Israel bans Norwegian doctor from Gaza for life

[VCheng]

If that’s the case is Israel responsible for the Palestinians as a whole and using your logic makes them de facto Israeli citizens until they get their own state?

Responsibility for entry and exit privileges is very different than citizenship, Sir.

 

[AshishDelhi]

You are an Indian and you would suck up to anyone abusing Palestinians, Arabs or Muslims in general. That's the sole reason why Indians love Israel.

India is one of the stongest non muslim supporter of Palestine. We do not have any reason to hate Palestine but it does not mean that we shouldn't supprt Israel. Israel gave unconditional support during Kargil war.
It is similar to our relations with Iran and US. We are friends with both and it might help everyone in future. You can't expect Yemen to broker peace.

 

[ozzy22]

Responsibility for entry and exit privileges is very different than citizenship, Sir.

Why stop there when using your logic and Israel controls more than just the entry and exit privileges, as you put it

Your whole stance on this is odd. You are well known to criticize Muslims/Islamic countries. In lots of cases totally justifiable, but then you’re here defending Israel which in some cases is just as bad.

 

[VCheng]

Why stop there when using your logic and Israel controls more than just the entry and exit privileges, as you put it

Your whole stance on this is odd. You are well known to criticize Muslims/Islamic countries. In lots of cases totally justifiable, but then you’re here defending Israel which in some cases is just as bad.

Correction: I am not here to defend Israel. I am merely pointing out that in this case, it is legally on solid ground to deny entry to a humanitarian who is now no longer a humanitarian.

 

[ozzy22]

Correction: I am not here to defend Israel. I am merely pointing out that in this case, it is legally on solid ground to deny entry to a humanitarian who is now no longer a humanitarian.

Not just this instance/thread, but I have seen you defend Israel on numerous occasions.

 

[VCheng]

Not just this instance/thread, but I have seen you defend Israel on numerous occasions.

It depends on what the circumstances are, which I evaluate fairly and without prejudice. We can talk about it in other threads. Here, the topic is the denial of entry to a doctor by Israel.

 

[ozzy22]

It depends on what the circumstances are, which I evaluate fairly and without prejudice. We can talk about it in other threads. Here, the topic is the denial of entry to a doctor by Israel.

Well, you don’t fairly evaluate. Your logic seems to be that Muslim countries are worse and that justifies the way the Palestinians are treated, that just makes you a hypocrite and devalues your points on other issues. Why don’t you just be fair and criticize what’s wrong, rather than picking and choosing what fits your agenda.

 

[VCheng]

Well, you don’t fairly evaluate. Your logic seems to be that Muslim countries are worse and that justifies the way the Palestinians are treated, that just makes you a hypocrite and devalues your points on other issues. Why don’t you just be fair and criticize what’s wrong, rather than picking and choosing what fits your agenda.

Palestinians are only paying the price for their own decisions after they turned down the partition plan offered to them by the UN. They then proceeded to fight a war and lost. What is not fair about saying that?

 

[Pride]

Well we have said forever let the Kashmiris choose....

2ndly this isnt the thread for it..

First thing, Pakistan never said that but attacked it.

Secondly, It was you who were being "Language" Nazi over the choice of word. I have just given an analogy for "Administration" and control part.

 

[Dubious]

Secondly, It was you who were being "Language" Nazi over the choice of word. I have just given an analogy for "Administration" and control part.

My my ....What a response....I wasnt being nazi over the choice of words but pointing out the obvious...

 

[The_Showstopper]

Palestine is recognized by some countries as a Sovereign State and it is while Kashmir is not...

It should be many....

 

[The_Showstopper]

Correction: I am not here to defend Israel. I am merely pointing out that in this case, it is legally on solid ground to deny entry to a humanitarian who is now no longer a humanitarian.

What do you have to say about this.....

U.N. human rights investigators denied entry to Israel for Gaza inquiry - LA Times

 

[VCheng]

What do you have to say about this.....

U.N. human rights investigators denied entry to Israel for Gaza inquiry - LA Times

Any sovereign nation has this right. Would India allow such a UN mission into IOK?

 

[Pride]

My my ....What a response....I wasnt being nazi over the choice of words but pointing out the obvious...

Ha ha.. Well, Grammar Nazi and Language Nazi words are used as phrase in Internet for those who pin point or argue over grammar or choice of words respectively. I think you took it too personally.Nothing "Nazi" into that.

 

[Dubious]

Ha ha.. Well, Grammar Nazi and Language Nazi words are used as phrase in Internet for those who pin point or argue over grammar or choice of words respectively. I think you took it too personally.Nothing "Nazi" into that.

I know what they mean...Just as usual being the nazi to point it out