Until 2024 I hope government take a good effort to be very prudent in managing the economy, unnecessary foreign loan like for defense acquisition should be slashed.
I suggest Fighter jet acquisition should be delayed and we should wait for KFX/IFX program to complete its development inshaAllah. MALE UCAV acqusition also should be halted and better wait our own MALE UCAV program to complete its development in 2025 inshaAllah.
Acquisition coming from local defense industry should be prioritized and also increase R&D budget for several program that could improve our industrialization like N 245 and KFX/IFX.
New capital city construction should be halted and better the money is disbursed to pay government debt to state owned construction companies and also state owned companies like Pertamina and PLN so they can get more loan to invest new projects.
High way road program in Sumatra should be prioritized and completed in 2024. This program are essential to propel our economy by making our industry in Sumatra competitive so that we can speed up the overall economy growth while reducing our debt to equity ratio in the process.
AlhamduliLLAH good decision is made by President, Mindef and Bappenas officials, better support KFX/IFX program and MALE UCAV program and wait until mass production phase is started in 2026 inshaAllah for both program.
This is how to make the acquisition effecient and effective for both Indonesian AirForce and Indonesian economy by not buying Rafale until 2024 and wait for indigenous program instead.
Positive effects :
1.
Air Force
Improve capability since KF 21/IFX is 4.5 generation fighter and upgradable to 5 generation fighters
Possible more fighters are acquired due to cheaper price of KF 21/IFX for both acquisition (65 million USD) and maintenance cost
Communality in maintenance and operation by not operate too many of fighter type thus create less complexity and also lower maintenance and operation cost since PTDI is part of the OEM.
Increase deterrence by :
Decrease dependency on foreign country in the acquisition. local Upgrade and Future Refurbished program by local industry.
2.
Indonesia local defense industry
Improving knowledge, technology and human resource base, boosting production and Indonesian Aerospace brand name.
Giving opportunity for other related Aerospace related company like InfoGlobal, PT LEN Industry, PT Nusantara Turbin to contribute on the program and thus giving them chance to grow in fighter jet components market.
3.
Indonesian economy
Current situation: Lower Debt to equity ratio by not adding unnecessary foreign loan. Giving the government better image in the perception of Rating agency like Fitch rating due to its prudent economic policy
After KF 21/IFX reach mass production inshaAllah: local production, possibility to grow avionics and other aerospace related industries, much cheaper than Rafale and F 15 EX.
Effective and efficient spending
Retain more foreign exchange, hence strengthen currency
4.
Indonesian brand image
Important to boost Indonesian hightech products like aircraft, electronics, sofware, and others image in the perception of both domestic and foreign market.
5.
Geopolitics
Developing and making 5 generation fighter will increase the global leaders perception toward Indonesia
6.
Mental Revolution
Giving high confident to all Indonesian and improve "We can make it" mind set among Indonesian.
----------------------------------------------------------
Threat analysis
The situation in SCS is still relatively calm since USA is still very strong and China will not want to jeopardize its economic development by launching any military assault in the region at least until 2040.
Any way, it will be Vietnam, Philippine, and Malaysia/Brunei who will be targeted by China if that country is lead by crazy (which is not the case of current leadership). Indonesia will likely be spared by China as the dispute is not significant and happen in the edge of China nine dash claim.
We should focus on how to accelerate our local defense program and put more R&D on it. Radar acquisition IMO should also wait our two radar programs that are planned by Bappenas and PT LEN Industry (3 D radar). Getting foreign join program should also be done with the promise to make many RADAR so that TOT packet can be really significant.
-----------------------------------------------------
25 May 2021
Indonesia's plan to procure Rafale fighters hampered by funding roadblock
by Ridzwan Rahmat
However, a schedule of national projects that have been approved for foreign funding was obtained by
Janes on 21 May. It confirms that Rafale programme has not been included.
The schedule is published annually by the Indonesian Ministry of National Development Planning (Kementerian Perencanaan Pembangunan Nasional: BAPPENAS), and it spells out national programmes for which foreign loans can be obtained for the year.
As such, given the lack of endorsement from the BAPPENAS, the bid to procure 36 Rafale fighters has not been gazetted by the Indonesian Ministry of Finance (MOF) as a defence procurement programme for the 2021 financial year.
Full article
The Indonesian Ministry of Defense (MOD) has made further progress in its effort to procure 36 Rafale multirole fighter aircraft from Dassault Aviation but a formal...
www.janes.com