No last namaz for terrorists, sympathizers: Clerics

[M.SAAD]

What ever the criminal has done does not justify such extreme measures.

If offering Namaz-e-janaza is not acceptable for a terrorist then it should not be acceptable for a rapist, child molestor, murderer, thieves etc.

Every muslim has some basic religious regardless of his/her actions.

So you consider the 5 Talibans who killed 147 children in Peshawar as Muslims?? and justify saying of their Namaz E Janaza?


Yeah right, got it.


If your family members were the victims of the terrorist attacks, you would'nt be saying such a ridiculous statement .

 

[Zarvan]

Including Terrorists and Suicide Bombers ??

Yes they may be retards and idiots but even Abdullah Bin Ubai got his Janaza. No body can be denied of Janazah.

Sir,

The state has a right to order it----. An edict can passed to declare these people as faithless---and declare anyone dealing with these people as heretics----and then use the law of guilty by association---guilty by associating to offer a namaz a janaza---guilty by association to offer an Islamic burial after the edict has been passed.

No state can't Hazrat MUHAMMAD SAW led funeral of his worst enemy master of hypocrites Abdullah bin Ubai

So you consider the 5 Talibans who killed 147 children in Peshawar as Muslims?? and justify saying of their Namaz E Janaza?


Yeah right, got it.


If your family members were the victims of the terrorist attacks, you would'nt be saying such a ridiculous statement .

Islam rules doesn't change even if you have personally faced tragedy. Funeral is right as a Muslim even if you are the biggest moron still funeral is your right.

 

[Thorough Pro]

no one anti-Pakistan should ever be allowed to be buried in this land.

Hi,

Absolutely---there should be no namaz a janaza and no ismalic burial either----.

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

We all agree that terrorism have no place in Islam or killing innocent in suicide bombing in the name of Jihad is against the teaching of Islam but still there should be namaz e jaanaz for every person who believe in oneness of Allah and finality of Prophet Muhammad(PBUH). If there is no namaz e janaz for terrorist then it should not be for any killers who kill innocent for money or whatever reasons. Even criminals should have rights as they have their families who want to bury them as per normal tradition and giving them this right dont mean you support the act of terrorism . People even attend the funerals of their worst enemy and everyone of us will get rewards or punishment based on our deeds in this life

 

[Hyde]

This fatwah by the clerics could be technically correct but I am against it.

Every dead body deserves the right to be respected and the matter should be left between him and Allah. You can call him a terrorist, murderer and extremist and offer his final prayer at the same time, I see nothing wrong in it... By this logic, every murderer or sinner does not deserve funeral prayers

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

This fatwah by the clerics could be technically correct but I am against it.

Every dead body deserves the right to be respected and the matter should be left between him and Allah. You can call him a terrorist, murdered and extremist and offer his final prayer at the same time, I see nothing wrong in it... By this logic, every murdered or sinner does not deserve funeral prayers

yea they should have said no last namaz(janaza) for everyone who misinterpret religion Islam..

Its not actually right of terrorist but his families who may be innocent and would have nothing to do with terrorism

 

[RoadRunner401]

As a secularist I am vehemantly against this on two grounds:-

1. Howsoever the wrong might be but it is not for the clerics to judge these people. Do this and your on the road to perdition. Assumption has to be made that the persons were Muslim however wrong in their ways and the alone qualifies the right to be buried according to Islamic tradition.

2. Since they are dead the question of punishment does not arise but indeed if it did that would within the realm of the state.

Of course I would support all clerics to teach their followers not to go down the road of wrongdoing.

Just, because one is born with Muslim name doesn't mean he or she is a Muslim. Islam has given us some rules to follow. One of the things almighty made it clear is you are not a Muslim if others aren't safe from you.

you, are basically saying that these pigs are following Islam and therefore are to be treated as such, and the mullahs are saying no you are not a Muslim.

 

[MastanKhan]

Yes they may be retards and idiots but even Abdullah Bin Ubai got his Janaza. No body can be denied of Janazah.


No state can't Hazrat MUHAMMAD SAW led funeral of his worst enemy master of hypocrites Abdullah bin Ubai


Islam rules doesn't change even if you have personally faced tragedy. Funeral is right as a Muslim even if you are the biggest moron still funeral is your right.

Sir,

That was Prophet Mohammad's personal enemy---and even if Prophet Mohammad did---it is not necessary for the state to do the same---. interest.

 

[Zarvan]

Sir,

That was Prophet Mohammad's personal enemy---and even if Prophet Mohammad did---it is not necessary for the state to do the same---. interest.

For Islamic state it is

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Just, because one is born with Muslim name doesn't mean he or she is a Muslim. Islam has given us some rules to follow. One of the things almighty made it clear is you are not a Muslim if others aren't safe from you.

you, are basically saying that these pigs are following Islam and therefore are to be treated as such, and the mullahs are saying no you are not a Muslim.

No I am not. Islam prescribes what a Muslim should do. Very few of us achieve that 100%. Many of us go on to engage in crime from the lower end to the extreme. Tell me exactly at what point on the bandwidth would you decide that xyz does not deserve Muslim funeral rites?

And who is going to decide this?

 

[MastanKhan]

This fatwah by the clerics could be technically correct but I am against it.

Every dead body deserves the right to be respected and the matter should be left between him and Allah. You can call him a terrorist, murderer and extremist and offer his final prayer at the same time, I see nothing wrong in it... By this logic, every murderer or sinner does not deserve funeral prayers

Sir,

When you dignify his burial----you are creating a martyr. Sinners don't fall into that category----you are taking too much liberty with the definition of a terrorist to your personal understanding and advantage.

Why would a sinner fall into that category----.

Some dead bodies need to be chopped up and served to dogs and scavengers---.

For Islamic state it is

No it is not----kid till yesterday you were enjoying playboy and hustler and porno movies and jacking off ten times a day----don't come here to preach your hypocrisy----.

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

Sir,

When you dignify his burial----you are creating a martyr. Sinners don't fall into that category----you are taking too much liberty with the definition of a terrorist to your personal understanding and advantage.

Why would a sinner fall into that category----.

Some dead bodies need to be chopped up and served to dogs and scavengers---.

When someone is dead then his soul stay alive no matter what you do to his dead bodies....to bury some dead bodies in graves no matter how evil they have been in their lifetime no way mean that you are glorifying their wrong actions

does those who kill others for money fall in this category?

 

[Hyde]

Sir,

When you dignify his burial----you are creating a martyr. Sinners don't fall into that category----you are taking too much liberty with the definition of a terrorist to your personal understanding and advantage.

Why would a sinner fall into that category----.

Some dead bodies need to be chopped up and served to dogs and scavengers---.

That's the other side of extremism in my opinion

How about just hand over the dead bodies to the family of deceased? Once you have exterminated the terrorist, it is no longer a threat to you. If the body is unclaimed for the certain period of time, hand it over to Edhi trust and they can offer funeral prayer, bury it at appropriate time and place. I don't see them being dignified in either way.

These bastards are only terrorist until they are alive, if we do the same with their dead bodies which they do, there is hardly any difference between extremists and us.

 

[MastanKhan]

When someone is dead then his soul stay alive no matter what you do to his dead bodies....to bury some dead bodies in graves no matter how evil they have been in their lifetime no way mean that you are glorifying their wrong actions

does those who kill others for money fall in this category?

Hi,

Then et us feed them to pigs---actually let us kill some pigs and put the terrorist body and the pig body in a grinder and make mince meat out of it----and show them the recording on the TV and newsprint and flyer drop---and then let us see how many terrorists want to come ahead to blow themselves up or do the fight---.

let us see how many want to be terrorists afterwards----or let us just bury them with the bodies of pigs----. Let us do an experiment and see what happens to the soul theory of yours

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

Hi,

Then et us feed them to pigs---actually let us kill some pigs and put the terrorist body and the pig body in a grinder and make mince meat out of it----and show them the recording on the TV and newsprint and flyer drop---and then let us see how many terrorists want to come ahead to blow themselves up or do the fight---.

let us see how many want to be terrorists afterwards----or let us just bury them with the bodies of pigs----. Let us do an experiment and see what happens to the soul theory of yours

you forget to mention pissing on dead bodies the way american soldiers did in Afghanistan..If you want to give lesson to others then give harsh punishment to those terrorist you capture in public but abusing dead bodies dont serve any purpose and most of these sucide bombers have their bodies in pieces any way..discussion here is about whther they or their families should have this right of janaz