What's new

Large numbers of farmers marching to Delhi

. . .
why doesnt Modi just give the farmers want they want and end this? surely they cant be asking for much.
Why? Because -

  • he is a good leader
  • most of Indian etablishment know this is good for India and stand by it.
  • most of the political class also know it's good for India and stand by it.

Now why? Because what was a good idea decades of is now archaich. Similiar to how state owned corporations enjoying monopolies like PIA, Pak Steel etc might have been good idea decades ago but today they are loss making and hold back innovation. They have just become dole outs for the employees and trhe consumer suffers.

The Indian farmer is tied into a fixed regime which assured him certain guranteed price but today this is holding agriculture back. By undoing this fixed regime a dynamic, competitive and innovative agriculture sector will get a chance to take root. But this means change. And those who will face the change - the farmers are out protesting.

But if Modi is good by India he will hold his ground.
 
.
Why? Because -

  • he is a good leader
  • most of Indian etablishment know this is good for India and stand by it.
  • most of the political class also know it's good for India and stand by it.

Now why? Because what was a good idea decades of is now archaich. Similiar to how state owned corporations enjoying monopolies like PIA, Pak Steel etc might have been good idea decades ago but today they are loss making and hold back innovation. They have just become dole outs for the employees and trhe consumer suffers.

The Indian farmer is tied into a fixed regime which assured him certain guranteed price but today this is holding agriculture back. By undoing this fixed regime a dynamic, competitive and innovative agriculture sector will get a chance to take root. But this means change. And those who will face the change - the farmers are out protesting.

But if Modi is good by India he will hold his ground.
Modi is an idiot. He will end up replacing the middle man system with heavy subsidisation as has happened in UK farming. Small/medium farms will simply not be able to compete and the farmers will need bailout after bailout. Half of our EU negotiations used to be about farming and fishing subsidies.

The subisidised future of indian farming will drive innovation and efficiency into the ground just as much as what is going on now.
 
.
Why? Because -

  • he is a good leader
  • most of Indian etablishment know this is good for India and stand by it.
  • most of the political class also know it's good for India and stand by it.

Now why? Because what was a good idea decades of is now archaich. Similiar to how state owned corporations enjoying monopolies like PIA, Pak Steel etc might have been good idea decades ago but today they are loss making and hold back innovation. They have just become dole outs for the employees and trhe consumer suffers.

The Indian farmer is tied into a fixed regime which assured him certain guranteed price but today this is holding agriculture back. By undoing this fixed regime a dynamic, competitive and innovative agriculture sector will get a chance to take root. But this means change. And those who will face the change - the farmers are out protesting.

But if Modi is good by India he will hold his ground.


Problem isn't what he did, it's the way the BJP and his hindutva government operate i.e the way he did it

Prior to a policy that would effect hundreds of millions they should really have had a consultative period and explained why the new laws were necessary going forward and the problems caused by the current system



What happened however is that because India is such a divided poisonous place at the moment, the government tried to strong arm its policy through without reaching out to anybody
Demonetisation was good on paper however created massive problems for many

The farmers thought they were going to get screwed
In a functional democracy this would have been resolved through dialogue but once again India is incredibly toxic and the hate is flowing so as the farmers starting protesting everyone joined in including Pakistani assets shall we say to stir the situation

the hindutva extremism that is now rampant in India responded in the only way it knows how by declaring everyone anti state Pakistan and China funded Khalistanis

then Social Media has become a CESS POOL of hate with Hindus declaring a Hindu rashtra and stating they would never go to a gurdwara again and Sikhs finally getting burnt by hindutva extremism and bakhts and responding

with the craziness on India's Republic Day a new low




speaking from a purely Pakistani point of view things are going well


And we should let this play out whilst supporting the Sikhs and next getting the Indian Muslims ready for another round of anti CAA agitation, this is what we are planning now😉

Hindutva has been so helpful it's crazy
 
.
why doesnt Modi just give the farmers want they want and end this? surely they cant be asking for much.
It is just a drama, this whole protest is just a drama buy some landlords. Are farmers present only in Punjab? There are farmers in every state of India but why are only Punjabi and Haryanvi farmers doing this drama? Why no farmer from Bihar, West Bengal, Kerela or Karnataka protesting? And the ones protesting in Karnataka are Punjabis who work in Bangalore.

This is just a new normal. When CAA came a false narrative that Muslims will lose citizenship was pushed which caused drama, then this Farm laws drama came which doesn’t say that MSP will be abolished but still Punjabi farmers are doing drama, next when Uniform Civil Code (UCC) will be passed by the government then these same Libtard brigade will provoke Muslims with fear mongering that this UCC will strip Muslims of your special rights, while UCC as the name suggests is One nation One law for all and all laws will be applicable to all Indian citizens and every citizen will have equal rights instead of some having special rights etc and then after this provocation a terror outfit PFI will sponsor riots and road blockages and then all the same drama.

