IOK: India Killing civilians in protest today in Kashmir

[Salik]

Kashmir unlike Balochistan or Punjab or Sind was entirely princely state. Name me one area of Kashmir that was under British direct control? Bahawalpur was not part of Punjab and Seraiki was the dominant language. Please learn before posting like a fool, tarek sahab.

Got no clue what you are smoking there dude. Kashmir massacres were going on in 1930's. His poems that you mentioned came respectively in 1905 and 1910. When he wrote saray jahan say accha, he was young and inexperienced, his views dramatically changed just 5 years later when he wrote cheen o Arab Hamara ye Hindustan hamara (Central Asia is ours, Arabia is ours, Subcontinent is ours). A man who became a fierce supporter of protection of Muslim lands throughout the world will ignore a Muslim majority state of Kashmir? You make no sense.

Your posts are illogical, no base, and childish. Kindly read proper history before posting crap and wasting bandwidth.

Kashmir was entirely princely state, Baluchistan was almost entirely princely state. If Allamah Iqbal could mention Baluchistan, he could have also mentioned Kashmir, which is not the case. The fact is, he skipped Kashmir from his vision.

Here's is the map. Please check the princely state percentage of Baluchistan and also N.W.F.P.

Secondly, your own provided link says:

"A leading political activist Dr. Mumtaz Hassan noted one day when he was sitting with Iqbal and discussing political struggle in Kashmir, the poet mentioned about a Persian poem ‘Saqi Nama’ in Payam-e-Mashriq, which he had written in Nishat Bagh in Kashmir (1920)."

So Allamah Iqbal's literary work on Kashmir had started before 1920. His formal speeches might have started later. More importantly his work on Kashmir was in pretext of Muslims as ummah. When he tilted towards nationalism and talked about division of British India, he skipped Kashmir. Not only he skipped Kashmir but also other Muslim majority states like Hyderabad and Bengal.

 

[American Pakistani]

Kashmir was entirely princely state, Baluchistan was almost entirely princely state. If Allamah Iqbal could mention Baluchistan, he could have also mentioned Kashmir, which is not the case. The fact is, he skipped Kashmir from his vision.

Here's is the map. Please check the princely state percentage of Baluchistan and also N.W.F.P.

Secondly, your own provided link says:

"A leading political activist Dr. Mumtaz Hassan noted one day when he was sitting with Iqbal and discussing political struggle in Kashmir, the poet mentioned about a Persian poem ‘Saqi Nama’ in Payam-e-Mashriq, which he had written in Nishat Bagh in Kashmir (1920)."

So Allamah Iqbal's literary work on Kashmir had started before 1920. His formal speeches might have started later. More importantly his work on Kashmir was in pretext of Muslims as ummah. When he tilted towards nationalism and talked about division of British India, he skipped Kashmir. Not only he skipped Kashmir but also other Muslim majority states like Hyderabad and Bengal.

Did you learn history in tarek fateh's house? Kashmir was entirely princely state, same as Bahawalpur was or Kalat was. Allama Iqbal mentioned the provinces that were ruled by outsider colonial power i.e. British. Kashmir, Kalat, Bahawalpur, Swat were ruled by local rulers. Kashmir is comparable to Kalat or Bahawalpur, not Balochistan. Your mixing up of apples with oranges and calling Red color a Green color shows level of your iq and your knowledge you gathered from the likes of tarek and indian media.

About the link you quoted, you just validated my last post. Where I tried to educate your nonsense that Allama Iqbal used to say "saray jahan say accha". I explained you already that when he wrote that poem it was the year of 1904 when uprising against British was at peak and Iqbal was a young inexperienced man from British India. His views start changing soon after that and in late 1900's he wrote "Tarana e milli" which unites Muslims. There after like your quotes says about 1920's on Kashmir and by 1930's Iqbal was very much involved in Kashmir. And lol at your knowledge, Hyderabad was again an entirely princely state of Hindu majority not Muslim and was not linked with proposed independent homeland in North west, whereas Bengal too was not linked with the proposed independent homeland in the Northwest.