What's new

My journey as a Pakistani-Hindu

ArsalanKhan21

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 4, 2015
Messages
4,006
Reaction score
-2
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
My journey as a Pakistani-Hindu – The Express Tribune Blog

My journey as a Pakistani-Hindu
By Raj Kumar Published: November 13, 2015
Tweet

30248-hindu-1447417546-523-640x480.jpg

I believe religion is not the cause of tension between us, as religion itself teaches us tolerance and co-existence. PHOTO: REUTERS

When I went to the United States for a semester abroad, I was frequently asked a rather bothersome question,

“How are you treated, being a minority in your country?”

My answer has always been very simply, I am treated just like anyone else; one of their own. But if one were to believe the media, then we are victims of discrimination, brutal killings and part of the largest migration in human history.

For the last four years, I have been living with a Muslim family as a paying guest and I have never felt discriminated on the basis of my religion, or any other basis for that matter, in their home. The only form of prejudice I have ever faced is when I went to Islamabad for higher education. As I introduced myself in class, the mere mention of my name made the other students and teacher question if I was Indian. I couldn’t understand how they failed to know that the Pakistani population constituted 1.2% Hindus.

However, that wasn’t the last of it. During a cricket match between India and Pakistan, one that we were watching in class, and I was supporting the Pakistani team, much to the astonishment of some of my classmates. In fact, a friend of mine even asked why I was not supporting the Indian team. In that moment, I wish I had a Pakistani copy right patent next to my name, so I didn’t have to give any explanations. Did I have to support the Indian team simply because of my name or religion?

As far as my identity is concerned, there are many times that I have had to show my NADRA identity card to ensure people that I am a Pakistani, be it the local merchant or the traffic police. But I don’t believe a Muslim feels any differently in the US. I am sure s/he has to prove his/her identity as an American-Muslim too.

Unlike what everyone seems to think, for me, it has been a blessing to be born into a Hindu family in a Muslim state; I have been treated with nothing but respect, care and love. From schooling to university, I was always surrounded by Muslim friends. I have studied Islamiat like every other student in Pakistan, and furthermore, I was extremely appreciated by my teachers.

I was the first Hindu to get admission in the Army Public School Chhor Cantonment in Mirpur Khas, Sindh. I remember the days when I used to fast during Ramazan as a respectful gesture to my Muslim friends. On the first day of my fast, the warden of the hostel offered me a seat near him and we opened our fast together. I also remember the days when I participated in Muharram procession in the small town of Dhoronaro.

Even though the common notion is that minorities in Pakistan need to be pitied, I have never felt that way. Most of the blame I would set for such a deplorable reputation would be at the media; it has portrayed the situation of the minorities living in Pakistan as third-class citizens. Yet, I have never been treated anything remotely close to that. Last month, I travelled to India for the first time as I had to attend a conference in Chandigarh. Even though I was in a country that was home to millions belonging to the same religion and caste as me, I missed my country, my home, my identity and my people.

I won’t deny that I was bombarded with questions regarding the status of Hindus in Pakistan. But being a Pakistani Hindu, I was unbiased and precise with my answers. I told them that I have always felt like a star of my country and I feel safe, which is why I am as loyal as any Muslim in the country. Pakistan doesn’t just belong to Muslims; it belongs to all the residents of its soil. Furthermore, there is good and bad everywhere in the world, but one should stay positive and if it’s about the security, then the Muslims themselves are not safe either. So why single out a particular community based on what is being portrayed to the world?

I believe religion is not the cause of tension between us, as religion itself teaches us tolerance and coexistence. I have been sharing my religious festivals (Holi, Diwali, and Raksha bandhan) with my Muslims friends and I tend to participate in their festivals (Eidul Fitr) with the same zeal.

I even took my friends to Katas Raj Temple, which is the national heritage, just so they realise that it doesn’t just belong to Hindus.

We are a happy family with different identities. As a nation, we share the same food, clothes, buildings, laws, and events. All these elements are what bring us together under the same umbrella, then why do we look for reasons to hate each other?

Besides, living here as Raj, my name has provided me quite a unique edge over everyone else; according to one of my female friends, my name is easy to remember (I believe I have Shahrukh Khan to thank for that), and makes me easy to fall in love with! Well, there we have it. I wouldn’t want it any other way. Surprised?

Tweet

102 Comments Print Email
Follow @etribune
on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook
2695.jpg

Raj Kumar
The author is an educationist and a freelance trainer. He tweets as @RKGujar.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.
 
