What's new

Indonesia Defence Forum

1474 troops how much ammo they spend :sniper::sniper::guns::guns:
Its about time we make good use of equestrian. There are many places in Indonesia where they are seriously needed.
Germany mountain warfare unit used mule and horse to pack and carry their equipment.
Maybe horse very useful to carry and tow light artillery also logistic.

How much money to care the horse?
 
.
US army cavalry still retain their horse detachments, for ceremony purpose but they still being trained to slash with saber and shoot with revolver while on horseback. India army still deploying their horse regiment. Well Prabowo will take a liking for such idea

View attachment 593111 View attachment 593112 View attachment 593113 View attachment 593114

Is it possible to use kavkud to enhance our infantry or raiders capabilities in asymmetric field like facing KKB in papua perhaps ?

More useful than a lot of our heavy vehicles tbh.

With our geographical character such as dense tropical forests and rugged mountains, I wonder why we do not have mountaineer infantry in specialities from the beginning ?
 
.
Russian Su-30 fighter jets criticized by Belarus, they want F-16
5944701-1.jpg

Russia has started implementing a contract on the delivery of a batch of its newest Su-30SM multirole fighter jets to Belarus, but some analysts raised concerns about costs over the entire life cycle of the aircraft, from fabrication to maintenance.

The publication Lenta.ru reported Friday that a wide range of renowned experts has expressed their concerns regarding Belarus selected Russian-made combat aircraft to replace ageing Soviet-era MiG-29 fleet.

Andrey Porotnikov, BelarusSecurityBlog’s project leader, said that operating and support costs of Russian aircraft are more expensive than U.S.-made F-16 fighter aircraft.

Usually, the combat aircraft life-cycle cost for an estimated life of 35 years is 2-2.5 times its purchase price, as a result of which the total cost of maintenance of each Belarus’s Su-30SM will cost $100-125 million.
And now, to sum up, the price of aircraft [about $ 50 million], the maintain of airworthiness and modernization. We get the amount from 185 to 210 million dollars for each (!) aircraft in the next 35 years. And the squadron [12 aircraft], respectively, from 2.22 billion to 2.52 billion dollars. The amount is not small, ”- Andrey Porotnikov stated.

Another disadvantage of the fighter manufactured in Russia is its AL-31FP engines, which six units “eat” during the Su-30SM life cycle (two of them are already installed and paid for at the time of purchase). This circumstance in the publication is explained by the fact that “Soviet (Russian) aircraft engines are traditionally inferior to Western ones not only in fuel efficiency but also in between-repairs and operating life cycles.”

“The Polish Air Force simultaneously operates the Soviet twin-engine fighter MiG-29 and the American single-engine F-16. It is assumed that the American fighter will fly off all 35 years with the same engine that was originally installed on it. Unfortunately, this does not work out with the MiG-29: eight engines will have to be replaced in the same period, ” explained analyst.

5868062.jpg

Photo by Airman 1st Class Duncan Bevan
According to TASS, the Su-30SM is a generation 4++ serial-produced and upgraded two-seat super-maneuverable fighter jet. The Su-30SM is furnished with two AL-31FP thrust-vectoring reheated double-flow turbofan engines. The fighter has an operating range of 1,500 km and flight endurance of 3.5 hours without refueling.

Still can't understand why TNI AU insisted on su35 when even belarus (a russian satelite state) prefer western design. Eastern bloc is inferior in specs and could potentially harm our relations with USA.

Eastern bloc procurement should be limited to small arms,coastal missile and Atgm's
 
.
Russian Su-30 fighter jets criticized by Belarus, they want F-16
5944701-1.jpg

Russia has started implementing a contract on the delivery of a batch of its newest Su-30SM multirole fighter jets to Belarus, but some analysts raised concerns about costs over the entire life cycle of the aircraft, from fabrication to maintenance.

The publication Lenta.ru reported Friday that a wide range of renowned experts has expressed their concerns regarding Belarus selected Russian-made combat aircraft to replace ageing Soviet-era MiG-29 fleet.

Andrey Porotnikov, BelarusSecurityBlog’s project leader, said that operating and support costs of Russian aircraft are more expensive than U.S.-made F-16 fighter aircraft.

Usually, the combat aircraft life-cycle cost for an estimated life of 35 years is 2-2.5 times its purchase price, as a result of which the total cost of maintenance of each Belarus’s Su-30SM will cost $100-125 million.
And now, to sum up, the price of aircraft [about $ 50 million], the maintain of airworthiness and modernization. We get the amount from 185 to 210 million dollars for each (!) aircraft in the next 35 years. And the squadron [12 aircraft], respectively, from 2.22 billion to 2.52 billion dollars. The amount is not small, ”- Andrey Porotnikov stated.

Another disadvantage of the fighter manufactured in Russia is its AL-31FP engines, which six units “eat” during the Su-30SM life cycle (two of them are already installed and paid for at the time of purchase). This circumstance in the publication is explained by the fact that “Soviet (Russian) aircraft engines are traditionally inferior to Western ones not only in fuel efficiency but also in between-repairs and operating life cycles.”

“The Polish Air Force simultaneously operates the Soviet twin-engine fighter MiG-29 and the American single-engine F-16. It is assumed that the American fighter will fly off all 35 years with the same engine that was originally installed on it. Unfortunately, this does not work out with the MiG-29: eight engines will have to be replaced in the same period, ” explained analyst.

5868062.jpg

Photo by Airman 1st Class Duncan Bevan
According to TASS, the Su-30SM is a generation 4++ serial-produced and upgraded two-seat super-maneuverable fighter jet. The Su-30SM is furnished with two AL-31FP thrust-vectoring reheated double-flow turbofan engines. The fighter has an operating range of 1,500 km and flight endurance of 3.5 hours without refueling.

Still can't understand why TNI AU insisted on su35 when even belarus (a russian satelite state) prefer western design. Eastern bloc is inferior in specs and could potentially harm our relations with USA.

Eastern bloc procurement should be limited to small arms,coastal missile and Atgm's
What if compared su 30s or su 35 to f15? For maintenance etc

F16 is par to soviet mig.
 
.
Russian Su-30 fighter jets criticized by Belarus, they want F-16
5944701-1.jpg

Russia has started implementing a contract on the delivery of a batch of its newest Su-30SM multirole fighter jets to Belarus, but some analysts raised concerns about costs over the entire life cycle of the aircraft, from fabrication to maintenance.

The publication Lenta.ru reported Friday that a wide range of renowned experts has expressed their concerns regarding Belarus selected Russian-made combat aircraft to replace ageing Soviet-era MiG-29 fleet.

Andrey Porotnikov, BelarusSecurityBlog’s project leader, said that operating and support costs of Russian aircraft are more expensive than U.S.-made F-16 fighter aircraft.

Usually, the combat aircraft life-cycle cost for an estimated life of 35 years is 2-2.5 times its purchase price, as a result of which the total cost of maintenance of each Belarus’s Su-30SM will cost $100-125 million.
And now, to sum up, the price of aircraft [about $ 50 million], the maintain of airworthiness and modernization. We get the amount from 185 to 210 million dollars for each (!) aircraft in the next 35 years. And the squadron [12 aircraft], respectively, from 2.22 billion to 2.52 billion dollars. The amount is not small, ”- Andrey Porotnikov stated.

Another disadvantage of the fighter manufactured in Russia is its AL-31FP engines, which six units “eat” during the Su-30SM life cycle (two of them are already installed and paid for at the time of purchase). This circumstance in the publication is explained by the fact that “Soviet (Russian) aircraft engines are traditionally inferior to Western ones not only in fuel efficiency but also in between-repairs and operating life cycles.”

“The Polish Air Force simultaneously operates the Soviet twin-engine fighter MiG-29 and the American single-engine F-16. It is assumed that the American fighter will fly off all 35 years with the same engine that was originally installed on it. Unfortunately, this does not work out with the MiG-29: eight engines will have to be replaced in the same period, ” explained analyst.

5868062.jpg

Photo by Airman 1st Class Duncan Bevan
According to TASS, the Su-30SM is a generation 4++ serial-produced and upgraded two-seat super-maneuverable fighter jet. The Su-30SM is furnished with two AL-31FP thrust-vectoring reheated double-flow turbofan engines. The fighter has an operating range of 1,500 km and flight endurance of 3.5 hours without refueling.

Still can't understand why TNI AU insisted on su35 when even belarus (a russian satelite state) prefer western design. Eastern bloc is inferior in specs and could potentially harm our relations with USA.

Eastern bloc procurement should be limited to small arms,coastal missile and Atgm's
strange , aren't they were one of the country that got permission by russia to do overhaul maintenance etc for sukhoi family ?
 
.
.
Hoping that they will expand the numbers of units (and therefore the horses), perhaps 2 or 3 Battallions would do.
 
.
Maybe horse very useful to carry and tow light artillery also logistic.

Only for logistic support (foods, ammo) but nothing heavy. And with domestic breed such as Sandalwood Pony we are looking 3-1 ratio, meaning 1 horse will be needed to carry the grass (food) for the other horse and itself.

With our geographical character such as dense tropical forests and rugged mountains, I wonder why we do not have mountaineer infantry in specialities from the beginning ?

Not needed. Indonesia mountains are mostly volcanic and aren't high enough to warrant specialized unit. Even the non volcanic mountains such as the Sudirman Mountain Range aren't that high either with the exception of it few peaks.
 
.
Hoping that they will expand the numbers of units (and therefore the horses), perhaps 2 or 3 Battallions would do.

Need more sniffer and specialized hunting Dogs instead, they are more useful for our current needs. Special breeds for military K9 is really rare and to obtain them our military must queing in long waiting list as the breeder prefer to provide them to more important clients...

http://www.uswardogs.org/war-dog-history/types-war-dogs/

Dogs can be used as a more effective scouts even compared with human and machinary, in Nam and primitive mountain jungle in New Guinea dogs extensively used by US military
Marine-war-dogs.jpg
 
.
F16 is par to soviet mig.
Mig 29 is more superior than F16 on the ground.
Mig 29 can operates from the runway that littered with debris, F16 will think twice.

Need more sniffer and specialized hunting Dogs instead, they are more useful for our current needs. Special breeds for military K9 is really rare and to obtain them our military must queing in long waiting list as the breeder prefer to provide them to more important clients...

http://www.uswardogs.org/war-dog-history/types-war-dogs/

Dogs can be used as a more effective scouts even compared with human and machinary, in Nam and primitive mountain jungle in New Guinea dogs extensively used by US military View attachment 593226
In the year of 2019, we should complement it with small portable drones.
Lucky if we have sufficient number of larger drones with better sensors, to loiter around ops area
Hm... Where is Cromwell,
 
. .
Not only menwa that get military training now? this is good activity MoD should work together with campuses for this programme and try to fusion it with their 'MOS' and abolish perpeloncoan, lebih berfaedah sama sama digojlok dibentuk mentalnya tapi beda lah kualitasnya kalau yang megang TNI.
Go go go
 
Last edited:
.
.
.
We need cheaper small drone for large scale deployment, not only stop at SF but to the Kostrad unit.
Equipping our Kostrad unit with protective gears, night vision googles, anti tank weapons, and drones at least at platoon level would be dope to deal with either near peer or insurgent.
As tip of the spear Kostrad should get budget priority, they are more ready for deployment than Kodam unit IMO.
What unit will be assigned to Expeditionary Forces? Any info yet? Jadi dibentuk kan?
 
Last edited:
.

Latest posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom