What's new

Osama Bin Laden raid revisted, the other perspectives, Pakistani locals in Abbottabad do not believe Osama bin Laden was in the city

Witnesses said they did not see Arabs in the city in Abbottabad.

How can a person survive without telephone, television, computer, internet connection, going shopping for food/water, and sanitation services?

What about having a car, etc. A cellphone, etc. Satellite for television, etc.

A little suspicious don't you think?
Why would he lack any of that if the Pak military was sheltering him close to training center? In fact wasn't he caught because the local agent that was buying things etc was traced after Dr Afridi spotted him ?
 
.
Summary execution? Sure, please go ahead, but prove his crime in a court of law first by due process, that is all.
Did US courts prove Afia's crime? Did US courts prove the crime of hundreds of thousands of innocent men, women and children died in USAF bombings?
 
.
Are you saying the Pakistani police did not arrest those wives at that residence? They actually had arrested them in some other location and lied to the Pakistani public?

They obviously captured them somewhere as they were eventually deported...unless you think this van is empty.

Again you are wrong... The cops just arrested people in the house, as they were told. there was no body of OBL to prove that they were his wives. and if they were there, were they interviewed .... no .... nothing came out.. come on... stop being a fool
 
.
Again you are wrong... The cops just arrested people in the house, as they were told.

Told by whom? Well at least you admit people got arrested.

there was no body of OBL to prove that they were his wives.

These women have no ID and their children have no DNA to test to see if Osama was their dad? Interesting.


That Dr Shakil Afridi was sentenced to 33 years in jail for running a fake vaccine campaign in order to try and get the kid's DNA in that building.

Dr Afridi had at least two female paramedical staff to help with the project, according to health department officials in Abbottabad.
It is believed that at least one of the women visited the Bin Laden compound to collect blood samples.

if they were there, were they interviewed .... no .... nothing came out.. come on... stop being a fool

really? It says here that they had been in custody from May 2nd 2011 until at least April 2nd 2012.
That's almost a year to keep some "nobody's" in basically jail. You don't find that time length a little excessive for only being "non-wives"??

April 2, 2012
ISLAMABAD: A Pakistani court on Monday convicted Osama bin Laden’s three widows and two of his grown-up daughters of illegal residency, sentencing them to 45 days detention and ordering their deportation.


The al Qaeda terror chief’s two Saudi and one Yemeni widows, together with their children, have been in Pakistani custody since bin Laden was killed by US Navy SEALs at a compound in Abbottabad on May 2, 2011.

Their conviction is a step towards deporting the women as Pakistan nears the first anniversary of the raid that humiliated the country and raised fears that at least someone in authority must have been complicit in hiding bin Laden.

Monday’s proceedings lasted three hours, presided over by a judge in a makeshift court set up in the plush house where they are living and where they will serve out their sentences, away from the prying eyes of media.

Police commandos barricaded the main gate of the two-storey house and policemen could be seen on the first floor by journalists, confined to the opposite side of the road in the leafy G6 neighbourhood of Islamabad.

Defence lawyer Muhammad Aamir said the 45-day sentence would date back to March 3, when they were formally arrested, and that the deportation process could be completed within two weeks.

“The interior secretary has been directed to arrange their deportation,” Aamir told reporters.

“I think it will be completed probably in two weeks,” he added.

He said the accused were “all in good health” and said they had all spoken during Monday’s proceedings.

Zakarya Ahmad Abd al-Fattah, the Yemeni brother of bin Laden’s youngest and reputedly favourite wife, Amal, said the judge also imposed a fine of 10,000 rupees ($110) each, which he said had already been paid.

“The court has also given direction to the government to arrange the necessary documents for their earliest repatriation, so that they can go to their own country as soon as possible,” he told reporters.

Bin Laden’s two other wives have been identified as Khairiah Sabar and Siham Sabar. The three women have an undisclosed number of children among them, but only those above 12 were charged.

Under Pakistani law, they faced a maximum sentence of five years.

According to a police report, bin Laden hid in Pakistan for 10 years after the 9/11 attacks and fathered four of his children in the country.

The account given to [Pakistani] interrogators by his youngest and reputedly favourite wife, Amal Abdulfattah, sheds new light on the al Qaeda leader’s life from when he fled Afghanistan in late 2001 until his death aged 54 last May.

Abdulfattah, 30, was shot while trying to protect her husband, according to the United States and her brother, visiting from Yemen, who has raised concerns about her health and that of her children while in Pakistani custody.

She said that after 9/11, they scattered and she came to Karachi with one of her daughters, Safia, her first child who was born in Afghanistan.

She stayed in Karachi for eight to nine months, moving between homes arranged for them by Pakistani families and bin Laden’s eldest son Saad.

Abdulfattah then met back with bin Laden in Peshawar, in northwest Pakistan. They stayed for eight or nine months in Swat, then for two years in Haripur, 90 minutes from Islamabad, before moving to Abbottabad in 2005.

During this time, Abdulfattah had four other children by bin Laden, two of them born in a public hospital.
 
Last edited:
.
Did US courts prove Afia's crime? Did US courts prove the crime of hundreds of thousands of innocent men, women and children died in USAF bombings?

Nice whataboutery! I think you want the Conspiracies Anonymous meeting further down the hall three doors to your left. :D
 
.
lol, I completely agree with you. Why should we Pakistanis be held responsible for a mass murderer of 3000 people?

Had I known where Osama Bin Laden was hiding I would have turned him in to USA for the billion dollar bounty on his head. lol.
Hi,

Pakistanis made themselves responsible for OBL---.

If from day two---pakistan had gone in and killed OBL and given his dead body to the US---history would be different.

Pakistanis were busy talking about who done it---america done it---rather than looking at the consequences of american military coming into the region.
 
. .
Osama Bin Laden raid revisted, the other perspectives, Pakistani locals in Abbottabad do not believe Osama bin Laden was in the city

View attachment 859815



Bashir Qureshi who was in Abbottabad at the time, said nobody Saw "Arabs" in the city.

Some suggested why would Pakistan hide a mass murderer?

Some also argued that Pakistanis would have gladly given up Osama Bin Laden for the bounty money on his head.

Or to see Osama Bin Laden tried in an international court of justice for murdering 3,000 people on 9/11.

Or... was the Osama Bin Laden another inside job.

@Clutch
@313ghazi
@waz


no proof provided by USA

hence BS

As USA didn't inform to Pakistan government... Because they believed that government & establishment is protecting to him.

It is very clear message...

protecting him?

so why no security?

Are you saying the Pakistani police did not arrest those wives at that residence? They actually had arrested them in some other location and lied to the Pakistani public?

They obviously captured them somewhere as they were eventually deported...unless you think this van is empty.




OBL was just another scam hatch by US and US installed Zadari gov
 
.
Nice whataboutery! I think you want the Conspiracies Anonymous meeting further down the hall three doors to your left. :D
Do anything but remember that karma never forgets nor forgive. How does it feel when CIA agent Daniel Pearl was executed without any court case? How the relatives of 3000 died 9/11 victims feel? How are Ukrainians feeling the heat of war right now when they killed countless innocent humans in Iraq war?
 
.
Pakistan was threatened or pressurized so it will be one sided story - a propaganda. After all, it did help Obama secure Presidential victory.

I mean a ritual of body being washed/carried in river. What are we, Vikings? 🤣

Benazir Bhutto hinted the death of Osama Bin Laden long before 9/11. If true, 9/11 is planned inside job and assassination of Benazir is not coincidence either. At the end, only ALLAAH knows best.
 
Last edited:
.
Do anything but remember that karma never forgets nor forgive. How does it feel when CIA agent Daniel Pearl was executed without any court case? How the relatives of 3000 died 9/11 victims feel? How are Ukrainians feeling the heat of war right now when they killed countless innocent humans in Iraq war?

