Is Indian economy really better than Pakistan?

[SMC]

How much FDI Pakistan attracted till NoW ?? in 2017

all your arguments are on if ,And will and but nothing concrete on ground

I just posted about what's concrete on the ground. 10,000 MW in 2018, 2500 KM of motorway, inter-city transit for all major cities, 160 km/h upgrade for ML-1. What do you not understand about that?

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

I'd first suggest how to learn to use sarcasm (in your previous post) as a form of argument. First thing, at least try to make it sound like something the other person is saying or would say. You are neither here nor there.

I have one rule, you know. I don't play rigged games. We can talk on a more neutral platform, like twitter, not one where the only way forward when I respond to your snide remarks is my getting banned and your having your way.

If you wanna play the game the way it should be played, on a level playing field, let me know and I will PM you my twitter ID.

...if you're not used to playing a fair game, feel free to let it pass and I will leave you to your ignorance.

 

[N.Siddiqui]

How much FDI Pakistan attracted till NoW ?? in 2017

all your arguments are on if ,And will and but nothing concrete on ground

Pakistan FDI in the past was about 7-8 billion USD per year for a full 9 years...it is there as investment and contributing to the growth, not something which vanishes in thin air, one of reason for Pakistan doing relatively better.

This year FDI is low at 2.8 billion USD but increasing fast...you know why. Also it is a myth that FDI is the only criteria of investment if you look at the repatriation rate of profits from FDI, check India repatriation rate, almost same as FDI attracted.

 

[John Reese]

And India has 7 times the population. So why do you keep mentioning absolute figures over and over when we know we're talking per capita?

Is Pakistan has better per ca-pita than india Now ??Right now all institution like IMF and world bank Predicting same Talk me one It will be.

Pakistan FDI in the past was about 7-8 billion USD per year for a full 9 years...it is there as investment and contributing to the growth, not something which vanishes in thin air, one of reason for Pakistan doing relatively better.

Not its Not Its hardly 3 billion $ last year And past 6 year from 2010

https://tradingeconomics.com/pakistan/foreign-direct-investment

 

[N.Siddiqui]

Is Pakistan has better per ca-pita than india Now ??Right now all institution like IMF and world bank Predicting same Talk me one It will be.



Not its Not Its hardly 3 billion $ last year And past 6 year from 2010

https://tradingeconomics.com/pakistan/foreign-direct-investment

Was talking about Musharraf era, 5.1 billion USD in 2005, 5.4 billion USD in 2006...

Pakistan positioned itself as one of the four fastest growing economies in the Asian region during 2000-07 with its growth averaging 7.0 per cent per year for most of this period. As a result of strong economic growth, Pakistan succeeded in reducing poverty by one-half, creating almost 13 million jobs, halving the country's debt burden, raising foreign exchange reserves to a comfortable position and propping the country's exchange rate, restoring investors' confidence and most importantly, taking Pakistan out of the IMF Program.

How much FDI Pakistan attracted till NoW ?? in 2017

all your arguments are on if ,And will and but nothing concrete on ground

About 80% of the $55 billion of the Chinese money for CPEC is private investment while the rest is composed of soft loans to the government, according to Shanghai Business Review.

The Chinese soft loans for CPEC infrastructure projects carry an interest rate of just 1.6%, far lower than similar loans offered by the World Bank at rates of 3.8% or higher.

Pakistani economy is already beginning to reap the benefits of the current and expected investments as seen in the 5.2% GDP growth in the current fiscal year, the highest in 9 years.

The World Bank's Pakistan Development Update of May 2017 says that "Pakistan’s economy continues to grow strongly, emerging as one of the top performers in South Asia".

Rapidly expanding middle class and rising demand for consumer durables like vehicles and home appliances attest to the positive impact of CPEC. Consumer confidence in Pakistan has reached its highest level since 2008, according to Nielsen.

US-based consulting firm Deloitte and Touche estimates that China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) projects will create some 700,000 direct jobs during the period 2015–2030 and raise its GDP growth rate to 7.5%, adding 2.5 percentage points to the country's current GDP growth rate of 5%.

 

[SMC]

I have one rule, you know. I don't play rigged games. We can talk on a more neutral platform, like twitter, not one where the only way forward when I respond to your snide remarks is my getting banned and your having your way.

If you wanna play the game the way it should be played, on a level playing field, let me know and I will PM you my twitter ID.

...if you're not used to playing a fair game, feel free to let it pass and I will leave you to your ignorance.

This platform is far better than anything bharatis will ever come up with. Your forums (and public) have no diversity of opinion, and people get banned left and right for not agreeing with the current status quo.

You know what's worse? You are messing up the name of good Captain Jack Sparrow. At least he makes funny and interesting remarks to get himself out of trouble, or runs away waving his arms sideways if he can't. You? You just keep digging a deeper hole for yourself.

 

[SMC]

Is Pakistan has better per ca-pita than india Now ??Right now all institution like IMF and world bank Predicting same Talk me one It will be.

Are you intentionally being an idiot? This entire thread is about Bharat being just barely ahead in per capita terms.

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

This platform is far better than anything bharatis will ever come up with. Your forums (and public) have no diversity of opinion, and people get banned left and right for not agreeing with the current status quo.

You know what's worse? You are messing up the name of good Captain Jack Sparrow. At least he makes funny and interesting remarks to get himself out of trouble, or runs away waving his arms sideways if he can't. You? You just keep digging a deeper hole for yourself.

So Bhartis came up with Twitter? Thanks, I'll take that as a complement.

Anyways, I understand your compulsions. Au Revoir!

 

[SMC]

So Bhartis came up with Twitter? Thanks, I'll take that as a complement.

Anyways, I understand your compulsions. Au Revoir!

I am not talking about Twitter. I am talking about whatever platforms bharatis can come up with on the internet. Check Bharati forums for a start and then compare them to Pakistani forums. The utter bigotry, lack of opinion diversity, jerking each other off is quite telling.

 

[hydrabadi_arab]

Their imports are also 10x of Pakistan .. ?

Imports are about 7-8x of Pakistan while exports 13x.

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

I am not talking about Twitter. I am talking about whatever platforms bharatis can come up with on the internet.

You must be having comprehension issues. Why are we talking about Indian platforms in the first place? All I said was, if you REALLY wanna go forth, come to a 'more neutral' platform like Twitter. Read it again if you have trouble understanding. I understand Indian platforms won't be neutral anymore than PDF is. That's why I said Twitter. Twitter isn't an Indian platform.

Check Bharati forums for a start and then compare them to Pakistani forums. The utter bigotry, lack of opinion diversity, jerking each other off is quite telling.

1. I'm not on any Indian platform. I like diversity more than uniformity. That's why I even bother to come here. If I wanted to be among all people of my own kind, I would have stayed in India.

2. That holds true both ways. Even here, if you REALLY wanna look around. I'm not complaining though. It's the nature of the game and it goes both ways. I know how to take a blow. That's not my problem at all. I would stress, I'm not complaining.

All I'm saying is, if you feel you can really stand in the ring, come to a ring where the referee is neither yours not mine.

 

[hydrabadi_arab]

I am not talking about Twitter. I am talking about whatever platforms bharatis can come up with on the internet. Check Bharati forums for a start and then compare them to Pakistani forums. The utter bigotry, lack of opinion diversity, jerking each other off is quite telling.

Captain is a joke, behaving like a 16 years old while being 40 years old budha. Hit ignore button.

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

Captain is a joke, behaving like a 16 years old while being 40 years old budha. Hit ignore button.

Done.

 

[Great Sachin]

As per IMF 2016 GDP
India - 2,256,397 million
Pakistan - 284,185 million

India is 8 times bigger economy
Since India has 4 times bigger land area...

That makes Indian economy to 2 times of Pakistan economy....

Do you really wanna compare....
India's economy is adding more than Pakistan GDP every year....

Right...CPEC is mostly about power and infra sector projects in Pakistan..you can add SEZ's. For China it is mostly about energy corridors, shifting industries, reaching the warm waters of Arabina sea...in reality Pakistan with CPEC will attract much more investment than the expenditure on CPEC...as most infra projects do....

CPEC set to attract $150b investment
According to a Khaleej Times report, the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) is planned to shoot up for a $150 billion investment, and a new whole world of business that will make it the largest economic region, as details of its size and stature are unveiled this week.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1181580/megaproject-cpec-set-attract-150b-investment/

how much is loan out of it

 

[SMC]

As per IMF 2016 GDP
India - 2,256,397 million
Pakistan - 284,185 million

India is 8 times bigger economy
Since India has 4 times bigger land area...

That makes Indian economy to 2 times of Pakistan economy....

Do you really wanna compare....
India's economy is adding more than Pakistan GDP every year....

Now we're talking about Land area to mean per capita?

India GDP - 2.4 trillion
Canada GDP - 1.6 trillion

Indian economy is about 50% bigger than Canada. Since Canada land area is about 3 times that of India, that makes Indian economy about 4-5 times of Canadian economy.

Do you really wanna compare?