What's new

Kolkata: Talks fail, no Bangladesh flights now

Black_cats

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
-5
Kolkata: Talks fail, no Bangladesh flights now

Subhro Niyogi and Prithvijit Mitra | TNN | Updated: Aug 21, 2021, 08:10 IST

85505828.jpg


The flights between the two countries were suspended in April during the height of the second wave.

KOLKATA: The Biman Bangladesh flights that were to resume on Sunday have been called off as an agreement on the resumption of flights could not be reached between the aviation authorities.

The announcement led to a gloom across the city’s hospitality sector and private hospitals that were getting ready to welcome back patients from Bangladesh, who accounted for around 8%-10% of footfalls till the pandemic.

“We had scheduled the resumption of flights from Sunday with the other two weekly services on Tuesday and Thursday. But we have not received permission from Indian authorities. Once an agreement is signed, we will announce the new dates,” a Biman Bangladesh official told TOI.

This will mean that SpiceJet and IndiGo flights that were also scheduled to resume will now be cancelled. While SpiceJet was supposed to start services on August 26, IndiGo was to start flights the next day. The flights between the two countries were suspended in April during the height of the second wave.

The news of the flight cancellation has dampened the spirit in the New Market-Sudder Street-Marquis Street-Free School Street-Park Street belt as well as hospitals in the city where Bangladeshis are a key clientele.

Bangladeshis account for over 50% sales at New Market, 70% business in hotels, guest houses and foreign currency exchanges on Sudder Street, Marquis Street, Free School Street, Royd Street and Rafi Ahmed Kidwai Road and 80% of the transport business in the area.

“We are disappointed since 20 online appointments had been issued to Bangladeshi patients who were to take the first few flights. Enquiries had been pouring in and we expected the number to proliferate with flights getting regular. But this is a setback for both Bangladeshi patients and us. They may now look for treatment in south-east Asian countries,” said Peerless Hospital CEO Sudipta Mitra.

Till the pandemic, 15% of Peerless’ patients would be from Bangladesh. They contributed 8%-10% of the hospital’s annual revenue.

AMRI Hospitals that had received 3,000 Bangladeshi patients a month across its three units before the pandemic already processed 300-400 visa invitation forms for Bangladesh patients who were scheduled to visit next week.

Most of them have emergency surgeries or treatment lined up, according to AMRI CEO Rupak Barua. “They mostly visit for complicated neuro and gastric surgeries that can’t wait. So, we will end up losing these patients,” said Barua.

More than 35 Bangladesh patients were listed for surgeries and consultations at CMRI Hospital over the next few weeks, according to COO Simmardeep Gill.

Ruby Hospital, too, was left disappointed by the flight cancellation.

“We were looking forward to welcoming them back since they generate a fair share of our revenue. We had issued 11 visa invitation forms to Bangladeshi citizens over the last one week. Most of them are cancer and haemotology patients who were planning to visit our hospital for long-term treatment. They can’t defer their treatment and will settle for other countries, which is unfortunate,” said

Ruby Hospital general manager – operations Subhashish Datta.

The return of patients is also crucial for tourism and business in Kolkata, said Travel Agents’ Federation of India chairman (East) Anil Punjabi.

“They invariably visit with families and do a lot of shopping that help the places like New Market and the shopping centres around it in central Kolkata. Their return would have helped the local economy,” Punjabi added.

 
Till the pandemic, 15% of Peerless’ patients would be from Bangladesh. They contributed 8%-10% of the hospital’s annual revenue.

AMRI Hospitals that had received 3,000 Bangladeshi patients a month across its three units before the pandemic already processed 300-400 visa invitation forms for Bangladesh patients who were scheduled to visit next week.

Most of them have emergency surgeries or treatment lined up, according to AMRI CEO Rupak Barua. “They mostly visit for complicated neuro and gastric surgeries that can’t wait. So, we will end up losing these patients,” said Barua.

More than 35 Bangladesh patients were listed for surgeries and consultations at CMRI Hospital over the next few weeks, according to COO Simmardeep Gill.
I have not heard any Bangladeshi patient died in Bangladesh because they could not go to India for treatment in the last few months. This means, all treatment facilities that patients seek in India are available in Bangladesh and Bangladeshi patients can get by with their life without setting foot in India.
 
I have not heard any Bangladeshi patient died in Bangladesh because they could not go to India for treatment in the last few months. This means, all treatment facilities that patients seek in India are available in Bangladesh and Bangladeshi patients can get by with their life without setting foot in India.

Are you sure about that? The ones who visit CMC Vellore are usually desperate.
 
Slowly, but surely, Bangladesh govt. should start imposing tariffs on Indian goods and services, especially services. Until trade deficit normalizes.

This can be done by checking air passengers for cash taken to India undeclared. And imposing stiff fines on people if found.

We have to arrest the drain of our money going to India for Indian medical services.
 
Kolkata: Talks fail, no Bangladesh flights now

Subhro Niyogi and Prithvijit Mitra | TNN | Updated: Aug 21, 2021, 08:10 IST

85505828.jpg


The flights between the two countries were suspended in April during the height of the second wave.

KOLKATA: The Biman Bangladesh flights that were to resume on Sunday have been called off as an agreement on the resumption of flights could not be reached between the aviation authorities.

The announcement led to a gloom across the city’s hospitality sector and private hospitals that were getting ready to welcome back patients from Bangladesh, who accounted for around 8%-10% of footfalls till the pandemic.

“We had scheduled the resumption of flights from Sunday with the other two weekly services on Tuesday and Thursday. But we have not received permission from Indian authorities. Once an agreement is signed, we will announce the new dates,” a Biman Bangladesh official told TOI.

This will mean that SpiceJet and IndiGo flights that were also scheduled to resume will now be cancelled. While SpiceJet was supposed to start services on August 26, IndiGo was to start flights the next day. The flights between the two countries were suspended in April during the height of the second wave.

The news of the flight cancellation has dampened the spirit in the New Market-Sudder Street-Marquis Street-Free School Street-Park Street belt as well as hospitals in the city where Bangladeshis are a key clientele.

Bangladeshis account for over 50% sales at New Market, 70% business in hotels, guest houses and foreign currency exchanges on Sudder Street, Marquis Street, Free School Street, Royd Street and Rafi Ahmed Kidwai Road and 80% of the transport business in the area.

“We are disappointed since 20 online appointments had been issued to Bangladeshi patients who were to take the first few flights. Enquiries had been pouring in and we expected the number to proliferate with flights getting regular. But this is a setback for both Bangladeshi patients and us. They may now look for treatment in south-east Asian countries,” said Peerless Hospital CEO Sudipta Mitra.

Till the pandemic, 15% of Peerless’ patients would be from Bangladesh. They contributed 8%-10% of the hospital’s annual revenue.

AMRI Hospitals that had received 3,000 Bangladeshi patients a month across its three units before the pandemic already processed 300-400 visa invitation forms for Bangladesh patients who were scheduled to visit next week.

Most of them have emergency surgeries or treatment lined up, according to AMRI CEO Rupak Barua. “They mostly visit for complicated neuro and gastric surgeries that can’t wait. So, we will end up losing these patients,” said Barua.

More than 35 Bangladesh patients were listed for surgeries and consultations at CMRI Hospital over the next few weeks, according to COO Simmardeep Gill.

Ruby Hospital, too, was left disappointed by the flight cancellation.

“We were looking forward to welcoming them back since they generate a fair share of our revenue. We had issued 11 visa invitation forms to Bangladeshi citizens over the last one week. Most of them are cancer and haemotology patients who were planning to visit our hospital for long-term treatment. They can’t defer their treatment and will settle for other countries, which is unfortunate,” said

Ruby Hospital general manager – operations Subhashish Datta.

The return of patients is also crucial for tourism and business in Kolkata, said Travel Agents’ Federation of India chairman (East) Anil Punjabi.

“They invariably visit with families and do a lot of shopping that help the places like New Market and the shopping centres around it in central Kolkata. Their return would have helped the local economy,” Punjabi added.

Just Ban it permannetly.

There was no report ppl are worried about medical treatement or shopping there.
 
BD must tax medical tourists heavily, this will bring in tax receipts and spur on better medical facilities on country.

There is a demand, GoB must force supply to meet this demand in country.
 
There is trust deficit between patients and Doctors in Bangladesh. Many people believe foreign Doctors are more skilled and they will get greater care and attention from Doctors abroad.
I know people personally who has sold their properties to treat their child in BD before coming to India.

Over 10Lakh people came in India on 2019 for medical treatment and more than 60% were Bangladeshi. We charge 20% dearer to these patients. Many of them are poor, even I know cases where they were transferred to govt hospital after they were exhausted of all their money. It can't be mere trust deficit between patients and Doctors in Bangladesh.

Between the patients have started coming, land border is open for 3 days a week. It takes at most 7-8 hours max to reach from Dhaka.
 
I know people personally who has sold their properties to treat their child in BD before coming to India.

Over 10Lakh people came in India on 2019 for medical treatment and more than 60% were Bangladeshi. We charge 20% dearer to these patients. Many of them are poor, even I know cases where they were transferred to govt hospital after they were exhausted of all their money. It can't be mere trust deficit between patients and Doctors in Bangladesh.

Between the patients have started coming, land border is open for 3 days a week. It takes at most 7-8 hours max to reach from Dhaka.
There are two factors why Bangladeshi patients go India. One is, there is a lack of accoutability for Doctors in Bangladesh, so some Doctors treat patients recklessly. Since independence 50 years ago, so far only one Doctor in Bangladesh faced trial and jail for wrong treatment. This lack of accountability eroded the trust among patients about getting best treatment from Bangladeshi doctors. Second is, treatment costs in leading Indian hospitals are comparatively cheaper than Bangladeshi leading hospitals. There is lack of govt. oversight over the rules and regulations about how private hospitals should be run in BD.

Still one should not assume, Bangladeshi patients are not getting treatment within the country. Every year more than 20 million patients admit to Hospitals within Bangladesh while only a few hundred thousands venture into other countries. So one should not overestimate the dependence. Many Indians think, Bangladesh have no good hospital, health care infrastructure is very primitive, that's why all Bangladeshi patients flocks to India in droves, this is not true.
 
Last edited:
I know people personally who has sold their properties to treat their child in BD before coming to India.

Over 10Lakh people came in India on 2019 for medical treatment and more than 60% were Bangladeshi. We charge 20% dearer to these patients. Many of them are poor, even I know cases where they were transferred to govt hospital after they were exhausted of all their money. It can't be mere trust deficit between patients and Doctors in Bangladesh.

Between the patients have started coming, land border is open for 3 days a week. It takes at most 7-8 hours max to reach from Dhaka.
This is half truth. Bangladeshi people visit India because they really trust India doctors. So even many will visit kolkata who aren't so severe to visit to valore or chennai!

And indeed there is valid reason.

Unless most of Bangladeshi doctors show commitment, care and compassion towards patients, people will not stop visiting India for medical tour.

Even people who go there with tourist visa consult to doctors.

If major operation, we require medical visa though.

So yes doesn't matter how some of people want to stop flight with India, I and most people of Bangladesh strongly oppose it!

There are huge differences between fantasy and reality, and expats are supposed not to understand the reality.

The bitter truth is Bangladeshi doctors always refuse it.

People who try to overlook human health problem and want to stop visiting India forever , I suggest them to live in Bangladesh instead of western counties.

If India is becoming beneficial for our medical tourism , we are actually becoming more beneficial , at least when human health is the case.

For the other things like shopping, tourism, India is way more beneficial though!

But that's different argument!

Ps - Also no one should forget that even people from usa visit India for medical tourism!

So yes truth to be told!
 
Last edited:
Just Ban it permannetly.
How many of us can afford to take medical care in Singapore? How many can even fly?

Most of people visit India through land border ( mostly benapole and darshana) , so what's thoughts for them?
BD must tax medical tourists heavily
Really? So they can die in Bangladeshi hospitals? Will you take the responsibility?

You guys are really impossible!

Try to be a human being first, show some mercy to them.

Bangladesh doesn't have NHS like UK, that you can prescribe like this.

And remember, BAL isn't fool , if it kick on the belly of people and will prevent people from taking medical service from India before providing the same quality service in cheaper cost , govt will collapse overnight.

I'm surprised how unrealistic you guys can be!
 
Last edited:
There are two factors why Bangladeshi patients go India. One is, there is a lack of accoutability for Doctors in Bangladesh, so some Doctors treat patients recklessly. Since independence 50 years ago, so far only one Doctor in Bangladesh faced trial and jail for wrong treatment. This lack of accountability eroded the trust among patients about getting best treatment from Bangladeshi doctors. Second is, treatment costs in leading Indian hospitals are comparatively cheaper than Bangladeshi leading hospitals. There is lack of govt. oversight over the rules and regulations about how private hospitals should be run in BD.

Still one should not assume, Bangladeshi patients are not getting treatment within the country. Every year more than 20 million patients admit to Hospitals within Bangladesh while only a few hundred thousands venture into other countries. So one should not overestimate the dependence. Many Indians think, Bangladesh have no good hospital, health care infrastructure is very primitive, that's why all Bangladeshi patients flocks to India in droves, this is not true.

I would care not one whit - what Sanghis think or verbalize about us. None of us in Bangladesh should. That ship has sailed.

They live in a mess of a country right now, with infra mostly not much better than ours, a declining economy and are poorer to boot. Wish them better luck going forward. Gurugram, Navi Mumbai, Pune and Bangalore are a few bright spots in an otherwise massive cesspool of mediocrity.

The fact that retail items and medical services are cheap in India, does not mean that their economy is doing any better than ours, Ullus who see that as a boast and chest-thump point are Ullus.

Witness their minister Rajnath Singh opening a visa Kiosk in a local mall a couple years ago. Cause for Indian celebration (and jubilation !!) in moribund times.


My sympathy and good wishes for all decent Indians and hope they may recover from the Sanghi takeover.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom