Israel bill to limit Muslim call to prayer passes parliamentary first reading

[The SC]

Fair enough, but how did Islam manage for 1300 years, before the invention of loudspeaker in 1900s?

They were small communities, and even in relatively big cities there were many mosques each covering a small area of its own where all the people around it will hear the Athan, and usually the mouthins were chosen for their strong voices too..

 

[salarsikander]

first don't call me dumbass and don't call me zionist,i'm anti-zionist
i said if you are not a religious jew then religion is not one of your claims,read what i wrote before,all the answers are there.
what culture? jewish culture! the use of power in shabat has no connection to culture.
not all the jews "kicked out".
there is nothing that prevents us from going back or staying in israel
if you think that there is something that prevents, so please tell me

My apologies for being rude.

So no religious thingy connection with Israel ? Then what claim a culture claim?
Dude move on from 2000bc countries shift and becomee non existent in period of millennium and you're still stuck there

 

[19887]

My apologies for being rude.

So no religious thingy connection with Israel ? Then what claim a culture claim?
Dude move on from 2000bc countries shift and becomee non existent in period of millennium and you're still stuck there

I think you didn't understand me at all until now
For secularists the main argument is historical
For religious/traditionals the main argument is religious

 

[salarsikander]

I think you didn't understand me at all until now
For secularists the main argument is historical
For religious/traditionals the main argument is religious

I get what yiy mean. In either case the argument is totally invalid.
Since you cannot put a historical claim. If it was historical. Then yoiu will never find njews everywhere on planet as DISPERSED. secondly, holding on to 3k old historical claim. Move on bud.

Not even by religious terms. You lot were kicked out from the land and are forbidden to return to it, until such time a messiah comes. It is very clear. As for secluarist/Zionist my signature is right

 

[19887]

I get what yiy mean. In either case the argument is totally invalid.
Since you cannot put a historical claim. If it was historical. Then yoiu will never find njews everywhere on planet as DISPERSED. secondly, holding on to 3k old historical claim. Move on bud.

Not even by religious terms. You lot were kicked out from the land and are forbidden to return to it, until such time a messiah comes. It is very clear. As for secluarist/Zionist my signature is right

1.)Continuing history of 3000+ years
2.)"You lot were kicked out from the land and are forbidden to return to it, until such time a messiah comes"
A.)not all the jews were exiled
B.)There is no prohibition to return or stay in Israel with or without Messiah
If you think that there is such a ban then show it to me

 

[salarsikander]

1.)Continuing history of 3000+ years
2.)"You lot were kicked out from the land and are forbidden to return to it, until such time a messiah comes"
A.)not all the jews were exiled
B.)There is no prohibition to return or stay in Israel with or without Messiah
If you think that there is such a ban then show it to me

LOl Denying the history again. Ok tell me one thing Why are you guys so much dispersed around the planet ?

http://www.rense.com/general43/torah.htm

http://www.nkusa.org/aboutus/zionism/opposition.cfm

 

[krash]

There were huge sprawling Islamic cities before 1900s.

Yes true. For that they used different passive instruments to amplify their voice and built a lot more mosques per unit area than today.

The debate is not whether Islam or Namaz will survive a ban on loudspeakers or not. It is of religious freedom. Otherwise, there are countries where Azan is not allowed at all, loudspeaker or no loudspeaker. People pray there just fine and on time.

 

[19887]

LOl Denying the history again. Ok tell me one thing Why are you guys so much dispersed around the planet ?

http://www.rense.com/general43/torah.htm

http://www.nkusa.org/aboutus/zionism/opposition.cfm

Why do you bring me again this links? it's not a source it's the opinion of very little group and that's it.
Why do so many of us were scattered around the world?
Because of Assyria, Babylon and Rome.

 

[HannibalBarca]

Why do you bring me again this links? it's not a source it's the opinion of very little group and that's it.
Why do so many of us were scattered around the world?
Because of Assyria, Babylon and Rome.

Well your bothers and SIsters said that it was bc of muslims that you are all round the wolrd...

 

[salarsikander]

Why do you bring me again this links? it's not a source it's the opinion of very little group and that's it.
Why do so many of us were scattered around the world?
Because of Assyria, Babylon and Rome.

LOOOOOOL. It was because you were kicked from your own land and dispersed. And say you were kicked by blah blah people. It was 3000 years ago. Now dont be stupid for claiming a culture or so called historic ties. Move on. Though you people are doomed to remain stateless.

 

[19887]

Well your bothers and SIsters said that it was bc of muslims that you are all round the wolrd...

Then they were wrong
There is no connection between Muslims and those who threw us out of our country
From among all the empires that occupied our country one after another, despite the fact that Muslims were not "angels" they were more tolerant than others.

LOOOOOOL. It was because you were kicked from your own land and dispersed. And say you were kicked by blah blah people. It was 3000 years ago. Now dont be stupid for claiming a culture or so called historic ties. Move on. Though you people are doomed to remain stateless.

It seems that you want to believe in your initial thesis
And once I refuting your thesis, you are left speechless
As a result you return to recite the same old rhetoric
Look, you don't have to believe or accept things that I said, but I advise you not to deprive quickly
Do not succumb to your prejudices, always check if you can contradict your opinions.
This discussion is over.

 

[salarsikander]

Then they were wrong
There is no connection between Muslims and those who threw us out of our country
From among all the empires that occupied our country one after another, despite the fact that Muslims were not "angels" they were more tolerant than others.


It seems that you want to believe in your initial thesis
And once I refuting your thesis, you are left speechless
As a result you return to recite the same old rhetoric
Look, you don't have to believe or accept things that I said, but I advise you not to deprive quickly
Do not succumb to your prejudices, always check if you can contradict your opinions.
This discussion is over.

I do not need to. Not that I have grudge against Jews. But I certainly despise Zionist. Which n every sensengoes against the teaching of Judaism.