What's new

'No question of letting US officials near INS Chakra': India dismisses Russian reports

maravan91

BANNED
Joined
Oct 10, 2017
Messages
849
Reaction score
0
Country
India
Location
India
'No question of letting US officials near INS Chakra': India dismisses Russian reports
NEW DELHI: The country's defence establishment has rejected Russian media reports that India allowed US military officials on board the nuclear-powered submarine INS Chakra, which has been leased from Russia for 10 years under a $900 million deal.
Though there was no official statement, sources said there was "no question" of letting US officials or "anyone else" near INS Chakra, the Akula-II class submarine inducted by the Indian Navy in April 2012, in violation of the terms of agreement inked with Russia. "This is a disinformation campaign being carried out by some vested interests," said a source.
Interestingly, it comes at a time when New Delhi is finalizing talks with Moscow to acquire another nuclear-powered submarine on lease for over $1.5 billion after it agreed to procure four Grigorivich-class stealth frigates - two will be built in India — for around $4 billion from Russia, as was earlier reported by TOI.

INS Chakra, which does not carry nuclear-tipped missiles due to international treaties, is currently undergoing repairs at its base at Visakhapatnam. There was some damage to the tiles covering the submarine's sonar dome.
A 13-member US delegation headed by Rear Admiral Brian Antonio, which came to India for a meeting of the Joint Working Group on Aircraft Carrier Technology Co-operation (JWGACTC) from October 29 to November 3, did however board aircraft carrier INS Vikramaditya for a four-hour brief on Indian aircraft carrier operations on the high seas.
India had commissioned the 44,400-tonne INS Vikramaditya, or the refitted Russian Admiral Gorshkov, in November 2013 after paying Russia $2.33 billion. "The two cases are very different. INS Vikramaditya is owned by India. INS Chakra, in turn, is only being operated by the Indian Navy on lease from Russia. Moreover, nuclear submarines and their operations are kept secret," said the source.

Russian news portal Kommersant on Thursday claimed the Indian Navy had permitted a US technical crew to inspect INS Chakra, saying the "unprecedented scandal" threatened "to seriously complicate the negotiations on the lease of the second nuclear submarine, and on other projects in the field of military-technical cooperation (between India and Russia)".
But on Friday, another Russian news portal, NEWS.ru, asserted that "French lobbyists" had "an ulterior role in spreading misinformation to further their own chances of selling a nuclear-powered attack submarine to India".

India had commissioned INS Arihant, the country's first indigenous nuclear-powered submarine with nuclear-tipped missiles, last year towards its long-standing ambition to have an operational nuclear weapons triad - the ability to fire nukes from land, air and sea. Three more follow-on submarines are being built after INS Arihant under the secretive Rs 90,000 crore Advanced Technology Vessel programme at Vizag.
https://m.timesofindia.com/india/no...m&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=TOIIndiaNews
 
International arms lobby r spending huge amount in indian media to sell their narrative
 
US is known to take down Russian secrets from her allies , i see new love between India and US and these things have a possibility and specially if Russian media is reporting must be based on some thing
 
These accusations can cut both ways. It's possible India is showing US-made equipment to the Russians. Given that India buys military equipment from both countries, such accusations will occasionally rise.
 
There may be some indian juvenile desperate to label this as "fake news" BUT facts about india back stabbing most reliable arms partner Russia is REAL and exposed by Russian officials and quoted by influential Russian daily.

Here is an analysis written by former indian diplomat.

Trust is crucial to India-Russia defence ties

The influential Russian daily Kommersant reported today on an intriguing development with ominous overtones for long-term India-Russia defence cooperation. It seems that Indian authorities gave access to a US Navy delegation of “well-trained technical specialists” to enter the top secret Russian nuclear submarine under the rubric “Project 9711″, which is on lease to Indian Navy within the framework of the so-called “special and privileged strategic partnership” between the two countries.

Apparently, the incident took place when the submarine was docked at the naval base at Vishakhapatanam while undergoing repairs. (The Indian Navy has christened the super secret Russian nuclear submarine as ‘Chakra’.) The Russian daily reported that this has been the second such serious breach of confidentiality that traditionally existed between Russia and India in defence cooperation with regard to the sharing of military technology with third parties.

In an earlier incident, a US Navy team was apparently allowed to visit the Russian-built aircraft carrier with the Indian Navy, Vikramaditya. Upon knowing about the security breach, the Russian side lodged a protest with the Indians. Obviously, that had no effect, as the latest incident involving the nuclear submarine suggests.
Unnamed Russian officials have described the Indian behavior as “outrageous.” According to Kommersant, the incident threatens to “seriously complicate negotiations both on the lease of the second nuclear submarine, and on other projects” in the field of military-technical cooperation between the two countries.

Given the high likelihood – nay, virtual certainty – that the Kommersant report is based on official Russian briefing, this must be taken as a warning from Moscow. Without going into details, Kommersant quoted Russian officials as pointing out that the incident involving the nuclear submarine is of a piece with several recent “unfriendly acts towards Russia” by the concerned Indian authorities.

http://blogs.rediff.com/mkbhadrakumar/2017/11/09/trust-is-crucial-to-india-russia-defence-ties/
 
Confirmed this is fake news and this website is posting repeatedly! Makes me think now many more threads are being started based on fake news to portray a false image ...
 
