Is Baluchistan more strategically significant than Afghanistan?

[Windjammer]

u.s just need a propaganda to involve in baluchistan

And India is always willing to play the drama queen role.

 

[SMC]

The indian involvement in Balochistan is more than proven. I have talked about this before. A Balochi separatist in an interview was asked if he was getting support from India, he paused for 5 seconds and then said we will take support from anyone. That is more than enough proof for indian support. And yes several indians have tried to spin this one by looking at this in a very narrow way. Won't work with me.

 

[Gin ka Pakistan]

So many non Baluch are force to leave Baluchistan , their property has lost value as no one wants to buy it.
A fund should be created to help people who are being forced to leave Baluchistan.

Baluch have no high tech Teachers Doctors and Engineers as their Sardars want no education for their people so it will always be outsiders who will come for their Oil and Gas , even if they want independence.

When its come to women right Baluch are as backwards as Taliban.

 

[James007]

And India is always willing to play the drama queen role.

i didnt know that india can do so,but u r highlighting india.i never expected that india can do so

 

[Dr.Evil]

If pak Govt. has any proof of Indian involvement they would have show it to whole world infront of the media like India has done.

Its all Propaganda against india to keep pak people happy that outside forces are conspiring against them.

Pls. dont tell us My uncle told me Indians are involved or My Granny told me Israelis are involved stories.

 

[pakdefender]

The indian involvement in Balochistan is more than proven. I have talked about this before. A Balochi separatist in an interview was asked if he was getting support from India, he paused for 5 seconds and then said we will take support from anyone. That is more than enough proof for indian support. And yes several indians have tried to spin this one by looking at this in a very narrow way. Won't work with me.

India is trying to pull a 'Mukhti Bani' on Pakistan again , we must not let it happen.

 

[LCA Tejas]

India is trying to pull a 'Mukhti Bani' on Pakistan again , we must not let it happen.

 

[pakdefender]

India has a record of supporting terrorists against Pakistan and by now we know their tactics quite well.

Let me tell you indians that you wil fail and we will galdly dispurse your burnt up ashes down your dirty and polluted river ganga

 

[T-Faz]

Afghanistan is different from Balochistan.Balochistan is Pak territory,Afghanistan is not.So,Indian presence in Afghanistan is not your problem.I would like to clarify what i mean by Indian presence in Afghanistan,by showing u a quote from the source that u only quoted to me.---







U will find other pictures as well.Feel free to go through them.All of them are from the source that u only quoted to me.

So far as the Afghan mentality is concerned,I would like to quote again from the source that u only provided me....



And yes,the report does talk about "India's allies" who think RAW has presence in Afghanistan.I would very much like to know which allies are we actually talking about here.

Regarding your second source,which talks about a RAW agent being caught in Balochistan,even the source says that it is an allegation or a claim.It is not like the pak officials were actually showing some proof.There is a difference between allegation and proof.U need to understand that.

Please sir, do not insult me by posting a couple of pictures of doctor's doing normal check up as some sort of paramount help to all afghanis. I appreciate the good work but there was no need to bring that here. Pakistan has been helping them for a very long time.

Here is a hospital especially for Afghani's in Quetta where they have been receiving medical help for the last 30 years.

Some of the pictures show extreme physical deformations/diseases, view with caution.

Malalai Hospital of RAWA Serves Afghans in Pakistan (photos)

The quote you gave from an Afghani source are NA officials, they are expected to go against Pakistan after what has happened to them.

Where was India's help when you friends, the Soviets were bombing innocent Afghanis.

 

[James007]

India is trying to pull a 'Mukhti Bani' on Pakistan again , we must not let it happen.

we dont play the role of u.s,our interst is an afgh

 

[Bushy]

The indian involvement in Balochistan is more than proven. I have talked about this before. A Balochi separatist in an interview was asked if he was getting support from India, he paused for 5 seconds and then said we will take support from anyone. That is more than enough proof for indian support. And yes several indians have tried to spin this one by looking at this in a very narrow way. Won't work with me.

It was Brahamdagh Bugti and he never said he was taking support from the RAW. All he said was he will take support from wherever it comes, not only specifically the RAW or the CIA.

^^ Does it not clearly prove that he doesn't have India's support yet?

However, the interviewer did try his best to put the name of the RAW and the CIA into Bugti's mouth, but that too didn't work.

It is just the age old psyche of average Zaid type fanatic who thinks whoever is against Pakistan, is a RAW agent. By these measures, George W Bush must have been a Havildar in RAW.

 

[T-Faz]

If pak Govt. has any proof of Indian involvement they would have show it to whole world infront of the media like India has done.

Its all Propaganda against india to keep pak people happy that outside forces are conspiring against them.

Pls. dont tell us My uncle told me Indians are involved or My Granny told me Israelis are involved stories.

An American war veteran wrote this.

Pakistan, America’s primary ally, feels it is fighting a surrogate war against India and Israel, who they believe are arming terrorists in Afghanistan to attack Pakistan. Pakistan, as the only Islamic nuclear power, feels it has been targeted for dismemberment by other US allies, although Pakistan is steadfastly aligned with the United States.

Daily terrorist attacks across Pakistan lend credence to this as does the “special relationship” India has with Karzai who has allowed Indian “security personnel” to operate openly in Afghanistan. The US has been silent on this because of Israeli involvement with India and covert terrorist attacks against Iran that Israel is helping stage from neighboring Balochistan.

GORDON DUFF: AFGHANISTAN AT A CROSSROADS : Veterans Today

 

[Windjammer]

There is a difference between oppression as in IOK and supporting terrorism as in Balochistan, which no doubt will be eliminated.
For those living in oblivion, ask any one with some military knowledge, he will enlighten you with the status and capability of the Baloch Regiment in Pakistan Army, on the other hand, there are just a bunch of opportunists called BLA, supported by none other than India, are running helter skelter to bewilderment of their masters across the border.
As for those accusing Pakistan for all the troubles in IOK, well if those 90,000 odd graves belong to infiltrators, then the half million Indian Army is surely cumbersome in their duties.

 

[SMC]

It was Brahamdagh Bugti and he never said he was taking support from the RAW. All he said was he will take support from wherever it comes, not only specifically the RAW or the CIA.

^^ Does it not clearly prove that he doesn't have India's support yet?

However, the interviewer did try his best to put the name of the RAW and the CIA into Bugti's mouth, but that too didn't work.

It is just the age old psyche of average Zaid type fanatic who thinks whoever is against Pakistan, is a RAW agent. By these measures, George W Bush must have been a Havildar in RAW.

Are you trying to read my mind? I never said it was Bramdagh Bugti. It was a different person and I remember his last name was something like Marri.

 

[pakdefender]

we dont play the role of u.s,our interst is an afgh

wait and watch you will be chased out of 'afgh' very soon