"Hindus and muslims being seperate nations is pakistani logic ,not indian logic."
actually no its not. INC kicked jinnah out of congress. if theyd just let hinm stay no partition nonsense. also, jinnah was LIBERal. HIS WIFE WAS A CHRISTIAN and he was edcuated in the west. hes not some radical crazy islamist.
i"ndia is a secular nation ,not a hindu nation.
therefore ,muslims can stay in this nation"
yeah the UAE is a muslim nation yet the majority of people there are not muslims- theyre not even arab.
"of course ,hindu majority areas like hyderabad and junagadh cannot stay in pak because pakistan is an avowedly islamic republic."
it can stay. theres no law agaisnt it. and tehre are plenty of islamic nations that have populations of other religions.
"on its creation ,the hindus all were forced to flee away from pak."
yeah and all msulims had to flee too.
ever heard of the gurdasupur train incident?
clearly not.
read 'cracking india'
i hoenslty dont know where u get your one sided view or not but more msulims were forced to cross the partition border lines than hindus and sikhs put together.
"from 15 percent of west pakistan's population ,the hindu population fell down to 2 percent just after its creation.
so did the sikh population fall.
obviously ,the creators of pakistan had no place for these minorities in mind while creating pakistan."
again thats not what happened. they decided to make areas that were already maj. muslim paksitan and other areas india. so all the msulims staying in areas given to india were afraid; and had evry realistic right to be; conversely all hindus/sikhs were scared of living in an area given to pakistan (and had every realsitic right to be) so they all fled cross border.
on the other hand in india, most muslims ,except in punjab and some areas of bihar were allowed to stay.
"except in punjab" wat about bengal? did it ever occur to youthat muslims fled punjab and bengal becase those were the regions that bordered the msulims states? as if muslims from the middle of the country would flee.
"the muslim population has grown from 10.6 percent according to the 1961 census to 13.4 percent according to the 2001 census ,in india"
um yes. ever heard of giivng birth to people? of course its grown.
"so muslims of kashmir can stay in india....nothing wrong with that.
if pakistan wanted junagadh or hyderabad ,it should have been a secular republic like turkey , but it is not......in fact it is an islamic republic .......so how can hindus stay there??"
saudi arabia, uae is full of foreigners and those are all isamic states FAR MORE STRICT AND CONSERVATIVE than pakistan was ever meant to be (keeping in mind jinnah wasnt religious or conservative). in dubai you have to get a liquor licence before touching a drop of alcohol. yet oddly enough people have no problem living and moving to uae.
also idnia denied kashmiris the right to self determination twice - at the ebginngin, and at the time when teh revised reosltuon was passed. on top of that india rigged their elections and has had a brutal military opertaion there for 20 years.
yeah well done.
but india ,which is secular republic , can keep kashmir ,as it is not a hindu nation.