Devil Soul
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2010
- Messages
- 22,931
- Reaction score
- 45
- Country
- Location
By:Kamran Rehmat 44 min ago | Comments (0)
PTIs score may determine the post-poll math
It is a million dollar question: can Imran Khan pull off the impossible? On that equation may be riding the outcome of this election in more ways than one.
The claims of a clean sweep are akin to talk being cheap; so, in my humble submission, that is ruled out (even in cricket terminology). I suspect the Kaptaan indulges in his favourite prediction game only to keep his partys morale on the necessary motivational keel, which is instructive, especially in a polity where the swing vote swings wildly towards the party projected to form the next government.
The PTI factor will play a crucial role in the make-or-break of the next government if it hits the straps. Heres how: if the party-for-change manages to win 35-40 National Assembly seats (reserved and minority seats included) and follows on its avowed decision to sit in the opposition by not breaking bread with either the PPP or the PML-N at the Centre, the big two status quo forces will be forced to join hands if neither wins a simple majority and/or has enough meat in terms of allies.
Such an eventuality would be a disaster-in-the-making given their recent history. There is such visceral acrimony between the PPP and PML-N that even if they were to somehow tide over the creases initially, its a cinch the probable coalition wont last.
This sort of situation would be tailor-made for the PTI to make itself count as the opposition, both in the short and long term. PML-N, presumably, would be more desperate than the PPP to form a coalition of the willing since the flock of Leaguers has historically been a fair weather friend. Also, the senior Sharif has been out of parliament for 14 years now; this is by all counts, his last big ticket to become prime minister. It will take a big heart for him to let the PPP and PTI form a coalition even if highly improbable, and something that will take a brave man to wager on!
But that is still some distance away with lots of ifs and buts riding on it. Purely from the PTIs perspective, if the rather fantastic clean sweep does not materialize and the party finds itself well short, the Kaptaan will have a situation on his hands. The young PTI hopefuls appear to have already taken the sweep for granted. A setback will require him to dig deep and hold the ship together.
However, there would still be positives to take home even if the PTI only manages to open a decent account.
The partys arrival as a serious contender bodes well for Project Democracy. Imran Khan and his legion of young party cadres deserve credit for breaking the stranglehold that status quo forces had over the electorate, and perpetuating a system designed to keep the reins of power with them. There is now a choice of substance before the electorate.
The single biggest contribution that the PTI has made and which is a change in itself regardless of there being immediate dividends or not is in creating a magnetic field for the youth: now they can not only participate in politics as candidates but effectively, carve out a role that potentially enables them to become tomorrows decision-makers at the highest level.
That it has actually awarded 35pc of tickets to candidates below the age of 40 will give them a strong sense of self-belief and encourage them to invest in their and hopefully, the countrys future.
Holding intra-party polls is another feather in the cap. It has already drawn grudging recognition even from naysayers, some of whom had predicted the exercise would be a death blow to the party given how the system works. Surviving the odds has earned PTI a distinction no other party can boast of.
Fellow commentator Saleem Safi, who isnt particularly enamoured of PTIs calling or even direction made an interesting remark recently about its contribution to the political landscape, and how it will fare in the coming elections the second part continues to vex every pundit worth his or her salt.
Safi said he didnt know what PTIs fate will be but it has done enough to soften the rod in the neck to borrow the Urdu colloquial for arrogance of the PML-N leadership, which used to haughtily shoo away politicians wanting to come under its shed, based on personal like or dislike.
In the same vein, he said the PTIs rising graph particularly among the youth also made the PML-N realize there was something like the youth, which exists (sic). Giving a random survey of his own in Islamabad, Lahore and Peshawar, he said, the party appeared to be riding a crest of popular wave but that it had left him confused about the eventual outcome.
At the least, what is apparent is that the party will offer genuine opposition in the parliament, for a change, and where it counts. In such an eventuality, it can use this time to build on its strengths and work out studiously on the loose ends.
The PTI as a potent opposition will keep the government on its toes, and have time on its hands to build pressure through all avenues available to push for one piece of legislation which is vital to its future: the right of vote for overseas Pakistanis a major chunk of which it may have been robbed of because big parties were scared of being at the receiving end of such a vote at its expense.
Indeed, a prominent TV anchor had tipped me off before the lenient verdict came out that the court hearing was little more than an attempt at grandstanding to be on the right side of history. The fact is that the idea for granting voting rights was broached the first time three years ago but had been deliberately stalled by the conniving bureaucracy, the PPP government and, later, by the PML-N as a partner-in-crime by not legislating on it.
A turnout in excess of 50%, most analysts suggest, could still turn the tables for PTI. The trump card is perhaps, held by more than 10 million voters in the 18-25 age bracket, and more than 36 million registered voters with no previous baggage.
The writer is Editor Pique Magazine based in Islamabad. He can be reached at kaamyabi@gmail.com
- See more at: Kaptaan
PTIs score may determine the post-poll math
It is a million dollar question: can Imran Khan pull off the impossible? On that equation may be riding the outcome of this election in more ways than one.
The claims of a clean sweep are akin to talk being cheap; so, in my humble submission, that is ruled out (even in cricket terminology). I suspect the Kaptaan indulges in his favourite prediction game only to keep his partys morale on the necessary motivational keel, which is instructive, especially in a polity where the swing vote swings wildly towards the party projected to form the next government.
The PTI factor will play a crucial role in the make-or-break of the next government if it hits the straps. Heres how: if the party-for-change manages to win 35-40 National Assembly seats (reserved and minority seats included) and follows on its avowed decision to sit in the opposition by not breaking bread with either the PPP or the PML-N at the Centre, the big two status quo forces will be forced to join hands if neither wins a simple majority and/or has enough meat in terms of allies.
Such an eventuality would be a disaster-in-the-making given their recent history. There is such visceral acrimony between the PPP and PML-N that even if they were to somehow tide over the creases initially, its a cinch the probable coalition wont last.
This sort of situation would be tailor-made for the PTI to make itself count as the opposition, both in the short and long term. PML-N, presumably, would be more desperate than the PPP to form a coalition of the willing since the flock of Leaguers has historically been a fair weather friend. Also, the senior Sharif has been out of parliament for 14 years now; this is by all counts, his last big ticket to become prime minister. It will take a big heart for him to let the PPP and PTI form a coalition even if highly improbable, and something that will take a brave man to wager on!
But that is still some distance away with lots of ifs and buts riding on it. Purely from the PTIs perspective, if the rather fantastic clean sweep does not materialize and the party finds itself well short, the Kaptaan will have a situation on his hands. The young PTI hopefuls appear to have already taken the sweep for granted. A setback will require him to dig deep and hold the ship together.
However, there would still be positives to take home even if the PTI only manages to open a decent account.
The partys arrival as a serious contender bodes well for Project Democracy. Imran Khan and his legion of young party cadres deserve credit for breaking the stranglehold that status quo forces had over the electorate, and perpetuating a system designed to keep the reins of power with them. There is now a choice of substance before the electorate.
The single biggest contribution that the PTI has made and which is a change in itself regardless of there being immediate dividends or not is in creating a magnetic field for the youth: now they can not only participate in politics as candidates but effectively, carve out a role that potentially enables them to become tomorrows decision-makers at the highest level.
That it has actually awarded 35pc of tickets to candidates below the age of 40 will give them a strong sense of self-belief and encourage them to invest in their and hopefully, the countrys future.
Holding intra-party polls is another feather in the cap. It has already drawn grudging recognition even from naysayers, some of whom had predicted the exercise would be a death blow to the party given how the system works. Surviving the odds has earned PTI a distinction no other party can boast of.
Fellow commentator Saleem Safi, who isnt particularly enamoured of PTIs calling or even direction made an interesting remark recently about its contribution to the political landscape, and how it will fare in the coming elections the second part continues to vex every pundit worth his or her salt.
Safi said he didnt know what PTIs fate will be but it has done enough to soften the rod in the neck to borrow the Urdu colloquial for arrogance of the PML-N leadership, which used to haughtily shoo away politicians wanting to come under its shed, based on personal like or dislike.
In the same vein, he said the PTIs rising graph particularly among the youth also made the PML-N realize there was something like the youth, which exists (sic). Giving a random survey of his own in Islamabad, Lahore and Peshawar, he said, the party appeared to be riding a crest of popular wave but that it had left him confused about the eventual outcome.
At the least, what is apparent is that the party will offer genuine opposition in the parliament, for a change, and where it counts. In such an eventuality, it can use this time to build on its strengths and work out studiously on the loose ends.
The PTI as a potent opposition will keep the government on its toes, and have time on its hands to build pressure through all avenues available to push for one piece of legislation which is vital to its future: the right of vote for overseas Pakistanis a major chunk of which it may have been robbed of because big parties were scared of being at the receiving end of such a vote at its expense.
Indeed, a prominent TV anchor had tipped me off before the lenient verdict came out that the court hearing was little more than an attempt at grandstanding to be on the right side of history. The fact is that the idea for granting voting rights was broached the first time three years ago but had been deliberately stalled by the conniving bureaucracy, the PPP government and, later, by the PML-N as a partner-in-crime by not legislating on it.
A turnout in excess of 50%, most analysts suggest, could still turn the tables for PTI. The trump card is perhaps, held by more than 10 million voters in the 18-25 age bracket, and more than 36 million registered voters with no previous baggage.
The writer is Editor Pique Magazine based in Islamabad. He can be reached at kaamyabi@gmail.com
- See more at: Kaptaan