.
Amazing. The article is full of instances where the author was discriminated against for being a Hindu. His loyalty questioned from school itself, having to show ID proof to prove citizenship, etc. Yet, the conclusion that he draws from all this is that he is the "star" of Pakistan. In India, if a Muslim wrote of such an experience, there would be universal outrage and a fresh round of "Award Wapsi" protesting against the treatment of minorities.

Just goes to show. If you set the bar low enough, anything except the pitch black becomes pristine. This guy has embraced dhimmitude and life as a third class (non)citizen and is proud of it. The only thing that he (probably) does not do is pay Jizya directly. And even that we can only assume because he hasn't mentioned it.

Well done Pakistan. Well done.
 
.
. This guy has embraced dhimmitude and life as a third class (non)citizen and is proud of it.

There is no Dhimmi or Jizya in Pakistan. You are being paranoid and should visit Pakistan before passing judgements. Why don't read some comments first on that page.

My journey as a Pakistani-Hindu – The Express Tribune Blog
  • Harjit Singh Dhanoa • a month ago
    I am British Sikh and went to Pakistan several years ago on work related visit and was based in Lahore for over six months. During my stay I had to travel extensively into villages and 'Chonna Mandies' and at times traveled very late at night.
    I felt so much at home & secure and was made to feel most welcome and enjoyed every minute of my stay.During my six months stay NOT once I was asked to produce my identity although I always carried my passport. I have traveled the world over and now retired. Pakistan was my best EVER trip.
    There are many amusing but extremely funny incidences that I love to relate to my friends particularly to my Pakistani friends.

    Amerta Langhani sujata 12 days ago
    sujata, I have been living in Karachi as a Pakistani Hindu for last 6 years & have been expecting same discrimination. But you know what! Sometimes we confuse discrimination with uniqueness/feeling of being odd one out among herd of people belonging to the same background. Have you ever met a person who was forcefully converted? You never know the background story. I can say this because I have met people converting by their own choice;calling it an inspiration from a certain faith or whatsoever! For the bindi thing;I know a married hindu girl from my university who puts on bindi,sundur & all the epitomes of her religion courageously for years. I always worried If thats safe for her? Thankfully she is SAFE. I always excuse my muslim friends for this as I myself would feel awkward for having bindi or anything on. But they appreciate her saying Its great that she is being herself and following her values. Isn't it a good example of mutual existence & tolerance? Its all about how you let yourself feel! And for cricket thing; they will even call Muslim; an Indian & gadaar If he supports India. After all Rawaitii Hareef hen India and Pak. Itna typical patriotism to banta hy :P
    I don't say Its all good. Fanatics and extremist are around us. But you can not label the whole nation.
 
Last edited:
.
Real sad state of affairs.

I remember living in Karachi where I used to had Punjabi Christians and Sindhi Hindu friends along with Muslim friends. Karachi is truly cosmopolitan.
 
.
Loved reading it. I always say, it's the media, painting the wrong picture. Unfortunately, people today rely so much on media & don't get their facts right.
 
Last edited:
.
Amazing. The article is full of instances where the author was discriminated against for being a Hindu. His loyalty questioned from school itself, having to show ID proof to prove citizenship, etc. Yet, the conclusion that he draws from all this is that he is the "star" of Pakistan. In India, if a Muslim wrote of such an experience, there would be universal outrage and a fresh round of "Award Wapsi" protesting against the treatment of minorities.

Just goes to show. If you set the bar low enough, anything except the pitch black becomes pristine. This guy has embraced dhimmitude and life as a third class (non)citizen and is proud of it. The only thing that he (probably) does not do is pay Jizya directly. And even that we can only assume because he hasn't mentioned it.

Well done Pakistan. Well done.

What are you talking about? He was not discriminated. All those questions are very normal for any minority group to hear in any country. Wether it's USA or Pakistan. Even British or American born Muslims or any minority group faces such questions. I find it totally normal, rather discriminating. How did you just come up with this conclusion of Jizya & dhimmitude? That doesn't even exist in Pakistan. Have you ever visited Pakistan?
 
Last edited:
.
There is no Dhimmi or Jizya in Pakistan. You are being paranoid and should visit Pakistan before passing judgements. Why don't read some comments first on that page.
Incorrect.
There is dhimmi status in Pakistan.

The Pakistani constitution legally bars non-Muslims from becoming either the President or Prime Minister or Chief of Military of Pakistan.

Thereby directly making all some/non-Muslim citizens of Pakistan second class citizens.

That a non-Muslim might never actually get elected to be the PM or Prez is acceptable, as long as he is at least not constitutionally discriminated against.

So please get your facts right. Or at the very least, don't presume that we are not aware of Pakistan's laws.
 
.
The Pakistani constitution legally bars non-Muslims from becoming either the President or Prime Minister or Chief of Military of Pakistan.

There are only few positions restricted for Muslims only. That does not mean other cannot all other positions.
 
.
There are only few positions restricted for Muslims only. That does not mean other cannot all other positions.
Those 'some' positions are the most important positions in Pakistan.
Which also emphasizes my point - that if even one post is barred for non-Muslims, the non-Muslim citizens of Pakistan automatically become second class citizens by the law.

Note - I know the ground reality might be that a non-Muslim might never get elected to be the PM or Prez but it is still okay as they are legally citizens of Pakistan with theoretically equal opportunities and rights. Legally discriminating against them very clearly says that there is a dhimmi status for non-Muslims in Pakistan.
 
. .
Incorrect.
There is dhimmi status in Pakistan.

The Pakistani constitution legally bars non-Muslims from becoming either the President or Prime Minister or Chief of Military of Pakistan.

Thereby directly making all some/non-Muslim citizens of Pakistan second class citizens.

That a non-Muslim might never actually get elected to be the PM or Prez is acceptable, as long as he is at least not constitutionally discriminated against.

So please get your facts right. Or at the very least, don't presume that we are not aware of Pakistan's laws.
Correctly said,infact Satya Prakash Singha, leader of the then Punjab Christian League, became the first Speaker of the Punjab Assembly after independence.But he resigned the next day after an editor wrote in the biggest Urdu-language newspaper that he never imagined that a non-Muslim would occupy that office in Pakistan
‘Religious discrimination harms Pakistan, defies Quaid’s vision’ - Pakistan - DAWN.COM
 
.
1.2% Hindus left only and Jinnah said Pakistan is for everyone .

Pakistan should worry about decreasing minority population . The feel good article want do much .
 
.
There is no Dhimmi or Jizya in Pakistan. You are being paranoid and should visit Pakistan before passing judgements. Why don't read some comments first on that page.

My journey as a Pakistani-Hindu – The Express Tribune Blog
  • Harjit Singh Dhanoa • a month ago
    I am British Sikh and went to Pakistan several years ago on work related visit and was based in Lahore for over six months. During my stay I had to travel extensively into villages and 'Chonna Mandies' and at times traveled very late at night.
    I felt so much at home & secure and was made to feel most welcome and enjoyed every minute of my stay.During my six months stay NOT once I was asked to produce my identity although I always carried my passport. I have traveled the world over and now retired. Pakistan was my best EVER trip.
    There are many amusing but extremely funny incidences that I love to relate to my friends particularly to my Pakistani friends.

    Amerta Langhani sujata 12 days ago
    sujata, I have been living in Karachi as a Pakistani Hindu for last 6 years & have been expecting same discrimination. But you know what! Sometimes we confuse discrimination with uniqueness/feeling of being odd one out among herd of people belonging to the same background. Have you ever met a person who was forcefully converted? You never know the background story. I can say this because I have met people converting by their own choice;calling it an inspiration from a certain faith or whatsoever! For the bindi thing;I know a married hindu girl from my university who puts on bindi,sundur & all the epitomes of her religion courageously for years. I always worried If thats safe for her? Thankfully she is SAFE. I always excuse my muslim friends for this as I myself would feel awkward for having bindi or anything on. But they appreciate her saying Its great that she is being herself and following her values. Isn't it a good example of mutual existence & tolerance? Its all about how you let yourself feel! And for cricket thing; they will even call Muslim; an Indian & gadaar If he supports India. After all Rawaitii Hareef hen India and Pak. Itna typical patriotism to banta hy :P
    I don't say Its all good. Fanatics and extremist are around us. But you can not label the whole nation.

You can find such individual anecdotal references everywhere. Some members of minority community, even in the most repressive places, are co-opted by offering them freebies so that they can then be displayed as exhibits of equal opportunities. These people are usually the illegitimate beneficiaries of such a system and have no interest in rocking the boat.

A black person is the President of the US. Yet no one ever claimed that blacks are not discriminated against in America. Non-Muslims are not even allowed to aspire for the top jobs in Pakistan. Where in all this do you not see a totally discriminatory state that reduces its minorities to third class status?
 
.
My journey as a Pakistani-Hindu – The Express Tribune Blog

My journey as a Pakistani-Hindu
By Raj Kumar Published: November 13, 2015
Tweet

30248-hindu-1447417546-523-640x480.jpg

I believe religion is not the cause of tension between us, as religion itself teaches us tolerance and co-existence. PHOTO: REUTERS

When I went to the United States for a semester abroad, I was frequently asked a rather bothersome question,

“How are you treated, being a minority in your country?”

My answer has always been very simply, I am treated just like anyone else; one of their own. But if one were to believe the media, then we are victims of discrimination, brutal killings and part of the largest migration in human history.

For the last four years, I have been living with a Muslim family as a paying guest and I have never felt discriminated on the basis of my religion, or any other basis for that matter, in their home. The only form of prejudice I have ever faced is when I went to Islamabad for higher education. As I introduced myself in class, the mere mention of my name made the other students and teacher question if I was Indian. I couldn’t understand how they failed to know that the Pakistani population constituted 1.2% Hindus.

However, that wasn’t the last of it. During a cricket match between India and Pakistan, one that we were watching in class, and I was supporting the Pakistani team, much to the astonishment of some of my classmates. In fact, a friend of mine even asked why I was not supporting the Indian team. In that moment, I wish I had a Pakistani copy right patent next to my name, so I didn’t have to give any explanations. Did I have to support the Indian team simply because of my name or religion?

As far as my identity is concerned, there are many times that I have had to show my NADRA identity card to ensure people that I am a Pakistani, be it the local merchant or the traffic police. But I don’t believe a Muslim feels any differently in the US. I am sure s/he has to prove his/her identity as an American-Muslim too.

Unlike what everyone seems to think, for me, it has been a blessing to be born into a Hindu family in a Muslim state; I have been treated with nothing but respect, care and love. From schooling to university, I was always surrounded by Muslim friends. I have studied Islamiat like every other student in Pakistan, and furthermore, I was extremely appreciated by my teachers.

I was the first Hindu to get admission in the Army Public School Chhor Cantonment in Mirpur Khas, Sindh. I remember the days when I used to fast during Ramazan as a respectful gesture to my Muslim friends. On the first day of my fast, the warden of the hostel offered me a seat near him and we opened our fast together. I also remember the days when I participated in Muharram procession in the small town of Dhoronaro.

Even though the common notion is that minorities in Pakistan need to be pitied, I have never felt that way. Most of the blame I would set for such a deplorable reputation would be at the media; it has portrayed the situation of the minorities living in Pakistan as third-class citizens. Yet, I have never been treated anything remotely close to that. Last month, I travelled to India for the first time as I had to attend a conference in Chandigarh. Even though I was in a country that was home to millions belonging to the same religion and caste as me, I missed my country, my home, my identity and my people.

I won’t deny that I was bombarded with questions regarding the status of Hindus in Pakistan. But being a Pakistani Hindu, I was unbiased and precise with my answers. I told them that I have always felt like a star of my country and I feel safe, which is why I am as loyal as any Muslim in the country. Pakistan doesn’t just belong to Muslims; it belongs to all the residents of its soil. Furthermore, there is good and bad everywhere in the world, but one should stay positive and if it’s about the security, then the Muslims themselves are not safe either. So why single out a particular community based on what is being portrayed to the world?

I believe religion is not the cause of tension between us, as religion itself teaches us tolerance and coexistence. I have been sharing my religious festivals (Holi, Diwali, and Raksha bandhan) with my Muslims friends and I tend to participate in their festivals (Eidul Fitr) with the same zeal.

I even took my friends to Katas Raj Temple, which is the national heritage, just so they realise that it doesn’t just belong to Hindus.

We are a happy family with different identities. As a nation, we share the same food, clothes, buildings, laws, and events. All these elements are what bring us together under the same umbrella, then why do we look for reasons to hate each other?

Besides, living here as Raj, my name has provided me quite a unique edge over everyone else; according to one of my female friends, my name is easy to remember (I believe I have Shahrukh Khan to thank for that), and makes me easy to fall in love with! Well, there we have it. I wouldn’t want it any other way. Surprised?

Tweet

102 Comments Print Email
Follow @etribune
on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook
2695.jpg

Raj Kumar
The author is an educationist and a freelance trainer. He tweets as @RKGujar.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

What a great story. He think that after the arrival of many refugees hare in india prefering to sleep on road rathar than going back and this proxy think that people will trust his story/
 
.
All those questions are very normal for any minority group to hear in any country. Wether it's USA or Pakistan.

That is precisely the low bar set by Islamic countries that I am talking about. You set the standards of oppression and then assume that the whole world must be the same. It is not. We don't enshrine discrimination against minorities in our Constitutions. We don't bar non-Muslims from being elected to government office. We don't bar them from worshiping and professing their faith. These are unique problems in Islamic countries which are then projected on to the whole world as a given.

Have you ever visited Pakistan?

Another standard trope - that in the age of free information one needs to "visit" a place to know facts. In fact, visiting a place as a tourist is likely to leave a wrong impression of a place. Pakistanis are well known as excellent hosts - a trait that they share with North Indians. That is a poor cover-up job for the greater ills in that society.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom