What's new

‘Neglected’ Bihari youths battle stigma in Bangladesh

BanglaBhoot

RETIRED TTA
Joined
Apr 8, 2007
Messages
8,839
Reaction score
5
Country
France
Location
France
DHAKA, 27 August 2013 (IRIN) - More than five years after Bangladesh's High Court granted them citizenship, many young Biharis continue to struggle against stigma in their quest for a better future.

"Despite having graduated from high school or university, we still can't get good jobs with a Bihari identity," Ijaj Hasan, a 20-year-old Bihari in Dhaka's Mohammadpur sub-district, told IRIN.

Ijaj who completed high school, now works as an assistant in a handicraft factory earning less than US$100 per month.

"I tried to get a government job, but failed," he said. "Even those Biharis with university degrees can't."

Bulbul Ahmed, a street vendor at the Mohmmadpur Bihari makeshift camp in Dhaka, home to some 25,000 Biharis, believes people continue to look down on them.

"Many of us want to go to work overseas, but can't even get a passport," he said.

Passport authorities will not give them passports, particularly when their addresses are listed as Bihari camps or settlements, say rights groups.

Landmark ruling

On 19 May 2008 the Bangladesh High Court approved citizenship and voting rights for Urdu-speaking Biharis.

There are 300,000 Biharis in dozens of camps and settlements in Dhaka and across the country, according to Al-Falah Bangladesh, an NGO campaigning for their rights.

Most Bihari youths are employed in low paid jobs such as day labourers after being denied education in state schools for decades.

According to Refugee and Migratory Movements Research Unit (RMMRU), a University of Dhaka affiliated research group, 94 percent of today's Bihari community are illiterate, compared with a national average of 46 percent.

Historical struggle

Many of Urdu-speaking people are from the Indian state of Bihar. They moved to East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) during and after partition in 1947, fearing communal violence there.

Under the West Pakistan-based government, they received preferential treatment while the majority of Bengali speakers were often marginalized when it came to accessing government jobs, land, property and contracts.

A 1948 decision declaring Urdu the national language of Pakistan underscored tensions between Bengalis and Biharis, who would later be accused of siding with the Urdu-speaking Pakistan army during Bangladesh's 1971 war for independence.

After the war, more than 100,000 Bihari Urdu-speakers moved to Pakistan, while thousands of other Urdu speakers were left stateless within Bangladesh.

Marginalized, discriminated against, and viewed as Pakistani collaborators, they were forced into squalid refugee camps and settlements where they continue to live to this day despite the 2008 high court ruling.

"There has been no significant improvement in the lives of Urdu-speaking people," said Ahmed Ilias, executive director of Al-Falah, noting that Biharis still do not receive the same rights as other Bangladesh citizens.

"Urdu-speaking people who live in the camps can't even open bank accounts, nor receive loans from a bank," he said.

"Social stigma continues and as a result Urdu-speaking people are struggling to integrate in the mainstream of the society. It seems that government is not concerned about us. We don't see any effective plan to properly rehabilitate the community," Ilias said.

Bihari children are unable to study in their mother tongue, leading many to drop out.

Government support needed

Mohammad Hasan, general secretary of the Association of Young Generation of Urdu-Speaking Community, said unemployment is rife in the Bihari community.

"Unable to access government jobs, many Biharis end up doing odd jobs or menial labour," he said.

CR Abrar, RMMRU's coordinator, said the mindset of the people and the politicians of the country towards its Urdu-speaking population remains problematic.

"Ministers and government officials often identify them as `standard Pakistanis' despite the High Court order. Thus there is still a lack of political will for the betterment of this community," he said, adding: "Civil society groups and rights groups are concerned about other minority groups, but this group is largely neglected."

A comprehensive programme is needed incorporating education, health rights and income generation and other basic rights issues, Abrar said.

"A mass awareness programme is now needed to ensure that Biharis are treated like other citizens."

http://www.irinnews.org/report/98651/neglected-bihari-youth-battle-stigma-in-bangladesh
 
.
Any comments idune, al zakir, monitor, m_saint etc?

Are there any other biharis on the forum?
 
.
then they should stop identify themselves as Bihari. I have few friends who are in top position despite being Bihari. One is even thinking of running for Mayor in Dhaka.
 
.
Any comments idune, al zakir, monitor, m_saint etc?

Are there any other biharis on the forum?

it is fact Hindu is in better condition than bihari Muslim

i was living in chittagong around 4 year, just behind khulshi ,there is Hugh bihari colony, if you will enter in that colony , you will feel like indian bihar , still every buddy speak hindi/urdu

but i never find ,they are less confident or suppress,or being discriminated , maje mai hai log

what ever be reason , not being develop ,

they are happy and very much in main stream
 
.
it is fact Hindu is in better condition than bihari Muslim

i was living in chittagong around 4 year, just behind khulshi ,there is Hugh bihari colony, if you will enter in that colony , you will feel like indian bihar , still every buddy speak hindi/urdu

but i never find ,they are less confident or suppress,or being discriminated , maje mai hai log

what ever be reason , not being develop ,

they are happy and very much in main stream

Thats a refugee camp without police protecting them. They dont own the colony. Like any other refugee they have little belongings. Things should start changing now as they were granted citizenship.
 
.
Any comments idune, al zakir, monitor, m_saint etc?

Are there any other biharis on the forum?

@ I am sure, there is not a single Bihari in this forum !(From Bangladesh) How come they will write something in this forum ? They are hardly any educated lots ! Rather they are too busy to repair your computer, car, bike, freeze etc. Few days back I gave a job to one Bihari as a painter. He was expart in all jobs. He can repair a fan, he can be a good "Rajmistree" for a construction job, he is a electric machanic. One day I went to his house at Kalshi (Mirpur), then he showed me his brother's shop. I asked him what he does ? Then he showed me a store room where they have collected all fuzed energy bulb and tube lights and then he repairs all those within no time.

@ So, this the common living of Biharis in our country. Some Biharis works as a "Rickshaw" puller, some works as box makers and so on.
 
.
then they should stop identify themselves as Bihari. I have few friends who are in top position despite being Bihari. One is even thinking of running for Mayor in Dhaka.

I also never heard that for being Bihari one is not getting job, admission in educational institutes. If one is educated, there's nothing about his ethnic background at least I've seen that. It's true their lives at Geneva camps are really poor but many Bangali also live that life in BD where 50% live under poverty line. If one can manage to be qualified from any ethnicity, there's no obstacle in getting with main stream society.

I'm giving example of my Bihari friend's family- my friend is currently working for NYPD, USA, one of his brothers is BCS Veterinary Physician, another one is currently lecturer in Australia who was lecturer at Khulna University before. This family owns more than average properties in Khulna city. If they are facing so much adversity in the society, how one became BCS cadre, another one got lecturer position in a public university? The reporter diverted the fact that people living under poverty line be it Bihari/Bangali or any can't manage to be with the main stream society.
 
.
it is fact Hindu is in better condition than bihari Muslim

i was living in chittagong around 4 year, just behind khulshi ,there is Hugh bihari colony, if you will enter in that colony , you will feel like indian bihar , still every buddy speak hindi/urdu

but i never find ,they are less confident or suppress,or being discriminated , maje mai hai log

what ever be reason , not being develop ,

they are happy and very much in main stream

I don't understand why do people mention Hindu here...Hindu are ethnically Bangali like Bangali Muslim, they're main stream part of the society. And in every participation it's treated as Bangali not Hindu or Muslim other than armed forces where I found that it's Hindu people who're not interested that much though there are barriers at the top level of military for them...they'll never be promoted as chief of staffs as far as I understand, their highest reach is Major General but it's only in armed forces not in other sectors. In the cadre levels there are always some Hindu guys at secretary level.
 
. .
I also never heard that for being Bihari one is not getting job, admission in educational institutes. If one is educated, there's nothing about his ethnic background at least I've seen that. It's true their lives at Geneva camps are really poor but many Bangali also live that life in BD where 50% live under poverty line. If one can manage to be qualified from any ethnicity, there's no obstacle in getting with main stream society.