Looks like some 3rd party is desperate to break Indo-Russia relationship . Indo-Russia military relationship is far deeper than Indo-US military relationship will ever be.
 
There may be some indian juvenile desperate to label this as "fake news" BUT facts about india back stabbing most reliable arms partner Russia is REAL and exposed by Russian officials and quoted by influential Russian daily.

Here is an analysis written by former indian diplomat.

Trust is crucial to India-Russia defence ties

The influential Russian daily Kommersant reported today on an intriguing development with ominous overtones for long-term India-Russia defence cooperation. It seems that Indian authorities gave access to a US Navy delegation of “well-trained technical specialists” to enter the top secret Russian nuclear submarine under the rubric “Project 9711″, which is on lease to Indian Navy within the framework of the so-called “special and privileged strategic partnership” between the two countries.

Apparently, the incident took place when the submarine was docked at the naval base at Vishakhapatanam while undergoing repairs. (The Indian Navy has christened the super secret Russian nuclear submarine as ‘Chakra’.) The Russian daily reported that this has been the second such serious breach of confidentiality that traditionally existed between Russia and India in defence cooperation with regard to the sharing of military technology with third parties.

In an earlier incident, a US Navy team was apparently allowed to visit the Russian-built aircraft carrier with the Indian Navy, Vikramaditya. Upon knowing about the security breach, the Russian side lodged a protest with the Indians. Obviously, that had no effect, as the latest incident involving the nuclear submarine suggests.
Unnamed Russian officials have described the Indian behavior as “outrageous.” According to Kommersant, the incident threatens to “seriously complicate negotiations both on the lease of the second nuclear submarine, and on other projects” in the field of military-technical cooperation between the two countries.

Given the high likelihood – nay, virtual certainty – that the Kommersant report is based on official Russian briefing, this must be taken as a warning from Moscow. Without going into details, Kommersant quoted Russian officials as pointing out that the incident involving the nuclear submarine is of a piece with several recent “unfriendly acts towards Russia” by the concerned Indian authorities.

http://blogs.rediff.com/mkbhadrakumar/2017/11/09/trust-is-crucial-to-india-russia-defence-ties/



Its already confirmed and debunked .... fake news my juvenile delinquent. Maybe if you weren't so blinded by your hate and bias for indians, it wouldnt be so hard to accept
 
First Russia leased them a Chakra gari and then dictates terms...you have balls Russies!
 
There may be some indian juvenile desperate to label this as "fake news" BUT facts about india back stabbing most reliable arms partner Russia is REAL and exposed by Russian officials and quoted by influential Russian daily.
So NEWS.ru is NOT an influential daily, right? Un-named sources in government, yeah right! Sounds legit!

Actually leave everything. In December, Russian minister is visiting India to finalize leasing of another nuclear submarine to India. Lets see if that deal works out or not. Surely Russia won't be leasing more subs to an untrustworthy country!
 
IN as I know is a very disciplined and professional force, the news seems to be fake as no navy would reveal any information about it's nuclear weapons or systems that operate them, IN will not even share any information related to their Kilos let alone Chakra...
 
There may be some indian juvenile desperate to label this as "fake news" BUT facts about india back stabbing most reliable arms partner Russia is REAL and exposed by Russian officials and quoted by influential Russian daily.

Here is an analysis written by former indian diplomat.

Trust is crucial to India-Russia defence ties

The influential Russian daily Kommersant reported today on an intriguing development with ominous overtones for long-term India-Russia defence cooperation. It seems that Indian authorities gave access to a US Navy delegation of “well-trained technical specialists” to enter the top secret Russian nuclear submarine under the rubric “Project 9711″, which is on lease to Indian Navy within the framework of the so-called “special and privileged strategic partnership” between the two countries.

Apparently, the incident took place when the submarine was docked at the naval base at Vishakhapatanam while undergoing repairs. (The Indian Navy has christened the super secret Russian nuclear submarine as ‘Chakra’.) The Russian daily reported that this has been the second such serious breach of confidentiality that traditionally existed between Russia and India in defence cooperation with regard to the sharing of military technology with third parties.

In an earlier incident, a US Navy team was apparently allowed to visit the Russian-built aircraft carrier with the Indian Navy, Vikramaditya. Upon knowing about the security breach, the Russian side lodged a protest with the Indians. Obviously, that had no effect, as the latest incident involving the nuclear submarine suggests.
Unnamed Russian officials have described the Indian behavior as “outrageous.” According to Kommersant, the incident threatens to “seriously complicate negotiations both on the lease of the second nuclear submarine, and on other projects” in the field of military-technical cooperation between the two countries.

Given the high likelihood – nay, virtual certainty – that the Kommersant report is based on official Russian briefing, this must be taken as a warning from Moscow. Without going into details, Kommersant quoted Russian officials as pointing out that the incident involving the nuclear submarine is of a piece with several recent “unfriendly acts towards Russia” by the concerned Indian authorities.

http://blogs.rediff.com/mkbhadrakumar/2017/11/09/trust-is-crucial-to-india-russia-defence-ties/

REAL like your airforce guys spotting submarines by looking down at bay of Bengal.
 
So New Delhi finally caves inn under pressure and admit British arms manufacturers were allowed to have a look around the submarine.
Russia will not be happy, britain is a major Nato Ally
 
Back
Top Bottom