Sukhois have two pilots

Most importantly he says he was behind a hill which means he did not have line of sight to crash site (could not directly see it).

Even prominent western Think tank DFRLab agrees that the MiG-21 was hit when it was moving towards India

 

[Metal 0-1]

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/27-f...irspace-dg-ispr.604031/page-677#post-12576872

 

[Oracle]

Listen carefully what IOK eyewitness saying .. It was 2nd indian jet that crashed in sher makri area on the other side of LOC..

there is no evidence .... no clear video
PAF only has blip in radar
indian media isnt showing anything... all claims of eyewitness claiming they saw downing plane but cant comment on site it crashed...
kashmiri confused with helicopter as 2nd plane as well