What's new

Kerala and Tamil Nadu are quiet champions of India

manlion

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 22, 2013
Messages
7,568
Reaction score
-3
It was Salman Rushdie who observed many years ago that south India not only felt, but functioned like another country.

After a recent 10-day coast-to-coast journey in Kochi, then Chennai to Puducherry along the scenic East Coast Road -- taking in the splendid 10-acre Dakshina Chitra 'living' museum and the rock-cut temples of Mahabalipuram -- Mr Rushdie's insight holds unshakably true.

There is a degree of civility, efficiency, cleanliness and cultural ease here that has all but vanished in the squalid, chaotic and rootless urban agglomerations of the Hindi heartland.

Above the cash counter at a large highway eatery serving vegetarian thalis in Tamil Nadu was a notice in bold lettering that summed up the sense of fair play: 'Dear Customers, Pls. Demand Bill for Your Purchase. If not give call (three cell numbers given) to Get Your Purchase Absolutely Free'.

Kerala and Tamil Nadu are the quiet champions of India. You can banish the creeping trepidation of encounters with boorish, unhelpful functionaries, the push-and-shove of public places, or sullen drivers of smelly car-hailing rides who either fail to arrive, are often clueless about routes or unable to use GPS.

In southern cities, Uber drivers answer promptly, arrive within minutes, and know their way about; officials may have gone to village schools but speak perfect English; pedestrian pavements are wide and women safe on the streets after dark.

Some reasons for these well-ordered standards of civic life are obvious: Both states have zero population growth, 100 per cent literacy, and high levels of investment in education, health care and public transport -- Kochi's car ferries, for example, work to a clockwork time table.

A shining example of this is the fourth Kochi-Muziris Biennale, the country's biggest and longest international art show, an event so exhilarating in the city's historic Fort precinct that it makes exhibitions in Delhi, Mumbai and Bengaluru look like Cinderella's shop-soiled stepsisters.

Despite the constraints imposed by last year's floods last year, the government came through with generous financial support; indeed, it helped marshall so many private sponsors, led by Yusuff Ali, the Gulf's supermarket king, that the list takes up 17 pages of the biennale's fat catalogue.

The world-class show continues till March 31, featuring some 99 artists from 30-odd countries in a dozen venues, many of them in restored government buildings and abandoned spice warehouses.

The Kochi biennale is an institution-in-the-making but it is a novice as compared to the century-old musical sabhas of Chennai in January-February, the apogee of the cultural calendar.

Something like a hundred venues feature the best in Carnatic music and classical dance; at the apex is the Music Academy, run by the city fathers, to regimental perfection.

From early morning to late evening a succession of concerts follows an exact, well-advertised plan in a hall with state-of-the-art acoustics. No delay is brooked; no one gets in for free; excellent meals and coffee are served at precise breaks.

Nowhere else in the country can you encounter such engaged or knowledgeable audiences that come from distant cities.

A senior executive I met said he bought family season tickets for two weeks each year. "It is my happiest time off."

In its 90th cycle last month a star guest was Indra Nooyi, proud daughter of the city, and cousin of the classical vocalist Aruna Sairam.

One reason for the enduring success of these institutions is their independence from government interference, unlike New Delhi, where mouldering decay is hastened with philistine appointments and changing political dispensations.

Captivated by the zeitgeist, young professionals are moving south in search of not just a relaxed vibe but opportunities in the travel and hospitality business.

A young couple from Mumbai moved to Kochi, they told me, not just for the quality of life but better prospects.

They now run customised tours and a boutique aptly named Kingdom of Calm. They enthusiastically Whatsapped me the best eateries including 'the most fabulous Kerala beef fry'.

In Puduchery's elegantly revived French quarter, Sid Saikia quit apparel exports in Delhi to put his savings into restoring a 19th century Indo-French courtyard house as a homestay. He calls it Gratitude.

A small brass plaque at the door reads: 'If you are looking for a room please ring the doorbell.'

The 18th century political philosopher Edmund Burke decreed that good manners were more important than good laws. Several aspects of south India are proof of his axiom.

https://m.rediff.com/news/column/qu...Qwq99wd6qVBLd8iL-1E6Fw-OZNNZmrZpQINbHpXcSdp6s
 
.
This just shows different aspects of different states. To claim that the advantages of one state in certain criteria automatically invalidates the contribution of other states is simply not right.

Each state in India is unique, each contributes in its own ways.
 
.
There is a degree of civility, efficiency, cleanliness and cultural ease here that has all but vanished in the squalid, chaotic and rootless Hindi heartland,' says Sunil Sethi.

In Puduchery's elegantly revived French quarter, Sid Saikia quit apparel exports in Delhi to put his savings into restoring a 19th century Indo-French courtyard house as a homestay. He calls it Gratitude.

A small brass plaque at the door reads: 'If you are looking for a room please ring the doorbell.'

gratitude ?

 
.
Tamil Nadu? LOL! It's a dirty shit hole and ugly to boot. Chennai is feral. The people are rude and unfriendly. A fair call on Kerala however.

Sri Lanka is far, far, far cleaner and orderly that toilet nadu anyday (even with the retarded 'government' currently in power).



 
.
nice home in Pondicherry / Puducherry, Kalki @ 02:55 " I speak Tamil well, I am a Tamil ponnu / girl "
 
Last edited:
.
Captivated by the zeitgeist, young professionals are moving south in search of not just a relaxed vibe but opportunities in the travel and hospitality business.

A young couple from Mumbai moved to Kochi, they told me, not just for the quality of life but better prospects.

They now run customised tours and a boutique aptly named Kingdom of Calm. They enthusiastically Whatsapped me the best eateries including 'the most fabulous Kerala beef fry'.

In Puduchery's elegantly revived French quarter, Sid Saikia quit apparel exports in Delhi to put his savings into restoring a 19th century Indo-French courtyard house as a homestay. He calls it Gratitude.

The exposure to western imperialist British, Portuguese, French , (Jews) culture had contributed in the development , civilization , education of Kerala and Tamilnadu to evolve as premier states. Similar to the contribution of Muslims to northies e.g development of arts etc

Cochin Jews

 
.
The exposure to western imperialist British, Portuguese, French , (Jews) culture had contributed in the development , civilization , education of Kerala and Tamilnadu to evolve as premier states. Similar to the contribution of Muslims to northies e.g development of arts etc
Keralam and Tamil Nadu had some of the shortest periods of foreign rule, although they had some of the longest periods of foreign contact.

Live long the Republic of India, but can't ignore the millennia of history where these two regions had different colours from the rest.
 
.
Keralam and Tamil Nadu had some of the shortest periods of foreign rule, although they had some of the longest periods of foreign contact.

Live long the Republic of India, but can't ignore the millennia of history where these two regions had different colours from the rest.

Kerala /Tamilnadu had very ancient trade/cultural contacts with Arabs, Syrians, Jews, Romans, Portuguese, Danes French, Chinese etc. This exposure helped evolved hem to be forward thinking

Printing, education (of outcast otherwise denied under Hindu caste system) were some other western contributions

India’s first printing press and Rev. Ziegenbalg

In the realm of modern printing in India, the men who laid the strong foundation were Rev. Bartholomäus Ziegenbalg and his associates and printer Johann Gottlieb Adler at the Protestant Mission in Tranquebar, Tamil Nadu

The small, sleepy coastal village of Tharangambadi, (literally, Land of the Dancing Waves; anglicized name Tranquebar), has the unique distinction being home to the second largest Danish fort in the world – Dansborg Fort – a symbol of Danish power in this part of southern India. It was built by Ove Gedde, Commander of the Danish Royal Navy and Tranquebar’s earliest Governor,

Later over a period, the Danes built additional facilities, and by the 1770s, it became a well fortified trade-post, including Zion Church, the oldest Protestant Church in India. The fort is just adjacent to the sea shore in the back drop of a azure blue sea – the Bay of Bengal. A picturesque place that turns golden yellow at dawn in the glow of the sunrise

Upon arrival here, Rev. Ziegenbalg, did not lose his time to learn the local tongue Tamil, a highly advanced, perfect and literature-rich Dravidian language. With the knowledge of native tongue he could take the message of Christ across the people here. He realized only through local language his missionary work would become easier. He set up schools in Tanjore (now Thanjavur), Madras (now Chennai) and Tinnelveli (now Tirunelveli).

Again this time in the forefronts were the Christian Missionaries . It was here at Tarangampadi, the modern printing was revived at the initiative of Bartholomäus Ziegenbalg and his co-workers.

https://navrangindia.wordpress.com/2016/09/09/indias-first-printing-press-and-rev-ziegenbalg/
 
.
Kerala (or Malabar) and Tamilnadu are different (people), yet similar (languages). Tamil nationalists and chauvinists often try to claim Kerala, as if it was a part of Tamilnadu. Nope. People, cultural differences all subtle, sometimes distinct differences. However, I agree that keeping away north Indian Hindutva/RSS filth is one thing these states did, unlike rest of India who had fallen for Gujarat 2002 genocide heroes and obsessed with Hindu-Muslim religious hatred.
 
.
Kerala (or Malabar) and Tamilnadu are different (people), yet similar (languages). Tamil nationalists and chauvinists often try to claim Kerala, as if it was a part of Tamilnadu. Nope. People, cultural differences all subtle, sometimes distinct differences. However, I agree that keeping away north Indian Hindutva/RSS filth is one thing these states did, unlike rest of India who had fallen for Gujarat 2002 genocide heroes and obsessed with Hindu-Muslim religious hatred.

Kerala was once part of ancient Tamilakam comprising of the 3 Tamil kingdoms - Chera, Chola, Pandya. Malayam evolved out of Tamil Manipravalam (Tamil mix sanskrit) some 600yrs agao (??)

Onam was celebrated by Tamils during the sangam era , Tamil's Thaipusam is Thai pooyam in Kerala. Tamil Karru sami (ayaanar) is Ayappan, Kannagi is Bhagavthi amman in Kerala. Except for cuisine, kerala women dress -mundu, sambandham tradition initiated by nambodiris and other minor differences, culturally they are close.

Now cite me a case where present Tamil nationalist claiming Kerala.

Malayali winner of Super 4 Reality Show, singing Tamil song with flawless diction (better than Tamilnadu's singers)

 
Last edited:
. .
Oh, we sing not along Tamil, but Hindi, Telgo, Urdu or Arabic, in that case :)

I aware of that, my purpose was to compare the perfect Tamil diction of a Malayali student from a remote place - Trissur. Malayalis living in ME learn Arabic and most learn Hindi , no surprise if the sing Arabic or Hindi songs .
 
.
Tranquebar - Tarangambadi - Tamilnadu's little Denamrk , unlike Cochin or Pondicherry is yet to be exploited by northie "professionals"

 
Last edited:
. .
Auroville - Tamilnadu-Pondicherry's experimental city of the future, under threat from imperialist National Highway

 
Last edited:
.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom