What's new

Karachi operation in dire straits

@AgNoStiC MuSliM

mazhar abbas writes during shahid hayat's time @AgNoStiC MuSliM

Mazhar AbbasWednesday, January 22, 2014
From Print Edition


64 11 45 2


Over 20 million people of this mega city are sitting on a “volcano,” that can explode anytime and no one knows the magnitude of the explosion, but surely it can be quite devastating, if not handle with care. Therefore, save Karachi if you want to save Pakistan.



Karachi is not only the economic hub but country’s backbone. We are already paying the price of what we had done to this beautiful city in the last 66 years.



Once a federal capital, city of lights, mini Pakistan, now we are short of graveyards, as all major graveyards are overflowing. The city is simply becoming “unmanageable, if not totally ungovernable.”If one go through the files of “Karachi’s law and order” case in Supreme Court, it is an eye opener and provide proper guideline to the federal as well as Sindh government.



For the first time, the court deeply went into the causes behind deteriorating law and order, supply of weapons (both by land and sea) drugs, root cause of violence, role of the agencies from police to rangers, from FIA to Custom.



Its 2011 verdict followed by implementation hearings saw desire results as the SC even exposed the possible involvement of land mafia and thus probe the role of Board of Revenue as well.



The present Karachi operation has a background and SC decision of 2011 and its follow up provided the basis for theoperation clean up. Now the two phases of operation has been completed (so they say) and the Federal Interior Minister Ch Nisar during his visit to the city last week hinted towards the third and final phase, which he said would be “very tough.” operation clean up. Now the two phases of operation has been completed (so they say) and the Federal Interior Minister Ch Nisar during his visit to the city last week hinted towards the third and final phase, which he said would be “very tough.”



However, the assessment of the first two phases did not gave very encouraging results because the operation was not conducted in the manner it was planned and approved by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif four months back.



What are we going to see in the final phase? Speedy trials, fast convictions, executions, massive drive for de-weaponisation. If nothing of that sort is coming, I am afraid its result would not be very different from the first two phases.



For instance, it was decided that in the first phase, massive drive would be launched for the verification of car and motor cycle registration and officials from traffic police, Excise and Taxation Department and Rangers would check and verify papers of all vehicles. The drive ended after one week, due to political pressures.



Secondly, it was decided that no one would be allowed to display arms and private guards of VIPs, MNAs, MPAs, ministers etc would be told not to display it in public or during travel. Strict action would be taken against all those who violate the instructions.



Thirdly, it was decided that vehicles with tainted glasses would not be allowed and action would be taken.Fourthly, it was decided that speedy trial courts would be set up in large number for early disposal of cases and strict punishment be recommended for illegal weapons.



Fifth, It was also decided that proper verification drive be launched for over a million licensed weapons, which had been given without verification.



Chief Minister of Sindh, Syed Qaim Ali Shah was appointed as the Captain and one was expecting Governor of Sindh, Dr Ishratul Ibad to act as Vice-Captain and DG, Rangers would act as operational commander.



After four months of the first two phases Karachi remained as violent as ever because the decisions which both Federal and Sindh government had jointly taken were not implemented.



If there were some “secret success” achieved, at least the people are not aware of these victories.Police become the major victim of these two phases followed by rangers. So, even if over 10,000 suspects were arrested, as they officially claimed, what is the ultimate result? Where are they?



Sindh government had taken few steps like “Witness Protection Bill,” amendment in Anti Terrorism Act, to make video link statement of witness acceptable but so far we had not seen its implementation in any case.



The provincial government also introduced Sindh Arms Act, 2012 under which one person can hold only four licenses. The provincial government has also increased the maximum punishment for holding illegal weapon up to 14 years. But has anyone been convicted? The answer is NO.



Karachi need special attention and who knows better than Nawaz Sharif. This is the third operation in his three terms The first in 1992 military operation, second in 1998 when he imposed governor’s rule and now the third.