They don’t care what does the law state or not, if it is done by BJP oppose it, call it death of democracy, call it fascist, call it authoritarian, call it black law and do fear mongering. These all opposition dudes are losers and will lose all future General Elections thats why such stupid stunts.

The very same Congress party that supported the very same CAA and Farm Laws are now calling them Black laws.

Fear mongering with fake facts that Big corporates will take over your land or force you to cultivate what they want or contract farming etc is being done else even the farmer leader Rakesh Tikait’s home town people say he is just doing politics. These so called farmers rode in a luxury car convoy and call themselves poor.

Muslims of India dislike Modi and its their choice and right, and because they dislike Modi, they are also tweeting that Modi is torturing farmers, Modi is doing bad with Famers, thsese laws are stupid (even though none of them have read the laws) and the laws will destroy India and that we (muslims) support farmer leader Rakesh Tikait, and this hate for Modi cause them to without any reason support Rakesh Tikait even though Rakesh Tikait’s brother Naresh Tikait once openly said that Muslims of India should be killed, India belongs to Hindus and Muslims have no right to live in India. Yet these Muslims support his brother Rakesh Tikait because Rakesh is protesting against Modi.

This is all politics and drama.
 
Last edited:
.
Prior to a policy that would effect hundreds of millions they should really have had a consultative period and explained why the new laws were necessary going forward and the problems caused by the current system
The effect is not on hundreds of millions but 10s of millions mostly Punjabi farmers.To make an omelette you have to break a few eggs. Take it from this was needed. With regards to consulation in South Asia this would entail talking, talking, talking until the year 2050. Then after some chai more talking.

The problem in life is not that you don'[t know what to do but doing it. Because that often entails pain. You can look at Pakistan. Everybody knows PIA needs to be sold or scrapped, ditto Pak Steel, ditto other enterprises that chew away billions of dollars every year. Money which could build dams, 100s of hospitals, 1,000s of schools. But what happens?

The reason China has moved at the speed it has is because instead consulting. It fcukin did it.
 
.
Why? Because -

  • he is a good leader
  • most of Indian etablishment know this is good for India and stand by it.
  • most of the political class also know it's good for India and stand by it.

Now why? Because what was a good idea decades of is now archaich. Similiar to how state owned corporations enjoying monopolies like PIA, Pak Steel etc might have been good idea decades ago but today they are loss making and hold back innovation. They have just become dole outs for the employees and trhe consumer suffers.

The Indian farmer is tied into a fixed regime which assured him certain guranteed price but today this is holding agriculture back. By undoing this fixed regime a dynamic, competitive and innovative agriculture sector will get a chance to take root. But this means change. And those who will face the change - the farmers are out protesting.

But if Modi is good by India he will hold his ground.
You explained it well, without any Bias, kudos to you👌🏻.
Fear mongering has caused them to do this.
 
.
.
why dont you give PDM what they want ?

PDM demands are not rational. the farmers on the other hand arent asking for much it seems, and by giving it to them the farmers will be happy and India has one less headache. its not like the farmers are asking for the BJP to step down, or for someone in cabinet to be replaced.

relax. light lo jee.
 
.
The effect is not on hundreds of millions but 10s of millions mostly Punjabi farmers.To make an omelette you have to break a few eggs. Take it from this was needed. With regards to consulation in South Asia this would entail talking, talking, talking until the year 2050. Then after some chai more talking.

The problem in life is not that you don'[t know what to do but doing it. Because that often entails pain. You can look at Pakistan. Everybody knows PIA needs to be sold or scrapped, ditto Pak Steel, ditto other enterprises that chew away billions of dollars every year. Money which could build dams, 100s of hospitals, 1,000s of schools. But what happens?

The reason China has moved at the speed it has is because instead consulting. It fcukin did it.


Let's just look at how we can take advantage

The poison is brimming and we need to use it
 
. .
Why? Because -

  • he is a good leader
  • most of Indian etablishment know this is good for India and stand by it.
  • most of the political class also know it's good for India and stand by it.

Now why? Because what was a good idea decades of is now archaich. Similiar to how state owned corporations enjoying monopolies like PIA, Pak Steel etc might have been good idea decades ago but today they are loss making and hold back innovation. They have just become dole outs for the employees and trhe consumer suffers.

The Indian farmer is tied into a fixed regime which assured him certain guranteed price but today this is holding agriculture back. By undoing this fixed regime a dynamic, competitive and innovative agriculture sector will get a chance to take root. But this means change. And those who will face the change - the farmers are out protesting.

But if Modi is good by India he will hold his ground.
There's no problem with idea of SOEs, the problem is in the mindset of people thinking of them as baap ka Mal, and politicians bowing down to investors instead of nurturing the SOEs
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom