What's new

No proof of Indian involvement in Balochistan: Hillary to Pakistan

EjazR

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 3, 2009
Messages
5,148
Reaction score
1
No proof of Indian involvement in Balochistan: Hillary to Pak- Politics/Nation-News-The Economic Times

NEW DELHI: The US is not buying Pakistan’s attempt to blame insurgency in Balochistan on India. US secretary of state Hillary Clinton, who was on a visit to Pakistan, said that there is no evidence to back up Islamabad’s charge of Indian involvement in Balochistan.

“Well, first of all, we have no evidence of that. I mean, we just have no evidence of that,” Ms Clinton told a group of Pakistani editors in Lahore. Islamabad has repeatedly accused New Delhi of fomenting trouble in the province.

The US secretary of state, who had recently expressed scepticism about Pakistan’s lack of knowledge over al-Qaeda, further described Balochistan as “a very volatile region” and added that she had not seen any evidence from Pakistan about India’s involvement in Balochistan. “Not that I’ve seen...I have not seen it. I have not seen anything like that. So I can’t agree with you because I personally don’t have any information,” she said.

Her comments are significant in the backdrop of Pakistan’s renewed attempt to pin its internal troubles on India. Ms Clinton’s mention that there is no evidence also pulls the carpet from under Islamabad’s claim that it had “solid evidence” to prove India’s involvement in Balochistan. Islamabad had even said said that it was ready to share this “evidence” of “India’s interference” with New Delhi.

Pakistan’s attempt to blame India for the insurgency in Balochistan is not a new accusation but had received impetus after the Sharm-el Sheikh Indo-Pak joint statement, which had a reference to the troubles in Balochistan. The joint statement declared that Pakistani Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gilani “mentioned that Pakistan has some information on threats in Balochistan and other areas.”

That reference had given Pakistan a handle to slam India for its internal problems and blame Baloch insurgency on India. Even as the internal situation in Pakistan deteriorates, Islamabad has tried unsuccessfully to shift the focus to India and its role in Balochistan. In the latest fact, Pakistan’s interior minister Rehman Malik had accused India of instigating trouble and abetting violence in Balochistan and also accused India of funding and helping the Taliban based along the Pakistan-Afghanistan border.

Increasing the decibel level, Mr Malik said that he counted India among the ``elements’’ that do not want Pakistan to be stable. However, Mr Malik’s comments had found no takers.

India also rubbished the claim with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh calling it “far fetched and far from truth”. The prime minister had further said that the senior minister who had levelled the charge of India funding the Taliban also knew well that there was no truth in the allegation.
 
Today 5 trucks with Indians weapons caught in wazirstan operation. When finished with TTP Indians will pay. Get ready

---------- Post added at 03:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:02 PM ----------

No only weapons but also medic, books etc from India shown on Geo News
 
Today 5 trucks with Indians weapons caught in wazirstan operation. When finished with TTP Indians will pay. Get ready

---------- Post added at 03:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:02 PM ----------

No only weapons but also medic, books etc from India shown on Geo News

Can you provide link to this news item?
 
Today 5 trucks with Indians weapons caught in wazirstan operation. When finished with TTP Indians will pay. Get ready

---------- Post added at 03:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:02 PM ----------

No only weapons but also medic, books etc from India shown on Geo News

Please provide links or stop trolling and creating the news :no: This is a defence forum not a forum to discuss your fantasies and dreams.
 
Keep up the good work EjazR......

Everyday new developments rubbish the Pakistani claims to India's involvement in Balochistan and support for TTP.......

To date I or other members here have not seen any proof (Sources.....evidence)....to prove the India-Balochi connection.......and still waiting....

Good thing I didnt hold my breath!!!
 
it doesnt matter. If you show proof, they will still say its "fabricated" by India. But one thing is clear, Indian involvement or not, Pakistan better do something really fast about the TTP and the likes - there s a blast every other day these days.
 
Proof of Indian hand South Waziristan: army

ISLAMABAD: The security forces have found substantial evidence of Indian involvement for assisting terrorists in South Waziristan Agency, Director General ISPR Major General Athar Abbas said.

‘Indian literature and weapons under the use of terrorists have been recovered from South Waziristan and more evidence is being gathered,’ he said addressing a joint media briefing on Operation Rah-e-Nijat here Monday.

Minister for Information and Broadcasting Qamar Zaman Kaira, Secretary Information Suhail Mansoor and Principal Information Officer Ch Rashid Ahmed were also present.

‘We have sent all the proofs of Indian involvement to the Foreign Office for their onward presentation at the appropriate forum,’ he said.—APP

DAWN.COM | Pakistan | Proof of Indian hand South Waziristan: army
 
Accepting Indian Involvement in Baluchistan or their TTP backing doesn't suit America. They are only looking to see the reality they like and they have paid for their blindness in Iraq, about to pay in Afghanistan and will be paying in Pakistan in near future. Reality of Indian Involvement in Baluchistan or FATA doesn't help America but that doesn't mean reality would change on ground. If you guys think India is not involved in Baluchistan and elsewhere in the country, just relax and take your chill-pill.. this fcuking government is on the fall and a$$-lickers are will be seeking flats in UK. Once trash from Parliament and Presidency is cleansed, you will see India's real face and you will not be alone who would see that. Time is near when Indian friends would be giving Kashmir and Punjab as their excuse for their doings in Baluchistan and you wont have to wait longer for that.
 
Strange thing is that Gen MacCrystal, who is sitting in Afghanistan and is the Commander of the US Operations, if he says something of the Indian Factor related to Pakistan in his thorough assessment of the situation, that does mean that he knows something, some intelligence or something with concrete proof has been presented to him due to which he mentioned the Indian Factor in his report, and in my view he is much more informed then Ms.Clinton who got this seat not based on her qualifications, but we may all know the WHY.

Plus her & democrats past & present pro-indian attitude is well known to all.
 
Keep up the good work EjazR......

Everyday new developments rubbish the Pakistani claims to India's involvement in Balochistan and support for TTP.......

To date I or other members here have not seen any proof (Sources.....evidence)....to prove the India-Balochi connection.......and still waiting....

Good thing I didnt hold my breath!!!
did u or any other member here use to get proof of such involvements?
 
Today 5 trucks with Indians weapons caught in wazirstan operation. When finished with TTP Indians will pay. Get ready

---------- Post added at 03:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:02 PM ----------

No only weapons but also medic, books etc from India shown on Geo News

India has the permission from civil govt. of Pakistan for the transit of its carvans.
India have permission to use Pakistan airspace.
India has the permission to keep armed military personals in their embassy at Islamabad.
india is doing nothing illegal by sending those trucks to Pakistan!

BTW, our Pro indian illegitimate govt. of Pakistan is fully protected by US. :smokin:
 
Last edited:
Strange thing is that Gen MacCrystal, who is sitting in Afghanistan and is the Commander of the US Operations, if he says something of the Indian Factor related to Pakistan in his thorough assessment of the situation, that does mean that he knows something, some intelligence or something with concrete proof has been presented to him due to which he mentioned the Indian Factor in his report, and in my view he is much more informed then Ms.Clinton who got this seat not based on her qualifications, but we may all know the WHY.

Plus her & democrats past & present pro-indian attitude is well known to all.

Your entire argument is based on assumptions......

Except for saying that India's presence in Afghanistan makes Pakistan nervous....neither has McChristal implicated India, nor has he presented any proof....

What I fail to understand is how easily and naively you guys forget that the US is paying their hard earned Tax payer dollars to Pakistan as aid so it can fight an enemy that can be as easily eliminated as telling India to stop.......
And not just that....after knowing that India is involved in fomenting trouble in Pakistan...leading to more strain on the US.....the US decides to arm India with the latest weapons, civilian nuclear deal and other incentives.......
Do you think the Americans are stupid to support India, Pay Pakistan to fight the Talibs and at the same time suffer losses in their troops on a daily basis just so they can befriend India.....
Is it just me or are u guys getting delusional-paranoid as each day passes....
Please calm down and think rationally.....
 

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom