What's new

New Delhi eyes Israel's IRON DOME

We don't need the Iron Dome IMO. It is used to intercept hostile crude rockets from Hamas and other militant groups who don't have sophisticated arms.

Since when did we start getting rockets from the other side of the border.

Iron Dome is a good tech but just because it is good doesn't mean it suits our needs.

Besides, it's too effing expensive for something we are not going to face.

Iron Dome ore similar C-RAM (Counter Rocket, Artillery, and Mortar) weapons are needed for the defence of forwarded bases and are not comparable to bigger air defence systems like Maitri or Akash SAM.
For Israel, with their geographical location, they are needed to defend their cities, which is not important for us, but for the protection of IA or IAF bases it could be interesting. The question however is, it we have to use expensive missiles to counter such threats, or if C-RAM guns are more suitable for areal defence?
 
.
A JV ala Barak-8 for next gen BMD system would be a better step.
 
. .
Can iron dome protect the installation from Barrage of Rocket from MBRL ,i dont think so and its freaking expensive the best defence is the offence .
 
. . . .
Alternative C-RAM systems:


 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
I haven't checked the actual specifications for CRAM, but physically it can only be effective for much lesser area and for much less intensity. In real war scenario on would have hundreds of flying rockets and shells at a given moment, and a gun can only aim at one target only. As I said a system similar to Iron dome, where you can target multiple objects simultaneously or something similar to Guided anti artillery projectiles(eg 76mm 50 mm etc), where the anti projectile can correct mid-course direction using radar, that will be an effective solution.. I think that iron dome is quite close to that as initial investment in radar is always useful, even if you are don't have enough anti projectiles, it gives you the warning of incoming threat and also even of you take a hit, you know the enemy location for retaliation fire. It itself gives an advantage. But what will matter most is that the cost for each anti missile or anti projectiles fired for each enemy rockets. If you have a system which is coupled with the Iron doe like radar and a guided 50mm anti artillery shells(where the gun is able to fire at-least one round per second with a kill probability of more then 90%). A single guided anti artillery projectile should not be that costly compared to existing iron dome missiles(@ 40K$). Or better would be to have both the iron dome type missiles and anti artillery system coupled with one radar, where the missiles can form the 15km to 7km of defense area for multiple barrage and anti guided projectile for less then 7km and only for less intensity barrages(considering they would be even cheaper then anti missiles of iron dome). And again I'm suggesting this strategy/system only for offensive forces or the border forces ..Don't couple it with the other defense systems. As deep keys strategic areas will not come under fire of such missiles or artillery systems anyway, they definitely need a system like Aakash bare minimum in case of India. India can afford to take hit near border if enemy decide to use sophisticated arms unlike Israel in real war, hence the purpose is totally different.
 
.
setting aside my political or military views on the 'conduct' of this needless war -- I'm actually quite impressed by this israeli iron dome system

while it hasn't been perfect, it seems to have gotten the job done more than half the time...


I wish Palestinians were afforded such a luxury to protect them as well.
 
.
Iron dome is to protect against 50-80 km range rockets and Pakistani and Chinese boundary is way farther. There is no way delhi is buying such a system. We need long range missiles like PAD and AAD with long range radars like Lstar and swordfish. We can get the iron dome model and software to deploy the PAD and AAD. We should try to achieve iron dome type accuracy and efficiency.

If delhi is actually planning to buy this then I guess those pathetic politicians just wanna protect their houses from maoists, because I dont know How Iron done is usefull to Delhi.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom