What's new

Is China the World’s New Colonial Power?

Solomon2

BANNED
Joined
Dec 12, 2008
Messages
19,475
Reaction score
-37
Country
United States
Location
United States
Untitled.png


Every weekday before dawn, a morning migration takes place near the desert on Africa’s southwestern coast. At 5:30 in the Namibian enclave Swakopmund, whose century-old buildings still bear the imprint of German colonization, solitary men in khaki uniforms emerge from houses and apartment complexes, the white reflective strips on their pants flashing as they walk briskly through the darkness. They are not African but Chinese. No one else is stirring in the Atlantic Coast town as the men converge on a tidy house on Libertina Amathila Avenue, the only one in the neighborhood with its lights ablaze.

Dylan Teng, a boyish 29-year-old engineer with a brush cut and wire-rimmed glasses, is among the last to arrive. Just as he has done nearly every day since landing in Namibia three and a half years ago, Teng joins the others in wolfing down a breakfast of steamed buns and rice porridge. He picks up a packed lunch prepared by a company chef and at precisely 6 o’clock, with stars still glimmering overhead, he boards a bus emblazoned with the letters C.G.N. — China General Nuclear, a state-owned behemoth that owns the biggest Chinese project in all of Africa.

An hour later, as the sun clears the horizon, the bus winds through a craggy moonscape and descends to the Husab Uranium Mine, a $4.6 billion investment that is the second-largest uranium mine in the world. Teng has made this trip nearly a thousand times, but Husab always seems like a mirage: a virtual city stretching seven miles across the desert floor, from two vast open pits being gouged out of the rocky substratum to a processing plant that, on the last working day of 2016, produced its first drums of U₃O₈, the yellowcake that can be used to generate nuclear power (and also to make weapons). “We had a big ceremony that day,” Teng says...

...in little more than 1,000 days, China’s reach has spread far beyond the uranium mine.

Just north of Swakopmund, a Chinese telemetry station sprouts from the desert floor, its radar dishes pointing skyward to track satellites and space missions. Twenty-five miles south, in Walvis Bay, a state-owned Chinese company is building an artificial peninsula the size of 40 baseball fields as part of a vast port expansion. Other Chinese projects nearby include new highways, a shopping mall, a granite factory and a $400 million fuel depot. Chinese trade flows through the port: shipping containers filled with cement, clothing and machinery coming in; tiles, minerals and — in some cases — illegal timber and endangered wildlife heading out to China. The activity is so frenzied that rumors of a proposed naval base in Walvis Bay, though vehemently denied by Chinese officials, do not strike locals as implausible...

...The workers and migrants carrying out China’s global vision are now so ubiquitous in Africa — as many as a million of them, according to one estimate — that when my wife and I wandered into a Hunanese restaurant in Addis, the red-faced workers devouring twice-cooked pork blurted out: “Ah, laowai laile!” “Foreigners have come!” It seemed rude to point out that they were foreigners, too...

...China provides no-strings financing that, unlike Western aid, is not conditional on such fine points as human rights, clean governance or fiscal restraint. “We welcomed China very much because, for the first time, it gave us a real alternative to a Western-driven agenda, whether it was South Africa or the Western world,” Calle Schlettwein, Namibia’s minister of finance, told me. “The Chinese say, ‘We want you to be masters of your own destiny, so tell us what you want.’ ” But they have their conditions, too, he says. “They want de facto total control over everything, so it’s difficult to bring about a situation that is truly beneficial.”

...The infrastructure is welcome, but as projects made possible by loans — financed by the Chinese — they have saddled the economy with debt and done little to alleviate the nearly 30 percent unemployment rate. Over the last few months, moreover, a series of scandals involving Chinese nationals — including tax evasion, money-laundering and poaching endangered wildlife — has soured locals on a foreign presence that can seem largely extractive: pulling uranium, timber, rhino horns and profits out the country without benefiting a population that, because of apartheid’s legacy, ranks among the most unequal economically in the world. In January, a Windhoek newspaper captured the rising sentiment with an illustration on its front page of a golden dragon devouring the Namibian flag. The headline: “Feeding Namibia to the Chinese.”

...Is China the savior for developing nations, the only world power investing in their future — or is this the dawn of a new colonial era?...

...Schlettwein, the finance minister, told me, “I don’t think those are real investments, but opportunities latched onto by Chinese enterprises without really adding value to the Namibian economy.”..

07mag-07namibia-t_CA6-master675.jpg

Building new storage facility at Walvis Bay

07namibia3-master675.jpg

The Chairman Mao Zedong High School, donated and built by China, in Otjomuise

07mag-07namibia-t_CA1-master675.jpg

A Chinese telemetry station for tracking satellites and space missions.

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/02/magazine/is-china-the-worlds-new-colonial-power.html?_r=0
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
To the extent that Chinese infrastructure projects in Africa and elsewhere meet existing/projected needs for the foreseeable future, they should be welcome. China has not taken anyone else's place forcefully - it is only filling a void left by rich countries and multilateral institutions such as WB/IMF/ADB. Fact of the matter is, without Chinese initiative, these projects would not be in existence. Japan is a distant second in the game of financing infrastructure projects and they have their constraints.

Having said that, there is definitely an element of over-investment, and the precise figure is yet to be ascertained. As and when each project will come on-stream, we will get a better picture as to which ones are truly beneficial and which are debt albatrosses around the neck.
 
. . .
Ask the Native Americans and the Indigenous Australians whether or not Chinese colonalism can be compared to Western colonialism, if you can find any of them left.

Western colonialism and slavery was enforced with violence and murder, completely different from China's method which does not involve violence.

I'd love to say the world has changed, but it hasn't. The Western world is still dropping multiple bombs every other minute on someone's head in the Middle East as we speak right now. They are still carving out their own spheres of influence in the Middle East using violence and murder... not much has changed.
 
Last edited:
. .
what China is doing is a new form of colonialism. China provides a service/financing to Africa and they send back natural resources.

question now is can Africa prosper or will they just be a renter economy? can Africa prosper under black leadership? look at South Africa... look at Zimbabwe, they are actually regressing than progressing.

China should just take over the leadership as well. this wouldn't be apartheid. China can just use it's leadership and wisdom to bring stability and prosperity to the average African.
 
.
Supa Powan colonization in Kashmir starts with killing of the innocent.

Chinese one in Africa starts with bilateral trade and infrastructure investment.

That's the reason China is not a Supa Powa.

Indian form of colonialism is a malignant type, reminds me of the Europeans

what China is doing is a new form of colonialism. china provides a service/financing to Africa and they send back natural resources.

question now is can Africa prosper or will they just be a rentier economy?? can Africa prosper under black leadership?? look at South Africa... look at Zimbabwe, they are actually regressing than progressing.

China should just take over the leadership as well. this wouldn't be apartheid. China can just use it's leadership and wisdom to bring stability and prosperity to the average African.

New form of colonialism? It's called infrastructure development. Colonialism is forced and brutal which your ancestors are more familiar with :lol:
 
. . .
Indian form of colonialism is a malignant type, reminds me of the Europeans



New form of colonialism? It's called infrastructure development. Colonialism is forced and brutal which your ancestors are more familiar with :lol:


let's not get into "your ancestors" since your ancestors did the same thing in Asian over it's long history.

I said China is providing services for natural resources. which is fine. my question is whether Africans can take advantage of this to prosper. Africa countries tend to fail because of corrupt leaders.


I love this documentary it shows the Chinese and Africa relationship
 
.
let's not get into "your ancestors" since your ancestors did the same thing in Asian over it's long history.

I said China is providing services for the natural resources. which is fine. my question is whether Africans can take advantage of this to prosper. Africa countries tend to fail because of corrupt leaders.

I beg to differ, Chinese certainly did not massacre other race. Yes the domination of Vietnam was a millenium timespan but no records exists of Chinese mass murdering Viets. What Europeans did was robbing resources in Africa, turn Africans into slaves, travel as far as America and occupy that land, massacre Native Americans, did the same with Australia, turn South East Asia in Western colonies. Forced unequal treaties to many countries. We have recorded proof that when China first traveled to Africa and the couple of times that followed we came there in peace and for trade.

Yes you did say providing services for resources, it's called infrastructure investments not new form of colonialism.
What you are suggesting is colonialism when you said China should be taking over their governments. Perhaps it is America that should relinquish her power to China. Let us teach you Chinese wisdom how to behave as a rational power instead of bombing countries day and night. :lol:
 
. .
Traditional forms of 'colonialism' is what you are talking about. But what China is doing is called 'economic colonialism' where the superior economy and financial institutions of one country dominates one ore more lesser entities. Infrastructure development is a necessary component of that exploitation. Simply put, the more developed the subordinate, the more wealth can be transferred to the superior country.

China isn't the only country doing overseas investments. You don't hear people saying Japan is the new type of colonialist lol. When China does it we are called the colonialist :lol: , I expected more intelligence from you old man, what a disappointment :o:
 
.
View attachment 394343

Every weekday before dawn, a morning migration takes place near the desert on Africa’s southwestern coast. At 5:30 in the Namibian enclave Swakopmund, whose century-old buildings still bear the imprint of German colonization, solitary men in khaki uniforms emerge from houses and apartment complexes, the white reflective strips on their pants flashing as they walk briskly through the darkness. They are not African but Chinese. No one else is stirring in the Atlantic Coast town as the men converge on a tidy house on Libertina Amathila Avenue, the only one in the neighborhood with its lights ablaze.

Dylan Teng, a boyish 29-year-old engineer with a brush cut and wire-rimmed glasses, is among the last to arrive. Just as he has done nearly every day since landing in Namibia three and a half years ago, Teng joins the others in wolfing down a breakfast of steamed buns and rice porridge. He picks up a packed lunch prepared by a company chef and at precisely 6 o’clock, with stars still glimmering overhead, he boards a bus emblazoned with the letters C.G.N. — China General Nuclear, a state-owned behemoth that owns the biggest Chinese project in all of Africa.

An hour later, as the sun clears the horizon, the bus winds through a craggy moonscape and descends to the Husab Uranium Mine, a $4.6 billion investment that is the second-largest uranium mine in the world. Teng has made this trip nearly a thousand times, but Husab always seems like a mirage: a virtual city stretching seven miles across the desert floor, from two vast open pits being gouged out of the rocky substratum to a processing plant that, on the last working day of 2016, produced its first drums of U₃O₈, the yellowcake that can be used to generate nuclear power (and also to make weapons). “We had a big ceremony that day,” Teng says...

...in little more than 1,000 days, China’s reach has spread far beyond the uranium mine.

Just north of Swakopmund, a Chinese telemetry station sprouts from the desert floor, its radar dishes pointing skyward to track satellites and space missions. Twenty-five miles south, in Walvis Bay, a state-owned Chinese company is building an artificial peninsula the size of 40 baseball fields as part of a vast port expansion. Other Chinese projects nearby include new highways, a shopping mall, a granite factory and a $400 million fuel depot. Chinese trade flows through the port: shipping containers filled with cement, clothing and machinery coming in; tiles, minerals and — in some cases — illegal timber and endangered wildlife heading out to China. The activity is so frenzied that rumors of a proposed naval base in Walvis Bay, though vehemently denied by Chinese officials, do not strike locals as implausible...

...The workers and migrants carrying out China’s global vision are now so ubiquitous in Africa — as many as a million of them, according to one estimate — that when my wife and I wandered into a Hunanese restaurant in Addis, the red-faced workers devouring twice-cooked pork blurted out: “Ah, laowai laile!” “Foreigners have come!” It seemed rude to point out that they were foreigners, too...

...China provides no-strings financing that, unlike Western aid, is not conditional on such fine points as human rights, clean governance or fiscal restraint. “We welcomed China very much because, for the first time, it gave us a real alternative to a Western-driven agenda, whether it was South Africa or the Western world,” Calle Schlettwein, Namibia’s minister of finance, told me. “The Chinese say, ‘We want you to be masters of your own destiny, so tell us what you want.’ ” But they have their conditions, too, he says. “They want de facto total control over everything, so it’s difficult to bring about a situation that is truly beneficial.”

...The infrastructure is welcome, but as projects made possible by loans — financed by the Chinese — they have saddled the economy with debt and done little to alleviate the nearly 30 percent unemployment rate. Over the last few months, moreover, a series of scandals involving Chinese nationals — including tax evasion, money-laundering and poaching endangered wildlife — has soured locals on a foreign presence that can seem largely extractive: pulling uranium, timber, rhino horns and profits out the country without benefiting a population that, because of apartheid’s legacy, ranks among the most unequal economically in the world. In January, a Windhoek newspaper captured the rising sentiment with an illustration on its front page of a golden dragon devouring the Namibian flag. The headline: “Feeding Namibia to the Chinese.”

...Is China the savior for developing nations, the only world power investing in their future — or is this the dawn of a new colonial era?...

...Schlettwein, the finance minister, told me, “I don’t think those are real investments, but opportunities latched onto by Chinese enterprises without really adding value to the Namibian economy.”..

View attachment 394342
Building new storage facility at Walvis Bay

View attachment 394340
The Chairman Mao Zedong High School, donated and built by China, in Otjomuise

View attachment 394341
A Chinese telemetry station for tracking satellites and space missions.
Paying money for goods is colonialism? Building schools, hospitals, infrastructure in Africa is colonialism? Majority of Africans disagree with you. Maybe you're disappointed China is not stealing resources like Europeans. I'm disappointed too.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom