Israeli PM Netanyahu endorses Kurdish independence, cites chaos in Iraq

[Militant Atheist]

Well, government of Israel is filled with Jews. Isn't it?

Okay. That is 1000 people for you, including Cabinet members, Knesset Members and their families. What about millions of other Jews? When you say that "Jews are a dangerous species" you're generalizing.

 

[nForce]

well , pardon me if arabs put you to too much work , but i'm no arab

Didnt notice the flag. I have edited my post

 

[Alienoz_TR]

Okay. That is 1000 people for you, including Cabinet members, Knesset Members and their families. What about millions of other Jews? When you say that "Jews are a dangerous species" you're generalizing.

I am reading every jewish comment on gazettas like jpost and haaretz. Dont give me lesson about humanism.

 

[al-Hasani]

Ahh.. well its Arabs that I address.


and again.. its Arabs that I address.. pardon me for addressing the wrong flag.

What have Arabs to do with Kurds you Indian clown? They only live in tiny parts of two Arab countries (Syria and Iraq).

80% of all Kurds live in either Turkey or Iran. Same with 80% of the territory that they claim.

Which religions are you talking about? Nearly all Arabs are either Muslims or Christians. Ironically both Abrahamic religions that emerged among Semitic people and in today's Arab world and later spread to most of the world.

Lastly which cultures and ethnicities are you talking about? The Arab world despite its enormous size is surprisingly homogenous and share a common ancient Semitic history, ancient civilizations and now one branch of that (Arab) for the past 1400 years or so.

You are an Indian. You are basically made up of 1000's of different ethnic groups that do not even speak the same language, hundreds of historical provinces etc. Let alone dozens of different religions, sects etc. Your country came to an existence just 67 years ago.

And here you are showcasing your enormous ignorance again. Like 100's of other Indians here. You people take the price not only when it comes to ignorance when events in the ancient ME region are discussed but also when it comes to meddling in issues that you do not have the slightest business in.

Besides it's mostly only the Palestinians that make up like 3% of the nearly 450 million Arabs worldwide that are in direct conflict with Israel. 90% of the Arab world have never been in direct conflict with Israel to begin with.

I suggest you educate yourself a little. You are in a bad need of it.

Also just because many people out there confuse Iran and Iranians for Arabs it does not mean that this is the case. You can't even recognize basic flags of ME countries.

What a fail. One wonders why this section is messed up when idiots like these are running around freely like headless chickens.

 

[500]

Kurdish state de facto already exists:

 

[Militant Atheist]

I am reading every jewish comment on gazettas like jpost and haaretz. Dont give me lesson about humanism.

Haaretz comment section is filled with anti-Israeli comments. JPost comment section is filled with Christians United for Israel comments.

 

[PeaceGen]

I wouldn't really be surprised if decades from now they reveal that Israeli Intelligence Service was behind ISIS.

That would go against Israeli nature.

Isn't this a case of yet another 'hey let's blame the other side for all our wrongs'?

 

[Jihad_]

Israelis 'using Kurds to build power base' | World news | The Guardian

Israeli military and intelligence operatives are active in Kurdish areas of Iran, Syria and Iraq, providing training for commando units and running covert operations that could further destabilise the entire region, according to a report in the New Yorker magazine.

Israel's aims, according to Hersh, are to build up the Kurdish military strength in order to offset the strength of the Shia militias and to create a base in Iran from which they can spy on Iran's suspected nuclear-making facilities.

"Israel has always supported the Kurds in a Machiavellian way - a balance against Saddam," one former Israeli intelligence officer told the New Yorker. "It's Realpolitik. By aligning with the Kurds Israel gains eyes and ears in Iran, Iraq and Syria. The critical question is 'What will the behaviour of Iran be if there is an independent Kurdistan with close ties to Israel? Iran does not want an Israeli land-based aircraft carrier on its border."

What about supporting Palestinian State?

 

[Militant Atheist]

That would go against Israeli nature.

Isn't this a case of yet another 'hey let's blame the other side for all our wrongs'?

I said I wouldn't be surprised, I didn't say its definite. Why do you think that such case is not probable? Infiltrate the organization and make them attack their sworn enemies, Shiites. ISIS coordination and tactics suggest that they definitely have backing of powerful people, organization(s).

What's the other side? I don't take sides as none of the players benefit me and people of my country or the people of middle-east for that matter.

 

[Kaniska]

What have Arabs to do with Kurds you Indian clown? They only live in tiny parts of two Arab countries (Syria and Iraq).

80% of all Kurds live in either Turkey or Iran. Same with 80% of the territory that they claim.

Which religions are you talking about? Nearly all Arabs are either Muslims or Christians. Ironically both Abrahamic religions that emerged among Semitic people and in today's Arab world and later spread to most of the world.

Lastly which cultures and ethnicities are you talking about? The Arab world despite its enormous size is surprisingly homogenous and share a common ancient Semitic history, ancient civilizations and now one branch of that (Arab) for the past 1400 years or so.

You are an Indian. You are basically made up of 1000's of different ethnic groups that do not even speak the same language, hundreds of historical provinces etc. Let alone dozens of different religions, sects etc. Your country came to an existence just 67 years ago.

And here you are showcasing your enormous ignorance again. Like 100's of other Indians here. You people take the price not only when it comes to ignorance when events in the ancient ME region are discussed but also when it comes to meddling in issues that you do not have the slightest business in.

Besides it's mostly only the Palestinians that make up like 3% of the nearly 450 million Arabs worldwide that are in direct conflict with Israel. 90% of the Arab world have never been in direct conflict with Israel to begin with.

I suggest you educate yourself a little. You are in a bad need of it.

Also just because many people out there confuse Iran and Iranians for Arabs it does not mean that this is the case. You can't even recognize basic flags of ME countries.

What a fail. One wonders why this section is messed up when idiots like these are running around freely like headless chickens.

wow...that for this information that i have highlighted....I was under impression that Arab nation along with Iran also conflict with Israel....Then why the heck there is so much of noise among Islamic nations?...If Arab nations who are primarily leaders among the muslim nations can deal with Israel, then why not other Muslim nations like BD, Pakistan always have -ve impression about Israel?...

 

[Falcon29]

wow...that for this information that i have highlighted....I was under impression that Arab nation along with Iran also conflict with Israel....Then why the heck there is so much of noise among Islamic nations?...If Arab nations who are primarily leaders among the muslim nations can deal with Israel, then why not other Muslim nations like BD, Pakistan always have -ve impression about Israel?...

Why the hell does Israel matter so much? It's been decades now that Arab nations and Muslims nations cooperate with Israel in many fields and have diplomatic relations.

That's a bad thing, in reality they shouldn't be. A good thing would be that they put an end to their injustice and all other injustice in the region.

 

[AugenBlick]

Well, government of Israel is filled with Jews. Isn't it?

ISIS is filled with muslims isn't it.

 

[al-Hasani]

wow...that for this information that i have highlighted....I was under impression that Arab nation along with Iran also conflict with Israel....Then why the heck there is so much of noise among Islamic nations?...If Arab nations who are primarily leaders among the muslim nations can deal with Israel, then why not other Muslim nations like BD, Pakistan always have -ve impression about Israel?...

I was talking about war here. No Arab country has any dealings with Israel from what I am aware of other than neighboring countries who are forced to deal with the country directly.

By dealings I mean real dealings that you have with every other state. Israel is pretty much boycotted by the entire Arab world and most of the Muslim world due to their actions regarding Palestine.

In any case this is about Kurds who have no relevance in 95% of all Arab countries.

Your compatriot unfortunately just acted like one giant ignorant and there are too many of those from India on PDF which gives you a bad reputation here among Middle Eastern people.

A friendly advice to all of them. Don't comment on issues that you have little or close to no knowledge about just because you feel so or want to score some easy "points" here.

Unless you want to appear as nothing more than an ignorant.

 

[Kaniska]

I was talking about war here. No Arab country has any dealings with Israel from what I am aware of other than neighboring countries who forced to deal with the country directly.

By dealings I mean real dealings that you have with every other state. Israel is pretty much boycotted by the entire Arab world and most of the Muslim world due to their actions regarding Palestine.

In any case this is about Kurds who have no relevance in 95% of all Arab countries.

That makes more sense to me now..

 

[al-Hasani]

That makes more sense to me now..

Feel free to ask questions. I am open for any serious discussion. But users like your compatriot here are only annoying.

You see if I wanted to comment on something about Indian or South Asian affairs the least I would do beforehand was a bit of research.

I am far from the only one that shares those complains btw. We have users from all over the ME that share similar opinions.

I realize that the forum is full of Indian users but still a bit of research is not too much to expect before entering a discussion in "foreign territory".