Yeah, those experiments happened when life was cheap. That is when Tyrants like Mao, Lenin and Stalin mass murdered people. Please don't compare USSR to India, we don't want our country to be Balkanized.
All your examples of Socialist countries are terrible to worst. I wouldn't really compare the situation of AAP, they are sitting on a gold mine called Delhi. Bring AAP to Jharkhand, West Bengal, Tripura oh wait all these places had their time with Communists and guess what, they're now living in 'richness'.
Spoken like a classic commie. No, they are not propaganda, the ones going on with propaganda are the communists. Oh, the Tank Man was never mowed by the Tanks he faced, there was never such allegation, but the real issue was tanks ran over people protesting in Tiananmen square. Don't obfuscate Jamahir. Given your like Wikipedia, look up Red terror.
Again, you're living in the good old days where means where not important. I'm talking about sustenance, you're talking about a momentary lala land, that didn't last enough. Or it's safe to say, it's an un sustainable model of governance, and what better example we have than Libya where the same leader was hunted down by his own people.
A country that has a few million people couldn't manage to remain livable with communism. Whatever be the actual definition of communism according for you, but if you put Communism and capitalism and compare them, capitalism have taken people out of poverty. Communism not so much. It's like a religion, perpetual poverty and suffering is what Communist principles thrive on. The jealous for the rich.
Because competition drives growth. Heard the term Survival of the fittest? We live in such a society. I had a friend in collage who was very active in SFI, where he talked about similar things like you, where we don't have to compete if we a sweeper earns the same as an Engineer. No matter the value or quality of the job done. My answer to you will be the same I gave it to him, I worked hard to reach where I am, he didn't work hard enough or had bad lucks, either way it's not my fault he's where he is. Why should he be rewarded the same way as him? Isn't it promoting laziness?
You should read that thread in full.
Libya drowned in the Arab Spring. Do I need to explain more? Which says, that's all it took to take down the utopia, one small rebellion. That's how weak your little Socialist country was.
There was a time when there were Pakistanis like Masood Azhar came and lived in Kashmir like it's a walk in the park, there were also times when we could find Afghans or Chechens in Kashmir. Did our country broke apart? There was a time when few Naga militants grew so powerful that India didn't even had any control in Nagaland and surrounding states, when Nagas shot down our plane. Did India break apart?
Please, I have read what Gaddafi wrote some time back. I've been a student of economics, so far it's theories never failed, that is the basic Economic problem "Human wants are unlimited, Nobody can claim that all of his wants have been satisfied and he has no need to satisfy any further want." Libya may have been a model socialist state. It's in the past, the best working model so far has been democracy with common laws. Pretty much survived two world wars, civil wars and been here for like 240+ years, and is the most common form of government that's best suited for a country like India. You can disagree with me, and criticize democracy as much as you want but you will not be prosecuted for it. Pretty low standard to compare with when it comes to communist countries.
No dude. This is a misconception propagated by ISI that Modi is bad for India.
