What's new

‘Meteoric’ rise of a Pakistani agitator

BanglaBhoot

RETIRED TTA
Joined
Apr 8, 2007
Messages
8,839
Reaction score
5
Country
France
Location
France
RAWALPINDI // When Zaid Zaman Hamid, a television personality and defence analyst, is not saying something on television that can be viewed by some as controversial or conspiratorial, he is busy denying the controversies that surround him.

On a recent morning, Hamid was telling a caller at his office in Rawalpindi that he does not have a profile on Facebook, the internet social networking site, and that he is not looking for “dating” as had been described in the profile.

Hamid knew who was behind these fake profiles on Facebook and another networking site, Orkut. “The Indians!”, he said.

“I am probably the most hated man in India right now. So, it is quite understandable that they are doing a psychological warfare against me.”

Indians are incensed because in a recorded show last week, Hamid predicted a final confrontation with India that would result in conquering Delhi, the Indian capital. The television network refused to air the episode. It was, however, leaked on YouTube.

But Indians are not the only ones who Hamid regularly, and passionately, castigates in his television appearances.

He equally loathes Americans and Israelis. In fact, the list is quite long and includes Afghans, al Qa’eda, the Pakistani Taliban and the current Pakistani political government, said Hamid, who surprisingly for all his venom and bravado comes across as pleasant and good-humoured.

Just two years ago, Hamid, 44, was a relatively unknown self-styled threat and defence analyst who was running the think tank Brass Tacks in Rawalpindi, the garrison city that is the headquarters of the Pakistani military.

His rise to fame has been quick – “meteoric” in his own words.

Media in Pakistan has mushroomed in the past several years. Dozens of new television networks have sprung up and are battling for superiority. Political talkshows have become popular, even more than the soap operas, and talk show hosts are new sensations.

Hamid has a weekly television show, also called Brass Tacks, on a local television network, NewsOne. He also frequently appears on shows on other television networks and radio stations.

Hamid said in his programme, he analyses and points out the security threats that Pakistan is facing.

Critics say Hamid thrives on grand conspiracies and they find his staunchly nationalistic jingoism outlandish. Bloggers keep writing for and against him. Op-eds have appeared against his show and label him as a Pakistani neoconservative.

“Unlike liberal critics that have been pointing to deficiencies in the rule of law, the inadequacies of institutions, the lack of due process and the general devolution of Pakistani civic sensibilities, these Pakistani neoconservatives want to edify our violent capabilities into moral superiority,” wrote Rafia Zakaria, in a recent column in Daily Times, a newspaper based in Lahore.

What Hamid is doing, Ms Zakaria wrote without naming him in the article, is “ingenious in its repackaging of Islamism in a supposedly ‘scholarly’ form that can be digested by middle-class audiences fishing for pseudointellectual discourse”.

But Hamid said he is simply a man on a mission to save Pakistan.

Hamid claims the United States is out to denuclearise Pakistan. “It is applying what I call the Yugoslavia Solution,” he said.

“The ultimate game plan is to ultimately take out Pakistan’s nuclear and missile programme. To achieve that, the US needs to do certain steps. Everything is heading to that direction.

“But the Americans don’t want to make a false move. Because, that can backfire very severely. So, there are multiple ways by which they are trying to achieve this. Number one is by imposing a politically corrupt government, which will implode Pakistan from within. Create an environment of mismanagement and financial corruption to the extent Pakistan becomes a dysfunctional and failed state. That was the most fundamental component of the Yugoslavia strategy,” he said.

“Secondly, support insurgencies on the ground. Where they will further accelerate the dismemberment of the country.”

It is quite a turnaround for a man who fought against the Soviets in Afghanistan in a war that was mainly funded by the United States.

An engineer by qualification, Hamid fought for six years in Afghanistan but returned to Pakistan in 1992 when different mujahideen factions started fighting among themselves for the control of Kabul.

“The life that I have spent behind is full of experiences and adventures where I had practically dealt with every issue which this nation is facing today in terms of security, in terms of politics, in terms of religion. These are the main issues today. I have been thick into this.”

In 2000, Hamid opened his think tank. “I realised there was a vacuum of proper security consultants in Pakistan,” he said. And of course, it was absolutely niche concept. Practically people would laugh at me when I would go to the corporate environment that I am a security consultant. They would ask me what do I sell. I would say I sell nothing but ideas. They said we only need guards. I said no, I will develop your security policy. People didn’t know what a security policy is.”

He denies that he is forming a cult based on his own personality.

“Nothing can be further from truth than that,” he said.

“I am trying to bring people to an ideology. Ideology as Muslims and identity as Pakistanis.”

Hamid said he was not intimidated by the fact that he talks against almost everyone, and was not concerned about the threats or dangers to his personal security.

“When the nation is at stake and at risk, individuals don’t matter. I know if I become silent today because of my personal security, tomorrow the entire country’s security will be at stake.”

