What's new

Italy warns India about ship firing detentions

MINK

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jan 22, 2011
Messages
556
Reaction score
0
Country
India
Location
India
Italy warns India about ship firing detentions

ROME: Italy warned India on Wednesday that it was creating a “dangerous” precedent by detaining two Italian marines who were on an anti-piracy mission when they allegedly killed two Indian fishermen at sea.

Premier Mario Monti relayed the warning during a telephone call with his Indian counterpart Manmohan Singh as the diplomatic standoff reached the highest levels of government as well as the halls of the European Union.

According to a statement from Monti’s office, Singh agreed to transfer the marines from prison to somewhere “adequate to their status.”

The marines, who were providing anti-piracy security aboard a cargo ship, are accused of shooting the fishermen Feb. 15 after mistaking them for pirates off India’s southwest coast.

A court in the southern state of Kerala on Monday ordered them jailed for another two weeks while officials investigate.

New Delhi says the case should be tried in India because the killings occurred on an Indian boat. Rome says the shooting took place in international waters and the case should be handled in Italy.

Italy says the presence of military personnel aboard the cargo ship is governed by an Italian law conforming to UN anti-piracy resolutions, and that such personnel are part of the Italian state and therefore immune to the jurisdiction of foreign states.

Italy has already sent a high-level delegation to New Delhi to try to negotiate the transfer of the marines, and the foreign minister traveled there last week.

It has now enlisted the European Union, which has begun making contacts “aimed at finding a satisfactory solution as soon as possible,” according to Maja Kocijancic, a spokeswoman for EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton.

During the phone call Wednesday, Monti told Singh that any Indian position “not fully in line with international law risks creating a dangerous precedent concerning international peace and anti-piracy missions,” the statement from Monti’s office said.

The statement noted that Indian military officers taking part in such missions would similarly be at risk in other jurisdictions if India were to press the case against the Italians.

Singh, the statement said, assured Monti he would consider Italy’s requests that the marines be treated appropriately with “maximum attention.”


Italy warns India about ship firing detentions - Arab News
 
. .
Italy could possibly bring down the weight of the EU behind it, this is getting very interesting. Italy doesn't seem to be backing down at all and they seem persistent they could try and politically and economically damage Hindustan depending on how far they wish to escalate this.

Singh, the statement said, assured Monti he would consider Italy’s requests that the marines be treated appropriately with “maximum attention.”

I hear the two captives are being treated very well by the Hindustanis.
 
.
We should set a precedent by sentencing them to life imprisonment or perhaps 14 years at least. Life of our fishermen is worth just as much as the life of these Italian marines. But I don't see much hope. These Italian ministers will definitely try to speak to Sonia Gandhi , and she , being Italian born might get emotionally compromised and try to get these murderers released.
 
.
What I would like to know what is the reaction to this story in Italy? What are the streets of Rome saying about this?
 
.
We should set a precedent by sentencing them to life imprisonment or perhaps 14 years at least. Life of our fishermen is worth just as much as the life of these Italian marines. But I don't see much hope. These Italian ministers will definitely try to speak to Sonia Gandhi , and she , being Italian born might get emotionally compromised and try to get these murderers released.

not after the humiliating defeat of congress in elections,there are elections coming in three states within few months,If she want to give opposition a reason to bash her even more,she is more than wel come.BTW its not in her hands to release italian mercenaries,In India we follow rule of law,so the courts will decide there fate and i do not think so that jaylalitha will allow the release of italian mercenaries.

---------- Post added at 08:31 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:30 AM ----------

We should set a precedent by sentencing them to life imprisonment or perhaps 14 years at least. Life of our fishermen is worth just as much as the life of these Italian marines. But I don't see much hope. These Italian ministers will definitely try to speak to Sonia Gandhi , and she , being Italian born might get emotionally compromised and try to get these murderers released.

not after the humiliating defeat of congress in elections,there are elections coming in three states within few months,If she want to give opposition a reason to bash her even more,she is more than wel come.BTW its not in her hands to release italian mercenaries,In India we follow rule of law,so the courts will decide there fate and i do not think so that jaylalitha will allow the release of italian mercenaries.
 
.
Our students were killed in streets of australia and our govt filed a protest and slept
these mariners killed our fisherman and we are getting warnings for their court trial
life of theirs is very precious and those who killed by them are nothing
 
.
Italy may have to resort to military action if india continues to act like a child. The Italians only ask that their marines be unharmed and treated as 1st class in the indian system. The last thing india wants is for Italy to come down to india and take their marines back with force, and joining them would be a country who has had a long history in dealing with india, the British.
 
.
I think Italy may try to retaliate with banning Indian visas to Italy and using the EU to pressure Hind. It's certainly within their capacity. Also they may issue a travel warning to Hind.
 
. .
they will have to take sonia gandhi too with these murderers..package deal or no deal..
 
. . . .
Italy will not be alone. Expect Britain and France also. And the nightmare of india is revitalized.

Britain can barely manage as it is...France won't risk a deal worth approximately 20 Billion dollars..and Italy will be stupid to do anything like this in Indian Ocean...
 
.
Back
Top Bottom