Daniel Pearl was some Wall Street Journal reporter. If you think he was a spook then I guess he was only a part-time spook.

Like as if the CIA is going to risk sending some Jewish agent out in the middle of nowhere in Pakistan to get some info. It was Daniel Pearl's own undoing to try and get a Richard Reid story.
 
Last edited:
.

Hillary Clinton on Bin Laden Death: No One Watching 'Could Breathe for 35 Minutes'​

By Dana Hughes April 11, 2012

Hillary Clinton spoke bluntly about Syria, North Korea and the death of Osama bin Laden at the U.S. Naval Academy Tuesday, where as the keynote speaker at the close of a foreign policy conference she revealed that none of those watching the operation that killed the al Qaeda leader last year "could breathe for 30-35 minutes."
The Secretary of State prepared remarks on U.S. strategy in the Asia-Pacific region for the conference, but later took questions from the young future officers about any topic.
Though most of the evening focused on current global challenges to American foreign policy, the secretary's most poignant words were about the man responsible for the largest loss of life on American soil in modern history - Osama bin Laden.
When a student asked Clinton to reflect on bin Laden's death and the process leading up to the Navy Seal mission that killed him last May, she began by talking about her time as a senator from New York during 9/11, and how many of her constituents were affected by the terror attack. She said even all those years ago, she didn't believe there wasn't "anybody in Pakistan who doesn't know where Bin Laden is."
As she gave a play-by-play account of the day Bin Laden was killed, she recalled how none of the officials in the room watching the operation, including President Obama, "could breathe for 30-35 minutes."
Clinton also shared how moved she was when she saw the spontaneous gathering of young people, mostly college students, at the gates of the White House as Obama announced Bin Laden's death. She reflected on what that announcement meant to those constituents who lost so much on 9/11.
"They could think about the future in a way they hadn't been able to before," Secretary Clinton told the students, smiling as she said that closure made her very pleased.
Earlier, one of the midshipmen asked Clinton her thoughts on the diplomatic efforts to resolve the violence in Syria. Describing the continued stand-off with Russia as "frustrating," Clinton said she expected the G-8 conference beginning tomorrow, featuring foreign ministers from eight of the world's largest economies, to be a "rough couple of days" given Russia's deep ties to the Assad regime and it's unwillingness to stop supporting Syria. Clinton threatened that the U.S. and other allies may go back to the U.N. Security Council and force Russia to either veto or abstain on a new resolution condemning the violence.
"There doesn't seem to be any other pass than that one right now," Clinton said, vowing to keep pushing for a resolution, particularly one allowing humanitarian action into the country.
It's estimated up to ten thousand people have been killed in the conflict in Syria, which continues as a deadline for a truce set by U.N. Special Envoy Kofi Annan passes.
"We are not going to give up until we can get some action," Clinton said.
The Secretary of State's keynote speech centered on U.S. Asia-Pacific policy and she called North Korea's impending satellite launch a provocation that threatens the security of the region.
Clinton said the U.S. along with Japan, South Korea, Russia and China will work in "sending a clear message to Pyongyang that true security only will come from living up to its commitments and obligations." But in contrast Clinton praised Myanmar, which she refers to as Burma, as a country that was once rogue but is now engaging with America and the world, and is better because of it.
"Much of the history of the 21 st century is being written before our eyes," Secretary Clinton said. "And a quick glance at Burma and North Korea shows that we have a deep stake in how that history plays out."


Hillary Clinton thought there is nobody in Pakistan who does not know where Osama Bin Laden is? lol.

I don't know where Osama Bin Laden is whether dead or alive. lol.

Then bring proof of those accomplices who wanted to hide the mass murderer, so they too can be brought to justice.

Did you actually think 242 million people in Pakistan would hide a mass murderer?
You would if you consider what he did was jihad.
 
. . . .

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom