What's new

Kalabagh dam declared lifeline for future

Kabira

BANNED
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
14,383
Reaction score
-20
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
LAHORE:
The Lahore Chamber of Commerce and Industry is running a campaign to pave way for the construction of Kalabagh Dam, which they say, is a lifeline for the country’s future. The chamber is holding seminars and discussions with experts to clear any misunderstandings impeding its materialisation.


“Poverty, hunger and darkness would be our fate if we don’t build dams to store water, which is depleting fast. Nation will not forgive people who are opposing Kalabagh Dam for their own interests,” said former LCCI vice-president Abdul Basit. “Only because of government’s silence over KBD, the country is suffering a loss of Rs132 billion annually. This amount could be saved by initiating construction of the dam.”

The dam is not only beneficial to Punjab but would also contribute to erasing poverty from Khyber-Pakhtunkhawa. It would irrigate 800000 acres of cultivable land that is located 100-150 feet above River Indus level in the province. Experts say this land could only be brought under cultivation if the river level is raised and that could only be possible with the construction of the dam. The only other alternative is to pump the water which is very costly. Pumping water for potential cultivable land would cost farmers Rs5,000 per acre annually, while canal water after the construction of the dam would cost only Rs400 a year.

Critics argue that if the dam is built, it would turn Sindh into a desert, but the experts are of the opinion that the province would get additional 4.75 million acre feet of water. Punjab would receive additional 2.04 MAF, Balochistan 1.56 MAF and K-P 2.01 MAF.

“A general consensus could not be reached as the dam issue has been much politicised. The civil society would have to play a crucial role in creating a larger consensus as new large water reservoirs would benefit every Pakistani,” said Basit.

He said that another significant aspect connected with the construction is the surety of sufficient amount of electricity at a much cheaper price. “The capacity of the dam is equal to the capacity of 750 medium dams. The country’s dependence on power generated through thermal sources is costing us a lot and we face formidable challenges in both national and international markets. Kalabagh dam, if built, would generate 12 billion units of electricity at Rs1.54 per unit. In its absence, the shortfall is covered through electricity production at a price of Rs15 per unit. This means that the country is bearing additional burden of Rs180 billion or Rs1,000 per capita per year, he added.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 13th, 2014.

h
 
They keep talking about benefits but dams also have negative impacts. So they also need to convince people that positives outweigh negatives.

Interestingly it's very politicized and a provincial issue as different provinces have differing opinions regarding it. For Sindh, according to some sindhis, the negatives outweight the positives. What do you think should be done? How would you convince people?
It seems that all Pakistanis agree that 'something' must be done about it. Gilani Saheb has said that there would be a plebiscite about it so let's see.
 
Interestingly it's very politicized and a provincial issue as different provinces have differing opinions regarding it. For Sindh, according to some sindhis, the negatives outweight the positives. What do you think should be done? How would you convince people?

Sindh is crying for no reason at all. KPK concerns are genuine if cities will submerged. First KPK need to be convinced.
 
Sindh is crying for no reason at all. KPK concerns are genuine if cities will submerged. First KPK need to be convinced.

They are already looking for alternate locations for it, according to some sources (I don't know how feasible they'll be). Moreover, Gilani Saheb said that there would be a plebiscite regarding it. Let's see where it goes. Hopefully it's all for the best and all provinces agree this time.
 
Last edited:
For Sindh, according to some sindhis, the negatives outweight the positives.

According to some Sindhis - "Punjab will extract electricity from water, and will give useless/hollow water to them", Best of luck in convincing.


@ TOPIC - KBD whenever will be built only with danda in backs of Jagirdars & Waderas.
 
KBD is must for Pakistans Future and its Energy needs. Every province would benefit from it. This dam is a victim of our negative thinking.
 
Everybody knows the story & stats, the main question is why the construction of Kala Bagh dam & even Bhasha dam is always stopped & opposed by rented jabronis? These are the questions that needs to be answered immediately & the construction of these 2 dams needs to start immediately.
 
Kalabagh Dam's name has to be changed to something else, been too politicized. The Jahils are too stubborn.
 
I'll agree if the electricity is given solely to KPK and Punjab gets half of allocated water....... Punjab has enjoyed a lot on other provinces cost................. We don't want to add another "Metro" to Lahore, while our cities go without electricity........... enough of Punjabi gunda-raj........... our cities, our water, our way or no way! :D

If it weren't for @Hyperion @EyanKhan & @A.Rafay - This dam would've been built by now ! :mad:

KBD truly is the life-line of Pakistan & without it we're suffering incalculable damage ! :(
 
According to some Sindhis - "Punjab will extract electricity from water, and will give useless/hollow water to them", Best of luck in convincing.


@ TOPIC - KBD whenever will be built only with danda in backs of Jagirdars & Waderas.

Ah yes, the Wadera issue! Thanks for bringing that up. It will be interesting to know the opinion of the average man about this whole issue and how much are they aware of it.
 
if we all know how controvertial this dam is why the Government start building bhasha and dasu?? They arnt politicised, why is that have to focused on the controvertial projects?
 
Back
Top Bottom