Karachi has become a paradise for the militants, land, drugs and arms mafia. Kidnapping for ransom, mobile snatching, bank robberies, illegal occupation of land worth billions of rupees, is order of the day. The city is the safest heaven for all kind of militants and since 80s.it remained safe heavens for both national and international militants.



After 9/11, many top al-Qaeda leaders took shelter in this very city including Khalid Sheikh Mohammad, Ramzi bin al-Sheiba. Now agencies feared that hundreds of militants from different armed groups have surrounded the city and most live in the outskirts of Karachi.



Traders, one of the major victims of kidnapping for ransom and “parchi system”, feared that any relaxation may give more strength to the criminals.



For instance, recently some of the criminals involved in bhatta and kidnapping cases after arrest send “parchi” to some businessmen from jail to increase extortion money. One passed a message that since they now have to pay money to the lawyers for the bail, they required extra money to get bail.



There should be a fourth phase too and that is the “revival of old Karachi”. The city needs a local police system, no political interference, fast justice, metropolitan transport, circular railway and above all Karachi Mass Transit system, which is pending for the past 40 years.



We want Captain of this operation to play the captain’s knock like Misbah ul Haq played in Sharjah. But can he do that? If not, politician results may not be very different and the people will suffer most.

who let uzair baloch escape? shahid hayat?

Jamal KhurshidSaturday, November 02, 2013
From Print Edition


404 1 0 0


Karachi



Police have been trying to arrest banned People’s Aman Committee chief Uzair Baloch and notorious gangster Baba Ladla in the Arshad Pappu murder case, AIG Karachi Shahid Hayat told the Supreme Court on Friday.



The AIG Karachi stated that raids had been carried out at the residence of Uzair Baloch but he could not be arrested. The police were taking action against the Lyari gangsters and had arrested some of them, including the notorious Amin Buledi, while another wanted gangster Jabbar Langra was killed in an encounter.



Hayat said the law enforcers were facing resistance in Lyari but the deployment of personnel and number of pickets had been increased in the restive neighbourhoods. The arrest of 10 to 15 “A-list gangsters” of Lyari would improve the law and order situation.



The three-member bench headed by Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry was hearing the petition of Farzana, the sister of Juma Sher, who was said to have been killed along with Pappu and his brother Yasir Arafat in Lyari earlier this year in March.



The petitioner, seeking the recovery of her brother, disputes the police’s claim that the man who was killed with the notorious gangster was Sher. The woman also sought the cancellation of a case against her second brother Munawwar for the murder of a police officer.



On the case against the petitioner’s brother, a special board had been constituted to investigate the case. After due inquiry, no evidence was found against Munawwar in the police officer’s killing. Hayat stated the report would be filed before the trial court.



Regarding the recovery of Sher, he said the SSP Anti-Violent Crime Cell had been given the task to ascertain the whereabouts of the petitioner’s brother for further investigation. But, he added, the policemen arrested in relation to Pappu’s murder had confirmed that Sher was killed along with the men.



The police chief submitted that DNA and other evidence could not be collected as their bodies were burnt to ashes by the killers.



The court reprimanded SP Investigations Junaid Shiekh, who did not appear in the court in the morning for the hearing. The AIG Karachi was directed to take disciplinary action against the officer for misconduct as he had to submit a report on the involvement of the petitioner’s brother in the policeman murder case.



Khalid Shamim case



The apex court directed the wife of Khalid Shamim, a suspect linked to the murder of Muttahida Qaumi Movement leader Dr Imran Farooq in London, to approach the Sindh High Court where her petition is already pending for adjudication.



The three-member bench headed by the chief justice was hearing the application of Beena Khalid, who submitted that her husband, an accounts officer at the Karachi Water and Sewerage Board was picked up by law enforcers in Malir on January 6, 2011, and his whereabouts were still unknown.



The AIG Karachi submitted that the woman’s petition had been already pending before the Sindh High Court since 2011 and the matter was being taken up regularly.

in London recently

BikWCHTIMAEYR0o.jpg:large
 
Last edited:
this is BBC report by the way @AgNoStiC MuSliM
‮پاکستان‬ - ‭BBC Urdu‬ - ‮’رینجرز تو خود ایک مسئلہ ہیں‘‬

’رینجرز تو خود ایک مسئلہ ہیں‘

حسن مجتبیٰ

بی بی سی اردو ڈاٹ کام، نیویارک



آخری وقت اشاعت: جمعرات 5 ستمبر 2013 ,‭ 11:34 GMT 16:34 PST​

130904154600_rangers-op-in-karachi.jpg

رینجرز دو دہائیوں سے زیادہ عرصے میں تین سے زائد بڑے آپریشن کا حصہ رہی ہے

نواز شریف حکومت نے کراچی میں رینجرز کو ہدف یا ٹارگیٹیڈ آپریشن کے فرائض تفویض کیے ہیں جو فورس سنہ 1990 سے لےکر آج تک کراچی سمیت سندھ کے لینڈ سکیپ کا مستقل حصہ بنی ہوئی ہے۔ رینجرز کراچی یا سندھ سےگئی کب تھی کہ پھر سے طلب کر لی گ‏ئی ہے؟

کراچی سمیت سندھ میں گذشتہ دو دہائیوں سے زیادہ عرصے میں تین سے زائد بڑے آپریشن کیےگئے ہیں جن کے نتیجے میں مبینہ طور پر بے شمار ماورائے عدالت قتل، تشدد اور ٹارگٹ کلنگز بشمول پولیس و دیگر قانون نافذ کرنے والوں کے ہوئی ہیں لیکن کراچی کے حالات میں ذرا برابر بھی فرق نہیں آیا۔

اسی بارے میں
متعلقہ عنوانات
کلِککراچی میں ٹارگٹڈ آپریشن کا فیصلہ

"نواز شریف حکومت کا ماضی میں دو سے زائد بار خاتمہ ہوا۔ وزرائے اعظم تبدیل ہونے سے نہ آپریشن رکے، نہ ٹارگٹ کلنگز اور نہ ہی ماورائے عدالت قتل۔ ایک دفعہ تو نواز شریف سے بینظیر بھٹو کو سندھ کی صورتحال اور اس کے خلاف لگاتار آپریشنز ورثے میں ملے لیکن نتیجہ صرف ماورائے عدالت قتل۔"

سنہ 1991 میں سندھی لوک فنکار گلشیر تیونو کی ہلاکت سے لےکر کراچی میں نوجوان سرفراز شاہ کی ہلاکت تک رینجرز کراچی سمیت سندھ کے بگڑے حالات کا حصہ تو رہی ہے لیکن مسئلے کا حل نہیں۔

کراچی سمیت سندھ میں تعلیمی ادارے، ہاسٹلز، کھیلوں کے میدان ،یہاں تک کہ قومی ورثے کی عمارات تک رہائشی اور آپرینشنل کمیپوں کے طور پر رینجرز کے زیر استعمال رہی ہیں۔

کراچی یونیورسٹی اور سندھ یونیورسٹی جامشورو کے امن مان کی ذمہ داریاں بھی رینجرز کے کنٹرول میں رہی ہیں اس کے باوجود ان کیمپسوں میں خون خرابہ اور خاص طور سندھ یونیورسٹی میں پروفیسر اور طلبہ کے قتل بھی ہوتے رہے۔

130904155124_rangers-op-in-karachi.jpg

رینجرز سنہ 1990 سے لےکر آج تک کراچی سمیت سندھ کے لینڈ سکیپ کا مستقل حصہ بنی ہوئی ہے

نواز شریف اور ان کی جماعت پاکستان مسلم لیگ نون تیسری بار وفاق میں اقتدار میں ہیں اور تیسری مرتبہ کراچـی میں آپریشن ہو رہا ہے۔

نواز شریف حکومت کا ماضی میں دو سے زائد بار خاتمہ ہوا۔ وزرائے اعظم تبدیل ہونے سے نہ آپریشن رکے، نہ ٹارگٹ کلنگز اور نہ ہی ماورائے عدالت قتل۔ ایک دفعہ تو نواز شریف سے بینظیر بھٹو کو سندھ کی صورتحال اور اس کے خلاف لگاتار آپریشنز ورثے میں ملے لیکن نتیجہ صرف ماورائے عدالت قتل۔

کراچی میں آپریشن کے کامیاب نتائج کا لرزہ خير اندازہ اس سے بھی لگایا جا سکتا ہے کہ ایک آدھ کو چھوڑ کر باقی کراچی آپریشن میں حصہ لینے والے تمام کے تمام پولیس افسران قتل کردیےگئے۔

ایسا بھی ہوا کہ نواز شریف نے آخری دفعہ گورنر سندھ اور ملک کی ہر دلعزیز شخصیت حکیم محمد سیعد کے قتل کے پس منظر میں سندھ کی حکومت کی چھٹی کرا دی اور اس کی جگہ فوجی آمر جنرل ضیاء کے دنوں کے سندھ میں وزیر اعلیٰ اور اس وقت کے اپنی پارٹی کے معتمد خاص سید غوث علی شاہ کو سندھ کا مشیر اعلیٰ مقرر کر کے شہر کراچی میں خصوصی فوجی عدالتیں قائم کیں۔ لیکن نتیجہ صفر۔

سوائے اس کے کہ ایم کیو ایم سے تعلق رکھنے والے کارکنوں کو خصوصی فوجی عدالتوں سے پھانسی کی سزائيں ہوئيں اور ایمنسنٹی انٹرنیشنل اور ہیومن رائٹس واچ سمیت انسانی حقوق کی عالمی تنظیموں نے ایسی سزاؤں کو انسانی حقوق کی خلاف ورزی کی نشاندہی کرتے ہوئے ان کی شدید مذمت کی۔

"رینجرز کراچی سمیت سندھ میں جا بجا اپنی چوکيوں پر جس طرح شہریوں کی تذلیل کرتے نظر آتی ہے ایسی تذلیل غزہ کی پٹی پر بھی نہیں ہوتی ہوگی۔"

پھر فوجی آمر جنرل پرویز مشرف کے ہاتھوں نواز شریف حکومت کا تختہ الٹے جانے کے بعد کراچی میں ایم پی اے ہاسٹل رینجرز کی زیر نگرانی نیب کا حوالاتی اور تشویشی مرکز بنا جہاں خود سندھ کے معزول مشیر اعلیٰ غوث علی شاہ اور وزیر اسماعیل راہو سمیت نواز شریف حکومت کے کئی لوگوں کو کئی ماہ تک نظربند رکھاگیا۔

110818095646_jp_karachi304x171_nocredit.jpg

رینجرز کو کراچی میں ماورائے عدالت قتل کے الزامات کا سامنا رہا ہے

آئین کی رو سے صوبے کی سول انتظامیہ رینجرز کو اندرونی سلامتی کے فرائض دینے طلب کرسکتا ہے لیکن اس کے آدھے اخراجات وفاق ادا کرے گا۔ سندھ کے ساتھ یہ ہوا ہے کہ سنہ 1992 سے رینجرزکا ہاتھی سندھ پال رہا ہے۔

رینجرز کراچی سمیت سندھ میں جا بجا اپنی چوکيوں پر جس طرح شہریوں کی تذلیل کرتے نظر آتی ہے ایسی تذلیل غزہ کی پٹی پر بھی نہیں ہوتی ہوگی۔

سنہ 1990 میں رینجرز سندھ میں امن و امان کی ڈیوٹی دینے آئی تو جامشورو ریلوے پھاٹک پر مشہور سندھی لوک فنکار گلشیر تیونو کو گاڑیوں کی چیکنگ کے دوران کئي گھنٹوں جون کی دوپہر کھڑا کر دیا جس سےوہ کچھ دنوں بعد انتقال کر گیا۔

ایک بھیانک کیس رینجرزکے ہاتھوں مارچ سنہ 1996 میں روہڑی کے قریب جاگیرانی قبیلے سے تعلق رکھنے والے چھ دودھ فروش دیہاتیوں کے ماورائے عدالت قتل کا بھی ہے جب روہڑی شہر سے دودھ فروخت کر کے اپنے گاؤں لوٹنے والے ان دودھ فروشوں کو ڈاکو قرار دے کر قتل کیا گیا تھا۔

ہیومن رائٹس کمیشن آف پاکستان نے اس واقعہ کی تفتیش کرنے کے لیے اپنی فیکٹ فائنڈنگ ٹیم بھیجی تھی جس نے اپنی رپورٹ میں جاگیرانی دودھ فروشوں کے قتل کو جعلی مقابلہ اور ماورائے عدالت قتل قرار دیا تھا تاہم رینجرز کے ترجمان نے اس کی تردید کی تھی۔
"اگر کراچی آپریشن کا مقصد سندھ میں پی پی پی اور ایم کیو ایم کے پاور بیس کو ہدف بنانا ہی ٹارگیٹیڈ آپریشن کی منزل مقصود ہے تو پھر اس کے نتائج بلوچستان سے مختلف نہیں نکلیں گے۔"

سنہ 1993 سے 1996 تک چاہے بینظیر بھٹو کی حکومت یا سنہ 1992 سے 1993 اور پھر 1997 سے 1999 تک نواز شریف کی حکومت تلے کراچی سمیت سندھ میں انسانی خلاف ورزیوں اور سینکڑوں ماورائے عدالت قتل کے سال تھے جن کے متعلق دستاویزات اب ملکی اور عالمی انسانی حقوق کی آرکائیوز کا حصہ ہیں۔

ٹنڈو بہاول، شاہ بندر، یوسف جکھرانی، گمبٹ کے حیدر شاہ اور کراچی میں ایم کیو ایم کے کارکنوں اور مرتضی بھٹو سمیت کئی ماورائےعدالت قتل ان ادوار میں فوج، رینجرز اور پولیس کے ہاتھوں ہوئے۔ بلوچوں سے تو چاہے ‌زبانی جمع خرچ سہی لیکن صدر زرداری نے معافی مانگ لی لیکن کراچی سمیت سندھ کے عوام سے ان کے دور میں آپریشنز کے دوران سنگین خلاف ورزیوں پر نواز شریف نے کبھی معافی نہیں مانگی۔

سندھ کا مسئلہ بمشول امن و امان سے زیادہ سیاسی اور انسانی حقوق کا ہے۔ اسے اگر سندھ میں پی پی پی اور ایم کیو ایم کے پاور بیس کو ہدف بنانا ہی ٹارگیٹیڈ آپریشن کی منزل مقصود ہے تو پھر اس کے نتائج بلوچستان سے مختلف نہیں نکلیں گے۔ رینجر کراچي اور سندھ میں وہی کرے گی جو ایف سی بلوچستان میں کر رہی ہے۔ جسے ایم آر ڈی کے دنوں میں سندھ میں تعینات کرنے پر سندھ کے لوگوں نے بہری پولیس کا نام دیا تھا۔

 
@AgNoStiC MuSliM

ordinary MQM workers and mohajirs were subjected to extortion in 1992 operation by the army and the police

