Is Baluchistan more strategically significant than Afghanistan?

[SMC]

If pak Govt. has any proof of Indian involvement they would have show it to whole world infront of the media like India has done.

Its all Propaganda against india to keep pak people happy that outside forces are conspiring against them.

Pls. dont tell us My uncle told me Indians are involved or My Granny told me Israelis are involved stories.

Dude, please go post this simplistic argument on BR and co. These arguments are simplistic and naive to the order I cannot even begin to explain.

---------- Post added at 05:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:02 PM ----------

Also, on top of this, the proof of indian involvement have been provided to the relevant states several times now.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

lol,my aunt is frm kashmir,and my father have served few years in kashmir.they also say pak is spreading terror in kashmir.terrorist come frm pak and kill the innocent ones.even they dont care whether a muslim or hindu is being killed.he also says condition is improving day by day but certain events always happen.this is a big proofffffffffffffff

Just 1 thing?
Why u keep 750 000 force in kashmir?
Why Kashmiris are protesting daily?
Were 100000 kashmiris who have died in 63 years all Pakistani Mujahedeen?
Do Kashmiris call themselves indian?
Why Kashmiri leader call themselves Pakistani?
Why kashmiris want to join Pakistan?
Why they burn indian flags?
WHY WHY WHY??????????
And if ur compairing Balouchistan with Kashmir ur sadly mistaken.......
I myself belong from Mari tribe a strict balouch tribe and let me tell u 100000% balouch elders voted to join PakistanBUT i dont have to prove my loyality on some forum..... and the BLA are nothing more then outlawed, offended criminals being paid and trained by terrorists in Kabul........Ferari camps in past were run with outside help.Pak army f..ked them up.and suddenly after decades recently this tide of BLA activities has risen from the dead..........and its not a secret who trains and arms themmmmm and finances there terrorist activities .funny thing is even there leadership is boasting of living and recieving help from a bastard terrorist agency.
PAKISTAN ZINDABAD...............The edge of Balouch sword for those who terrorise my MOTHERLAND.

 

[James007]

Dude, please go post this simplistic argument on BR and co. These arguments are simplistic and naive to the order I cannot even begin to explain.

---------- Post added at 05:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:02 PM ----------

Also, on top of this, the proof of indian involvement have been provided to the relevant states several times now.

which relevant states,no relevant states shown ever any kind of proof to india.i think those proof might have lost due to mishandling of those relevant states

 

[Windjammer]

i didnt know that india can do so,but u r highlighting india.i never expected that india can do so

At minute level, it's always Indian members ranting the Baluchistan issue and for them the threshold is Aaj tak.
Hence the world moves .

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Please sir, do not insult me by posting a couple of pictures of doctor's doing normal check up as some sort of paramount help to all afghanis. I appreciate the good work but there was no need to bring that here. Pakistan has been helping them for a very long time.

Here is a hospital especially for Afghani's in Quetta where they have been receiving medical help for the last 30 years.

Some of the pictures show extreme physical deformations/diseases, view with caution.

Malalai Hospital of RAWA Serves Afghans in Pakistan (photos)

The quote you gave from an Afghani source are NA officials, they are expected to go against Pakistan after what has happened to them.

Where was India's help when you friends, the Soviets were bombing innocent Afghanis.

Do tell him about 4 million afghans living as refugees in Pakistan and rest who now have Pakistan ID and call themselves Pakistani instead of afghanis.

 

[SMC]

which relevant states,no relevant states shown ever any kind of proof to india.i think those proof might have lost due to mishandling of those relevant states

If you start to talk like a grown up I might show you respect. The relevant states of Afghan gov, US Gov, indian gov. Musharraf himself mentioned several times about giving proof to these states. Now if you're going to have your head in the sand and only believe what is told by the western and indian media then I am afraid you're just another indian teenager in whose mind the world is very simple.

 

[James007]

wait and watch you will be chased out of 'afgh' very soon

i will wait,india has finally done this under u.s umbrella.india wil l work there with or without u.s.also u.s is not going anywhere,u cant make afgh as ur proxy sorry this hurts a lot but its true

 

[thebrownguy]

India has a record of supporting terrorists against Pakistan and by now we know their tactics quite well.

Let me tell you indians that you wil fail and we will galdly dispurse your burnt up ashes down your dirty and polluted river ganga

Please don't get religion into this.

 

[James007]

If you start to talk like a grown up I might show you respect. The relevant states of Afghan gov, US Gov, indian gov. Musharraf himself mentioned several times about giving proof to these states. Now if you're going to have your head in the sand and only believe what is told by the western and indian media then I am afraid you're just another indian teenager in whose mind the world is very simple.

dude the basic thing is that ,i never heard that any proof is given to india,it doesnt make result whether mush mentioned or not.even u r talking abt u.s.u.s also have rejected that there is no indian involvement in afgh-pak region.i think u can understand wat i say.this is the statement u will get frm every indian.m not a teenager,i m near to complete my engg

 

[James007]

At minute level, it's always Indian members ranting the Baluchistan issue and for them the threshold is Aaj tak.
Hence the world moves .

we don't give shyt to aaj tak,so the world doesnt move like this

 

[Dr.Evil]

Dude, please go post this simplistic argument on BR and co. These arguments are simplistic and naive to the order I cannot even begin to explain.

---------- Post added at 05:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:02 PM ----------

Also, on top of this, the proof of indian involvement have been provided to the relevant states several times now.

Is it the secret given the foreign office of Pakistan.

Foreign Secretary and Foreign Minister of pak keeps on repeating the same mantra - We have the proof, we will share at the correct time.

Evidence jama karke Achar Bana Rahe hain Foreign office mein.

 

[James007]

India has a record of supporting terrorists against Pakistan and by now we know their tactics quite well.

Let me tell you indians that you wil fail and we will galdly dispurse your burnt up ashes down your dirty and polluted river ganga

let the ganga to come to pak,it will definately wash ur mind,this is wat we can do.

 

[pakdefender]

i will wait,india has finally done this under u.s umbrella.india wil l work there with or without u.s.also u.s is not going anywhere,u cant make afgh as ur proxy sorry this hurts a lot but its true

you are hiding under the balls of the americans and you have not brought anything advantagous to the US so why would they continue to bleed for india's objectives in Afghanistan ?!?

The Yanks have NOW realized this that you ( indians ) have nothing to offer to them in strategic terms as far as afghanistan is concerend.

The main concern of the yanks at the moment is the insurgency in Afghanistan and india has done nothing ( other than blame Pakistan ) in this regrard so the US is not foolish that they will continue to bleed for india when india does not bring anything meaningfull to help them!

All india does is blame Pakistan ... which by now has become boring to listen to , even for the Americans.

Your time will be up when the yanks leave , even the cows in india know this.

 

[SMC]

dude the basic thing is that ,i never heard that any proof is given to india,it doesnt make result whether mush mentioned or not.even u r talking abt u.s.u.s also have rejected that there is no indian involvement in afgh-pak region.i think u can understand wat i say.this is the statement u will get frm every indian.m not a teenager,i m near to complete my engg

Well it seems your brain has not matured too much considering the types of arguments you're putting forward, which are very very simplistic in nature. Whether or not you heard of India being provided proof is irrelevant as is US rejecting proof. First is irrelevant on the grounds that it will hurt indian interests deeply if they even accept that they were provided proof. Secondly, again it will hurt US interests if they accept Indian involvement as it will give Pakistan an upper hand in the relationship between US and Pakistan and will give Pakistan more leverage over the US.

More or less, fact is even if you ignore this, a Balochi separatist leader pretty much admitted indian support. That was mentioned in my first post in this topic.

 

[SMC]

Is it the secret given the foreign office of Pakistan.

Foreign Secretary and Foreign Minister of pak keeps on repeating the same mantra - We have the proof, we will share at the correct time.

Evidence jama karke Achar Bana Rahe hain Foreign office mein.

How do you know they have not given proof to india or others? India or others will not necessarily announce they have gotten proof, especially if it works against their interests. In fact Musharraf and even current government has said several times they have provided proof to indian, US, afghan governments.