Indian government should hang its head in shame: BBC filmmaker

[jamahir]

Equal rights are given to all of them, but the level of respect is different.

let us not complicate by saying "my sister versus someone else's sister".

equal rights means respect for everyone based on their conduct... when my brother does wrong, he simply is wrong... and when i say "conduct", i don't connect it with culture-dependent assumption of "conduct" but with what is common among all humans.

 

[Screambowl]

let us not complicate by saying "my sister versus someone else's sister".

equal rights means respect for everyone based on their conduct... when my brother does wrong, he simply is wrong... and when i say "conduct", i don't connect it with culture-dependent assumption of "conduct" but with what is common among all humans.

respect equally right... then what is the respect you give to your mother and what is the respect you give to your wife. are they equal?

 

[jamahir]

respect equally right... then what is the respect you give to your mother and what is the respect you give to your wife. are they equal?

your are confusing rights with conduct for different relationships.

 

[Screambowl]

your are confusing rights with conduct for different relationships.

rights don'T tell you to respect the lady . this comes from morals. Relationships are formed because of morals. If there are no morals, no relationship.

 

[DesiGuy]

Indian government should hang its head in shame: BBC filmmaker

[/QUOTE]

na....they won't. There is no shame at all to begin with.

 

[jamahir]

rights don'T tell you to respect the lady . this comes from morals. Relationships are formed because of morals. If there are no morals, no relationship.

if there is no respect, there is no need to maintain relationships... imagine parents who had tried to "honor kill" their son or daughter... should the child continue respect to the parents?? should the child compromise and "adjust"?? rather, the child should bring legal punishment to the parents.

 

[Screambowl]

if there is no respect, there is no need to maintain relationships... imagine parents who had tried to "honor kill" their son or daughter... should the child continue respect to the parents?? should the child compromise and "adjust"?? rather, the child should bring legal punishment to the parents.

you are confusing between respect and MORALS!

 

[jamahir]

you are confusing between respect and MORALS!

"morals" are for backward villagers... respect is what builds civilizations.

 

[Screambowl]

"morals" are for backward villagers... respect is what builds civilizations.

Being a Muslim you do not know what is the deference between 'Izzat aur Ikhlaq'
Mujam alfaz al-qiyam al-akhlaqiyah wa-tatawwuruha al-dalali bayna lughat al-shir al-Jahili wa-lughat al-Quran al-karim

 

[gubbi]

Are you an Indian? If so were you brought up according to Indian culture or some other culture? If so, how many women have you raped until now? How much dowry have you taken? What about female infanticide and honor killings? If you have done all this due to your upbringing then you must blame Indian culture. If not, STFU.

Idiot.
I am an Indian. So why should I STFU? If you cannot face the degradation of our society in the name of so called 'culture' or 'values', I pity people like you. And, no, I will not STFU. Who are you to decide what "values" women should abide by? Who are you to decide what rules women should stick to? Why not apply that same yardstick to men? People should be and will be made uncomfortable to face this nasty truth that men in our societies do not treat women right. This stupid attitude that women need to be protected by men is ridiculous.
Women are strong. Women are powerful. And 'hell hath no fury known than a women scorned' remains as true to this day as it was first realized. So stop belittling yourselves in this false bravado that Men are superior and need to place and worship women on a pedestal, provided women 'behave' themselves. Treat them with respect as your equals.

 

[DeathInvader]

"morals" are for backward villagers... respect is what builds civilizations.

People build civilizations. People with morals. Respect is what they offer one another. While moral is the flame, respect is what fuels civilizations.

 

[Bitter Melon]

Idiot.
I am an Indian. So why should I STFU? If you cannot face the degradation of our society in the name of so called 'culture' or 'values', I pity people like you. And, no, I will not STFU. Who are you to decide what "values" women should abide by? Who are you to decide what rules women should stick to? Why not apply that same yardstick to men? People should be and will be made uncomfortable to face this nasty truth that men in our societies do not treat women right. This stupid attitude that women need to be protected by men is ridiculous.
Women are strong. Women are powerful. And 'hell hath no fury known than a women scorned' remains as true to this day as it was first realized. So stop belittling yourselves in this false bravado that Men are superior and need to place and worship women on a pedestal, provided women 'behave' themselves. Treat them with respect as your equals.

Oh my apologies. Seems you were born in a red light area and hence hate the culture you were born in, but let me assure you my culture is absolutely fine and I have faced no cultural degradation nor have I seen any women around me being degraded. Who said I decide values for women? It is the women around me who gave me the values I have and they are just fine. Stop projecting issues your women faced raising you on to the society. If men are superior and women are goddesses in my culture, you must realize we like it this way and would not change it for the world. You can continue to think men are inferior and women are slags, that is your outlook in life. Shows up pretty much in everything you speak about.

 

[jamahir]

Being a Muslim you do not know what is the deference between 'Izzat aur Ikhlaq'
Mujam alfaz al-qiyam al-akhlaqiyah wa-tatawwuruha al-dalali bayna lughat al-shir al-Jahili wa-lughat al-Quran al-karim

i will get someone to translate that.

but seeing what goes for "akhlaqi-pan" in south asia, i will say that other cultures have done fine with respect and without morality.

People build civilizations. People with morals. Respect is what they offer one another. While moral is the flame, respect is what fuels civilizations.

the problem of south asia ( afgh, ind, pak, bd ) is too much morality and too little respect... such people don't build civilizations, rather they degrade parts of human civilization as a whole.

 

[Screambowl]

i will get someone to translate that.

but seeing what goes for "akhlaqi-pan" in south asia, i will say that other cultures have done fine with respect and without morality.

if there is no Moral of respecting women, how are you suppose to respect? lol..Moral is your inner thoughts( zehen ke ander) Respect is something to be shown ..

 

[Jlaw]

Modhi is making bad choices . he seem like a very narrow minded person. I liked manmohhan

There appear to be more peace on the border between the neighbors when Mannohhan was in power. Modi is one of those guys who talk tough but India doesn't have the capability to back Modi's nationalist rhetorics.