Canada: Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada

he MQM alleged that it was being specifically targeted by the army operation (Asian Survey Feb. 1993, 131; AI Feb. 1996, 4; The Far East and Australasia 1996 1996, 858). Several sources indicate that the army and intelligence agencies had become increasingly alarmed at the MQM's growing strength in urban Sindh, where it had become a "virtual parallel government" and was "sounding an increasingly aggressive note" toward the government in Islamabad (UNRISD June 1993, 32; Asian Survey Nov. 1995, 1000; The Economist 1-7 July 1995, 30). On 19 June 1992, combined police and army forces raided MQM offices in Karachi with the assistance of the dissident MQM Haqiqi group (MQM(H) or "real" MQM), which was then installed and sanctioned as the only faction acceptable to the government (Asian SurveyNov. 1995, 998, 1000; UNRISD June 1993, 32; AI Feb. 1996, 4; ibid. Dec. 1993, 38). Several sources indicate that support for the MQM(H) was part of an army strategy to weaken, if not crush, the main MQM(A) faction under Altaf Hussain (The Herald May 1994a, 32; ibid. Aug. 1995a, 26; Asian Survey Nov. 1995, 1000-01; AI Feb. 1996, 4). Efforts to discredit the Altaf faction as a "criminal organization" were aided by the army's allegations of having uncovered 23 MQM torture cells where "hundreds" of political opponents and party dissidents had been tortured and killed (AI Dec. 1993, 38-40; ibid. Feb. 1996, 4; Asian Survey Nov. 1995, 1001; The Far East and Australasia 1996 1996, 858).

Over the following months hundreds of MQM(A) activists in Karachi and Hyderabad were arrested and the party leadership driven underground (AI Dec. 1993, 38;
Asian Survey Nov. 1995, 1001; UNRISD June 1993, 32). Most of the party's elected representatives to the provincial and national assemblies resigned their seats, and criminal charges were brought against many of them (AI Dec. 1993, 38; ibid. Feb. 1996, 4; UNRISD June 1993, 32). While Altaf Hussain and the top MQM leadership went into self-imposed exile in London (Asian Survey Nov. 1995, 1001; The Herald May 1994b, 42b), many who remained were reportedly pressured to join the Haqiqi faction (UNRISD June 1993, 32; The Herald Aug. 1995a, 26). As the police and army carried out raids, mass round-ups and siege-and-search operations in pursuit of MQM(A) leaders and militants over the next 30 months, thousands of ordinary MQM supporters and mohajirs were subjected to arbitrary arrest and detention, extrajudicial execution, beatings, torture, extortion and other ill-treatment (The Herald Nov. 1994b, 63-64; AI Dec. 1993; ibid. 5 Apr. 1994; ibid. 13 Dec. 1994; ibid. Jan. 1995; UNRISD June 1993, 32).

in a later report The Herald noted that the new operation was "lopsided and uneven," with security forces "not targetting all criminals, but a particular group of political activists" (ibid. Aug. 1995a, 25). Despite General Babar's claim that security forces had adopted a new strategy of "target arrests" (IPS 18 Aug 1995; The Herald Aug. 1995a, 27), mass round-ups and military-style siege-and-search operations were still commonly used (see subsection 4.1) (AFP 20 Aug 1995; The Herald Aug. 1995b, 28-30; AI 17 Aug. 1995; Country Reports 1995 1996, 1338). There was growing evidence that the Rangers and police were involved in human rights abuses, including beatings, extortion, disappearances, torture and extrajudicial executions of suspected militants in faked encounter killings (see subsections 4.2 to 4.4) (IPS 18 Aug. 1995; AFP 29 Aug. 1995; AI 17 Aug. 1995; ibid. Feb 1996, 17-18; The Herald Aug. 1995b, 28-30; ibid. Nov. 1995a, 46-47; ibid. Nov. 1995c, 56-58).

According to one source, the abuses committed during cordon-and-search operations are worse in low-income areas such as Orangi, Baldia and Korangi; while the procedures of arrest and extortion are the same,

During Operation Clean-up the army's Field Investigation Team (FIT) reportedly operated several interrogation cells in Karachi in which detainees were "subjected to severe torture" (The Herald Nov. 1994b, 64; ibid. Jan. 1995b, 50), and extortion
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom