What's new

Indus Basin - Pakistan

Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
20,487
Reaction score
182
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Before we look at the history of Pakistan we have to look at the land of Pakistan. That is the geographic space that Pakistan occupies. A land goes to define the people, the history, culture, religion and even economy of countries.

If in 1947 only East Bengal had voted for Pakistan then today that Pakistan would have followed an entirely differant trajectory. The conomy, the peoples , the culture, post 1947 history, the problems and the strengths would be entirely differant. In fact most of you would not be able to recognize this 'Pakistan' with Dhaka as it's capital.

It is safe to say that without land there can be no state and that the land will go a long way in defining that country including it's history. So let us look at the 'tandoor' that made us who we are today. Whether we are native or we are a mix of outside influences our geography has played it's role in the making of Pakistan.

So let us begin by looking at the making of the Indus Basin. Long time ago, about 55 million years the Indian Plate collided with the Eurasian plate. The point where it collided pushed up the mountain rim around South Asia including the Himalalyas. That movement continues even today which explains the earthquakes we still get in Pakistan. The point where both the Indian plate and Eurasian plate scrape against each other are known as the fault line.

Himalaya-formation.gif


Map 2. The fault line running through Pakistan adjacent to which most earhquakes are centred as both the Indian plate Eurasian plates grind.

upload_2015-4-18_23-28-4.jpeg



As a interesting observation you the tectonic fault line between Eurasia and India mirrors something else. The line runs proximate with Khyber Pak, Balochistan borders with Punjab, Sindh. The line roughly defines the split between Iranian language group of Pashto, Baloch and the Indic languages Punjabi, Sindhi. This also happens to define the plains of Punjab, Sindh and the hilly or high plateaux of the westerly Baloch highlands and hills of Khyber Pak. A coincidence but nevertheless interesting overlap of plate tectonics, geography, languages and peoples. In a sense this Pakistan sits bang on the meeeting point of South and Central Asia. In fact it bridges both worlds in geography, ethnic groups, languages and as we will see history as it's central position would mean it would recieving tow differant sets of influences.

Map 3 Physical Map of Pakistan. Please compare with above map.

pakphysical.jpg


Map 4 Language Map. With the Iranic and Indic divide running along the sale fault line.

4.png


I am sure you can see the coincidence of Maps 2, 3 and 4. Eurasian or Central Asian meet the Indic world around the middle of Pakistan. Pakistan sits on between both worlds Central and South Asian. This location would have profound effect on our history over the centuries as in between being independant we would fall victim to either invaders from the west [ Persia/Greeks/Central Asia ] which was very often or occasionally from the east [ India/British] from begining of our recorded history. The final product of this dance played out in Indus Basin over countless millenia is todays Pakistan. This is how you became who you are today.

Now let us look exactly at what Indus Basin is. To begin with we have to define 'basin' which in geographic terms means "A river drainage basin is an area drained by a river and all of its tributaries". So when we say Indus Basin we mean all the area within which rainfall collects in drains into one river. So Indus Basin is the area where all rainfall eventually flows into Indus River and finally drains into the Arabian Sea.

Map 5 Indus Basin

map-of-the-indus-basin-source-us-senate-report.jpg


Map 6 Indus Basin Map 7

6a01053614d678970c0133f4744c73970b-pi


Maps 5 and 6 show clearly the extent of the Indus Basin. Map 7 is a satelite image of Pakistan. The green of the irrigated area feeding off the Indus irrigation system is clearly visible. Indus Basin in Pakistan is clearly divided from India by the huge Thar Desert on the right of the green strip of the indus irrigated zone.

It is however important to note that small strip of Indus Basin extends into Afganistan ( Map 5 ) and in fact Kabul falls within Indus basin as that part of Afghanistan drains into Kabul River which flows into Pakistan and meets Indus River near Attock.

Furthermore part of Tibet in China also falls within the indus Basin, so does Indian Occupied Kashmir and Indian Punjab. Small portion of Rajasthan also are within the basin. However Pakistan is central to the basin. 95% of Pakistan's population live within the Indus Basin whereas it is nominal in Afganistan, China, India.

I will finish this off this in next post but can people not post anything as it will cause a break in my presentation. I am sure you can wait a bit. Thank you.
 
.
Another well written article sir, your posts are very enlightening. :cheers:

From what I have read, the Indus river is one of the major "cradles of civilization" in the world.

For China our equivalent is the Yellow river, it is said that our ancestors/civilization originated from there.

I wonder if there was much contact between the IVC and Ancient China during those times?
 
.
8 above I have Continued from Post #1

Map 8 - Divide between Indus Basin and India - The sky blue line the bottom shows the Rann of Kutch which is salt marsh or dry salty scrubland. The green line shows Thar Desert which ranges from absolute desert to semi arid desert and at places is upto 200 miles wide. The Thar Desert acts as a major divide between Indus Basin and India. The satelite map below shows the physical geography nicely.

IHf7MUW.jpg


On the map 8 above I have marked various points along Pak India border which are numbered. I will show some these points close up below so you can appreciate why this desert acts as a divide. Most of it is absolute desert and sand like Sahara Desert. While there are water sources but these are far and distant and in the past would have acted as a major barrier. THe border is NOT artificial. It follows natural divider - the desert.

Map 9 - Rann 1
uluyHGu.jpg


Map 10 - Thar 1
I0zg77a.jpg


Map 11 Thar 2

zI6bSao.jpg


Map 12 Thar 9
et1ubg2.jpg


Map 13 Thar Desert marked red.

Y1wdlYC.jpg


As you can see Thar desert marked red Map 13 effectively partitions off the Indus Basin from India. The Indus River with the habitable green strip is entirely separated from rest of South Asia. In effect the Indus Basin is a sub region of South Asia like Iberia or Scandanavia are in Europe. Just like Scandanavia or Iberia can have separate existance yet be part Europe Indus Basin has to be looked at in the same way. These are satelite images and the basin is not a subjective creations but represents physical geography on the ground.

Only north in the Punjab region above Marker Thar 9 is there a bridge between the Indus Basin and rest of South Asia. The only thing to get partitioned 'artifically' in 1947 was the zone above Thar 9 in Punjab. It would be worth noting though that before 1870s even this bridge would have been narrower as Thar Desert would have extended more north. If you look at Map 12 Thar 9 you can see what modern irrigation can do. On the Pak and Indian side of the border irrigation has only left 4 to 5 mile strip of semi desert. Before 1870s when the British started massive irrigation systems the area north of Thar 9 would have been similar semi desert. Thus the Punjab 'bridge' would have been narrower. Of course as we all know in 1947 it was this 'bridge' that was shut off to create a border.

I think this amply shows that there is nothing artificial about most of Pak India boder. From the wastes of Rann of Kutch on the Arabian Sea to the Himalayas in a straight line is 700 miles approx. Of that most of it 550 miles is Thar Desert, semi to arid. Only 150 miles in the final portion of the border is not natural division.

I think this covers the indus Basin as in definition and we can now begin with it's history which will start from dawn of time to 1947. I want Pakistani's to further explore the concept of the Indus Basin so that they are able to explain to others in a accurate, logical fact based way. They must let geography do the talking. You can explore Google Maps and traverse the border from Rann of Kutch on the Arabian Sea and move north and as you zoom in you will just see miles and miles of sand and dunes. Bear in mind it goes from pure sand to scrubland, semi to semi desert to slowly merge into rainfed zones in India.

Thar Desert

images


images
 
Last edited:
.
This shows that contrary to what is commonly assumed that a artificial line divides Pak and India in fact for most of the 700 miles ( 550 miles ) there is either salt plain, salty marsh of the Rann of Kutch in the south and the vast expense of the Thar Desert. This effectively acts as divider between the Indus Basin of Pakistan and rest of South Asia/India. The satelite map 13 shows the Thar Desert. I think it clearly shows that the Indus Basin is a natural and distinct sub unit from India.

Great Rann of Kutch - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Thar Desert - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The purpose of this is to show Pakistani's that their physical geography is indeed DISTINCT from India. They should not fall for words like ARTIFICAL or even PARTITION. I will give a simple logical argument why they should not use language like that later. But for now for please digest the contents of this thread. Understand what the Indus Basin is and what the boundaries are. Also understand the Indus Basin's central role in sustaining our Pakistan. Always remember this dictum. What Nile is to Egypt Indus is to Pakistan

Thar Desert

GD-Thar-Desert-India.jpg



RJ_NH_28-3-Thar_desert-20131011.jpg


stock-photo-thar-desert-india-april-beduin-driver-of-the-camel-all-over-the-thar-desert-in-rajasthan-173765660.jpg

Rann of Kutch - Dry Salt

1403517606.kutch_Rann_white_desert_2.jpg


AVN7_RANN_16216f.jpg


Salty Marsh

3025421684ef18d6332323.jpg
 
Last edited:
. .
Back
Top Bottom