‘Meteoric’ rise of a Pakistani agitator - The National Newspaper
 
.
Zaid Zaman Hamid will go down in history for his magnificent statement that "Ajmal Kasab is Amar Singh, a Sikh".

That statement should be inscribed on Zaid Hamid's grave stone in due course of time.


RAWALPINDI // When Zaid Zaman Hamid, a television personality and defence analyst, is not saying something on television that can be viewed by some as controversial or conspiratorial, he is busy denying the controversies that surround him.

On a recent morning, Hamid was telling a caller at his office in Rawalpindi that he does not have a profile on Facebook, the internet social networking site, and that he is not looking for “dating” as had been described in the profile.

Hamid knew who was behind these fake profiles on Facebook and another networking site, Orkut. “The Indians!”, he said.

“I am probably the most hated man in India right now. So, it is quite understandable that they are doing a psychological warfare against me.”

Indians are incensed because in a recorded show last week, Hamid predicted a final confrontation with India that would result in conquering Delhi, the Indian capital. The television network refused to air the episode. It was, however, leaked on YouTube.

But Indians are not the only ones who Hamid regularly, and passionately, castigates in his television appearances.

He equally loathes Americans and Israelis. In fact, the list is quite long and includes Afghans, al Qa’eda, the Pakistani Taliban and the current Pakistani political government, said Hamid, who surprisingly for all his venom and bravado comes across as pleasant and good-humoured.

Just two years ago, Hamid, 44, was a relatively unknown self-styled threat and defence analyst who was running the think tank Brass Tacks in Rawalpindi, the garrison city that is the headquarters of the Pakistani military.

His rise to fame has been quick – “meteoric” in his own words.

Media in Pakistan has mushroomed in the past several years. Dozens of new television networks have sprung up and are battling for superiority. Political talkshows have become popular, even more than the soap operas, and talk show hosts are new sensations.

Hamid has a weekly television show, also called Brass Tacks, on a local television network, NewsOne. He also frequently appears on shows on other television networks and radio stations.

Hamid said in his programme, he analyses and points out the security threats that Pakistan is facing.

Critics say Hamid thrives on grand conspiracies and they find his staunchly nationalistic jingoism outlandish. Bloggers keep writing for and against him. Op-eds have appeared against his show and label him as a Pakistani neoconservative.

“Unlike liberal critics that have been pointing to deficiencies in the rule of law, the inadequacies of institutions, the lack of due process and the general devolution of Pakistani civic sensibilities, these Pakistani neoconservatives want to edify our violent capabilities into moral superiority,” wrote Rafia Zakaria, in a recent column in Daily Times, a newspaper based in Lahore.

What Hamid is doing, Ms Zakaria wrote without naming him in the article, is “ingenious in its repackaging of Islamism in a supposedly ‘scholarly’ form that can be digested by middle-class audiences fishing for pseudointellectual discourse”.

But Hamid said he is simply a man on a mission to save Pakistan.

Hamid claims the United States is out to denuclearise Pakistan. “It is applying what I call the Yugoslavia Solution,” he said.

“The ultimate game plan is to ultimately take out Pakistan’s nuclear and missile programme. To achieve that, the US needs to do certain steps. Everything is heading to that direction.

“But the Americans don’t want to make a false move. Because, that can backfire very severely. So, there are multiple ways by which they are trying to achieve this. Number one is by imposing a politically corrupt government, which will implode Pakistan from within. Create an environment of mismanagement and financial corruption to the extent Pakistan becomes a dysfunctional and failed state. That was the most fundamental component of the Yugoslavia strategy,” he said.

“Secondly, support insurgencies on the ground. Where they will further accelerate the dismemberment of the country.”

It is quite a turnaround for a man who fought against the Soviets in Afghanistan in a war that was mainly funded by the United States.

An engineer by qualification, Hamid fought for six years in Afghanistan but returned to Pakistan in 1992 when different mujahideen factions started fighting among themselves for the control of Kabul.

“The life that I have spent behind is full of experiences and adventures where I had practically dealt with every issue which this nation is facing today in terms of security, in terms of politics, in terms of religion. These are the main issues today. I have been thick into this.”

In 2000, Hamid opened his think tank. “I realised there was a vacuum of proper security consultants in Pakistan,” he said. And of course, it was absolutely niche concept. Practically people would laugh at me when I would go to the corporate environment that I am a security consultant. They would ask me what do I sell. I would say I sell nothing but ideas. They said we only need guards. I said no, I will develop your security policy. People didn’t know what a security policy is.”

He denies that he is forming a cult based on his own personality.

“Nothing can be further from truth than that,” he said.

“I am trying to bring people to an ideology. Ideology as Muslims and identity as Pakistanis.”

Hamid said he was not intimidated by the fact that he talks against almost everyone, and was not concerned about the threats or dangers to his personal security.

“When the nation is at stake and at risk, individuals don’t matter. I know if I become silent today because of my personal security, tomorrow the entire country’s security will be at stake.”

‘Meteoric’ rise of a Pakistani agitator - The National Newspaper
 
.
Well most of the worlds greatest revolutionists had a meteoric rise or else they would never actually be able to provide that impact.
 
.
I think the concept of Brasstacks as explained in the article is extremely relevant for Pakistan and also Bangladeshis who should be looking at the idea also. The role of a security analyst should be to look at all possibilities and that is what he did in the aftermath of the Mumbai attacks. Maybe some restraint in his comments would have been advisable but he covered the ground thoroughly and put India on the back foot.
 
.
I think the concept of Brasstacks as explained in the article is extremely relevant for Pakistan and also Bangladeshis who should be looking at the idea also. The role of a security analyst should be to look at all possibilities and that is what he did in the aftermath of the Mumbai attacks. Maybe some restraint in his comments would have been advisable but he covered the ground thoroughly and put India on the back foot.

:rofl: Earth to Munshi!! Come in Munshi!!

He was ignored, that's right, ignored, by the Indian establishment throughout the whole saga. Nobody in world politics notices him, yet, but they might start doing so if he begins to influence public opinion.

His personalty cult, a kind of opium for the Pakistani middle class in order to make "sense" of what is happening in their own country.
 
.
:rofl: Earth to Munshi!! Come in Munshi!!

He was ignored, that's right, ignored, by the Indian establishment throughout the whole saga. Nobody in world politics notices him, yet, but they might start doing so if he begins to influence public opinion.

His personalty cult, a kind of opium for the Pakistani middle class in order to make "sense" of what is happening in their own country.
I'm no fan of the guy, but you gotta appreciate a guy who puts up a good fight.

He has really silenced the Indians on every occasion. That's not ignoring, thats tucking your tail and running.
 
.
I'm no fan of the guy, but you gotta appreciate a guy who puts up a good fight.

He has really silenced the Indians on every occasion. That's not ignoring, thats tucking your tail and running.

Which Indians has he silenced? AFAIK, he's only causing embarassment to teh GOP, them having to shut him down occasionally.

And again, what is he fighting against, the truth? :lol: If so, then yes, he put up a spirited fight alright. His imagination is pretty creative, gotta give him that.

He's like that American radio host who keeps talking about grand conspiracies....can't remember his name atm.
 
.
Its ironic how you berate the Indian media for their inaccurate reporting, and then praise Zaid Hamid for "putting up a good fight".

Is that what journalists are supposed to do ?
 
.
Which Indians has he silenced? AFAIK, he's only causing embarassment to teh GOP, them having to shut him down occasionally.

And again, what is he fighting against, the truth? :lol: If so, then yes, he put up a spirited fight alright. His imagination is pretty creative, gotta give him that.

He's like that American radio host who keeps talking about grand conspiracies....can't remember his name atm.
What about that Indian guy on Express News?

What was his name? Some Verma? That was a classic battle.
 
.
Its ironic how you berate the Indian media for their inaccurate reporting, and then praise Zaid Hamid for "putting up a good fight".

Is that what journalists are supposed to do ?
We need people who can roll up their sleeves and beat India on their on level. We have people like Zaid Hamid for this job.

Watching him demolish Indians and Indians just going like "aaa, I mean, ummm" is a sheer treat :). I think you have to be Pakistani or not Indian to appreciate it.
 
.
What about that Indian guy on Express News?

What was his name? Some Verma? That was a classic battle.

Yes, I saw that video. The Verma guy was basically treating Zaid Hamid like a little kid, since he knew that its impossible to have a rational discourse with this guy. He'll always come up with a list of accusations and fail to address the point of the argument.

I don't know how you can call it a "classic" battle, unless your definition of battle is couple of undergraduate debaters trying to outdo each other.

A "classic battle" is one in which the opponents present the facts, not the latest imaginings of their beraved minds.
 
.
Watching him demolish Indians and Indians just going like "aaa, I mean, ummm" is a sheer treat :). I think you have to be Pakistani or not Indian to appreciate it.

Yes, as I said, its a treat for middle-class Pakistanis who want to escape from the grim realities of their own country, find a way to blame India and the world at large.

And please, don't even compare him to the Indian media. Infact, to call him a mediaperson would be an insult to the journalistic fraternity.

Try speaking to someone from the South Asian Journalists Association and see what they think of him.
 
.
I guess in the absence of a viable film industry, Pakistanis have adopted Zaid Hamid as their escape from reality!
 
.
Its ironic how you berate the Indian media for their inaccurate reporting, and then praise Zaid Hamid for "putting up a good fight".

Is that what journalists are supposed to do ?

Fact Check
I don't remeber Zaid Hamid ever being called a journalist or he himself claiming to be one.
 
.
Fact Check
I don't remeber Zaid Hamid ever being called a journalist or he himself claiming to be one.

So what is he? An entertainer?

If course he's a journalist, since he comes on a news channel and analyses current events. (If you could call that analysing)
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom