What's new

Is South Korea's new KF-21 fighter similar to India's AMCA stealth jet?

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
South Korea on Friday unveiled the prototype of its new '4.5 generation' fighter dubbed the KF-21 Boramae (young hawk trained for hunting), nearly 20 years after the project to build it was announced.

A fighter of the 4.5 generation is classified as having high manoeuvrability, advanced weapons for air-to-air and air-to-surface missions, features to reduce radar signature and integration of radar and infra-red sensors. A 4.5 generation fighter carries its weapons on external hardpoints on the wings and fuselage, unlike 5th generation aircraft that have internal weapons bays to increase stealth.

South Korean President Moon Jae-in and Indonesian Defence Minister Prabowo Subianto were among the key participants at the launch of the fighter.

In 2001, then South Korean president Kim Dae Jung had pledged to develop an indigenous fighter for the country by 2015 to replace its fleet of F-4 and F-5 aircraft.

In 2019, reports emerged Indonesia was backtracking on its commitments to the KF-21 project. Indonesia had agreed to provide $1.3 billion to buy 48 aircraft and also secure transfer of technology for it. However, Indonesia has provided only around $202 million so far, Yonhap reported. South Korea and Indonesia are continuing talks on the project.

History of KF-21

The formal development of the KF-21 fighter began in late 2015. According to South Korea's Yonhap news agency, the country had allocated $7.9 billion to develop and build 120 KF-21 fighters.

The KF-21, a twin-engine aircraft, is capable of carrying up to 7.7 tonnes of weapons and fuel under its wings and fuselage.

The first flight of the KF-21 is expected to be completed in 2022. The KF-21 resembles the US F-35 stealth fighter outwardly. South Korea is a user of the F-35, and the KF-21 has been touted as a “cheaper, less-stealthy alternative” to the US jet.

The current variant of the KF-21 does not feature an internal weapons bay, but future variants could have it. "Based on this 4.5 generation platform, South Korea will be capable of building more advanced versions down the road," professor Bang Hyo-Choong of the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST) told Yonhap.

South Korea is purchasing air-to-air missiles for the first KF-21 batch from European companies MBDA and Diehl BGT.

South Korea has adopted a phased development approach to building the KF-21. "The KF-X Block I will not have an internal weapons carriage, which is planned for subsequent production blocks. The initial version will also lack air-to-ground striking capability since the home-grown long-range air-to-ground missile is to be developed by the mid-2020s," Defense News reported in 2019. Israeli company Elbit is assisting in the development of the radar of the KF-21.

KF-21 and AMCA

The KF-21 will be powered by two F414 engines, built by US company GE. GE delivered the first F414 engines to South Korea last year. Interestingly, the F414 will also power the initial variants of India's under-development Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA) stealth fighter. The DRDO currently plans to fly the first prototype of the AMCA by 2025.




The AMCA will be similar to the KF-21 in being a twin-engine fighter with an approximate take-off weight of around 25 tonnes.

While similar in layout to the KF-21, the AMCA is being designed with an internal weapons bay. The DRDO has also hinted at developing an unmanned version of the AMCA. In February this year, A.K. Ghosh, the director of the AMCA project for DRDO, told The New Indian Express, "We have plans in future to incorporate 6th generation technologies, where it will be possible to fly AMCA aircraft in an autonomous mode for dangerous missions.”

The Indian Air Force currently expects to buy up to 125 AMCA fighters. According to reports, the first two squadrons of AMCA jets would be powered by the F414 engines, while the remaining ones would be equipped with a higher-thrust engine to be developed in India with foreign assistance.


.
 
The development is begun in 2011 and this is the base C 103 design that is completed in Desember 2012. At that time there is only ADD Korea and Indonesian Aerospace. KAI and LM comes in 2015 and use C 103 design as base and refine it into final C 109 design.

No we dont follow AMCA, AMCA follow F35 design and KFX/IFX program has official partnership with Lockheed Martin since 2015 the maker of F22 and F35


This is Indonesian wind tunnel history where you can see C 103 design (finish in Desember 2012), pretty much a base of final C 109 design.

 
Who wrote this article?
The development is begun in 2011 and this is the base C 103 design that is completed in Desember 2012. At that time there is only ADD Korea and Indonesian Aerospace. KAI and LM comes in 2015 and use C 103 design as base and refine it into final C 109 design.

No we dont follow AMCA, AMCA follow F35 design and KFX/IFX program has official partnership with Lockheed Martin since 2015 the maker of F22 and F35


This is Indonesian wind tunnel history where you can see C 103 design (finish in Desember 2012), pretty much a base of final C 109 design.

AMCA doesn’t follow any design, it is a unique design of its own.
1618038381690.png

1618038428686.png

1618038434849.jpeg
 
Yes - The AMCA is an Indian attempt to copy the J31 / F35 / KF-21 / X-2 Shinshin / TFX designs ....

All of the J31 / F35 / KF-21 / X-2 Shinshin / TFX have prototype / flying units with TFX being the last in that list, all India has is computer rendering pictures and vapourware .. So, yes, India is attempting to copy ...
 
Who wrote this article?

AMCA doesn’t follow any design, it is a unique design of its own.
View attachment 732683
View attachment 732684
View attachment 732685
It looks like a ripoff J-31 (which is an F-35 copy itself) with JF-17 elements in its wings. It will definitely be inferior to J-31 and perhaps even AZM. India will likely be forced to buy foreign fighters yet again unless it plans on only bullying PAF for the few months/years the balance of power will be tipped in IAF's favour (before AZM is operational).
 
It looks like a ripoff J-31 (which is an F-35 copy itself) with JF-17 elements in its wings. It will definitely be inferior to J-31 and perhaps even AZM. India will likely be forced to buy foreign fighters yet again unless it plans on only bullying PAF for the few months/years the balance of power will be tipped in IAF's favour (before AZM is operational).
Inferior to Azm, may I ask what is azm, do we even have a publicly displayed model of atleast wha it looks? And damn you’re funny that PF-X will be superior to AMCA. It doesn’t even look remotely same to FC-31. But where is Azm? And you got to know who’s superior before both took off? You’ll just paint a chinese jet green and call it PF-X.
Who wants to bet South Korea's KF21 will actually come out quicker whereas AMCA will only be on design boards and Indians will be looking to buy the South Korean KF21
KF21 is not a 5th gen aircraft, their designers also say that, they will gradually make it a 5th gen aircraft.
Yes - The AMCA is an Indian attempt to copy the J31 / F35 / KF-21 / X-2 Shinshin / TFX designs ....

All of the J31 / F35 / KF-21 / X-2 Shinshin / TFX have prototype / flying units with TFX being the last in that list, all India has is computer rendering pictures and vapourware .. So, yes, India is attempting to copy ...
Old AMCA Design-exists*
Le PDF: Reeeeee Indians copied F-22 Raptor
1618051375030.jpeg


Le new design of AMCA-exists*
Le PDF: Indians copied J-31 (as if it is an aircraft worth to copy).
1618051461750.jpeg
 
Last edited:
J-31
1618051732209.jpeg

1618051855856.jpeg

AMCA
1618051765006.jpeg

1618051885782.png



The tail wings, are different shape, the wings are different shape, the Rudders are of different shape, cockpit shape is different, but then this forum is becoming troll hub, an Indian posts anythings start your usual trolling that it is a copy, as inferior as imported parts assembled.

@krash pls take care of the useless troll posts above in the thread.
 
Yes - The AMCA is an Indian attempt to copy the J31 / F35 / KF-21 / X-2 Shinshin / TFX designs ....

All of the J31 / F35 / KF-21 / X-2 Shinshin / TFX have prototype / flying units with TFX being the last in that list, all India has is computer rendering pictures and vapourware .. So, yes, India is attempting to copy ...
tFX has a prototype where ?
 
Back
Top Bottom