I'm giving example of my Bihari friend's family- my friend is currently working for NYPD, USA, one of his brothers is BCS Veterinary Physician, another one is currently lecturer in Australia who was lecturer at Khulna University before. This family owns more than average properties in Khulna city. If they are facing so much adversity in the society, how one became BCS cadre, another one got lecturer position in a public university? The reporter diverted the fact that people living under poverty line be it Bihari/Bangali or any can't manage to be with the main stream society.

Exception cannot be a example most of the Bihari generation in last 4 decade pass their life inside ghettos so most of them failed to get any education as the were hanging between become a Pakistani or Bangladeshi . my experience with Bihari is seeing them working as hair dresser in lalmatia area .
 
.
@ I am sure, there is not a single Bihari in this forum !(From Bangladesh) How come they will write something in this forum ? They are hardly any educated lots ! Rather they are too busy to repair your computer, car, bike, freeze etc. Few days back I gave a job to one Bihari as a painter. He was expart in all jobs. He can repair a fan, he can be a good "Rajmistree" for a construction job, he is a electric machanic. One day I went to his house at Kalshi (Mirpur), then he showed me his brother's shop. I asked him what he does ? Then he showed me a store room where they have collected all fuzed energy bulb and tube lights and then he repairs all those within no time.

@ So, this the common living of Biharis in our country. Some Biharis works as a "Rickshaw" puller, some works as box makers and so on.

You're saying about unfortunate poor people of BD not particularly Bihari...plz recap. Any Bangladeshi without question allows the contribution of Akram Khan towards our cricket team, he is the guy who took our cricket to most prestigious position- he is Bihari. If he's Bihari, both Nafees and Tamim are also Bihari.
 
.
Exception cannot be a example most of the Bihari generation in last 4 decade pass their life inside ghettos so most of them failed to get any education as the were hanging between become a Pakistani or Bangladeshi . my experience with Bihari is seeing them working as hair dresser in lalmatia area .

I'm saying that like those Bihari guys there are more Bangalis deprived of education, jobs. If one has qualification, he'll get his job at least will not be rejected for his ethnic identity Bihari. If you have any good example where one Bihari being qualified was rejected from job for his identity, let us know.

I always accept the truth of their miserable life in ghettos but here the talks were on discrimination based on ethnic identity Bihari.
 
.
@monitor @PlanetSoldier I have an idea....how about relocating them to Chittagong hilly areas??The government(all parties) have been relocating Bengalis from different region to CTG for a quite a long time to hold control of the area....do you think we can trust a Bihari majority population in Rangamati/Bandarban??If we could relocate them then it would give them scopes to farm and establish government schools to bring out the future generation out of poverty.Also given their expertise in mechanical areas...government could give them quotas in technical education and make skilled labors out of them and have them work in other countries!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
@monitor @PlanetSoldier I have an idea....how about relocating them to Chittagong hilly areas??The government(all parties) have been relocating Bengalis from different region to CTG for a quite a long time to hold control of the area....do you think we can trust a Bihari majority population in Rangamati/Bandarban??If we could relocate them then it would give them scopes to farm and establish government schools to bring out the future generation out of poverty.Also given their expertise in mechanical areas...government could give them quotas in technical education and make skilled labors out of them and have them work in other countries!

Brainstormed too much...huh :pissed: ? Only the quota system is feasible to get them on main stream society and forget other parts, there are dangers as well :disagree: .
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
@monitor @PlanetSoldier I have an idea....how about relocating them to Chittagong hilly areas??The government(all parties) have been relocating Bengalis from different region to CTG for a quite a long time to hold control of the area....do you think we can trust a Bihari majority population in Rangamati/Bandarban??If we could relocate them then it would give them scopes to farm and establish government schools to bring out the future generation out of poverty.Also given their expertise in mechanical areas...government could give them quotas in technical education and make skilled labors out of them and have them work in other countries!

Are you nuts? It would be like adding oil to the fire.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom