What's new

Major wheat deficit looming

It is a government failure to grow staple food as per demand/need of the country.

Are you claiming That PML_N Government had overcome this and PTI failed.

Teaser

According to Khan, food prices were going up globally, but the situation in Pakistan had deteriorated owing to failure of the previous government to announce the wheat support price on time and bring down rising prices of various inputs, including fertilizers.


Khan ruled out any further increase in the wheat procurement price that has already been raised to 625 rupees per 40 kg from 510 rupees.
 
.
Pakistan is likely to face three million tons wheat deficit next year as the country’s estimated consumption is 29 million whereas production will be around 26 million tons.


The projected consumption of 29 million tons includes buffer stocks of one million tons of wheat, 1.2 million tons for seed and 0.3 million for poultry feed.


The issue of wheat deficit came under discussion at a meeting of National Assembly Standing Committee on Commerce, headed by Syed Naveed Qamar.


During discussion on import of wheat through Trading Corporation of Pakistan (TCP), Secretary Commerce Sualeh Ahmad Faruqi confirmed that wheat deficit had also been projected for next year.


Chairman TCP Riaz Memon informed the committee that the government had imported 2.165 million tons of which 1.6 million tons was imported by TCP and 0.465 million tons by Passco. He further stated that 30 bulk vessels of TCP arrived from October 2020 to March 2021 and not a single vessel went into demurrage.


According to him, average imported wheat at port was Rs 45.6 per kg, adding signing of commercial agreements with recipient agencies helped in efficient cargo clearance from port by recipient agencies and timely payment of dues i.e. 91 percent amount was recovered as on March 3, 2021. The total invoice amount was Rs 81.64 billion, of which Rs 74.71 billion is received while Rs 7.28 billion is receivable.


He said the next consignment of 0.3 million tons wheat would arrive in August 2021 to avoid glut in the market and ensure that prices of domestic wheat did not plummet. This was confirmed by Secretary Commerce who assured the committee that there would be no glut in the market due to imported wheat as its arrival has been delayed till August.


The committee members criticised Punjab government for revising down Minimum Support Price (MSP) from Rs 1800 to Rs 1650/40 kg. This price will certainly encourage smuggling of wheat to Sindh where price is Rs 2100/40 kg. Private sector will also make all out efforts to procure wheat despite ban on procurement by the provincial government. According to Article 151 of the Constitution, it’s a common market, which means goods cannot be restricted.


After the standing committee’s meeting, Syed Naveed Qamar lamented the projected wheat shortage next year, adding that wheat production in the country was going down whereas import was on the rise. He further stated that support price of wheat fixed by the government was unrealistic. Sindh has announced minimum support price of Rs 2000 /40 kg whereas Punjab revised it down - from Rs 1800 to 1650/40 kg.


“Who will sell his wheat at Rs 1650/40 kg, when the price of imported wheat is Rs 2500/40 kg,” he queried.


Naveed Qamar contended that continuation of import of wheat was in the interest of mafias, adding that expensive wheat was being imported in the name of price control.


“We are extending benefit to farmers of other countries but are not ready to give subsidy to Pakistani farmers,” he said.

Last year projected wheat deficit was 1.5 million tonns but we imported 2.6 million tonn wheat. This year projected wheat deficit is 3 million tonns means double than previous year.
I have seen the new imported wheat at first I thought it was residue of wheat grading such bad quality
First gov should ban wheat import
Second establish same support price to stop inter provincial smuggling
And focus on international smuggling at borders
Pakistan is likely to face three million tons wheat deficit next year as the country’s estimated consumption is 29 million whereas production will be around 26 million tons.


The projected consumption of 29 million tons includes buffer stocks of one million tons of wheat, 1.2 million tons for seed and 0.3 million for poultry feed.


The issue of wheat deficit came under discussion at a meeting of National Assembly Standing Committee on Commerce, headed by Syed Naveed Qamar.


During discussion on import of wheat through Trading Corporation of Pakistan (TCP), Secretary Commerce Sualeh Ahmad Faruqi confirmed that wheat deficit had also been projected for next year.


Chairman TCP Riaz Memon informed the committee that the government had imported 2.165 million tons of which 1.6 million tons was imported by TCP and 0.465 million tons by Passco. He further stated that 30 bulk vessels of TCP arrived from October 2020 to March 2021 and not a single vessel went into demurrage.


According to him, average imported wheat at port was Rs 45.6 per kg, adding signing of commercial agreements with recipient agencies helped in efficient cargo clearance from port by recipient agencies and timely payment of dues i.e. 91 percent amount was recovered as on March 3, 2021. The total invoice amount was Rs 81.64 billion, of which Rs 74.71 billion is received while Rs 7.28 billion is receivable.


He said the next consignment of 0.3 million tons wheat would arrive in August 2021 to avoid glut in the market and ensure that prices of domestic wheat did not plummet. This was confirmed by Secretary Commerce who assured the committee that there would be no glut in the market due to imported wheat as its arrival has been delayed till August.


The committee members criticised Punjab government for revising down Minimum Support Price (MSP) from Rs 1800 to Rs 1650/40 kg. This price will certainly encourage smuggling of wheat to Sindh where price is Rs 2100/40 kg. Private sector will also make all out efforts to procure wheat despite ban on procurement by the provincial government. According to Article 151 of the Constitution, it’s a common market, which means goods cannot be restricted.


After the standing committee’s meeting, Syed Naveed Qamar lamented the projected wheat shortage next year, adding that wheat production in the country was going down whereas import was on the rise. He further stated that support price of wheat fixed by the government was unrealistic. Sindh has announced minimum support price of Rs 2000 /40 kg whereas Punjab revised it down - from Rs 1800 to 1650/40 kg.


“Who will sell his wheat at Rs 1650/40 kg, when the price of imported wheat is Rs 2500/40 kg,” he queried.


Naveed Qamar contended that continuation of import of wheat was in the interest of mafias, adding that expensive wheat was being imported in the name of price control.


“We are extending benefit to farmers of other countries but are not ready to give subsidy to Pakistani farmers,” he said.

Last year projected wheat deficit was 1.5 million tonns but we imported 2.6 million tonn wheat. This year projected wheat deficit is 3 million tonns means double than previous year.
I have seen the new imported wheat at first I thought it was residue of wheat grading such bad quality
First gov should ban wheat import
Second establish same support price to stop inter provincial smuggling
And focus on international smuggling at borders
 
. .
The whole problem of agriculture in Pakistan can be summarised in these three quotes.

“Who will sell his wheat at Rs 1650/40 kg, when the price of imported wheat is Rs 2500/40 kg,” he queried.

In a free market you sell for the price you can get. Rs1650 is better than zero. If it makes you a profit, it's good business, if it doesn't, consider selling to someone else, or growing something else. What is stopping them from selling their wheat in the markets? The higher imported wheat prices are because that's the cost of the free market outside of Pakistan.

The only failure of government here is that they don't create easy access for farmers to the market. Of course that won't change whilst the bottlenecks sit in parliament, the senate, the judiciary, and every other arm of the state.

“We are extending benefit to farmers of other countries but are not ready to give subsidy to Pakistani farmers,” he said.

Why should agriculture be subsidised? Why can't these people run their business efficiently themselves. If they are incapable they should be upskilled through agricultural colleges, not subsidised by the state.

It is a government failure to grow staple food as per demand/need of the country.

Govt is not responsible for growing food, farmers are.
 
.
Last year projected wheat deficit was 1.5 million tonns but we imported 2.6 million tonn wheat. This year projected wheat deficit is 3 million tonns means double than previous year.
Food deficit started during Khota Biryani govt
1616162030178.jpeg

Population growth 2.5%, wheat growth -2% since last 2 years. Well done PTI.
Food deficit started during your favorite Khota Biryani govt
1616162083303.jpeg

Lack of governance
Food deficit started during your favorite Khota Biryani govt, Patwari
1616162165410.jpeg

It is a government failure to grow staple food as per demand/need of the country.
So how did your favorite PMLN govt got record deficits in food trade? Why did they fail to plan country's future during their term?
1616162262918.jpeg

Govt is not responsible for growing food, farmers are.
According to Biryanis everything good is Pmlns fault and everything wrong is PTIs fault
 
Last edited:
.
Another wheat crisis....people should eat less ....government has no role in wheat management crisis...

In the current world Gov'ts MUST be involved in farming and business.
Saudi Gov't buys food for the have no food Arabs in SA. The Chinese CCP gov't guys food on the open market for Chinese. Egyptians same. All Gov't are in the construction business and funding arms dealers.
So long as even ONE gov't, bank funded corporation or national/local bank is manipulating the market then ALL gov'ts, corps and banks must.
To not support your local industry and farmers is to betrayed them to outside influences. If your nation allows immigration then your unsupported people and corporations end up being bought out, impoverished and reduced to servitude in their own lands.
Either support your people or you will have no people.
 
.
To not support your local industry and farmers is to betrayed them to outside influences.
When food production is cheaper outside than inside the country then, it's better to import than to give subsidy for the benefit of food mafias and cartels
 
.
When food production is cheaper outside than inside the country then, it's better to import than to give subsidy for the benefit of food mafias and cartels

You would go and live in a foreign land and off of the wealth accumulated by others.
Pakistanis in Pakistan would try to build their country and wealth. They are competing against subsidized corporate farmers all over the world. When the playing field is not level you do NOT trade.
 
.
You would go and live in a foreign land and off of the wealth accumulated by others.
Pakistanis in Pakistan would try to build their country and wealth. They are competing against subsidized corporate farmers all over the world. When the playing field is not level you do NOT trade.

You're sat in Canada waving Chinese flags in your basement. See the irony?
 
.
Food wastage is the key issue.
36 million tonnes of food wasted each year.
Pakistan is also extremely vulnerable to climate change and will see a 50% reduction in crop yield by 2030, according to the German Watch’s Global Climate Risk Index of 2012. so we need a social compaign and laws to stop it.
 
.
negative. there is more than enough wheat. it is being hoarded by zakheera khor mafia. Imran Khan has full powers now, with the Establishment standing firmly beside him, he has no excuse to let these mafias get away. It's high time he reigns them in and eliminates them. no more "they are too powerful" or "government's hands are tied" excuses. It's time to brake bones & give nose bleeds.
agree!!! for past few years floor mill owners & mafia have been hoarding wheat...large quantity is 'smuggled' to Afghanistan...personally knew 2 parties involved in such practice
 
.
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan is likely to face three million tons wheat deficit next year as the country’s estimated consumption is 29 million whereas production will be around 26 million tons.

The projected consumption of 29 million tons includes buffer stocks of one million tons of wheat, 1.2 million tons for seed and 0.3 million for poultry feed.

The issue of wheat deficit came under discussion at a meeting of National Assembly Standing Committee on Commerce, headed by Syed Naveed Qamar.

During discussion on import of wheat through Trading Corporation of Pakistan (TCP), Secretary Commerce Sualeh Ahmad Faruqi confirmed that wheat deficit had also been projected for next year.

Chairman TCP Riaz Memon informed the committee that the government had imported 2.165 million tons of which 1.6 million tons was imported by TCP and 0.465 million tons by Passco. He further stated that 30 bulk vessels of TCP arrived from October 2020 to March 2021 and not a single vessel went into demurrage.

According to him, average imported wheat at port was Rs 45.6 per kg, adding signing of commercial agreements with recipient agencies helped in efficient cargo clearance from port by recipient agencies and timely payment of dues i.e. 91 percent amount was recovered as on March 3, 2021. The total invoice amount was Rs 81.64 billion, of which Rs 74.71 billion is received while Rs 7.28 billion is receivable.

He said the next consignment of 0.3 million tons wheat would arrive in August 2021 to avoid glut in the market and ensure that prices of domestic wheat did not plummet. This was confirmed by Secretary Commerce who assured the committee that there would be no glut in the market due to imported wheat as its arrival has been delayed till August.

The committee members criticised Punjab government for revising down Minimum Support Price (MSP) from Rs 1800 to Rs 1650/40 kg. This price will certainly encourage smuggling of wheat to Sindh where price is Rs 2100/40 kg. Private sector will also make all out efforts to procure wheat despite ban on procurement by the provincial government. According to Article 151 of the Constitution, it’s a common market, which means goods cannot be restricted.

After the standing committee’s meeting, Syed Naveed Qamar lamented the projected wheat shortage next year, adding that wheat production in the country was going down whereas import was on the rise. He further stated that support price of wheat fixed by the government was unrealistic. Sindh has announced minimum support price of Rs 2000 /40 kg whereas Punjab revised it down - from Rs 1800 to 1650/40 kg.

“Who will sell his wheat at Rs 1650/40 kg, when the price of imported wheat is Rs 2500/40 kg,” he queried.

Naveed Qamar contended that continuation of import of wheat was in the interest of mafias, adding that expensive wheat was being imported in the name of price control.

“We are extending benefit to farmers of other countries but are not ready to give subsidy to Pakistani farmers,” he said.—MUSHTAQ GHUMMAN


 
. . .
agree!!! for past few years floor mill owners & mafia have been hoarding wheat...large quantity is 'smuggled' to Afghanistan...personally knew 2 parties involved in such practice
Imran Khan is responsible for food mafia since 1947: Opposition
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom