What's new

Military, KPK not on same page

Edevelop

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 2, 2007
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
23
Country
Pakistan
Location
Turkey
ISLAMABAD - The military establishment and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government are not on the same page on the counter-terror arrangements in the province, in an underlined indication that security situation in the province may keep posing challenges in the wake of apparent reluctance from both the sides to shoulder responsibility while passing the buck to each other.
In their background interactions with journalists, the security officials sound vocal in shifting the blame of continued security lapses’ spree to the KPK government, saying some provincial government functionaries were opposing the anti-terror drive and were creating hurdles in the conduct of related operations by the security agencies.
On the other hand, the KPK government rejects this contention to argue that the FATA (Federally Administered Tribal Areas) that is the breeding ground for terrorism, is under the military’s complete security control and that the terrorist attacks in the KPK are emanating from the tribal region.
It is mentionable here that two brazen attacks in the ongoing Ramazan, one each in Parachinar, Kurram Agency and Dera Ismail Khan, a settled district of KPK, saw the respective killings of 57 persons and release of 253 hardened Taliban militants.
KPK Information Minister Shaukat Yousafzai labels the terrorist activities, particularly the suicide attacks, as a ‘legacy’ inherited from the previous regimes. But asked if the security lapses were justified on any pretext, he said, “Of course not. But the military, its security agencies and the federal government have to share equal blame.”
The minister pointed to the suicide attack in Parachinar to ask as to who was responsible for the security lapse there? “Isn’t FATA under the direct military control? We don’t have any jurisdiction over tribal areas,” he told this correspondent on Friday.
He said, due to ineffective security measures in FATA and the frontier regions (FRs), terrorists were moving from the tribal areas to unleash violence in KPK. “If you talk about the DI Khan jail break incident, you have to find out why the military and its paramilitary wings failed to stop the terrorists from fleeing?”
Yousfazai said the KP police needed to be equipped with counterterrorism security equipment and training. “Averting this kind of incident was far beyond the police’s capability. Other state institutions are also to be held accountable.”
The military officials, however, come up with an opposing view. “Our terms of engagement in FATA are quite different from KPK. The FATA comes under the federal government’s ambit that provides us the necessary support in our operations but the same is lacking in KPK. Some powerful government functionaries often play negative role in sabotaging our efforts to take on terrorism,” officials said to allege that two incumbent ministers in the KPK government were directly instrumental in opposing and even disrupting the military’s anti-terror actions on several occasions.
The officials recalled the background briefings given to Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif during his visit to the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) headquarters last month in support of their stance. Reportedly, the military command had informed the PM that strong opposition to military actions from political leaderships in KP and Balochistan was seriously hampering the army’s counterterrorism and counter-insurgency drives resulting in no let up in violence. It was purportedly recommended to the PM that ‘surgical cleansing’ was necessary to take to task the non-state elements sponsoring terrorism in different parts of the country.
Referring to these briefings, the details of which were exclusively published in The Nation on July 12 and 13, the military officials said, “We are having the support and cooperation from the Centre, particularly the interior ministry. But unless the provincial political leadership plays its role, the terrorism would remain unabated whether it’s FATA, KPK, Balochistan or Karachi.”
When questioned on this count, Shaukat Yousafzai referred to the last year Bannu jailbreak incident, which saw the escape of nearly 400 Taliban militants. “That time the KPK security was completely in the hands of military because the ineffective political regime was virtually non-existent. Who is to be blamed then? Political opposition to military action can never justify the security lapses.”
He furthered, “Our provincial government has inherited this mess and we’re trying to fix it. The suicide attacks started in Musharraf’s era against the dictator’s wrong policies that threw the entire nation in war on terror. And the last government was too ineffective to respond to the challenge of terrorism. As a result, we’re bearing the brunt.”
The military has launched two large-scale operations in Khyber and Kurram Agencies that have caused the respective displacements of around or over 80,000 and 60,000 residents from these tribal agencies. While the United Nations seeks funds for humanitarian assistance to the conflict-affected people, their sufferings seem to stay for long due to adverse security situation in the areas they come from.
Moreover, the Parachinar incident appears to have negated the security officials’ claims of retaining control over central parts of Kurram Agency while highlighting the security challenges still prevalent in the tribal region.

Counter-terror drive: Military, KPK not on same page
 
.
Similar is a case with federal govt as well and thats Pakistan's dilemma ""the civil military relations"" Terrorists are sucking the blood like leeches their population is springing but no one cares
 
.
Similar is a case with federal govt as well and thats Pakistan's dilemma ""the civil military relations"" Terrorists are sucking the blood like leeches their population is springing but no one cares

Wrong! PMLN and Military both have cross many birdges since May 11, the problem only remains how they deal with an impulsive IK's attitude and that too will going to be addressed pretty soon......IA.
 
.
Wrong! PMLN and Military both have cross many birdges since May 11, the problem only remains how they deal with an impulsive IK's attitude and that too will going to be addressed pretty soon......IA.

i disagree at one hand Army wants to fight the terrorist PML n and PTI both wish to withdraw from this fight i do not see this happening in the coming future ,although i wish peace to prevail soon bohat khon beh gaya hai ab.
 
.
Wrong! PMLN and Military both have cross many birdges since May 11, the problem only remains how they deal with an impulsive IK's attitude and that too will going to be addressed pretty soon......IA.

Care to explain which bridges N-League and Military have crossed since May 11? And just for your record, we're talking about Anti Terrorism here, not some personal love affairs..
 
.
i disagree at one hand Army wants to fight the terrorist PML n and PTI both wish to withdraw from this fight i do not see this happening in the coming future ,although i wish peace to prevail soon bohat khon beh gaya hai ab.

Although I'm a PTI supporter but I personally want IK to man handle these TTP scumbags. But the thing is, IK just want to check and bring them to peace talks for once. If he gets succeed (although chances are very slim) it will be good, otherwise military ops are the only option left. Peace is what everyone want, be it via fight or peace talks..
 
.
Although I'm a PTI supporter but I personally want IK to man handle these TTP scumbags. But the thing is, IK just want to check and bring them to peace talks for once. If he gets succeed (although chances are very slim) it will be good, otherwise military ops are the only option left. Peace is what everyone want, be it via fight or peace talks..

I can see what IK is trying to do but these people have no regard out of 55days of PTI govt in KPK these people have attacked over 50+ times !! they have killed two PTI MPA's the message is loud and clear , they are against the state , they do not accept the constitution nor judiciary or democracy, they have killed thousands of civilians and equal proportion of soldiers. How on earth do you see IK can negotiate with these scum bags? i just do not see it happening unfortunately worst hit are pakistanis from KPK to Karachi , so much blood is down the drain and their is no end in sight and with IK's current i just dont see it happening.
 
.
i disagree at one hand Army wants to fight the terrorist PML n and PTI both wish to withdraw from this fight i do not see this happening in the coming future ,although i wish peace to prevail soon bohat khon beh gaya hai ab.

Dear........PMLN don't want an open field for PTI for any repercsussions, for them unless PTI too on board this future strategy, they won't take it soley on thier own....so all the deliberations in this regards like APC is to only take IK on board somehow as well, which IK denying both PMLN & PA foolishly to his own vested interest.....pathetic!!
 
.
Dear........PMLN don't want an open field for PTI for any repercsussions, for them unless PTI too on board this future strategy, they won't take it soley on thier own....so all the deliberations in this regards like APC is to only take IK on board somehow as well, which IK denying both PMLN & PA foolishly to his own vested interest.....pathetic!!

its more about politics & point scoring than people dont get me wrong though i do appreciate the APC efforts made by PML. Besides that the point in question was civil military affairs and both PTI and PML have the similar stance on fight on terrorism and i.e we dont want to fight where as military does and this difference of opinion is sucking the blood of this nation. Both should wake up before it gets too late
 
.
I can see what IK is trying to do but these people have no regard out of 55days of PTI govt in KPK these people have attacked over 50+ times !! they have killed two PTI MPA's the message is loud and clear , they are against the state , they do not accept the constitution nor judiciary or democracy, they have killed thousands of civilians and equal proportion of soldiers. How on earth do you see IK can negotiate with these scum bags? i just do not see it happening unfortunately worst hit are pakistanis from KPK to Karachi , so much blood is down the drain and their is no end in sight and with IK's current i just dont see it happening.

You are absolutely right, and I do agree with it. But the thing is, neither army nor our federal govt is willing to launch an all out offensive against these TTP rats to finish them all at once. There are also almost no plans of fencing Pak-Afg border etc.. So how do you see all this being sorted out in near future? After all we're already in war against TTP since past 9 years with no fruitful results whatsoever..
 
.
Although I'm a PTI supporter but I personally want IK to man handle these TTP scumbags. But the thing is, IK just want to check and bring them to peace talks for once. If he gets succeed (although chances are very slim) it will be good, otherwise military ops are the only option left. Peace is what everyone want, be it via fight or peace talks..
Hire Burka Avenger then, cuz only a superhero can handle this menace overnight.
 
.
its more about politics & point scoring than people dont get me wrong though i do appreciate the APC efforts made by PML. Besides that the point in question was civil military affairs and both PTI and PML have the similar stance on fight on terrorism and i.e we dont want to fight where as military does and this difference of opinion is sucking the blood of this nation. Both should wake up before it gets too late

101% Agreed on political point scoring, but PML stance on terrorism could tilt towards PA and for operations overnight ...I can bet you!!
 
.
Dear........PMLN don't want an open field for PTI for any repercsussions, for them unless PTI too on board this future strategy, they won't take it soley on thier own....so all the deliberations in this regards like APC is to only take IK on board somehow as well, which IK denying both PMLN & PA foolishly to his own vested interest.....pathetic!!

what vested interests?? jew gold??
 
.
Isnt he right? Fata is under federal govt while it is Pata that is under kpk? So whats the fuss about?.

On the other hand, PM needs to chair a meeti g between CMs of all provinces, than chair a meeting with full CT & E policy with CMs, DG isi, DGMO,MI,COAS,IGs, DG IB, and MoI.

Andno one should be allowed to leave till they come to a conclusion. Be it dialogue or the attack, atleast everyone will be on board
 
.
101% Agreed on political point scoring, but PML stance on terrorism could tilt towards PA and for operations overnight ...I can bet you!!

i do not think they will join up alone too much to lose politically unless PTI joins in ! and i hope it does sooner than later
 
.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom